Symmetries at the origin of hierarchical emergence
Fernando E. Rosas · 2025
Read Symmetries at the origin of hierarchical emergence by Fernando E. Rosas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00984.txt.
Introduction
Fernando Rosas wrote a 2025 paper on why the world seems organized in layers. Many systems show nested emergent levels, each with its own rules: atoms, cells, organisms, societies. Our knowledge is naturally organized around those levels, and Rosas asks what creates that pattern.
He proposes that hierarchical emergence of this kind arises from underlying symmetries. When a system has the right symmetries, higher layers with their own regularities can appear. The paper develops that proposal as a general account of emergence. If correct, it would give scientists a shared principle for when new levels of description should exist.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Fernando E. Rosas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00984
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Symmetries at the origin of hierarchical emergence Fernando E. Rosas Abstract Many systems of interest exhibit nested emergent layers with their own rules and regularities, and our knowledge about them seems naturally organised around these levels. This paper proposes that this type of hierarchical emergence arises as a result of underlying symmetries. By combining principles from information theory, group theory, and statistical mechanics, one finds that dynamical processes that are equivariant with respect to a symmetry group give rise to emergent macroscopic levels organised into a hierarchy determined by the subgroups of the symmetry. The same symmetries happen to also shape Bayesian beliefs, yielding hierarchies of abstract belief states that can be updated autonomously at different levels of resolution. These results are illustrated in Hopfield networks and Ehrenfest diffusion, showing that familiar macroscopic quantities emerge naturally from their symmetries. Together, these results suggest that symmetries provide a fundamental mechanism for emergence and support a structural correspondence between objective and epistemic processes, making feasible inferential problems that would otherwise be computationally intractable. I Introduction Our ability to successfully navigate and learn about the world, despite the limitations imposed by ‘no free lunch’ theorems 68 ; 2 , suggests that our world has special properties that make this success possible. A key factor enabling this seems to be that the world displays nested yet distinct layers of organisation — a property often called emergence 40 ; 21 ; 18 . Emergence gives rise to a separation of scales that allows each level to exhibit its own rules and regularities, which can be learned while disregarding the activity of levels below 55 ; 48 . This hierarchical architecture is mirrored in the organisation of knowledge into scientific disciplines (physics \to chemistry \to biology \to sociology and economics), where each field abstracts away details of the levels below to form its own effective theories 8 . Emergence has been studied in statistical physics via phase transitions and renormalisation group theory, which provide a powerful framework that describes how separation of scales occurs and what the resulting emergent laws are (i.e., universality) 41 ; 67 ; 62 ; 25 . Complementing this work, a line of investigations inspired by theoretical neuroscience has focused on multiscale dynamics, characterising various aspects of emergence in terms of information-theoretic principles 60 ; 36 ; 56 ; 11 . These approaches provide rigorous tools to identify when emergent levels arise in general systems far from the thermodynamic limit, but have not yet identified fundamental principles that can explain how this happens. Furthermore, all of these approaches are limited in the degree to which they account for how emergence enhances learnability and inference. Building on these developments, this paper proposes symmetry — more precisely, dynamical equivariance — as a fundamental driver of hierarchical emergence in both objective and epistemic processes. The results presented here show that when the dynamics of a stochastic process commute with a symmetry group, they naturally induce coarse-grained variables whose evolution is informationally self-contained, so that microscopic details of their instantiation are irrelevant for predicting their future. Moreover, the algebraic structure of the symmetry group reveals a whole hierarchy of emergent variables. Each subgroup corresponds to a coarser or finer partition of the microscopic state space, and the subgroup lattice is mirrored by a partial order over informationally closed macroscopic levels. Crucially, the same symmetries that generate a hierarchy in objective processes also shape the structure of Bayesian beliefs held by an observer who only has partial access to the system. The hierarchical nature of these beliefs allows tracking macroscopic properties of high-dimensional systems while disregarding low-level details, making otherwise unfeasible inference problems tractable. These ideas are illustrated on paradigmatic models from statistical mechanics and