Characterizing topology at nonzero temperature
Julia D. Hannukainen, Nigel R. Cooper · 2025
Read Characterizing topology at nonzero temperature by Julia D. Hannukainen, Nigel R. Cooper (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00464.txt.
Introduction
Topological phases are usually defined at absolute zero, but real devices run warm. Julia Hannukainen and Nigel Cooper compare methods for characterizing topology at nonzero temperature in 2025. Their test bed is one-dimensional inversion-symmetric fermionic chains, especially the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model.
One candidate, the ensemble geometric phase, generalizes the zero-temperature Zak phase to mixed states. It stays well defined at nonzero temperature, yet its signal vanishes in the thermodynamic limit, limiting practical use. Knowing which characterizations survive warmth tells experimentalists what they can actually measure in topological materials. The Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model is the standard first example of a topological insulator. Nearest and next-nearest hopping keep the model rich yet still solvable. For folks who hunt such states in the lab, the gain is a short list of tests. They still mean much when the gear runs warm, as real gear must.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Julia D. Hannukainen, Nigel R. Cooper |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00464
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Characterizing topology at nonzero temperature Julia D. Hannukainen, Nigel R. Cooper Abstract We compare different methods for characterizing topology at nonzero temperatures, as applied to one-dimensional inversion-symmetric fermionic chains and focusing on the Su–Schrieffer–Heeger model with nearest- and next-nearest-neighbor hopping. Whilst the ensemble geometric phase, a mixed-state generalization of the Zak phase remains well defined at nonzero temperature, the modulus of the corresponding expectation value vanishes in the thermodynamic limit, limiting its practical use. To develop a diagnostic that is suitable also for very large systems, we introduce local density operators acting on neighboring sites, which distinguish topological phases by comparing their expectation values. The topological phase is identified from the relative magnitude of these expectation values, which only requires measuring two local expectation values at nonzero temperature, together with one additional nonlocal expectation value when next-nearest-neighbor hopping is included. In addition, we generalize the local chiral marker to mixed Gaussian states, fully determined by its single-particle correlation matrix, with a nonzero purity gap in their effective single-particle Hamiltonian. The presence of a purity gap ensures that the correlation matrix can be adiabatically flattened to an effective projector. Evaluating the chiral marker with respect to the band-flattened correlation matrix yields a real-space topological invariant that coincides with the winding number in the zero-temperature limit. The ensemble geometric phase, the local density operators, and the local chiral marker, provide complementary schemes to identify and measure topological phases of the Su–Schrieffer–Heeger chain beyond pure states. I Introduction In equilibrium, topology is a property of the many-body state at zero temperature, which for Gaussian states is the ground state of a quadratic Hamiltonian. A topological phase can be protected by symmetries, which may be local or spatial in nature. This means that ground states belonging to distinct topological phases cannot be connected by a finite-depth local unitary circuit that respects the protecting symmetry Chen et al. 2010 . From the Hamiltonian perspective, this implies that parent Hamiltonians of different phases cannot be smoothly deformed into one another without either closing the energy gap or breaking the protecting symmetry Chen et al. 2010 . Gaussian states protected by local symmetries are classified Schnyder et al. 2008 ; Kitaev 2009 ; Ryu et al. 2010 ; Ludwig 2015 into ten symmetry classes Cartan 1926 ; Zirnbauer 1996 ; Altland and Zirnbauer 1997 , determined by the combinations of time-reversal, particle-hole, and chiral symmetry. The distinct phases are characterized by known topological invariants such as the Chern number Thouless et al. 1982 ; Kohmoto 1985 ; Read and Green 2000 , and winding number Ryu et al. 2010 , which are evaluated for the ground state wave function. Quantum systems described by mixed states, arising for example at nonzero temperature or under dissipation, require a different framework for topological classification and characterization. The