Mass transfer stability for AM CVn binaries with white dwarf donors

Ryosuke Hirai · 2025

Read Mass transfer stability for AM CVn binaries with white dwarf donors by Ryosuke Hirai (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01377.txt.

Introduction

Ryosuke Hirai studies pairs of white dwarf stars that pass mass between them. Some pairs hold two helium white dwarfs. When one feeds the other in a stable way, the pair can become an AM CVn system. How many such pairs exist in our galaxy is not known.

Hirai works out when that mass flow stays stable. His tests treat each dwarf as cold and fully packed. The count of stable pairs sets the birth rate of AM CVn systems. That rate helps scope hunts for their faint light and for the waves they send through space.

Catalog record

CREATORRyosuke Hirai
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01377

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mass transfer stability for AM CVn binaries with white dwarf donors Ryosuke Hirai Abstract Abstract Double white dwarf binaries (DWDBs) with Helium components are progenitors to AM CVn binary systems. Their Galactic production rate may be given by the number of stably mass transferring DWDBs in the Milky Way. The theoretical criteria for stable mass transfer in DWDBs is calculated assuming that component white dwarfs are completely cold and degenerate. Respective fractions of surviving AM CVn and DWDB which merge are then calculated by applying this criteria to population synthesis estimates for Galactic DWDB. However, emerging observations of the local DWDB population suggest that Helium white dwarf (He WD) components are typically hot, and only partially degenerate when they begin mass transferring. Using recent numerical simulations of He WD donors in DWDBs, we qualitatively describe a temperature dependent stable mass transfer criteria for Galactic DWDBs. Mass transfer is even more stable than previously thought, or equivalently, DWDB mergers are even rarer. Realistic finite temperature treatments will deepen the dearth in observed AM CVn binaries compared to DWDB merger products. [a,b,c]Lucy O. McNeill 1 Introduction Double white dwarf binaries (DWDBs) with Helium donors are the progenitors to a variety of transient phenomena and stellar populations [ 1 ] . DWDBs which are unstable to mass transfer and merge may be the origin of type .Ia supernova, calcium rich transients, R Cor Bor stars, and hot sub dwarf stars. On the other hand, DWDBs which stably mass transfer are potential progenitors of AM CVn binaries. The observed rates of these transients and stellar populations can be compared with binary stellar evolution theory. For example, the AM CVn birth rate may be a proxy for the stable mass transfer rate in the Galactic DWDB population, or equivalently the survival rate of interacting DWDBs. This rate can ultimately be compared with the predicted population of white dwarfs in the Milky Way [ 2 ] . The instantaneous stellar radius response to mass loss is often used to characterize whether a given DWDB is dynamically stable or unstable to mass transfer. Assuming that white dwarfs (WDs) are completely degenerate at the moment of mass transfer [ 3 ] , their radius is independent of internal thermal structure. In units of R_{\odot}/100 for white dwarfs with mass m , this zero–temperature mass radius relation is [ 4 ] \begin{split}&R_{\mathrm{cold}}(m)=1.14\left(\left(m/1.44\right)^{-2/3}-\left(m/1.44\right)^{2/3}\right)^{1/2}\times\\ &\left(1+3.5\left(m/\left(5.7\times 10^{-4}\right)\right)\right)^{-2/3}+\left(\left(5.7\times 10^{-4}\right)/m\right)^{-2/3}.\end{split} (1) The mass transfer for a WD with R_{\mathrm{cold}} will be stable if the rate of expansion of the Roche lobe radius R_{\mathrm{RL}} , given by [ 5 ] R_{\mathrm{RL}}=a_{\mathrm{RL}}\frac{0.49q^{2/3}}{0.6q^{2/3}+\mathrm{log}\left(1+q^{1/3}\right)}, (2) is faster than the expansion of the R_{\mathrm{cold}} . Here, a_{\mathrm{RL}} is the separation of a binary with mass ratio of the donor and accretor q=m_{D}/m_{A} . Respective expansion rates of R_{\mathrm{RL}} and R_{\mathrm{cold}} are quantified with differentials \zeta , where the response of R_{\mathrm{cold}} to mass loss for a donor with mass m and radius given by Equation ( 1 ) is characterised by: \zeta_{\mathrm{cold}}\equiv\frac{\mathrm{d\ ln}R_{\mathrm{cold}}}{\mathrm{d\ ln}m}\approx-1/3. (3) For the expansion rate of the binary Roche radius, the