Finite-Sample Valid Rank Confidence Sets for a Broad Class of Statistical and Machine Learning Models

Onrina Chandra, and Min-ge Xie · 2025

Read Finite-Sample Valid Rank Confidence Sets for a Broad Class of Statistical and Machine Learning Models by Onrina Chandra, and Min-ge Xie (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00316.txt.

Introduction

Ranking institutions from samples is common, but sample noise makes the ranks themselves uncertain. Onrina Chandra and Min-ge Xie build finite-sample valid rank confidence sets in 2025, covering a broad class of statistical and machine learning models. A confidence set lists the ranks a population might truly hold.

Uncertainty quantification becomes crucial when latent characteristics are poorly separated and many estimated ranks may be wrongly ordered. Finite-sample validity means the guarantees hold at the actual sample size, not just asymptotically. Honest rank sets could keep league tables in education, health, and research from overstating small differences. Rank confidence sets answer with a set of plausible ranks instead of one fragile ordering.

Catalog record

CREATOROnrina Chandra, and Min-ge Xie
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE118 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00316

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Finite-Sample Valid Rank Confidence Sets for a Broad Class of Statistical and Machine Learning Models Onrina Chandra, and Min-ge Xie Abstract Ranking populations such as institutions based on certain characteristics is often of interest, and these ranks are typically estimated using samples drawn from the populations. Due to sample randomness, it is important to quantify the uncertainty associated with the estimated ranks. This becomes crucial when latent characteristics are poorly separated and where many rank estimates may be incorrectly ordered. Understanding uncertainty can help quantify and mitigate these issues and provide a fuller picture. However, this task is especially challenging because the rank parameters are discrete and the central limit theorem does not apply to the rank estimates. In this article, we propose a Repro Samples Method to address this nontrivial inference problem by developing a confidence set for the true, unobserved population ranks. This method provides finite-sample coverage guarantees and is broadly applicable to ranking problems. The effectiveness of the method is illustrated and compared with several published large sample ranking approaches using simulation studies and real data examples involving samples both from traditional statistical models and modern data science algorithms. Key words: Inference on discrete parameter space; Finite-sample performance guarantee; Repro sample method; Latent model; Rank of performance. Introduction The ranking performance of institutions such as universities, hospitals or sports teams, plays a crucial role in shaping decisions across many areas. Prospective students choose colleges based on league tables, patients rely on hospital ratings when seeking care and sponsors follow conference standings to gauge sport teams performance. These rankings are almost always derived from sampled data, imperfect measurements, or subjective evaluations, which introduce variability and potential biases. A university’s placement in a league table, for example, may shift simply because of small fluctuations in survey responses. Similarly, a hospital’s star rating can move up or down if a few outcome metrics change. Ignoring this uncertainty can mislead decisions; students may choose a school based on noise, or resources may go to a hospital whose top rank is unstable. Therefore, it is crucial to develop statistical tools that not only estimate rank but also quantify its uncertainty. Confidence intervals help distinguish real differences from random variation, promoting transparent, evidence-based decisions and avoiding the false certainty of exact ranks. In this paper, we aim to rank K populations \mathcal{P}_{1},\mathcal{P}_{2},...\mathcal{P}_{K} that are defined through a characteristic described by a set of unknown (numeric or non-numeric) feature values \bm{\eta}=(\eta_{1},\eta_{2},...,\eta_{K}),^{\top} where \eta_{k} is a set of features associated with the k^{th} population \mathcal{P}_{k} , for k=1,2,..,K , and \bm{\eta}\in\Omega , an arbitrary feature space. More specifically, we assume the populations are ranked based on a characteristic parameter \bm{\theta}=(\theta_{1},\theta_{2},\ldots,\theta_{K})^{\top} of K elements, where \bm{\theta}=\zeta(\bm{\eta}) is a function of features \bm{\eta} for a mapping function \zeta(\cdot) from \Omega\rightarrow\Theta\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{K} . Our target is the ranks of the K populations, denoted by \bm{R} , is determined by the ranking order of the K elements of \bm{\theta} : \bm{R}=(r_{1},\ldots,r_{K})=\mathcal{S}(\bm{\theta})=\mathcal{S}(\theta_{1},\ldots,\theta_{K})\in[K]^{{K}} (1) where the rank of the k^{th} population is defined as r_{k}=\sum_{1\leq i\leq K,i\not=k}{\bf 1}(\theta_{i}\leq\theta_{k}) and \mathcal{S}(\cdot) is the corresponding mapping function from \theta\to[K]^{K} , where the notation [K] denotes