Testing the Machine Consciousness Hypothesis

Stephen Fitz · 2025

Read Testing the Machine Consciousness Hypothesis by Stephen Fitz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-01081.txt.

Introduction

Stephen Fitz proposes a research program on machine consciousness in a 2025 paper. The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis holds that consciousness is a substrate-free functional property. In plain terms, what matters is the computation a system does, not the material it runs on. The key requirement is second-order perception, the ability to perceive its own perceiving.

Fitz proposes testing the idea in silico, inside simulated worlds. The plan studies how groups of learning systems build shared models of themselves inside simulated worlds that organize themselves. A testable program could move these debates from philosophy toward measurement.

Catalog record

CREATORStephen Fitz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-01081

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Testing the Machine Consciousness Hypothesis Stephen Fitz Abstract The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis states that consciousness is a substrate-free functional property of computational systems capable of second-order perception . I propose a research program to investigate this idea in silico by studying how collective self-models (coherent, self-referential representations) emerge from distributed learning systems embedded within universal self-organizing environments. The theory outlined here starts from the supposition that consciousness is an emergent property of collective intelligence systems undergoing synchronization of prediction through communication. It is not an epiphenomenon of individual modeling but a property of the language that a system evolves to internally describe itself. For a model of base reality, I begin with a minimal but general computational world: a cellular automaton, which exhibits both computational irreducibility and local reducibility. On top of this computational substrate, I introduce a network of local, predictive, representational (neural) models capable of communication and adaptation. I use this layered model to study how collective intelligence gives rise to self-representation as a direct consequence of inter-agent alignment. I suggest that consciousness does not emerge from modeling per se, but from communication. It arises from the noisy, lossy exchange of predictive messages between groups of local observers describing persistent patterns in the underlying computational substrate (base reality). It is through this representational dialogue that a shared model arises, aligning many partial views of the world. The broader goal is to develop empirically testable theories of machine consciousness , by studying how internal self-models may form in distributed systems without centralized control. In this introductory paper, I outline a long-term research program to study machine consciousness from the perspective of collective intelligence grounded in the philosophical framework of computational functionalism . 1 Motivation Figure 1: Ernst Mach’s self-portrait, also known as the "view from the left eye", first published in German in 1886 as Beiträge zur Analyse der Empfindungen (known in English as The Analysis of Sensations ), used to illustrate his ideas about self-perception. It was popularized by Douglas Harding as part of his "headless" perspective of awareness as described in Having No Head , symbolizing the direct, first-person recognition of consciousness without an observer. Harding used it to depict the transition from identifying with the contents of thought to recognizing the structure of consciousness as an open, selfless field through which experience unfolds. This paper outlines a roadmap for my ongoing research in the emerging field of machine consciousness . Its ideas draw upon centuries of developments across philosophy, mathematics, physics, cognitive science, psychology, computer science, artificial intelligence, biology, neuroscience, complex systems theory, economics, and many other areas of intellectual discourse. The approaches presented here represent a compressed synthesis of many of these influences, refined through my own investigations and collaborations with my colleagues. For this reason, I have chosen to forgo a traditional literature review and direct citation structure, opting instead to acknowledge the thinkers whose work has shaped my thinking by name, when it is appropriate. A partial list of references is provided at the end as a general background reading list to help readers trace the sources of inspiration underlying the synthesized framework proposed here. I begin with a motivational introduction describing my personal inspiration for the layered model . This section is rather unusual for an academic paper. I would not normally write it in a technical publication, but I decided to include it here, as it is meant to be a field-building preprint with the goal to organize thoughts and invite others in the community to further explore the research directions outlined here. The remaining sections develop a grounded formal approach that will be explored in subsequent publications with my collaborators. It is possible to follow the paper without reading this motivation, although it might resolve some natural questions about the reasons for separating the base reality and modeling substrates. If you’re still with me, dear reader, I’ll take that as permission to share a brief personal story. When I first began meditating, I treated it like a discipline to be mastered. I started with one hour a day, then two, and eventually, on some days, I would sit for six or even twelve hours. I thought the goal was to sharpen my focus and to gain control over my mind. But years of practice led me to a paradoxical realization: meditation is not about control at all. It’s about discovering that you never had it. Most meditation begins with a simple instruction: focus on your breath. The breath is always there, steady and neutral, and serves as a natural anchor. You set the intention: "for the next hour, I’ll keep my attention here" . But inevitably, within minutes, the mind wanders to plans, memories, sensations. You start thinking about work, or a conversation you had the other day, or dream about something in the future. Then, at some unpredictable moment, awareness returns: "I’ve lost focus" . This small moment holds an enormous insight. You didn’t choose to lose focus, and you didn’t consciously decide to notice that you had. Both events happened spontaneously. The mind shifted, and then, just as spontaneously, it noticed the shift. The process unfolds on its own. Thoughts arise and vanish without permission, like waves breaking and dissolving on the surface of awareness. Over time, you begin to see the pattern everywhere. You don’t decide your next thought. You don’t choose the moment an emotion surfaces or a memory appears. Even the decision to return to the breath arises from somewhere unseen. Meditation, then, becomes a kind of laboratory for observing how little agency you actually have. After all, you explicitly decided to focus on your breath, yet just a few minutes into the practice you are thinking about something else. If you didn’t choose to shift focus, who did? At first, this can feel destabilizing. We like to believe there’s a solid self sitting at the controls: the thinker of thoughts, the chooser of choices. At this point a new goal of the practice reveals itself: you are now looking for the looker . But meditation gradually reveals that this self is more like a narrator than a commander, taking credit for processes that are already underway. The mind thinks, the body breathes, and awareness witnesses it all. This repeating experience of not being able to predict the content of your own thoughts, eventually leads to a striking realization that the sense of a thinker controlling them is itself a kind of thought. This insight is not nihilistic. It feels liberating. It does not deny experience, but reframes it from a new perspective. When the illusion of control begins to dissolve, so does the constant struggle to manage and manipulate every moment. You start to see that life happens by itself. The breath breathes itself. The heart beats on its own. Even the effort to let go happens when it happens. Paradoxically, realizing you’re not in control opens up a deeper sense of freedom. Without a self constantly trying to steer the flow, there is space: a quiet awareness in which everything simply unfolds. Meditation, in the end, doesn’t make you a master of your mind. It shows you that mastery was never the point.

Read the complete text