Gravitational lensing inside and outside of a marginally unstable photon sphere in a general, static, spherically symmetric, and asymptotically-flat spacetime in strong deflection limits
Naoki Tsukamoto 1 · 2025
Read Gravitational lensing inside and outside of a marginally unstable photon sphere in a general, static, spherically symmetric, and asymptotically-flat spacetime in strong deflection limits by Naoki Tsukamoto 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01688.txt.
Introduction
Naoki Tsukamoto studies light bending near unstable photon spheres in general spacetimes. Photon spheres trap light rays in loops around black holes. Rays bent just inside or outside can shape shadow images. The Event Horizon Telescope reads those shadows now.
Near-future space views may catch rays near the spheres with more detail. Tsukamoto works out lensing traits for a general static, spherical case. His results cover exotic spacetimes as well as black holes. They give observers a guide to tell object types apart by their light rings. Static spherical symmetry keeps the math general yet tractable, a middle ground between toy cases and full numeric relativity runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Naoki Tsukamoto 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01688
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational lensing inside and outside of a marginally unstable photon sphere in a general, static, spherically symmetric, and asymptotically-flat spacetime in strong deflection limits Naoki Tsukamoto 1 Abstract It is believed that rays bent inside and outside photon spheres could affect partially the black hole shadow images by the Event Horizon Telescope and the rays near photon spheres would be detected by near-future space observations. The features of the rays near the photon spheres in not only black hole spacetimes but also exotic spacetimes would be important since one will need them to exclude black-hole mimickers. The deflection angles of the rays deflected by photon spheres diverge logarithmically and we can treat them by a strong-deflection-limit analysis. The error of the strong-deflection-limit analysis becomes large if antiphoton spheres exist in the spacetimes and the analysis breaks down when the photon spheres and the antiphoton spheres degenerate to form a marginally unstable photon sphere. This is because the deflection angles of the rays bent by the marginally unstable photon sphere diverge in powers. In this paper, we extend Eiroa, Romero, and Torres’s method to gravitational lensing of rays inside and outside of the marginally unstable photon sphere in a general, static, spherically symmetric, and asymptotically-flat spacetime in strong deflection limits and we apply it to a Reissner-Nordström spacetime and a Hayward spacetime with the marginally unstable photon sphere. We have also confirmed that the deflection angles in the strong deflection limits by the method converge correctly to the deflection angle without approximations, while there are the mismatches of the coefficient of the power-divergent term of the deflection angles of the rays deflected just outside of the marginally unstable photon sphere in a semi-analytic calculation by the author previously. I Introduction Recently, the direct detection of gravitational waves by binary black hole has been reported by the LIGO and VIRGO Collaborations Abbott:2016blz ; LIGOScientific:2018mvr ; LIGOScientific:2020ibl ; KAGRA:2021vkt ; LIGOScientific:2025slb and the ring-shape images of supermassive black hole candidates at the centers of the giant elliptical galaxy M87 and the Milky way galaxy have been reported by the Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration Akiyama:2019cqa ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp . Strong gravity near black holes would cause high energy phenomena and it would be important to detect the black holes and to understand their astrophysical environments. Compact objects such as black holes and wormholes have photon spheres which are spheres constructed by unstable circular light orbits due to their strong gravity Perlick_2004_Living_Rev . Several aspects of the photon spheres such as the bounds of their radii Hod:2017xkz ; Peng:2018nkj ; Hod:2020pim ; Hod:2023jmx , their numbers Hod:2017zpi ; Cunha:2020azh ; Cunha:2024ajc ; Padhye:2024yrj , and their relationship to photon absorption cross sections Sanchez:1977si ; Decanini:2010fz ; Wei:2011zw , quasinormal modes Press:1971wr ; Goebel_1972 ; Stefanov:2010xz ; Raffaelli:2014ola ; Igata:2025plb ; Igata:2025hpy , a centrifugal force and gyroscopic precession Abramowicz_Prasanna_1990 ; Abramowicz:1990cb ; Allen:1990ci ; Hasse_Perlick_2002 , Bondi’s sonic horizon Mach:2013gia ; Chaverra:2015bya ; Cvetic:2016bxi ; Koga:2016jjq ; Koga:2018ybs ; Koga:2019teu , and the stability of thin-shell wormholes Barcelo:2000ta ; Koga:2020gqd ; Tsukamoto:2023kvk , were investigated eagerly. If the gravity of compact objects is moderate, they could have also antiphoton spheres