Charge state equilibration of nitrogen-vacancy center ensembles in diamond: The role of electron tunneling
Audrius Alkauskas, Chris G. Van de Walle, Lukas Razinkovas, Ronald Ulbricht · 2025
Read Charge state equilibration of nitrogen-vacancy center ensembles in diamond: The role of electron tunneling by Audrius Alkauskas, Chris G. Van de Walle, Lukas Razinkovas, Ronald Ulbricht (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00952.txt.
Introduction
Audrius Alkauskas, Chris Van de Walle, Lukas Razinkovas, and Ronald Ulbricht study diamond defects in a 2025 paper. Nitrogen-vacancy centers are flaws in diamond where a nitrogen atom sits beside a missing carbon. They serve as quantum sensors and qubits, and their charge state decides how well they work.
Charge states can flip as electrons tunnel in and out, so ensembles of centers drift toward some balance over time. The authors examine that equilibration and the role of electron tunneling in reaching it. The lessons reach beyond diamond, to defects and impurities in wide-bandgap materials generally. Stable charge means steadier quantum devices.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Audrius Alkauskas, Chris G. Van de Walle, Lukas Razinkovas, Ronald Ulbricht |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00952
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Charge state equilibration of nitrogen-vacancy center ensembles in diamond: The role of electron tunneling Audrius Alkauskas, Chris G. Van de Walle, Lukas Razinkovas, Ronald Ulbricht Abstract The charge state stability of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers critically affects their application as quantum sensors and qubits. Understanding charge state conversion and equilibration is critical not only for NV centers in diamond but also for defects and impurities in wide-bandgap materials in general. The mechanisms by which these centers change charge state upon optical or electronic excitation without the presence of mobile carriers remain unclear, potentially affecting the performance of applications ranging from phosphors to power electronics. Here, we elucidate this issue for the case of photoionization of NV center ensembles. Using pump-probe spectroscopy, we ionize negatively charged NV centers and monitor the recovery of NV − \text{NV}^{-} on timescales of up to several seconds. We find that the recovery rate depends strongly on the concentration of surrounding nitrogen donors. Remarkably, the equilibration dynamics exhibit no discernible dependence on temperature, ruling out thermally activated processes. The multiphonon-assisted electron tunneling model, supported by density-functional calculations, explains the measurements and identifies tunneling as the equilibration mechanism. The nitrogen-vacancy ( NV ) center in diamond 15 has become a versatile platform for testing and implementing quantum technologies in sensing, communication, and computing 34 ; 22 ; 4 ; 8 ; 31 . The negatively charged state ( \text{NV}^{-} ) is pivotal for these applications because it offers the required optical and spin properties. Interactions with nearby deep-level dopants affect the equilibrium charge state of the NV center 12 . To establish the negative charge state, NV typically captures an electron from a neighboring single-substitutional nitrogen (N) defect, forming an \text{NV}^{-} – \text{N}^{+} pair 28 . Such charge transfer between deep-level defects cannot be explained by the Shockley-Read-Hall model 37 ; 20 , which depends on thermal excitation and carrier capture. For deep defects with high ionization energies, this mechanism is ineffective, suggesting that electron tunneling is responsible for the charge transfer 28 . Electron tunneling from the excited state of \text{NV}^{-} to nearby \text{N}^{+} defects has also been proposed as a mechanism for quenching \text{NV}^{-} photoluminescence (PL) 26 ; 9 . Related studies of direct inter-defect charge transfer in silicon 17 and tunneling through deep levels in quantum-dot heterostructures 36 highlight that tunneling between localized states can be highly efficient. Despite suggestions, there is a lack of experimental or theoretical evaluations. Understanding these mechanisms is essential for applications beyond the NV center, where optical or electronic excitation alters the charge state of deep defects or impurities in wide-bandgap semiconductors or insulators, such as phosphors, scintillators, or devices with (semi-) insulating layers. In this Letter, we investigate the charge equilibration dynamics of an ensemble of NV centers following photoionization, which converts \text{NV}^{-} centers to the neutrally charged \text{NV}^{0} state. Our transient spectroscopy results reveal that the recovery dynamics back to \text{NV}^{-} are governed by the concentration of N centers with no discernible dependence on temperature. We propose that the charge equilibration occurs via phonon-assisted