Closepacking effects on strangeness and baryon production at the LHC
J. Altmann, L. Bernardinis, P. Skands, V. Zaccolo · 2025
Read Closepacking effects on strangeness and baryon production at the LHC by J. Altmann, L. Bernardinis, P. Skands, V. Zaccolo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00671.txt.
Introduction
Four physicists, J Altmann, L Bernardinis, P Skands, and V Zaccolo, tackle a puzzle from the Large Hadron Collider in 2025. When protons collide, the share of strange hadrons grows as more charged particles are made. A hadron is a particle built from quarks, and strange ones carry a strange quark.
The widely used Pythia event generator, with its default Monash tune, predicts no such growth. The authors test a possible fix called string closepacking. In that picture, overlapping strings from the collision form a background field, mostly along the beam line. Checking this idea may help event models match what detectors see.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Altmann, L. Bernardinis, P. Skands, V. Zaccolo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 106 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00671
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Closepacking effects on strangeness and baryon production at the LHC J. Altmann, L. Bernardinis, P. Skands, V. Zaccolo Abstract Data from the LHC show a rise in strange-hadron production with charged-particle multiplicity in p p pp collisions. The Monte-Carlo event generator Pythia , using its default Monash tune, instead predicts constant strangeness. We investigate a mechanism invoked during hadronization called “string closepacking”, where overlapping strings generate a background field, here assumed to be predominantly aligned with the beam axis. This increases the effective string tension with rapidity, reducing strangeness suppression and thus enhancing strangeness production. We tune this model to LHC data and contrast it with several alternatives. We comment specifically on the challenge of simultaneously describing the strangeness data and the non-strange p / π p/\pi ratio, and introduce a mechanism which may act to suppress the latter. Many of the salient particle-production ratios can be qualitatively described by this model, although the Ξ c / D \Xi_{c}/D ratio and the shape of p ⟂ p_{\perp} spectra remain challenging to account for. 1 Introduction The Lund string model for hadronization Andersson:1983ia , as implemented in the Monte Carlo event generator Pythia Sjostrand:2006za ; Bierlich:2022pfr , has been shown to well describe data from e^{+}e^{-} colliders such as LEP and SLC OPAL:1994zan ; Hamacher:1995df ; DELPHI:2000ahn ; SLD:2003ogn ; ALEPH:2003obs ; L3:2004cdh ; Buckley:2009bj ; Skands:2014pea ; Amoroso:2018qga ; Jueid:2022qjg ; Korneeva:2024oho as well as having had some success in describing pp collisions Skands:2010ak ; Skands:2014pea ; TheATLAScollaboration:2014rfk ; CMS:2022awf ; Korneeva:2024oho . Recent data from the LHC however has highlighted discrepancies between Pythia predictions and pp collision events, prompting further investigations into string modelling, particularly in small systems. The baseline Lund string model (LSM) describes the fragmentation of a string of arbitrary invariant mass \gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}} . The string is taken to be in vacuum and isolated from any (other) sources of colour fields. This applies especially well to the context of hadronic Z decays, which is also the main reference case for constraining the nonperturbative modelling parameters of the LSM. The main generalization when going to pp collisions is that multiple parton-parton interactions (MPI) Sjostrand:1987su ; Sjostrand:2004ef as well as the colour-octet nature of gluon exchanges intrinsically lead to a picture of multiple such strings fragmenting simultaneously. Both the number and the lengths (invariant masses) of these strings can vary significantly from event to event, and when this is furthermore allowed to depend upon the proton-proton impact parameter Sjostrand:1986ep , one can successfully account Sjostrand:1987su for the very wide ( \sim negative-binomial) multiplicity distributions that are observed in minimum-bias collisions UA5:1985fid , with large long-range correlations Uhlig:1977dc ; UA5:1988osh , as well as for the comparatively large underlying events with a hard trigger (pedestal effect) UA1:1983hhd ; AxialFieldSpectrometer:1984fhw ; Field:2000dy ; CDF:2004jod ; ATLAS:2010kmf ; CMS:2010rux ; ALICE:2011ac . It is worth pausing to note that, in the context of the baseline LSM, these successes can be achieved while remaining within the comparatively simple paradigm that the fragmentation of a system of