On the analytical behavior of the k k – ω \omega turbulence model in buoyant-driven thermal convection
Da-Sol Joo · 2025
Read On the analytical behavior of the k k – ω \omega turbulence model in buoyant-driven thermal convection by Da-Sol Joo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01308.txt.
Introduction
Da-Sol Joo studies how heat-driven flow is modeled in fluids. When a fluid is heated from below, it churns in rolls. This setup is called Rayleigh-Benard convection. Models of churn must add the push of warm, light fluid, but no set form is agreed on.
Joo works out an exact solution for a common churn model in a flat layer. In that layer, churn is fed by heat push alone. An exact case gives model builders a firm check. It shows where the model holds and where its terms for heat push need a fix.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Da-Sol Joo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 100 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01308
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the analytical behavior of the k k – ω \omega turbulence model in buoyant-driven thermal convection Da-Sol Joo Abstract The representation of buoyancy-driven turbulence in Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes models remains unresolved, with no widely accepted standard formulation. A key difficulty is the lack of analytical guidance for incorporating buoyant effects, particularly under unstable stratification. This study derives an analytical solution of the standard k k – ω \omega model for Rayleigh–Bénard convection in an infinite layer, where turbulent kinetic energy is generated solely by buoyancy. The solution provides explicit scaling relations among the Rayleigh ( 𝑅𝑎 \mathit{Ra} ), Prandtl ( 𝑃𝑟 \mathit{Pr} ), and Nusselt ( 𝑁𝑢 \mathit{Nu} ) numbers that capture the simulation trends: 𝑁𝑢 ∼ 𝑅𝑎 1 / 3 𝑃𝑟 1 / 3 \mathit{Nu}\sim\mathit{Ra}^{1/3}\mathit{Pr}^{1/3} for 𝑃𝑟 ≪ 1 \mathit{Pr}\ll 1 and 𝑁𝑢 ∼ 𝑅𝑎 1 / 3 𝑃𝑟 − 0.415 \mathit{Nu}\sim\mathit{Ra}^{1/3}\mathit{Pr}^{-0.415} for 𝑃𝑟 ≫ 1 \mathit{Pr}\gg 1 . This framework quantifies the discrepancies in the conventional buoyancy treatment and clarifies their origin. Informed by this analysis, the buoyancy-related modelling terms are reformulated to recover the measured 𝑁𝑢 \mathit{Nu} – 𝑅𝑎 \mathit{Ra} – 𝑃𝑟 \mathit{Pr} trends. Only two dimensionless algebraic functions are introduced, which vanish in the absence of buoyancy, ensuring full compatibility with the standard closure. The corrected model is validated across a range of buoyancy-driven flows, including two-dimensional Rayleigh–Bénard convection, internally heated convection in two configurations, unstably stratified Couette flow, and vertically heated natural convection with varying aspect ratios. Across all cases, it provides highly accurate predictions. \lefttitle D-.S. Joo \righttitle Journal of Fluid Mechanics \corresau D-.S. Joo, keywords Bénard convection, Turbulence modelling, Turbulent convection 1 Introduction Buoyancy-driven turbulence is common in nature, spanning the oceans and atmosphere, and central to engineering, including indoor ventilation and nuclear safety. For such flows, Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) closures remain widely used in engineering applications owing to their favourable accuracy-to-cost ratio, with two-equation models such as the standard k – \varepsilon and k – \omega formulations being particularly common. References and review works on buoyancy-related RANS modelling can be found in 37 ; 47 ; 48 ; 25 ; 8 ; 34 ; 14 ; 22 ; 15 ; 23 . In natural convection, temperature acts as an active scalar that modifies the momentum field through buoyancy. The exact transport equation for turbulent kinetic energy ( k ) contains an explicit buoyancy-production term proportional to the inner product between the turbulent heat flux and gravity; the term is negative in stable stratification and positive in unstable stratification. Because the modelled k equation in both k – \varepsilon and k – \omega frameworks is derived from this exact equation, it is standard to include buoyant production in k . The central controversy concerns the scale-determining equation—namely, the dissipation ( \varepsilon ) or dissipation-per-unit- k ( \omega ) equation—which is usually the sole source of buoyancy-related modelling terms in two-equation RANS closures. As summarised in reference works ( 8 ; 22 ) and articles ( 26 ; 44 ; 24 ; 23 ) , there is no universally accepted prescription for representing buoyancy at this level. Broadly, two