electron tunneling between \text{N}^{0} and \text{NV}^{0} , facilitated by significant lattice relaxation of the N center. This hypothesis is supported by density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the electron–phonon interaction. We also provide a microscopic empirical model that replicates the observed dynamics and explains the lack of temperature dependence. Our approach should be applicable to other materials containing ensembles of deep-level defects, where electron tunneling serves as the mechanism for charge migration and equilibration. Optical excitation can photoionize \text{NV}^{-} by promoting an electron to the conduction band (CB), thereby converting \text{NV}^{-} to \text{NV}^{0} 5 ; 40 ; 3 ; 32 . The threshold for direct ionization is estimated to lie between 2.6 and 2.74 eV, based on both experimental 3 ; 7 and theoretical 13 ; 7 ; 32 studies. Time-resolved THz spectroscopy shows that electrons photoexcited from N to the CB recombine back to N within tens of picoseconds 44 ; 41 , indicating a strong recombination pathway. A similar recombination with N is likely to follow photoionization of NV . The ionization threshold of N from the neutral to the positively charged state is approximately 1.7 eV 30 ; 12 . The resulting model of the tunneling transition that equilibrates the charge after photoionization is depicted in Fig. 1 (a), illustrating the charge state transition (CST) levels: (0/-) for the NV center and (+/0) for the N defect. The tunneling of an electron from \text{N}^{0} to \text{NV}^{0} is an exothermic process that releases approximately 1 eV of energy. To establish a theoretical foundation for the tunneling process, we consider the multiphonon emission mechanism, which involves an energy-conserving transition followed by rapid vibrational relaxation to thermal equilibrium; this relaxation typically occurs on picosecond timescales 29 ; 43 . We employ a simplified microscopic model with three degrees of freedom: one for the electron and two for the vibrational motion associated with the NV center and the N donor, respectively. The charge tunneling rate between two spatially separated states in the coupled NV – N system is described by Fermi’s golden rule: \displaystyle\Gamma=\frac{2\pi}{\hbar}W_{fi}^{2}A(\Delta E;0), (1) where W_{fi} is the hopping matrix element representing the electronic charge transfer between the initial ( i ) and final ( f ) electronic states. The vibrational factor A(\Delta E,0) reflects the probability that the energy difference between the initial and final electronic states is entirely transferred to the vibrational system, allowing a non-radiative transition. This factor corresponds to the value of the normalized spectral function A(\Delta E;\hbar\omega) at \hbar\omega=0 , which describes the spectral density of phonon-assisted radiative transitions 21 ; 1 . In our model, this spectral function takes the form: \displaystyle A(\Delta E,\hbar\omega)= \displaystyle\sum_{mlnk}w_{m}(T)w_{l}(T)\left|\bigl\langle{\chi_{fn}^{\text{N}}}|{\chi_{im}^{\text{N}}}\bigr\rangle\left\langle\chi_{fk}^{\text{NV}}\middle|\chi_{il}^{\text{NV}}\right\rangle\right|^{2} \displaystyle\times\delta\left(\Delta E+\varepsilon_{i;ml}-\varepsilon_{f;nk}-\hbar\omega\right), (2) where \varepsilon_{i;ml} represents the vibrational energy of the system in the i electronic state, with N and NV having m and l excited phonons, respectively. The factors w_{l}(T) are Boltzmann weights that account for the temperature-dependent occupation of vibrational states. Figure 1: Phonon-assisted electron tunneling from \text{N}^{0} to NV 0 . (a) Exothermic charge transfer: the ionization threshold for \text{N}^{0} is 1.7 eV, and the energy released when the electron is captured by \text{NV}^{0} is about 2.7 eV. (b) Left: first-principles configuration coordinate (CC) potential energy surfaces of the N center. Inset: atomic structure of N0 with antibonding orbital isosurfaces in neutral state; arrows show atomic motion along the positive CC Q direction. Right: Optical spectral functions for the tunneling process at T=0 K and 300 K, where the value at E=0 corresponds to the vibrational factor A(\Delta E;0) in Eq. ( 1 ). The vibrational overlap integrals, \left\langle\chi_{fn}\middle|\chi_{il}\right\rangle , quantify the coupling between vibrational states in the initial and final electronic manifolds. This electron-phonon interaction is commonly characterized by the Huang–Rhys (HR) factor S 23 , which represents the average number of phonons excited during an electronic transition. For the NV center, the HR factor for the (0/-) charge-state transition is S\approx 1.3 32 , indicating a low probability of exciting more than two phonons. In contrast, the N defect exhibits much stronger electron-phonon coupling, with S\gg 1 16 , making it the dominant contributor to the lineshape function. This pronounced coupling arises from its structural configuration: \text{N}^{0}