đť’© = 2 {\cal N}=2 Higher Spins by Harmonic Superspace Methods

2025

Read đť’© = 2 {\cal N}=2 Higher Spins by Harmonic Superspace Methods (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00573.txt.

Introduction

Higher spin fields extend the usual cast of particles and forces, and supersymmetry doubles the stage again. A 2025 study develops higher spin theory with extended supersymmetry using harmonic superspace methods. Harmonic superspace was introduced in 1984 for describing supersymmetric field theories geometrically.

The harmonic approach gives an off-shell description of supersymmetric theories, covering Yang-Mills theory, supergravity, and matter with spins up to two. Extending it to higher spins tests whether those exotic fields can interact consistently. The work sits at the foundations of supersymmetry and quantum field theory. Off-shell descriptions keep all symmetries visible, which higher spin theories badly need. The maximal spins of the classic theories are one, two, and one half. The work is deep theory, and its worth is in the base it lays. If such fields can play well with the known ones, new doors in physics may open.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00573

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

đť’© = 2 {\cal N}=2 Higher Spins by Harmonic Superspace Methods Abstract Harmonic đť’© = 2 {\cal N}=2 superspace was discovered in 1984 as the powerful tool of the geometric superfield off-shell description of đť’© = 2 , 4 ​ D {\cal N}=2,4D supersymmetric field theories with the maximal spins 1, 2, and 1/2 ( đť’© = 2 {\cal N}=2 Yang-Mills theories, supergravity and matter hypermultiplets). My talk is a brief account of the basic achievements of the harmonic methods, including the newest applications in đť’© = 2 {\cal N}=2 theories of higher spins. Evgeny Ivanov Bogoliubov Laboratory of Theoretical Physics, JINR, 141980, Dubna, Moscow Region, Russia [email protected] To the memory of George Poghosyan 1 Supersymmetry and superfields Supersymmetry, despite lacking experimental confirmations, is in the heart of the modern of mathematical and quantum physics. It allowed to construct a lot of new theories with remarkable and surprising features: supergravities, superstrings, superbranes, {\cal N}=4 super Yang-Mills theory (the first example of the ultraviolet-finite quantum field theory), etc. It also exhibited unexpected relations between these theories, e.g., the “gravity/gauge” duality. The natural approach to supersymmetric theories is the superfield methods. The generalization of Minkowski space x^{m} to supersymmetry is {\cal N} extended Minkowski superspace \displaystyle{\cal M}^{(4|4{\cal N})}=\left(x^{m}\,,\;\theta^{\alpha}_{i}\,,\;\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\alpha}\,i}\right),\;i=1,\ldots,{\cal N}\,, where \theta^{\alpha}_{i}\,,\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\alpha}\,i} are anticommuting Grassmann coordinates, \{\theta,\theta\},\{\theta,\bar{\theta}\}=0 . The supersymmetric theories are adequately formulated off shell in terms of superfields defined on various superspaces (see, e.g., [ 1 , 2 ] and refs. therein). {\cal N}=1,4D chirality as the simplest Grassmann analyticity. {\cal N}=1,4D supersymmetry is an extension of the PoincarĂ© symmetry by spinor generators