Effects of Turbulent Energy Exchange between Electrons and Ions on Global Temperature Profiles

Tetsuji KATOsup1, Hideo SUGAMAsup1, 2, Mitsuru HONDAsup3 · 2025

Read Effects of Turbulent Energy Exchange between Electrons and Ions on Global Temperature Profiles by Tetsuji KATOsup1, Hideo SUGAMAsup1, 2, Mitsuru HONDAsup3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01618.txt.

Introduction

Tetsuji Kato, Hideo Sugama, and Mitsuru Honda study turbulent energy swaps in plasma. Small-scale churn moves heat and particles. It also moves energy between electrons and ions. In weak-collision plasma, that swap can beat direct collision swaps.

Past local studies showed ion heating can be hindered by such churn. The team asks how the swap shapes global temperature profiles. Profiles set fusion reactor performance. If churn steals heat from ions, reactor plans must account for it. Their work links micro churn to macro reactor outcomes. Global profiles link to alpha heating in burning plasma, the very heat source a fusion reactor must keep inside its ion core.

Catalog record

CREATORTetsuji KATOsup1, Hideo SUGAMAsup1, 2, Mitsuru HONDAsup3
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01618

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects of Turbulent Energy Exchange between Electrons and Ions on Global Temperature Profiles Tetsuji KATOsup1, Hideo SUGAMAsup1, 2, Mitsuru HONDAsup3 Abstract Microscale turbulence drives not only particle and heat transport but also energy exchange between different particle species. Previous local gyrokinetic studies have shown that turbulent energy exchange can exceed collisional exchange in weakly collisional plasmas, and that ion temperature gradient (ITG) turbulence may hinder ion heating by alpha-heated electrons. In addition, it has been clarified that trapped electron mode (TEM) turbulence transfers energy from electrons to ions, thereby enhancing ion heating. In this work, we extend these studies by examining the impact of turbulent energy exchange on the global temperature profiles at a steady state using the one-dimensional transport solver GOTRESS. For the case of DIII-D discharge #128913 [A. E. White et al. , Phys. Plasmas 15 , 056116 (2008)], turbulent energy exchange has minimal influence on temperature profiles. However, in the case of enhanced electron heating in a DIII-D-like tokamak plasma, energy transfer from hot electrons to cold ions driven by TEM turbulence becomes comparable to, or even exceeds, the collisional contribution, leading to a significant increase in the ion temperature profile. For ITER Baseline and SPARC standard H-mode scenarios [N.T. Howard et al. , Nucl. Fusion 65 , 016002(2024), P. Rodriguez-Fernandez et al. , J. Plasma Phys. 86 , 865860503(2020)], the turbulent energy exchange is largely compensated by the collisional one, producing only small effects. These results indicate that the impact of turbulent energy exchange on the global temperature profiles in steady‐state conditions of future fusion reactor scenarios is expected to be negligibly small, although it can become significant in situations such as plasma start-up phases, where the heating power is strongly unbalanced between electrons and ions. Microscale turbulence not only drives particle and heat fluxes but also induces energy exchange between electrons and ions [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . The previous study [ 1 ] has performed local gyrokinetic simulations to investigate turbulent energy exchange driven by ion temperature gradient (ITG) turbulence. It has reported that, in weakly collisional plasmas, the turbulent contribution to the energy exchange between electrons and ions can exceed that due to Coulomb collisions. In particular, turbulent energy exchange associated with ITG turbulence transfers energy from ions to electrons irrespective of the temperature difference between electrons and ions, and therefore may hinder the collisional energy transfer from alpha-heated electrons to ions. Reference [ 2 ] has found that trapped electron mode (TEM) turbulence transfers energy from electrons to ions, which is in the direction opposite to that of ITG turbulence. Furthermore, it has also examined the relationship between turbulent energy exchange and the energy fluxes, deriving a simple model that allows turbulent energy exchange to be estimated with low computational cost, and confirming its validity. In the present work, we extend those previous investigations of the local effects of turbulent energy exchange and examine its impact on the steady-state global temperature profiles. To predict the global temperature profiles, we employ GOTRESS [ 5 , 6 ] , which is a one-dimensional steady-state transport solver to solve the heat transport equations at a steady state given by, 0=-\frac{1}{V^{\prime}}\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho}\left\{V^{\prime}\left(\frac{5}{2}T_{a}\Gamma_{a}+q_{a}\right)\right\}+S_{a}, (1) where \rho is the normalized radial