Probing the Scalar Hair of Rotating Horndeski Black Holes through Thick Disk Images

Qian Wan, Yehui Hou, Minyong Guo · 2025

Read Probing the Scalar Hair of Rotating Horndeski Black Holes through Thick Disk Images by Qian Wan, Yehui Hou, Minyong Guo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00917.txt.

Introduction

Qian Wan, Yehui Hou, and Minyong Guo ask whether black hole photos can test new gravity ideas in a 2025 paper. Horizon-scale images of black holes may reveal more than the hole itself. They can probe black hole hair, extra fields a hole carries beyond mass, spin, and charge.

The team builds an analytic model of a thick, magnetized disk around a rotating black hole with scalar hair, in Horndeski theory. They then analyze what the disk would look like in a 230 gigahertz image. Comparing such images with telescope data could show whether scalar hair leaves a visible mark.

Catalog record

CREATORQian Wan, Yehui Hou, Minyong Guo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00917

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Probing the Scalar Hair of Rotating Horndeski Black Holes through Thick Disk Images Qian Wan, Yehui Hou, Minyong Guo Abstract Horizon-scale images of black holes provide a potential probe of fundamental physics, including tests of gravity and black hole hair. To assess the impact of scalar hair on accretion-flow imaging self-consistently, we construct an analytical model of a geometrically thick, magnetized disk around a rotating hairy black hole in Horndeski theory and analyze its 230 GHz image morphology. We find that scalar hair modestly alters the inflow and magnetic-field structure but strengthens gravitational redshift, markedly reducing the total flux and lensed ring brightness through relativistic transfer and spectral-shift effects. Moreover, we highlight a previously unexplored channel: the maximum interferometric diameter of the first photon ring responds strongly to the hair parameter but shows little dependence on accretion-flow details, making it a promising observable for constraining black - hole hair with future space-based interferometry. I Introduction Black holes are natural laboratories for testing gravitational theories and potential departures from the no-hair paradigm. In general relativity (GR), stationary black holes are completely specified by their mass, spin, and charge Israel:1967za ; Carter1971 ; Robinson:1975bv , motivating the exploration of extensions that introduce additional degrees of freedom while maintaining theoretical consistency. Nonminimal couplings or special dynamical fields can endow black holes with nontrivial scalar configurations Bekenstein:1974sf ; Sotiriou:2011dz ; Herdeiro:2014goa , which often concentrate near the horizon and can impact accretion dynamics and photon trajectories Cunha:2015yba . These effects may leave observable imprints in black hole images, which could be identified by next - generation very-long-baseline interferometry (VLBI) facilities such as the next-generation EHT Ayzenberg:2023hfw ; Johnson:2023ynn ; Tiede:2022grp and the Black Hole Explorer (BHEX) Johnson:2024ttr ; Lupsasca:2024xhq . In particular, BHEX will provide the angular resolution needed to probe the strongly lensed rings, which are especially sensitive to the underlying spacetime geometry. As the most general four-dimensional scalar-tensor theory with diffeomorphism invariance and second-order field equations, Horndeski theory provides a broad setting in which scalar hair may arise Horndeski:1974wa ; Kobayashi:2011nu . The theory is also widely employed in cosmology and astrophysics Gleyzes:2014dya ; Bellini:2014fua ; Kobayashi:2019hrl , combining theoretical generality with observational relevance. Recently, a spherically symmetric black hole solution with asymptotically flat behavior and logarithmic corrections sourced by scalar hair was obtained in Bergliaffa:2021diw . Its rotating counterpart was later constructed via the Newman-Janis algorithm Walia:2021emv and has since been explored in various contexts Seifi:2022xyw ; Jha:2022tdl ; Rayimbaev:2023bjs ; Donmez:2024gqb ; Ashraf:2024xwm ; Wu:2025ccc ; Zhen:2025nah ; Yang:2023lcm ; Lei:2023wlt ; Donmez:2024lfi ; Yang:2024cjf ; Carvajal:2025emj , including gravitational lensing Atamurotov:2022slw ; Bessa:2023ykd , black hole images Wang:2023vcv ; Hu:2023pyd ; Gao:2023mjb ; Heydari-Fard:2023kgf ; Sucu:2025vwy ; Meng:2025ivb ; Zeng:2025pch ; Heydari-Fard:2025biz , and polarization signatures under simplified emission models Shi:2024bpm ; Chen:2025ysv . Nonetheless, studies incorporating horizon-scale accretion flows and the corresponding imaging features remain limited. As the central engines of many low-luminosity active galactic nuclei, supermassive black holes are typically surrounded by magnetized, advection-dominated accretion flows (ADAFs) Narayan:1994xi ; Yuan:2014gma ; Blandford:1998qn ; Balbus:1991ay , where the plasma exhibits pronounced radial inflow and inefficient Coulomb coupling between ions and electrons Narayan:1995ic ; Mahadevan:1996jf ; Quataert:1998yn ; Yuan:2003dc . General-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations, though have highly computational demands, offer the most self-consistent approach currently to studying these accretion flows EventHorizonTelescope:2019pcy , and can be extended to explore dynamics in modified-gravity spacetimes Jiang:2023img ; Dihingia:2024cch ; Uniyal:2025hik ; Uniyal:2025uvc . At the same time, semi-analytic accretion models remain an important complementary tool, enabling rapid parameter exploration and controlled studies aimed at isolating individual physical effects Michel:1972oeq ; Page:1974he ; Popham:1998iw ; 2000ApJ…534..734M ; Broderick:2005my . However, many formulations in this class rely on simplifying assumptions—such as self - similar radial structure, geometric thinness, or nearly circular orbital motion—that are not generally valid in the strongly relativistic, horizon-proximate regime. Near the event horizon, gravity dominates the dynamics, making the ballistic approximation—treating the plasma motion as timelike geodesics—an effective and analytically tractable description of the flow Ulrich:1976zz ; Tejeda:2012kb ; Tejeda:2019lie . Using this approach, Hou:2023bep constructed a self-consistent model in Kerr spacetime, obtaining closed-form expressions for the density, temperature, and magnetic field by exploiting the separability of the geodesic equations Carter:1968rr . Building on this framework, we extend the analysis to rotating Horndeski black holes and investigate the associated implications for black hole imaging. We begin by examining how the scalar-hair parameter modulates key flow properties, including the density profile, thermal structure, and magnetic-field configuration. We then analyze the resulting observational signatures, such as the spatially resolved intensity maps, total flux, and the morphologies of the critical curve and inner shadow associated with this accretion flow. Particular attention is devoted to the influence of the hair parameter on the maximal interferometric diameter of the first photon ring Farah2025 , with emphasis on regimes that remain potentially accessible to BHEX observations. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Sec. II reviews the rotating hairy black hole solution in Horndeski theory and outlines the geodesic equations. Sec. III describes the accretion-flow model adopted in this work, including the density, temperature, and magnetic - field structures. Sec. IV presents a detailed analysis of the corresponding images and their observable features under various spacetime and flow parameters, while Sec. V specifically examines the constraining power of the first photon ring on black hole scalar hair. Sec. VI offers our concluding remarks. Throughout this paper, we adopt geometrized units with G=c=1 . II Rotating Horndeski Black Holes In this section, we briefly review the rotating hairy black hole solution in Horndeski theory and discuss the corresponding geodesic motion, which is essential for constructing the analytical disk model presented in the next section. II.1 The spacetime The rotating metric under study is obtained from the spherically symmetric solution in Horndeski theory via the Newman-Janis algorithm Walia:2021emv . In Boyer-Lindquist (BL) coordinates, it takes the form \displaystyle\begin{aligned} ds^{2}=&-\left(\frac{\Delta-a^{2}\sin^{2}\theta}{\Sigma}\right)dt^{2}+\frac{\Sigma}{\Delta}dr^{2}+\Sigma d\theta^{2}\\ &+\frac{2a\sin^{2}\theta}{\Sigma}\left[\Delta-(r^{2}+a^{2})\right]dtd\phi\\ &+\frac{\sin^{2}\theta}{\Sigma}\left[(r^{2}+a^{2})^{2}-\Delta a^{2}\sin^{2}\theta\right]d\phi^{2},\end{aligned} (1) where \Delta=r^{2}+a^{2}-2Mr+hr\ln(r/2M) , \Sigma=r^{2}+a^{2}\cos^{2}\theta . The spacetime is characterized by three parameters: the black-hole mass M , spin parameter a and scalar-hair parameter h . The hair parameter quantifies the deviation from the Kerr geometry. In the limit h\to 0 , Eq. ( 1 ) recovers the Kerr metric, whereas for a\to 0 , it reduces to the static spherical solution in Horndeski theory Bergliaffa:2021diw . The scalar hair contributes an additional gravitational potential around the black hole. From the metric form, an effective potential can be infered as \Phi\approx-\frac{M}{r}+\frac{h}{2r}\ln{\left(\f{r}{2M}\right)}\,. (2) There is a critical radius r=2\,\text{e}M\approx 5.4M , with e the base of the natural logarithm, at which the scalar force on test particles vanishes. For r>2\,\text{e}M , the scalar field exerts an attractive (repulsive) force toward the black hole when h\lessgtr 0 , corresponding respectively to dark-matter-like and dark-energy-like configurations. In what follows, we focus on the physically relevant, dark-matter-like case h\leq 0 . The metric in Eq. ( 1 ) features a Kerr-like ring singularity at \Sigma=0 . Outside it, the condition \Delta=0 typically yields two real roots defining the Cauchy and event horizons, r_{+}\geq r_{-} Afrin:2021wlj . Since \Delta(2M)=a^{2}\geq 0 , the event horizon lies inside it, r_{+}\leq 2M . As h decreases, the outer horizon radius r_{+}

Read the complete text