Super-Extensive Charging Power in the Absence of Global Operations

Anupam §, Sheryl Mathew §, Sibasish Ghosh · 2025

Read Super-Extensive Charging Power in the Absence of Global Operations by Anupam §, Sheryl Mathew §, Sibasish Ghosh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00788.txt.

Introduction

Anupam, Sheryl Mathew, and Sibasish Ghosh study quantum batteries in a 2025 physics paper. A quantum battery stores energy in a quantum system, and researchers hope quantum effects can charge it faster than any classical device. Many charging schemes claim such an advantage, called superextensive charging power.

What physical ingredients that advantage truly needs is still unclear. The authors examine whether it can appear without global operations, the costly controls that act on the whole system at once. Their answer shapes how realistic quantum batteries might be built. If local control suffices, lab devices become much more plausible.

Catalog record

CREATORAnupam §, Sheryl Mathew §, Sibasish Ghosh
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00788

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Super-Extensive Charging Power in the Absence of Global Operations Anupam §, Sheryl Mathew §, Sibasish Ghosh Abstract Quantum batteries have emerged as a platform for investigating whether quantum effects can accelerate energy storage beyond classical limits. Although a variety of charging schemes have reported signatures of quantum advantage, the fundamental physical requirements for achieving superextensive charging power remain insufficiently understood. Here, we show that, in addition to Hamiltonian locality, a key structural property, g g -extensiveness , quantifying the distribution of interaction energy across lattice sites places a fundamental bound on charging performance in spin-lattice models. We prove that superextensive power scaling is possible only when the interaction-energy distribution becomes increasingly nonuniform, with the maximal local weight growing with system size. This criterion explains why many previously studied protocols fail to exhibit superextensive power, even when the Hamiltonians involve large participation numbers. We further demonstrate that this condition is realized in an experimentally relevant interacting model, where, despite fixed interaction order, the charging power scales superextensively. Our results establish g g -extensiveness as a necessary resource for quantum advantage in direct-charging protocols and provide a systematic framework for identifying and engineering physically feasible quantum batteries capable of outperforming classical counterparts in charging power. Introduction.— Since the advent of the concept of quantum battery 10 ; 1 ; 46 ; 8 ; 7 ; 12 , a central question has been whether quantum effects can enable superextensive power scaling beyond classical limits. Although the distinction between classical and quantum batteries remains debated 3 , it is widely accepted that charging processes generating entanglement or coherence 21 ; 37 ; 10 ; 4 ; 10 ; 60 ; 13 ; 34 , thereby enhancing power, can be regarded as genuinely quantum. Recent studies have explored diverse battery–charger architectures in pursuit of such quantum advantage, which can be broadly classified into two paradigms. In direct-charging protocols 11 ; 49 ; 37 ; 25 ; 40 ; 17 ; 22 ; 24 ; 61 , the battery is initialized in the ground state of its Hamiltonian and then subjected to a sudden quench that drives the system toward excited states. In contrast, in charger-mediated protocols 21 ; 20 ; 18 ; 2 ; 14 ; 50 ; 52 ; 19 ; 58 ; 15 , the battery interacts with an auxiliary quantum system at higher energy, enabling energy transfer until the battery becomes charged. Only a few models are known to exhibit superextensive power scaling. Notably, atomic–photonic hybrid systems such as the Dicke model and its variants display superextensive behavior when thermodynamic consistency is relaxed and the battery–charger coupling lies in the ultrastrong regime 21 ; 14 ; 16 ; 57 . In this limit, the enhanced coupling mediates energy transfer that scales superextensively with system size. The Dicke model also serves as one of the few experimentally realized platforms demonstrating such enhancement 47 ; 39 ; 32 ; 31 ; 45 ; 33 . In contrast, within the direct-charging paradigm, the only model known to produce superextensive power is the fermionic Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev (SYK) model. The spin and bosonic counterparts of the SYK model, however, fail to exhibit this scaling 49 . The enhancement in the fermionic case has been attributed to the nonlocal nature of the