Q_{\alpha},\bar{Q}_{\dot{\alpha}} \displaystyle\{Q_{\alpha},\bar{Q}_{\dot{\beta}}\}=4\,P_{\alpha\dot{\beta}}\,,\,\{Q_{\alpha},Q_{\beta}\}=\{\bar{Q}_{\dot{\alpha}},\bar{Q}_{\dot{\beta}}\}=0\,,\,[P_{m},Q_{\alpha}]=[P_{m},\bar{Q}_{\dot{\alpha}}]=0\,,\,P_{\alpha\dot{\beta}}=\frac{1}{2}(\sigma^{m})_{\alpha\dot{\beta}}P_{m}. {\cal N}=1,4D superspace is an extension of Minkowski space by a doublet of Grassmann anticommuting spinorial coordinates \theta^{\beta},\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\beta}} , \displaystyle x^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\,\Rightarrow\,(x^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}},\theta^{\beta},\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\beta}})\,,\,{\theta^{\beta}}^{\prime}=\theta^{\beta}+\epsilon^{\beta}\,,\,{x^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}}^{\prime}={x^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}}-2i(\theta^{\alpha}\bar{\epsilon}^{\dot{\alpha}}-\epsilon^{\alpha}\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\alpha}}). {\cal N}=1,4D superfields \Phi(x,\theta,\bar{\theta}) are functions given on {\cal N}=1 superspace, with the transformation law, \displaystyle\Phi^{\prime}(x^{\prime},\theta^{\prime},\bar{\theta}^{\prime})=\Phi(x,\theta,\bar{\theta}). There is one very essential distinction between Minkowski space and {\cal N}=1 superspace. While the former does not include any coordinate subset where the whole 4D PoincarĂ© symmetry could be linearly realized, the latter contains such smaller supermanifolds, {\cal N}=1,4D chiral superspaces (x_{L},\theta),(x_{R},\bar{\theta}) , with twice as less Grassmann coordinates: \displaystyle x_{L}^{\alpha\dot{\beta}}=x^{\alpha\dot{\beta}}+2i\theta^{\alpha}\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\beta}}\,,\quad\delta x_{L}^{\alpha\dot{\beta}}=-4i\theta^{\alpha}\bar{\epsilon}^{\dot{\beta}}\,,\quad x_{R}^{\alpha\dot{\beta}}=(x_{L}^{\alpha\dot{\beta}})^{\dagger}\,. The chiral superfields are carriers of the basic matter {\cal N}=1 multiplet: \displaystyle\varphi(x_{L},\theta)=\phi(x_{L})+\theta^{\alpha}\psi_{\alpha}(x_{L})+(\theta)^{2}F(x_{L})\,,S_{free}\sim\int d^{4}xd^{2}\theta d^{2}\bar{\theta}\,\varphi(x_{L},\theta)\bar{\varphi}(x_{R},\bar{\theta})\,. The chiral superfields can be looked upon as complex general {\cal N}=1 superfields subject to the covariant Grassmann analyticity condition [ 3 ] . \displaystyle\varphi(x_{L},\theta)=\Phi_{L}(x_{L},\theta,\bar{\theta})\,,\quad\frac{\partial}{\partial\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\gamma}}}\Phi_{L}=0\,. The same constraint can be rewritten in the basis (x,\theta,\bar{\theta}) in terms of spinor covariant derivatives \displaystyle\bar{D}_{\dot{\gamma}}\Phi_{L}(x,\theta,\bar{\theta})=0\,,\quad D_{\alpha}=\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta^{\alpha}}+2i\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\alpha}}\partial_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\,,\;\bar{D}_{\dot{\gamma}}=-\frac{\partial}{\partial\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\gamma}}}-2i`\theta^{\alpha}\partial_{\alpha\dot{\gamma}}\,, \displaystyle\{D_{\gamma},D_{\beta}\}=\{\bar{D}_{\dot{\gamma}},\bar{D}_{\dot{\beta}}\}=0\,,\quad\{D_{\gamma},\bar{D}_{\dot{\beta}}\}=-4i\partial_{\gamma\dot{\beta}}\,. The vanishing of anticommutators of the same chirality spinor derivatives is just the integrability condition for {\cal N}=1 chirality. This chirality underlies