computational neuroscience, where familiar macroscopic quantities (such as magnetisation or particle count) emerge exactly as informationally closed macroscopic processes naturally arising from underlying symmetries. II Symmetry and hierarchical emergence II.1 Emergence as informational closure Consider a system whose state is specified by the random variable X_{t}\in\mathscr{X} that is measured at discrete timepoints t\in\mathbb{Z} . A coarse-graining mapping \phi:\mathscr{X}\to\mathscr{Z} gives rise to another process Z_{t}=\phi(X_{t}) . This implies that any change in Z_{t} requires a change in X_{t} but not vice-versa — an asymmetry known as supervenience 45 . We call a coarse-graining Z_{t} emergent if, for the purpose of predicting the coarse-grained future \vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}=(Z_{t+1},\dots,Z_{t+L}) , knowing the past \mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t}=(\dots,X_{t-1},X_{t}) offers no advantage over knowing only the coarse-grained past \mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t}=(\dots,Z_{t-1},Z_{t}) , which implies that all relevant information has ‘moved up’ to the coarse-grained level. This idea can be operationalised via the condition of information closure 15 ; 19 , which requires that I\big(\mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t};\vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}\big)-I\big(\mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t};\vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}\big)=0\quad\forall L\in\mathbb{N},t\in\mathbb{Z}, (1) where I is Shannon’s mutual information. Information closure can be shown to be equivalent to \mathbb{E}\left\{\log\frac{p\big(\vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}|\mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t}\big)}{p\big(\vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}|\mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t}\big)}\right\}=0\quad\forall L\in\mathbb{N},t\in\mathbb{Z}. (2) As the above expression corresponds to a Kullback-Leibler divergence, this ensures that p\big(\vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}|\mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{X}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{X}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t}\big)=p\big(\vec{\bm{Z}}^{L}_{t+1}|\mathchoice{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\displaystyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\displaystyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 3.0mu\reflectbox{$\textstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-3.0mu\textstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 3.0mu$}}$}\mkern-3.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}{\mkern 2.0mu\reflectbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\vec{\reflectbox{$\mkern-2.0mu\scriptscriptstyle\bm{Z}\mkern 2.0mu$}}$}\mkern-2.0mu}_{t}\big) almost surely. This implies that the distinct initial conditions of the system that lead to different macroscopic outcomes can be effectively attained from a suitable macroscopic initial condition. Thus, information closure corresponds to self-contained levels of X_{t} whose regularities are suitable for being described in their own terms 55 ; 11 ; 19 . For this reason, in the sequel informationally closed coarse-grainings will be called ‘emergent levels’ or ‘macroscopic variables.’ Figure 1: Symmetry gives rise to simpler self-contained levels . (A) Dynamics of a Markov chain over 6 states, which respects symmetries equivalent to a triangle — known as the dihedral group of order 3, D_{3} . (B) Correspondence between the subgroups of D_{3} and the lattice of informationally closed levels of the Markov chain, which preserves the partial ordering. II.2 Dynamical symmetries Consider now a group G acting on X_{t} , so that there exist mappings g(\cdot):\mathscr{X}\to\mathscr{X} for all g\in G such that (g_{1}g_{2})\cdot x=g_{1}\cdot(g_{2}\!\cdot\!x) . A group action induces a partition on \mathscr{X} via ‘orbits’ of the form O_{x}:=\{x^{\prime}\in\mathscr{X}:g\!\cdot\!x=x^{\prime},g\in G\}. (3) This leads to the coarse-graining Z_{t}=\phi_{G}(X_{t}) given by \phi_{G}(x):=O_{x} 1 1 1 Any coarse-graining of a discrete state space can be seen as arising from a group in this manner. Consider a coarse-graining \phi corresponding to a partition with components C_{i} . Consider G_{i} the group of permutations of elements in C_{i} , and form G_{\phi}=\prod_{i\in\mathscr{I}}G_{i} their cartesian product. Then, the partition corresponds to the orbits of G_{\phi} . . For simplicity, the presentation will focus on finite groups G and discrete random variables. Under what conditions may the orbits of G generate an informationally closed level? To answer this, let us introduce the Reynolds operator 54 \mathscr{R}\{\mu\}=\frac{1}{|G|}\sum_{g\in G}g\!\cdot\!\mu, (4) which corresponds to averaging over all symmetry-equivalent versions of the dynamics. To investigate whether the dynamics respects symmetries, one can average the transition kernel over the group using the Reynolds operator to test if it behaves similarly across symmetry-related microstates. When applied on the conditional law over future blocks