lines of work can be distinguished. One omits any buoyant contribution from the scale-determining equation. The rationale is that shear production there can be motivated by canonical shear-flow analyses, whereas an analogous justification for a buoyant counterpart in \varepsilon or \omega is lacking ( 38 ) . The other line of work adds a buoyancy term to the scale-determining equation, modelling it by analogy with shear production and using the same functional form as the shear-production term in the \varepsilon - or \omega -equation. As described by 24 , in flows such as Rayleigh–Bénard convection, where shear production is nearly zero but buoyant production dominates, omitting the buoyant-production term from the \varepsilon equation can render \varepsilon a pure sink; when combined with finite buoyant production in k , this may lead to unphysical growth of k . A number of empirical blends have also been proposed for specific regimes ( 47 ; 48 ; 26 ; 24 ; 44 ) . A frequently cited guideline is to suppress buoyant contributions under stable stratification while adding them under unstable stratification, using the same functional form as the shear-production term ( 48 ) . Each of these studies explicitly acknowledged the empirical nature of their proposed treatments, and the proper representation of buoyancy in two-equation RANS closures remains an open issue. The lack of a unified criterion arises from the absence of theoretical analyses that establish how standard two-equation closures behave in canonical, buoyancy-dominated flows. In contrast, in shear-driven canonical flows, the analytical behaviour of standard RANS models is well established: they reproduce classical results—the logarithmic velocity law with the von Kármán constant, boundary-layer scaling, spreading rates of free-shear flows, and self-similarity in homogeneous shear and decaying turbulence. Such benchmarks have served both to justify the formulation of the models and to calibrate their coefficients ( 52 ; 46 ; 61 ) . Specifically, to the author’s knowledge, analytical criteria are available for modelling stably stratified flows, whereas corresponding criteria for unstable stratification remain scarce. In the stable regime, linear-stability analyses of stably stratified shear flows provide a clear physical measure of flow suppression, commonly formulated in terms of the flux Richardson number. This quantity, defined locally as the ratio of buoyant to shear production, attains a critical value of \mathit{Ri}_{f}=0.25 , beyond which stratification begins to stabilise the shear flow. Owing to this well-established threshold, \mathit{Ri}_{f} has long served as a practical modelling reference ( 17 ; 14 ) , guiding the selection of model constants in k – \varepsilon closures ( 7 ) and informing explicit algebraic closures for stable stratification ( 35 ) . By contrast, in unstably stratified buoyant flows, an appropriate model should account for the rate at which potential energy associated with density variations is converted into the kinetic energy of thermal plumes—a mechanism fundamentally different from shear production. In homogeneous shear flow, the dynamics are primarily governed by the shear rate S , k , and \varepsilon , yielding the local similarity relation \varepsilon/k\sim S , which is widely accepted as a standard modelling benchmark ( 46 ; 61 ) . For buoyant effects, however, evidence for such purely local self-similarity is scarce. This scarcity is often cited as an indirect justification for omitting a buoyancy term from the scale-determining equation, as in 38 . Instead, similarity in buoyant flows is typically expressed through global power-law relations among the Nusselt ( \mathit{Nu} ), Rayleigh ( \mathit{Ra} ), and Prandtl ( \mathit{Pr} ) numbers—for example, the relation \mathit{Nu}\sim\mathit{Ra}^{0.31} reported over 10^{6}\lesssim\mathit{Ra}\lesssim 10^{17} for \mathit{Pr}\approx 0.7 ( 40 ) . Because these relations depend on global temperature differences and a domain-scale length, the assessment of buoyancy effects in two-equation closures is more appropriately undertaken through domain-integrated analyses than through purely local arguments. Against this background, the present study adopts one-dimensional Rayleigh–Bénard convection as a canonical test bed for analysing buoyancy effects in the 61 k – \omega model. In this configuration, the mean flow vanishes and the turbulent kinetic energy budget is governed solely by buoyant production, thereby isolating the role of the buoyancy term in the \omega equation. This