Virtual Observability in Sequential Play

C. Monica Capra, Charles A. Holt, Po-Hsuan Lin · 2025

Read Virtual Observability in Sequential Play by C. Monica Capra, Charles A. Holt, Po-Hsuan Lin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01244.txt.

Introduction

C Monica Capra, Charles Holt, and Po-Hsuan Lin run experiments on timing and choices in a 2025 economics paper. In sequential play, one player moves first and another follows. When those moves are unobservable to each other, classic theory might suggest timing should not matter, since no information changes hands.

The authors test that idea, called virtual observability. Knowing who moves first can still shape expectations and choices, even when nothing is revealed. Their experimental evidence examines how strongly this timing effect changes behavior. The result matters for auctions, negotiations, and market design, where move order is a lever designers control.

Catalog record

CREATORC. Monica Capra, Charles A. Holt, Po-Hsuan Lin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01244

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Virtual Observability in Sequential Play Thanks: We thank Seong-Gyu Park for research assistantship; Ala Avoyan, Meng-Jhang Fong, David Gill, Thomas R. Palfrey, Stephanie W. Wang, and audiences at the 2025 WEAI annual conference and the 2025 North American Conference of the Economic Science Association for their valuable comments. This study was approved by the Claremont Graduate University IRB (protocol #5149). C. Monica Capra, Charles A. Holt, Po-Hsuan Lin Abstract When players make sequential decisions that are unobservable to one another, their behavior can nonetheless be influenced by knowing who moves first. This sequential structure, often referred to as “virtual observability,” suggests that timing alone can shape expectations and choices, even when no information is revealed. The original notion of virtual observability, however, is an equilibrium refinement based on the timing structure and has no bite in games with a unique equilibrium. In this paper, we experimentally examine whether timing still affects behavior in such games, using the Traveler’s Dilemma and the Trust Game. We find that in the sequential Traveler’s Dilemma without observability, first movers tend to behave closer to the equilibrium prediction than in the simultaneous version. In contrast, timing without observability has no effect on behavior in the Trust Game. JEL Classification Number: C92 Keywords: Virtual Observability, Traveler’s Dilemma, Trust Game, Magical Thinking Simply knowing that others have moved earlier is cognitively similar to having observed what they did. —Colin F. Camerer ( 9 ), p. 177 1 Introduction Consider a simple strategic interaction: you must decide whether to cooperate or defect, knowing that another player faces the same choice. If you move first and the other player moves second, but cannot observe your choice, does the timing matter? Standard game theory says “no,” since your action is unobservable, the other player’s decision cannot depend on your actual choice. Indeed, the sequential game with unobservable actions has the same strategic structure as the simultaneous game, and behavior should be identical. Yet, the invariance prediction does not match intuition. As a first mover, one might reason: “Even though the other player cannot see my choice, she will anticipate what I did, and if she anticipates I cooperate, she will cooperate too.” This reasoning treats the second mover as if she could observe the first mover’s action because the timing structure makes such an inference psychologically salient. The first mover behaves as if her choice casts a shadow forward in time, influencing the second mover’s expectations and responses. Colin Camerer introduced the general idea of Virtual Observability as: “…Simply knowing that others have moved earlier is cognitively similar to having observed what they did.” ( 9 , p. 177) . In a later study, 26 formalized the intuition behind virtual observability as an equilibrium refinement. Their approach proceeds as follows: (i) fix a game of imperfect information in which previous moves are unobservable; (ii) maintaining the temporal order of moves, assume that all previous moves are observable; (iii) find any subgame-perfect equilibria of the game with observable moves; (iv) If any such equilibrium is also a Nash equilibrium of the original game, then select this equilibrium of the original game; (v) otherwise, timing will not affect play. This refinement embodies two essential elements: virtual observable subgame perfection, which assumes that prior moves are virtually observable, and the Game-Nash refinement, which ensures that an equilibrium with virtually observable moves is also a Nash equilibrium of the original game. The latter prevents behavior from being pulled away from the Nash equilibrium. In this paper, we distinguish the Virtual Observability Refinement from a more general perspective that we call General Virtual Observability . Under General Virtual Observability, first movers adjust their behavior based on the assumption that prior moves are virtually observable, as in step (iii), without imposing the Game-Nash Requirement of step (iv) . The difference between the two concepts can be illustrated in the context of a weak prisoner’s dilemma shown in Figure 2 . In this game, mutual cooperation would yield the highest payoffs for both players, but it is weakly dominated. If player 1 moves first and player 2 moves second without observing 1’s actions, standard game theory predicts no change; the equilibrium remains mutual defection. However, player 1 may reason that his move is virtually observable and behave as if player 2 will best respond to his observed action, even though this belief is inconsistent with the Nash equilibrium of the original game. This distinction matters in games with a unique Nash equilibrium like this one: the Virtual Observability Refinement predicts no timing effects , since virtual observability is not a Nash equilibrium of the original game, whereas General Virtual Observability allows behavior to deviate from the Nash predictions. In our study, we use laboratory experiments to assess which of these perspectives better explains the behavior of financially motivated participants. We investigate this question using two canonical games: the Traveler’s Dilemma ( 4 ; 10 ) and a modified Trust Game ( 5 ) . Both games feature unique Nash equilibrium, making them ideal for distinguishing between the Virtual Observability Refinement and the General Virtual Observability perspectives on sequential moves with unobservable actions. In our experiment, we implement two versions of the Traveler’s Dilemma: a simultaneous version and a sequential version with unobservable actions. Under General Virtual Observability, a first mover who believes the second mover will undercut should claim the maximum. In the modified Trust Game, an investor and trustee make decisions about how much to invest and return, with transfers occurring only if the return meets a minimum threshold. We implement two sequential versions: investor-first and trustee-first, both with unobservable actions. Under General Virtual Observability, timing should matter asymmetrically: an investor who moves first and believes the trustee will match should invest fully, while a trustee who moves first should return nothing regardless of beliefs about virtual observability. We employ a within-subject design whereby participants made one-shot decisions in all four games without feedback. In the Traveler’s Dilemma, we find significant evidence of timing effects: first movers claim less than second movers on average (5.57 vs. 6.14), and first movers choose the equilibrium claim at significantly higher rates (37% vs. 15%). This pattern is inconsistent with the Virtual Observability Refinement, which predicts no timing effects. Interestingly, the direction also differs from General Virtual Observability’s prediction of maximum claims. Instead of moving away from Nash equilibrium, first movers appear to become more strategically sophisticated, moving toward the Nash equilibrium. In contrast, the Trust Game exhibits no significant timing effect. Neither investor nor trustee behavior varies systematically with move order. This null result echoes 26 , who found only modest timing effects in ultimatum bargaining, and suggests that virtual observability may be muted in games where other-regarding preferences dominate strategic considerations. Our findings contribute to the literature in several ways. First, we demonstrate that timing effects can emerge in games with unique Nash equilibria, extending the domain of virtual observability beyond coordination games. Second, we show that neither the Virtual Observability Refinement nor General Virtual Observability fully captures observed behavior—timing matters, but not always in the predicted direction. Third, we document an important boundary condition: timing effects appear stronger in the Traveler’s Dilemma than in the Trust Game,

Read the complete text