Jordan–Wigner transformation, which maps the fermionic SYK model to its spin representation 10 . It is in this transformed representation that superextensive charging power is obtained. In this Letter, we show that, as a direct consequence of the g -extensivity condition 5 , superextensive power scaling cannot occur if g does not scale with system size, even when the charging Hamiltonian is highly nonlocal. Moreover, realizing interactions whose locality scales with the system size is exceedingly difficult in any experimental setting. This naturally leads to a key question: can one achieve superextensive power using a Hamiltonian of constant locality, while keeping both the battery and charger Hamiltonians energy-extensive? In this work, we answer this question affirmatively. We demonstrate that within an experimentally feasible model featuring constant locality and a simple quench protocol it is, in principle, possible to attain superextensive power scaling. (a) (b) Figure 1: Energy Transitions. (a) Heatmap of absolute values of transition matrix elements \|P[E_{a}]H_{C}P[E_{b}]\| for an Ising charger in the diagonal basis of a modified central-spin battery. Degenerate levels are grouped as projections onto energy subspaces of the battery Hilbert space. (b) Same as (a), but with the battery and charger Hamiltonians interchanged. Here, total number of sites is seven. Interaction Order and g -Extensivity of the Hamiltonian.— Here, we consider lattice models 41 with local dimension d , and total number of sites N . The sites are collectively denoted as a set \Lambda . The battery and charger Hamiltonians defined on them are q -local and k -local, respectively. A k -local Hamiltonian can be expressed as a sum of local terms 27 , H=\sum_{X}h_{X}, (1) where X\subseteq\Lambda denotes subsets of the lattice sites, and h_{X}=0 whenever |X|>k . This general structure encompasses both short-range and long-range Hamiltonians with interaction order k , since h_{X} need not involve only neighboring lattice sites. To quantify the strength of local contributions, we define for any Hamiltonian the parameter g as \max_{i}g_{i}=g,\qquad g_{i}=\sum_{X:X\ni i}\|h_{X}\|. (2) This parameter measures the maximum cumulative strength of all local terms acting on a given site and is referred to as the g -extensivity of the Hamiltonian 5 . As an illustrative example, consider the transverse-field Ising model (TFIM), H=J\sum_{\langle i,j\rangle}\sigma_{i}^{z}\sigma_{j}^{z}+\alpha\sum_{j}\sigma_{j}^{x}, (3) where J is the interaction strength, \alpha the transverse field, and \langle i,j\rangle denotes nearest-neighbor pairs. All the sites i have equal values of g_{i} . For site 1 , the g_{1} evaluates to \displaystyle g_{1} \displaystyle=\sum_{X:X\ni 1}\|h_{X}\|=\|J\sigma_{1}^{z}\sigma_{2}^{z}\|+\|J\sigma_{1}^{z}\sigma_{N}^{z}\|+\|\alpha\sigma_{1}^{x}\| \displaystyle=2|J|+|\alpha|, (4) where we have assumed periodic boundary conditions. Role of Interaction Order.— The concept of a quantum battery gained prominence from the idea that charging protocols exploiting quantum resources; particularly entanglement may yield speedups over classical strategies. The underlying physical intuition is that restricting the evolution to the separable subspace severely limits the accessible dynamical pathways, whereas typical states in a generic many-body Hilbert space are highly entangled 28 ; 43 ; 30 . Entangling operations can therefore open additional “routes” in Hilbert space, enabling faster transitions from low-energy to high-energy states. Gyhm et al. 26 formalized this intuition by studying many-body batteries and identifying constraints on charging power that depend explicitly on the locality, or interaction order, of the charging Hamiltonian. Their results indicate that only global operations i.e., interaction order k scaling as k\sim\mathcal{O}(N) – can provide extensive quantum advantage over protocols without entanglement. This aligns with the expectation that highly nonlocal Hamiltonians can generate multipartite entanglement 54 during charging. It has further been argued that global operations are necessary to obtain superextensive power. Supporting numerical evidence appeared earlier in Ref. 49 , where a fermionic complex SYK (cSYK) model was shown to exhibit superextensive charging power. When mapped to spins via the Jordan–Wigner transformation, the resulting Hamiltonian contains highly nonlocal string operators, and it is widely believed 10 that these nonlocal terms are responsible for the observed enhancement. In the next section, we demonstrate that these limitations arise primarily from the assumption that either the

Read the complete text