response to mass loss only depends on mass ratio q [ 5 ] \zeta_{\mathrm{RL}}\equiv\frac{\mathrm{d\ ln}\left(R_{\mathrm{RL}}/a_{\mathrm{RL}}\right)}{\mathrm{d\ ln}m}=\frac{(q+1)}{3}\frac{2\log\left(q^{1/3}+1\right)-{q^{1/3}}/({q^{1/3}+1})}{\left(0.6q^{2/3}+\log\left(q^{1/3}+1\right)\right)}. (4) This can be approximated by \zeta_{\mathrm{RL}}\approx 1/3 [ 6 ] . There is a critical mass ratio, q_{\mathrm{crit}} below which |\zeta_{\mathrm{cold}}|<|\zeta_{\mathrm{RL}}| . In this case, mass transfer is stable. This is given by [ 7 ] q_{\mathrm{crit}}=1+\frac{\zeta_{\mathrm{cold}}-\zeta_{\mathrm{RL}}}{2}\approx 2/3. (5) According to this dynamical mass transfer stability criteria for completely degenerate white dwarfs (Equation ( 5 )), more equal mass ratios than q>2/3 lead to merger. Less equal mass binaries ( q<2/3 ) are stable and can therefore survive as AM CVn binaries. Analytic models have extended the stability boundary of Equation ( 5 ) to include e.g. mass accretion destabilizing mass transfer. For example, [ 2 ] accounts for the possibility of super Eddington accretion, and predicts q_{\mathrm{crit}}<2/3 , i.e. more mergers. Next, [ 8 ] account for angular momentum exchange facilitated by tidal torques, and find cases where it can stabilize, and also destabilize an otherwise stable, or unstable binary. The precise q_{\mathrm{crit}} depends on the strength of tidal coupling and also the mode of mass transfer (disc or direct impact). But in any case, all scenarios result in q_{\mathrm{crit}}\leq 2/3 . Finally, these criteria can be applied to theoretical predictions for the Galactic DWDB population. For example, DWDB component masses from Galactic population synthesis are shown in [ 2 ] ’s Fig. 1 and [ 9 ] ’s Fig 7. The most populated region in m_{D} , m_{A} space is just below the theoretical m_{D}/m_{A}=q_{\mathrm{crit}}=2/3 boundary, with m_{D} (donor) roughly between 0.18-0.26 M_{\odot} and m_{A} (accretor) between 0.30-0.50 M_{\odot} . In other words, most predicted Galactic DWDBs are low q systems with q<2/3 which survive as AM CVn systems. This is not consistent with observations. For example, the rates of AM CVn given by the ELM (Extremely Low Mass) WD survey [ 10 ] are a factor of 10 smaller than the rate of DWDB mergers [ 11 ] . Assuming that we understand selection effects associated with calculating these rates, it is challenging to mediate this discrepancy if the interacting DWDB survival rate is given by Equation ( 5 ), and if population synthesis estimates for DWDB are accurate. One explanation for relatively low AM CVn birth rates could be that most DWDBs can not survive as AM CVn due to the accretor (not donor) response [ 12 ] . Recent advances in the detection of detached DWDBs by eclipsing methods [ 13 ] reveal a hot and large population of He WD in short period DWDB which will interact within a Hubble time (orbital period P_{\mathrm{orb}}\lesssim 1 hr). If the Galactic population of DWDBs typically has hot and large donors at the onset of mass transfer [ 14 ] , then the basic assumption leading to Equation ( 5 )– that Helium white dwarfs have cooled to be degenerate (Equation ( 1 )) at the onset of mass transfer may not be valid. There are also recent exciting discoveries of DWDBs undergoing mass transfer. In particular, ZTF J0127+5258 [ 15 ] is the first ever detection of a mass transferring eclipsing DWDB with the donor temperature measured, which is 16,400 K. In addition, its measured period derivative \dot{P}_{\mathrm{orb}} is negative. In principle, the measured \dot{P}_{\mathrm{orb}} can be used in conjunction with other observables (e.g. radial velocity curves) to constrain binary properties and the mass transfer rate. In Table 1 we show two cases for the inferred properties of ZTF J0127+5258. The first row corresponds to the case of a 0.15+0.75M_{\odot} binary used for the light curve fitting. The second row corresponds to the inferred masses assuming a mass transfer rate, given the measured period derivative. Table 1: Properties of ZTF J0127+5258 from [ 15 ] . The first row are the masses and donor radius assumed for light curve fitting, assuming that the donor fills its Roche Lobe and that the accretor has a disc. The second row is the inferred masses and donor radius, combining binary evolution models for mass loss and the measured orbital period derivative. Mass estimation case m_{D} ( M_{\odot} ) m_{A} ( M_{\odot} ) R ( R_{\odot} )

Read the complete text