all the gauge and supergravity {\cal N}=1 theories: the interacting case just corresponds to replacing all covariant derivatives by the gauge-covariant ones through adding proper superfield gauge connections \displaystyle D_{\gamma}\;\Rightarrow\;{\cal D}_{\gamma}=D_{\gamma}+i{\cal A}_{\alpha}\,,\,\,\bar{D}_{\dot{\gamma}}\;\Rightarrow\;\bar{{\cal D}}_{\dot{\gamma}}=\bar{D}_{\dot{\gamma}}+i\bar{\cal A}_{\dot{\gamma}}\,,\,\,\partial_{\gamma\dot{\beta}}\;\Rightarrow\;{\cal D}_{\gamma\dot{\beta}}=\partial_{\gamma\dot{\beta}}+i{\cal A}_{\gamma\dot{\beta}}\,, still preserving the flat integrability constraints \displaystyle\{{\cal D}_{\gamma},{\cal D}_{\beta}\}=\{\bar{{\cal D}}_{\dot{\gamma}},\bar{{\cal D}}_{\dot{\beta}}\}=0\,. The general {\cal N}=1 matter is also described by chiral superfields, implying a general Kähler target geometry for bosonic fields [ 4 ] . For extended supersymmetries (with few sorts of Q generators) new kinds of Grassmann analyticities (different from chirality) can be defined. One of them, the harmonic SU(2) analyticity, just forms the basis of the Harmonic Superspace approach. 2 Harmonic superspace In four dimensions, the only self-consistent off-shell superfield formalism for {\cal N}=2 (and {\cal N}=3 ) theories is the harmonic superspace approach invented by A. Galperin, E. Ivanov, S. Kalitzin, V. Ogievetsky and E. Sokatchev [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Harmonic {\cal N}=2 superspace is defined as the coordinate set: \displaystyle Z=(x^{m}\,,\;\theta^{\alpha}_{i}\,,\;\bar{\theta}^{\dot{\alpha}\,j},u^{\pm i}),\quad u^{\pm i}\in SU(2)/U(1),\;u^{+i}u^{-}_{i}=1\,. (2.1) Its most important property is the presence of analytic harmonic {\cal N}=2 super-subspace: \displaystyle\zeta_{A}=(x^{m}_{A},\theta^{+\alpha},\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\alpha}},u^{\pm i}),\;\theta^{+\alpha,\dot{\alpha}}:=\theta^{\alpha,\dot{\alpha}i}u^{+}_{i},\;x^{m}_{A}:=x^{m}-2i\theta^{(i}\sigma^{m}\bar{\theta}^{j)}u^{+}_{i}u^{+}_{j}\,. It is closed under {\cal N}=2 supersymmetry. All basic {\cal N}=2 superfields are harmonic analytic: \displaystyle\underline{\rm SYM}: \displaystyle V^{++}(\zeta_{A})\,,\;\;\underline{\rm matter\;hypermultiplets}:\;q^{+}(\zeta_{A})\,,\,\bar{q}^{+}(\zeta_{A}) \displaystyle\underline{\rm supergravity}: \displaystyle H^{++m}(\zeta_{A})\,,\,H^{++\hat{\alpha}+}(\zeta_{A})\,,\,H^{++5}(\zeta_{A})\,,\hat{\alpha}=(\alpha,\dot{\alpha})\,. Here the upper indices “+” refer to the charge with respect to the denominator of the harmonic coset in ( 2.1 ). Example: {\cal N}=2 spin 1 multiplet . An instructive example is Abelian {\cal N}=2 gauge theory, \displaystyle V^{++}(\zeta_{A})\,,\quad\delta V^{++}=D^{++}\Lambda(\zeta_{A})\,,\;D^{++}=\partial^{++}-4i\theta^{+\alpha}\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\alpha}}\partial_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\,. It is possible to impose Wess-Zumino gauge (8 + 8 off-shell degrees of freedom): \displaystyle V^{++}(\zeta_{A})=(\theta^{+})^{2}\phi+(\bar{\theta}^{+})^{2}\bar{\phi}+2i\theta^{+\alpha}\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\alpha}}A_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}} \displaystyle+\,(\bar{\theta}^{+})^{2}\theta^{+\alpha}\psi_{\alpha}^{i}u^{-}_{i}+(\theta^{+})^{2}\bar{\theta}^{+}_{\dot{\alpha}}\bar{\psi}^{\dot{\alpha}i}u^{-}_{i}+(\theta^{+})^{2}(\bar{\theta}^{+})^{2}D^{(ik)}u^{-}_{i}u^{-}_{k}\,. These