time evolution of mixed states is governed by the Gorini–Kossakowski–Sudarshan–Lindblad master equation, which describes Markovian open-system dynamics through a combination of unitary Hamiltonian dynamics and dissipation Lindblad 1976 ; Gorini et al. 1976 ; Gardiner and Collett 1985 . The generator of the time evolution, the Lindblad super operator, can be represented as a non-Hermitian matrix acting on a doubled Hilbert space Prosen 2008 ; Prosen 2010 , making it possible to approach its topology through a classification of non-Hermitian matrices Bernard and LeClair 2002 ; Kawabata et al. 2019 ; Zhou and Lee 2019 . For quadratic Lindblad operators, where the Hamiltonian part is quadratic in fermionic operators and the dissipative part is built from linear dissipators, the Gaussian structure of the state is preserved under time evolution. In this setting, topology is defined through the classification of the quadratic Lindbladian itself, in close analogy to the tenfold way classification of quadratic Hamiltonians in equilibrium Lieu et al. 2020 , and general Lindblad operators, including interactions Sá et al. 2023 ; Kawabata et al. 2023 . An alternative viewpoint defines topology at the level of the density matrix itself, explored in contexts ranging mixed states to steady-state solutions of the Lindblad evolution Diehl et al. 2011 ; Bardyn et al. 2013 ; Rivas et al. 2013 ; Budich et al. 2015 ; Budich and Diehl 2015 ; Iemini et al. 2016 ; Bardyn et al. 2018 ; Tonielli et al. 2020 . A general classification of density-matrix topology was introduced in Ref. Altland et al. 2021 , based on the symmetry properties of the dynamical generators of fermionic matter in and out of equilibrium. In this formalism the classification of Gaussian steady-state solutions, \rho\sim\mathrm{e}^{-G} of the Gorini–Kossakowski–Sudarshan–Lindblad equation proceeds through an effective single-particle Hamiltonian G , whose eigenstates play a role analogous to ground states of pure states in equilibrium. The spectrum of G defines the purity spectrum, which reflects the degree of mixedness of single-particle modes Diehl et al. 2011 ; Bardyn et al. 2013 ; Budich and Diehl 2015 . Eigenvalues far from zero correspond to modes that are predominantly occupied or empty, while eigenvalues at zero represent totally mixed modes. A finite gap around zero—the purity gap—therefore guarantees that no mode is maximally mixed, and all modes are biased toward being either filled or empty. The negative-energy eigenstates of the effective Hamiltonian form a Slater determinant that serves as an effective ground state, and the topology is defined through the classification of the corresponding effective Hamiltonian ( Altland et al. 2021 ) . Several approaches have been proposed to characterize the topology of mixed states. The Uhlmann phase Uhlmann 1976 ; Viyuela et al. 2014a ; Viyuela et al. 2014b ; Huang and Arovas 2014 ; Budich and Diehl 2015 provides a mixed-state generalization of the geometric phase Berry 1984 ; Simon 1983 ; Wilczek and Zee 1984 , by defining parallel transport of density matrices through their purifications in an enlarged Hilbert space. However, because every density matrix admits a unique and smooth purification, one can always define a global gauge, making the Uhlmann phase to always be topologically trivial, even for topologically nontrivial pure states Budich and Diehl 2015 . In contrast, the ensemble geometric phase captures topological properties directly from the density matrix and reduces to the Zak phase,the one-dimensional Berry phase of the occupied band Zak 1989 , in the pure-state limit Bardyn et al. 2018 . The ensemble geometric phase applies to Gaussian states with a nonzero purity gap and has been extended to higher-dimensional systems, interacting states Wawer and Fleischhauer 2021a ; Wawer and Fleischhauer 2021b ; Huang et al. 2022 , and a broader framework of topological order parameters Huang and Diehl 2025 . It is constructed from Resta’s formulation of electric polarization, in which the polarization of a one-dimensional insulator is defined as the phase of the expectation value of a large-gauge, momentum-translation, operator evaluated in the many-body ground state Resta 1998 . The operator is defined as T=\text{exp}[(2\pi/L)\sum_{j}x_{j}n_{j}] , where L is the length of the one dimensional chain, x_{j} is the position at unit cell j , and n_{j} is the occupation number Resta 1998 . For a translation-invariant noninteracting system at zero temperature, Resta’s expression reduces to the Zak phase, connecting the many-body operator to the corresponding single-particle Berry phase. At nonzero temperature, evaluating the same expectation value