Newsvendor Decisions under Stochastic and Strategic Uncertainties: Theory and Experimental Evidence
Hang Wu, Qin Wu, Yue Liu, Mengmeng Shi · 2025
Read Newsvendor Decisions under Stochastic and Strategic Uncertainties: Theory and Experimental Evidence by Hang Wu, Qin Wu, Yue Liu, Mengmeng Shi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00994.txt.
Introduction
Hang Wu, Qin Wu, Yue Liu, and Mengmeng Shi study inventory choices under two kinds of doubt in a 2025 paper. A newsvendor must order stock before knowing demand: order too much and goods spoil, too little and sales are lost. Online commerce has raised the stakes for pricing and stocking together.
The authors model a sequential game between two competing retailers. Each first sets prices in public, then chooses inventory in private, while demand stays uncertain. They back the theory with experimental evidence. The setup mirrors leading e-commerce platforms, where rivals watch prices but hide stock. Results show how strategic play changes classic ordering rules.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hang Wu, Qin Wu, Yue Liu, Mengmeng Shi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 92 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00994
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Newsvendor Decisions under Stochastic and Strategic Uncertainties: Theory and Experimental Evidence Hang Wu, Qin Wu, Yue Liu, Mengmeng Shi Abstract The rapid expansion of digital commerce platforms has amplified the strategic importance of coordinated pricing and inventory management decisions among competing retailers. Motivated by practices on leading e-commerce platforms, we analyze a sequential duopolistic newsvendor game where retailers first publicly set prices and subsequently make private inventory decisions under demand uncertainty. Our theory predicts that higher profit margins and demand uncertainty intensify price competition, while optimal inventory responses to demand uncertainty are shaped by profit margins. Laboratory evidence, however, reveals that participants are generally reluctant to compete on price, frequently coordinating on salient focal (reserve) prices, particularly in low-margin settings, and show little sensitivity to demand uncertainty in pricing. On the inventory side, participants’ order quantities are largely insensitive to chosen prices and continue to exhibit well-documented Pull-to-Center biases. These findings reveal a disconnect between pricing and inventory decisions under competition and highlight the importance of accounting for persistent behavioral tendencies in retail operations. 1 Introduction The growth of digital commerce platforms has elevated the importance of coordinating pricing and inventory decisions under both strategic and stochastic uncertainty. On platforms such as Amazon, sellers participating in high-profile sales events like Prime Day or Lightning Deals typically announce prices in advance while adjusting inventory closer to the sales window. Publicly posted prices act as strategic commitments that determine how demand is allocated across competing sellers. Inventory is then chosen privately after prices are observed, but before demand is realized. A similar structure is found in the fast-growing live-streaming commerce sector, on platforms such as Taobao Live and Douyin, where retailers compete for consumer attention on a daily basis. In these marketplaces, sellers often pre-announce prices ahead of scheduled broadcasts through shop listings or stream previews, then adjust inventory in response to anticipated traffic. These settings illustrate a broader operational challenge that retailers coordinate two interdependent decisions, price and inventory. Two features of such markets are important for understanding retailers’ behavior: profit margins and demand volatility. Across product categories, margins range from thin markups on everyday items to substantial markups on limited-release goods. The degree of demand uncertainty also varies considerably, from relatively stable demand for frequently purchased items to more volatile demand for new or event-based products. These two features jointly determine how retailers balance strategic and operational incentives. Higher margins increase the value of avoiding stockouts, while higher demand volatility increases inventory risk. How retailers balance these forces when price is chosen strategically and inventory is chosen under demand uncertainty is not yet well understood. We study a sequential duopoly newsvendor game that captures these institutional features in a tractable way. Two retailers first set prices simultaneously. After observing each other’s prices, they choose inventory levels. Each retailer faces a demand function with two parts: a deterministic component allocated based on relative prices, and a stochastic shock that captures demand uncertainty. The deterministic allocation mechanism is grounded in classic search-theoretic models of price competition ( 45 ; 50 ; see 6 for a review). In these models, a fixed population of consumers allocates across sellers according to posted prices. A segment of consumers, known as “searchers”, actively search for the lowest price and always purchase from the retailer offering the lower price. The remaining “non-searchers” simply buy from the first store they encounter, provided the price is below their reservation value. Hence the lower-priced seller captures the searchers whereas the higher-priced seller serves the residual non-search segment. In line with the clearinghouse literature, we assume that the total market size is fixed. This assumption allows us to focus on how relative prices divide a given buyer pool across competing sellers and how this division interacts with inventory choices under demand uncertainty. If total demand depended on prices, price changes would affect market participation in addition to reallocating buyers across sellers. These mechanisms lead to different strategic considerations. Our analysis concentrates on the allocation mechanism because it determines the likelihood that a seller faces the high-demand or low-demand segment, and this likelihood is the object that interacts with inventory decisions in our setting. Fixing total demand allows us to study this interaction cleanly and to generate predictions that can be evaluated experimentally. Although participation responses matter in other environments, empirically, short selling horizons often feature a fixed buyer pool largely determined by external factors such as event timing or platform exposure. Hence, prices primarily influence which seller buyers choose rather than whether they enter the market. We characterize the subgame-perfect Nash equilibrium of the sequential pricing and inventory game. In symmetric equilibrium, sellers mix over a continuous range of prices and then choose inventory conditional on the price. Equilibrium inventory is characterized by a critical-fractile rule as in the classical newsvendor model, with the critical ratio now endogenously determined by the seller’s price through its probability of capturing the high-demand segment. This structure yields clear comparative statics. Higher profit margins soften price competition and increase equilibrium inventories. Greater demand volatility shifts the mixed-strategy price distribution toward lower prices. The influence of volatility on inventory depends on the margin. At high margins, volatility raises optimal inventory, while at low margins it lowers it. We test these predictions in a laboratory experiment that follows the two-stage game. The design varies profit margin (high vs. low) by changing unit cost and demand volatility (high vs. low) by changing the width of the demand interval. The experimental evidence is mixed compared to the predictions. On the pricing side, participants use dispersed prices, consistent with mixed-strategy competition, and prices are systematically lower in high-margin than in low-margin treatments, as predicted. However, contrary to the theoretical prediction, prices frequently cluster at the reservation value, especially in low-margin markets. This clustering suggests coordination on a salient focal point that provides payoff safety under thin margins, in line with findings from earlier studies on equilibrium selection and coordination ( 19 ). Demand uncertainty has little effect on pricing behavior, consistent with evidence that individuals often fail to reason backward through stochastic and strategic contingencies ( 34 ; 21 ; 9 ). Inventory choices also deviate systematically from the equilibrium benchmark. Participants tend to overstock in low-margin conditions and understock in high-margin ones, consistent with the well-documented pull-to-center (PtC) bias ( 46 ; 12 ). The response to demand volatility is asymmetric. In low-margin treatments, higher uncertainty leads participants to reduce inventory, as predicted, while in high-margin treatments, inventories remain largely unresponsive. Our work contributes to the growing literature on joint pricing and inventory decisions under uncertainty. Prior work has established how price and inventory interact in monopolistic or simultaneous‐move settings ( 41 ; 53 ; 38 ), but little is known about how decision makers coordinate these choices when pricing is strategic and inventory is determined sequentially under demand risk. We study this problem in a tractable duopoly model in which mixed-strategy price competition determines the probability distribution over demand states, and inventory is chosen conditional on price. This structure links strategic pricing to stochastic inventory control and yields sharp comparative-static predictions that we bring to the laboratory. We document systematic departures from full coordination. Participants adjust inventory only