coordinate, and V=V(\rho) is the volume enclosed by the flux surface at minor radius \rho . The prime denotes the \rho -derivative, and T_{a}=T_{a}(\rho) and S_{a}=S_{a}(\rho) are the temperature and heat sources for particle species a at \rho , respectively. The particle and heat fluxes, \Gamma_{a}=\Gamma_{a}(\rho) and q_{a}=q_{a}(\rho) are written as \displaystyle\Gamma_{a}=-\left\langle|\nabla\rho|^{2}\right\rangle D_{a}\frac{\partial n_{a}}{\partial\rho}, (2) \displaystyle q_{a}=-n_{a}\left\langle|\nabla\rho|^{2}\right\rangle\chi_{a}\frac{\partial T_{a}}{\partial\rho}, (3) where n_{a}=n_{a}(\rho) is the density for particle species a . The particle and heat diffusivities, D_{a}=D_{a}(\rho) and \chi_{a}=\chi_{a}(\rho) , comprise turbulent and neoclassical contributions: D_{a}=D_{a}^{\rm turb}+D_{a}^{\rm neo} , \chi_{a}=\chi_{a}^{\rm turb}+\chi_{a}^{\rm neo} . Table 1: Parameters for each device case DIII-D ITER SPARC Major radius R_{0}~[{\rm m}] 1.66 6.2 1.85 Minor radius r_{0}~[{\rm m}] 0.67 2.0 0.57 Toroidal field B_{0}~[{\rm T}] 2.1 5.3 12.2 Plasma current I_{p}~[{\rm MA}] 1.0 15.0 8.7 The total cumulative power P_{a}^{\rm total}=P_{a}^{\rm total}(\rho) inside the volume V(\rho) is calculated by \hskip-28.45274ptP_{a}^{\rm total}(\rho)=\int_{\rho}S_{a}V^{\prime}d\rho=P_{a}^{\rm heat}(\rho)+P_{a}^{\rm coll}(\rho)+P_{a}^{\rm turb}(\rho), (4) where the cumulative power for energy exchange between electrons and ions via Coulomb collision and microturbulence, P_{a}^{\rm coll}(\rho)=\int_{\rho}S_{a}^{\rm coll}V^{\prime}d\rho and P_{a}^{\rm turb}(\rho)=\int_{\rho}S_{a}^{\rm turb}V^{\prime}d\rho for a=e,i , respectively. Here, for convenience, the heat source S_{a} is taken to include not only auxiliary heating, alpha heating, and ohmic heating, but also radiation loss for electrons as negative contributions. The turbulent energy transfer from electrons to ions S_{i}^{\rm turb}(=-S_{e}^{\rm turb}) can be modeled as [ 2 ] S_{i}^{\rm turb}=\frac{\mathcal{E}^{\rm turb}_{e}-\mathcal{E}^{\rm turb}_{i}}{2R_{0}}, (5) where \mathcal{E}^{\rm turb}_{a}=q_{a}^{\rm turb}+5T_{a}\Gamma_{a}^{\rm turb}/2 , \Gamma^{\rm turb}_{a}=D_{a}^{\rm turb}\Gamma_{a}/D_{a} , Q^{\rm turb}_{a}=\chi_{a}^{\rm turb}Q_{a}/\chi_{a} for a=e,i , and R_{0} is the major radius. In this study, we incorporate the effect of turbulent energy exchange into GOTRESS using Eq. ( 5 ) and investigate several tokamak cases as shown in Tab. 1 . Here, for simplicity, we assume a tokamak geometry with magnetic flux surfaces that have concentric circular cross sections, noting that in Eq. ( 5 ) only the major radius R_{0} and the turbulent energy fluxes \mathcal{E}_{a}^{\rm turb} ( a=e,i ) are used to evaluate the turbulent energy exchange. The density profile is fixed, and the temperature profile is solved for. The current density profile is assumed to be proportional to (1-\rho^{2})^{2} . Fig. 1: Simulation results for conditions similar to the DIII-D discharge #128913 with the parameters (c_{e},c_{i})=(3.0,6.0) and heating powers (P_{e}^{\rm heat},P^{\rm heat}_{i})=(1.8,0.7) [MW]. Figures 1 (a–f) present, respectively, the global electron and ion temperature profiles, the cumulative electron and ion power, the density profile, and the collisional and turbulent energy exchanges. The circular markers in Figs. 1 (c) and (d) indicate the energy transport across a flux surface at each minor radius reported in Ref. [ 12 ] . Solid and dashed lines represent results with and without the turbulent energy exchange described in Eq. ( 5 ), respectively. In this study, we express the turbulent particle and heat diffusivities as D^{\rm turb}_{a}=0.2\chi^{\rm turb}_{a} (see e.g. [ 7 ] ) and \chi_{a}^{\mathrm{turb}}=c_{a}\chi_{a,\mathrm{BgB}}^{\mathrm{turb}} , where \chi_{a,\mathrm{BgB}}^{\mathrm{turb}} denotes the value obtained from the BgB model. The BgB model enables computationally efficient evaluations of microscale turbulence [ 8 , 9 ] . The tuning parameters c_{a} for a=e,i are adjusted so that the resulting temperature profiles and energy balance reproduce the experimental or reference data. Figure 1 shows simulation results for conditions similar to the DIII-D discharge #128913, representing an ITG-dominant case [ 1 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . The circular markers in Figs. 1 (c) and (d) indicate the energy transport across a flux surface at each minor radius reported in Ref [ 12 ] . As shown in Fig. 1 (f), the turbulent energy transfer contributes in the opposite direction to the collisional one. However, for the entire volume, P_{i}^{\mathrm{turb}}(\rho=1)(=-P^{\rm turb}_{e}(\rho=1)) is only 2.4% and 1.9% of P_{e}^{\mathrm{total}}(\rho=1) and P_{i}^{\mathrm{total}}(\rho=1) , respectively, and the resulting change in the temperature profiles is negligible as shown in Figs. 1 (a) and (b). This result is consistent with previous studies [ 1 , 11 ] , indicating that in this case the turbulent energy exchange can be safely neglected. Fig. 2: Simulation results

Read the complete text