which are spheres formed by stable circular light orbits, but the instability of the compact objects may be caused by the slow decay of linear waves near the antiphoton spheres Keir:2014oka ; Cardoso:2014sna ; Cunha:2017qtt ; Cunha:2017eoe ; Cunha:2022gde ; Zhong:2022jke . The alternatives to the photon spheres and the antiphoton spheres were also suggested by several researchers Claudel:2000yi ; Koga:2019uqd ; Cunha:2017eoe ; Gibbons:2016isj ; Shiromizu:2017ego ; Yoshino:2017gqv ; Galtsov:2019bty ; Galtsov:2019fzq ; Siino:2019vxh ; Yoshino:2019dty ; Cao:2019vlu ; Yoshino:2019mqw ; Lee:2020pre . Gravitational lenses are often used to survey dark objects such as the black holes, extrasolar planets, and dark matters Schneider_Ehlers_Falco_1992 ; Schneider_Kochanek_Wambsganss_2006 . The gravitational lenses have been mainly studied in a weak gravitational field for a hundred years since we do not have enough technology to detect astrophysical phenomena in strong gravitational fields until the last decade. Rays deflected by the photon spheres of the black holes and their gravitational lensing effects in strong gravitational fields have been intermittently investigated Hagihara_1931 ; Darwin_1959 ; Atkinson_1965 ; Luminet_1979 ; Ohanian_1987 ; Nemiroff_1993 ; Frittelli_Kling_Newman_2000 ; Virbhadra_Ellis_2000 ; Bozza:2001xd ; Bozza:2002zj ; Perlick:2003vg ; Nandi:2006ds ; Virbhadra:2008ws ; Hioki:2009na ; Bozza_2010 ; Tsupko:2017rdo ; Nakao:2018knn ; Gralla:2019xty ; Okabayashi:2020apz ; Hsieh:2021scb ; Aratore:2021usi ; Tsupko:2022kwi ; Aratore:2024bro ; Tsupko:2025hhf . The effects of the photon spheres on the apparent shape of stars collapsing into the black holes also have been investigated Ames_1968 ; Synge:1966okc ; Yoshino:2019qsh ; Koga:2025dii . It is believed that the rays deflected just inside and outside photon spheres could affect partially the observed ring images of the supermassive black hole candidates at the center of our galaxy and the elliptic galaxy M87 by the Event Horizon Telescope Akiyama:2019cqa ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp and the rays bent near the photon spheres would be detected by near-future space observations Lupsasca:2024xhq ; Johnson:2024ttr . It is important to investigate the features of the rays near the photon spheres in not only black hole spacetimes but also exotic compact objects such as wormholes Ellis:1973yv ; Chetouani:1984qdm ; Perlick:2003vg ; Muller:2004dq ; Nandi:2006ds ; Muller:2008zza ; Tsukamoto:2012xs ; Ohgami:2015nra ; Tsukamoto:2016qro ; Tsukamoto:2016zdu ; Shaikh:2018kfv ; Shaikh:2018oul ; Bronnikov:2018nub ; Shaikh:2019jfr ; Bronnikov:2021liv ; Maeda:2021wnl ; Olmo:2023lil ; Bugaev:2023mlc ; Zhang:2024sgs ; Xavier:2024iwr ; Tsukamoto:2024pid ; Bugaev:2024dte ; Solodukhin:2025opw and naked singularity Virbhadra:1998dy ; Virbhadra:2002ju ; Hioki:2009na ; Shaikh:2018lcc ; Shaikh:2019itn since one needs to exclude exotic compact objects or black-hole mimickers to reinforce claims that the observed objects must be supermassive black holes. Gravitational lensing of rays reflected by just outside of a photon sphere in a Schwarzschild spacetime in a strong deflection limit b\rightarrow b_{\mathrm{m}}+0 , where b and b_{\mathrm{m}} an impact parameter and a critical impact parameter of the ray, by Bozza et al. Bozza:2001xd . The deflection angle of the rays which pass near outside of the photon sphere diverges logarithmically can be expressed by \displaystyle\alpha \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\bar{a}_{+}\log\left(\frac{b}{b_{\mathrm{m}}}-1\right)+\bar{b}_{+}, (1) where \bar{a}_{+} and \bar{b}_{+} are a coefficient and a term which are determined by the metric of the spacetime with the photon sphere. Eiroa, Romero, and Torres suggested a method to obtain the coefficient \bar{a}_{+} and the term \bar{b}_{+} numerically and they applied it to a Reissner-Nordström black hole spacetime Eiroa:2002mk while Bozza made a semi-analytic formula in a general, static, spherically symmetric, and asymptotically-flat spacetime with the photon sphere to obtain the coefficient \bar{a}_{+} and the term \bar{b}_{+} and got \bar{a}_{+} in an analytic form and \bar{b}_{+} partially numerically in the Reissner-Nordström black hole spacetime Bozza:2002zj . The strong-deflection-limits analysis has been intensively studied and it has been extended over the last two decades Bozza:2002af ; Eiroa:2002mk ; Petters:2002fa ; Eiroa:2003jf ; Bozza:2004kq ; Bozza:2005tg ; Bozza:2006sn ; Bozza:2006nm ; Iyer:2006cn ; Bozza:2007gt ; Tsukamoto:2016qro ; Ishihara:2016sfv ; Tsukamoto:2016oca ; Tsukamoto:2016zdu ; Tsukamoto:2016jzh ; Shaikh:2018oul ; Shaikh:2019itn ; Takizawa:2021gdp ; Zhang:2024sgs ; Igata:2025taz . Tsukamoto Tsukamoto:2016oca ; Tsukamoto:2016jzh investigated an alternative of Bozza’s method Bozza:2002zj , obtained \bar{a}_{+} and \bar{b}_{+} in analytic forms in the Reissner-Nordström spacetime and confirmed that they are consistent with \bar{a}_{+} and \bar{b}_{+} obtained by Eiroa, Romero, and