the set of the first K positive integers, \{1,2,\dots,K\} throughout the paper. In practice, the \theta_{k} values are unknown, but we have sample data, say {\cal D} , collected from the K populations. The population ranks \bm{R} are often estimated by replacing \theta_{k} ’s in ( 1 ) with their estimate \hat{\theta}_{k}=\hat{\theta}_{k}({\cal D}) ’s using the sample data and consequently \widehat{\bm{R}}=(\hat{r}_{1},\ldots,\hat{r}_{K})=\mathcal{S}(\widehat{\bm{\theta}}) , where \hat{r}_{k}=\sum_{1\leq i\leq K,i\not=k}{\bf 1}(\hat{\theta}_{i}\leq\hat{\theta}_{k}) and \widehat{\bm{\theta}}=(\hat{\theta}_{1},\ldots,\hat{\theta}_{K}) . However, the uncertainty and error of estimators can lead to discrepancies between the ordering derived from \hat{\theta}_{k} ’s and the actual ordering dictated by the \theta_{k} values, particularly when some of the underlying \theta_{k} values are closely clustered. This potential for misordering highlights the importance of developing methods to provide confidence sets instead of just point estimates of ranks. For clarity and mathematics rigor, throughout the paper, we use {\cal D}^{\mathrm{obs}} to denote the observed (nonrandom) sample of {\cal D} . We also use \bm{\eta}^{(0)} and \bm{\theta}^{(0)} to denote the true values of \bm{\eta} and \bm{\theta} . We assume throughout the paper the true scores \theta^{(0)}_{1},\dots,\theta^{(0)}_{K} are distinct although they can be very close to each other. Thus, we seek to infer about the parameter of interest which is the true population rank \bm{R}^{(0)} using the observed sample data {\cal D}^{\mathrm{obs}}. \bm{R}^{(0)}=(r^{(0)}_{1},\ldots,r^{(0)}_{K})=\mathcal{S}(\bm{\theta}^{(0)})=\mathcal{S}(\theta^{(0)}_{1},\ldots,\theta^{(0)}_{{K}}) (2) 1.1 Challenges in Rank Inference Rank inference problems differ from most statistical inference problems because the parameter space of interest is discrete rather than continuous, which poses significant challenges for applying standard inferential tools. For instance, inference tools based on large-sample methods, such as the Central Limit Theorem, are generally not applicable because the regularity conditions required for the theorem, do not hold for point estimators of ranks. Frequentist approaches, such as bootstrap methods based on rank estimators, falter in this setting because the limiting distributions of discrete rank estimators are often unknown, and the bootstrap Central Limit Theorem does not apply. As noted in Hall and Miller, 2010 , even the limiting distribution of \max_{k}\hat{\theta}_{k} is elusive, complicating the development of valid inference procedures. Bayesian methods, though capable of generating credible sets for ranks, also encounter fundamental difficulties. Particularly, credible sets obtained using the posteriors distributions perform poorly in terms of covering the true rank in repeated runs because the Bernstein–von Mises theorem does not extend to discrete parameter spaces. Moreover, the performance of the credible sets depends critically on the choice of priors, for which there is no commonly agreed-upon choice. Again, when a Bayesian method enforces continuous prior on the latent parameter space \bm{\Theta} , it breaks any potential ties that may exist between the true population parameters. Our work addresses this critical gap by sidestepping these issues and developing a novel procedure to produce finite-samples valid confidence sets for the true population ranks. 1.2 Main goal of the paper Given observed data \mathcal{D}^{\mathrm{obs}} , we aim to construct a set \tilde{\Gamma}_{\mathcal{V}_{\alpha}}(\mathcal{D}^{\mathrm{obs}})\subset[K]^{K} of rank vectors that satisfies the finite-sample coverage constraint \mathbb{P}\!\big(\bm{R}^{(0)}\in\tilde{\Gamma}_{\mathcal{V}_{\alpha}}(\mathcal{D})\big)\geq 1-\alpha, for a prescribed confidence level \alpha\in(0,1) . This formulation parallels the construction of finite-sample valid prediction sets for discrete outcomes, but the inferential target here is an ordering S(\bm{\theta}) rather than a continuous parameter. Within the Repro-Samples framework, our method extends the notion of exact coverage from \bm{\Theta} to its induced rank space. 1.3 Existing Approaches to Rank Inference The task of quantifying uncertainty in the ordering of latent parameters \theta,\dots,\theta_{K} has progressed through a network of interconnected breakthroughs. Early work by Goldstein and Spiegelhalter, 1996 recognized that posterior uncertainty in hierarchical models should induce uncertainty in ranks. They aimed to critically examine the statistical challenges of “league tables” for comparing institutional performance using hierarchical models with shrunken estimates of institution-specific effects \theta_{k} , applying normal priors and Gibbs-sampler-based intervals. More recently, to provide joint credible intervals for the ranks under a Bayesian framework, Datta et al., 2024 compared an unstructured flat prior \pi(\theta) and the Fay–Herriot prior on \theta_{k} , using MCMC to produce full posterior rank‐distribution matrices. Gu and Koenker, 2023 recast ranking as a compound‐decision problem by modeling \theta_{k} through a mixing distribution G , estimated via

Read the complete text