multiple strings can be described as the summed fragmentations of each of its constituent strings, with universal parameters — taken to be the same as those measured in hadronic Z decays. This, however, leads to predictions, e.g., of approximately universal ratios of the production of each hadron spin and flavour type relative to the total amount of hadron production. Such universal behaviours have been convincingly ruled out by more recent measurements, in particular by the ALICE experiment Aamodt:2008zz ; ALICE:2017jyt ; ALICE:2018pal ; ALICE:2023wbx whose excellent particle identification (PID) capabilities down to very low track momenta have played a crucial role in reconstructing an almost complete set of ground-state ( L=0 ) hadrons 1 1 1 In the sense of having measurements of at least one isospin state for almost every distinct spin and strangeness combination, sometimes more. The main exception is the \Delta family of baryons whose strong decays make them particularly challenging to reconstruct. . We also note that analogous and sometimes even more striking conclusions are reached in the heavy-flavour sector Altmann:2024kwx . This has raised questions about whether hadronization in pp collisions, especially at high particle densities, differs in some more fundamental way from hadronization in Z decays. If one wishes to remain within a string context, one relatively obvious possibility (with some benefit of hindsight) is that it is the above-mentioned assumption of independently fragmenting strings which is violated. This question of so-called collective effects is one that has already been posed and explored in models such as Rope hadronization Bierlich:2017sxk ; Bierlich:2016faw and string shoving Bierlich:2016vgw ; Bierlich:2020naj ; Bierlich:2024odg , which model effects on the string tension and string kinematics respectively. An interesting complementary proposal is that, in a high-density “core” of high-multiplicity pp collisions, the string picture may break down and small droplets of quark-gluon plasma (QGP) be formed instead, while strings continue to fragment more or less as in vacuum in a low-density “corona” Werner:2007bf ; Pierog:2013ria ; Pierog:2019opp . Interest in collective nonperturbative effects has recently been reignited by the above-mentioned measurements of clear breakdowns of universality, such as the ratios of strange hadrons to pions from the ALICE collaboration ALICE:2017jyt ; ALICE:2018pal , which show an increase in strange hadron production relative to charged multiplicity in pp collisions. This rise in strangeness gives a good indication that nonperturbative strange-quark production (e.g., via string breaks) is altered in correlation with overall particle production, an effect which the baseline LSM fails to capture. The existing Rope hadronization model has shown promising success in describing such strangeness-enhancement effects, doing so by implementing string-tension modifications as an extension to the baseline LSM. More specifically, the Rope model increases the string tension in higher-density string systems, resulting in a reduced strangeness suppression (i.e., strangeness enhancement) in string breaks. The Rope hadronization model construction however requires spacetime modelling of string breaks, which is computationally expensive and in contrast to the standard LSM fragmentation procedure which is implemented entirely in momentum space. As an alternative, we update and extend a simpler momentum-space model for string-tension modifications, called “closepacking” which was first proposed in the context of a thermal string-breaking model Fischer:2016zzs ; in this work, we generalize the implementation to Schwinger-type string breaking and introduce sensitivity to relative flux orientations on the basis of Casimir scaling. The model employs the same basic premise of an increased string tension as the more elaborate Rope model and hence should share a number of its features. But where the Rope model attempts to trace the explicit evolution of the fragmenting parton systems in spacetime, with multi-string ropes breaking strand by strand, the closepacking model currently only attempts to describe a time-averaged “effective background” for each string, as a function of rapidity along the beam axis. The main consequence is a rapidity-dependent effective tension that depends on each string’s environment (relative to the beam axis). As such, our closepacking model is currently only applicable to pp collisions and not to heavy-ion ones where spacetime distances between string systems can be large compared to a typical hadron size. Such systems would be better addressed by the Rope model or by QGP-inspired models such as EPOS Pierog:2013ria ;