component fields constitute an Abelian gauge {\cal N}=2 off-shell multiplet. The invariant superfield action reads: \displaystyle S\sim\int d^{12}Z\,\,\big(V^{++}V^{--}\big)\,,\;D^{++}V^{--}-D^{--}V^{++}=0\,,\;\delta V^{--}=D^{--}\Lambda\,, (2.2) \displaystyle[D^{++},D^{--}]=D^{0},\quad D^{0}V^{\pm\pm}=\pm 2\,V^{\pm\pm}\,. The second harmonic gauge connection V^{--} is not analytic but it is expressed through V^{++} by the “harmonic zero-curvature condition” in ( 2.2 ). 3 Supersymmetry and higher spins Supersymmetric higher-spin theories provide a bridge between superstring theory and low-energy (super)gauge theories. Free massless bosonic and fermionic higher spin field theories were defined in [ 8 , 9 ] . The component approach to {\cal N}=1 , 4D supersymmetric free massless higher spin models was developed in [ 10 , 11 ] . The natural tools to deal with supersymmetric theories are off-shell superfield methods. In the superfield approach the supersymmetry is closed on the off-shell supermultiplets and so is automatically manifest. The complete off-shell {\cal N}=1 superfield Lagrangian formulation of {\cal N}=1,4D free higher spins was given by S.M. Kuzenko, et al [ 12 , 13 ] . An off-shell superfield Lagrangian formulation for higher-spin extended supersymmetric theories, with all supersymmetries manifest, was unknown for long even for free theories. This gap was filled in by I. Buchbinder, E. Ivanov, N. Zaigraev [ 14 ] . An off-shell manifestly {\cal N}=2 supersymmetric unconstrained formulation of {\cal N}=2,4D super Fronsdal theory for integer spins was constructed in the harmonic superspace approach. Manifestly {\cal N}=2 supersymmetric off-shell cubic couplings of {\cal N}=2,4D higher-spin gauge superfields to the matter hypermultiplets were further constructed in [ 15 , 16 ] . Quite recently, we generalized HSS non-conformal construction to the case of {\cal N}=2 superconformal multiplets and their hypermultiplet couplings [ 17 ] . Our papers just mentioned opened a new domain of applications of the harmonic superspace formalism, that time in {\cal N}=2 higher-spin theories. 4 {\cal N}=2 spin 2 multiplet Analogs of the {\cal N}=2 Yang-Mills superfield V^{++}(\zeta_{A}) are the following set of analytic gauge potentials: \displaystyle\Big(h^{++m}(\zeta_{A})\,,\;h^{++5}(\zeta_{A})\,,\;h^{++\hat{\mu}+}(\zeta_{A})\Big),\quad\hat{\mu}=(\mu\,,\dot{\mu})\,, \displaystyle\delta_{\lambda}h^{++m}={D}^{++}\lambda^{m}+2i\big(\lambda^{+\alpha}\sigma^{m}_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\alpha}}+\theta^{+\alpha}\sigma^{m}_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\bar{\lambda}^{+\dot{\alpha}}\big)\,, \displaystyle\delta_{\lambda}h^{++5}={D}^{++}\lambda^{5}-2i\big(\lambda^{+{\alpha}}\theta^{+}_{\alpha}-\bar{\theta}^{+}_{\dot{\alpha}}\bar{\lambda}^{+\dot{\alpha}}\big),\delta_{\lambda}h^{++\hat{\mu}+}={D}^{++}\lambda^{+\hat{\mu}}\,. The Wess-Zumino gauge can be chosen as: \displaystyle h^{++m}=-2i\theta^{+}\sigma^{a}\bar{\theta}^{+}\Phi^{m}_{a}+\big[(\bar{\theta}^{+})^{2}\theta^{+}\psi^{m\,i}u^{-}_{i}+c.c.\big]+\ldots \displaystyle h^{++5}=-2i\theta^{+}\sigma^{a}\bar{\theta}^{+}C_{a}+\ldots\,,\quad h^{++\mu+}=\ldots\,, with the residual gauge freedom: \displaystyle\lambda^{m}\;\Rightarrow\;a^{m}(x)\,,\;\lambda^{5}\,\Rightarrow\;b(x)\,,\;\lambda^{\mu+}\;\Rightarrow\;\epsilon^{\mu i}(x)u^{+}_{i}+\theta^{+\nu}l_{(\nu}^{\;\;\;\mu)}(x)\,. The physical fields are \Phi^{m}_{a},\psi^{m\,i}_{\mu},C_{a} (spins {\bf(2,3/2,3/2,1)} on shell). In the “physical” gauge: \displaystyle\Phi^{m}_{a}\sim\Phi_{\beta\dot{\beta}\alpha\dot{\alpha}}\Rightarrow\Phi_{(\beta\alpha)(\dot{\beta}\dot{\alpha})}+\varepsilon_{\alpha\beta}\varepsilon_{\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}}\Phi\,. 5 {\cal N}=2 spin 3 and higher spins The spin 3 triad of analytic gauge superfields is introduced as : \displaystyle\big\{h^{++(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}(\zeta)\,,\;h^{++\alpha\dot{\alpha}}(\zeta),\;h^{++(\alpha\beta)\dot{\alpha}+}(\zeta),\;h^{++(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}){\alpha}+}(\zeta)\big\}\,, \displaystyle\delta h^{++(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}=D^{++}\lambda^{(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}+2i\big[\lambda^{+(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}}\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\beta})}+\theta^{+(\alpha}\bar{\lambda}^{+\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}\big], \displaystyle\delta h^{++\alpha\dot{\alpha}}=D^{++}\lambda^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}-2i\big[\lambda^{+(\alpha\beta)\dot{\alpha}}\theta^{+}_{\beta}+\bar{\lambda}^{+(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}){\alpha}}\bar{\theta}^{+}_{\dot{\beta}}\big], \displaystyle\delta h^{++(\alpha\beta)\dot{\alpha}+}=D^{++}\lambda^{+(\alpha\beta)\dot{\alpha}}\,,\;\delta h^{++(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})\alpha+}=D^{++}\lambda^{+(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})\alpha}\,. The bosonic physical fields in WZ gauge are collected in \displaystyle h^{++(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}=-2i\theta^{+\rho}\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\rho}}\Phi^{(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}_{\rho\dot{\rho}}+\ldots\,\;h^{++\alpha\dot{\alpha}}=-2i\theta^{+\rho}\bar{\theta}^{+\dot{\rho}}C^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}_{\rho\dot{\rho}}+\ldots The physical gauge fields are \Phi^{(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})}_{\rho\dot{\rho}} (spin 3 gauge field), C^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}_{\rho\dot{\rho}} (spin 2 gauge field) and \psi^{(\alpha\beta)(\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta})i}_{\gamma} (spin 5/2 gauge field). The rest of fields are auxiliary. On shell, we are left with the spin content ({\bf 3,5/2,5/2,2}) . The general case with the maximal integer spin {\bf s} is spanned by the analytic gauge potentials \displaystyle h^{++\alpha(s-1)\dot{\alpha}(s-1)}(\zeta),h^{++\alpha(s-2)\dot{\alpha}(s-2)}(\zeta),h^{++\alpha(s-1)\dot{\alpha}(s-2)+}(\zeta),h^{++\dot{\alpha}(s-1)\alpha(s-2)+}(\zeta), where \alpha(s):=(\alpha_{1}\ldots\alpha_{s}),\dot{\alpha}(s):=(\dot{\alpha}_{1}\ldots\dot{\alpha}_{s}) . The relevant gauge transformations can also be defined and shown to leave, in the WZ-like gauge, the physical field multiplet with spins ({\bf s,s-1/2,s-1/2,s-1}) . The on-shell spin contents of {\cal N}=2 higher-spin multiplets can be summarized as \displaystyle\underline{spin\;1}:\;1,\,(1/2)^{2},\,(0)^{2} \displaystyle\underline{spin\;2}:\;2,\,(3/2)^{2},\,1 \displaystyle\underline{spin\;3}:\;3,\,(5/2)^{2},\,2

Read the complete text