Kicking for Goal or Touch? An Expected Points Framework for Penalty Decisions in Rugby Union

Kenny Watts, Jonathan Pipping · 2025

Read Kicking for Goal or Touch? An Expected Points Framework for Penalty Decisions in Rugby Union by Kenny Watts, Jonathan Pipping (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-00312.txt.

Introduction

After a penalty in rugby union, a team must choose: kick at goal for points, or kick to touch and chase a try. Kenny Watts and Jonathan Pipping build an expected points framework for that decision in 2025. The value of each option depends on field location and game context.

Expected points models convert a game situation into the points a team can expect from it on average. Comparing the two kicks on that scale gives coaches a principled guide instead of habit or gut feeling. The framework is a neat example of sports analytics turning a sideline judgment call into a measurable trade-off.

Catalog record

CREATORKenny Watts, Jonathan Pipping
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-00312

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Kicking for Goal or Touch? An Expected Points Framework for Penalty Decisions in Rugby Union Kenny Watts, Jonathan Pipping Abstract Following a penalty in rugby union, teams typically choose between attempting a shot at goal or kicking to touch to pursue a try. We develop an Expected Points (EP) framework that quantifies the value of each option as a function of both field location and game context. Using phase-level data from the 2018/19 Premiership Rugby season (35,199 phases across 132 matches) and an angle–distance model of penalty kick success estimated from international records, we construct two surfaces: (i) the expected points of a possession beginning with a lineout, and (ii) the expected points of a kick at goal, taking into account the in-game consequences of made and missed kicks. We then compare these surfaces to produce decision maps that indicate where kicking for goal or kicking to touch maximizes expected return, and we analyze how the boundary shifts with game context and the expected meters gained to touch. Our results provide a unified, data-driven method for evaluating penalty decisions and can be tailored to team-specific kickers and lineout units. This study offers, to our knowledge, the first comprehensive EP-based assessment of penalty strategy in rugby union and outlines extensions to win-probability analysis and richer tracking data. 1 Introduction Rugby union presents a recurring strategic decision immediately after a penalty with four possible ways to restart play: going for an immediate three points via a kick at goal or pursuing a potential seven-point try by either a scrum, a tap-and-go (both at the point of the penalty) or a kick to touch where the attacking team restarts play with a lineout. Generally, except when right on the opposition goal-line, a lineout is perceived to be a superior choice than a tap-and-go or a scrum since the attacking team can safely advance the ball down the field, with the lineout occurring where the ball crosses the touch line following the kick. This means that, once within distance to make a penalty kick \sim 60\text{m} from the opponent try line, the decision following a penalty is routinely between taking a lineout or kicking at goal. While the choice is often straightforward near the opposition’s corner, given a certain point difference, or late in a match, many game states are ambiguous and governed by convention, perceived kicker ability, and the expected quality of a team’s lineout. In contrast, American football has long relied on Expected Points (EP), Expected Points Added (EPA), and win-probability (WP) frameworks to guide fourth-down decision-making, translating field position and context into expected returns and actionable recommendations ( 8 ; 3 ; 9 ) . In that setting, WP and EP estimators are typically built using statistical machine learning models (e.g., Random Forests and gradient boosting), as is done in 4 and 1 . In rugby union, public research is only beginning to close this methodological gap, which can be largely attributed to a lack of publicly-available data. 5 propose a transparent, phase-level modeling framework for calculating Expected Points on English Premiership data, highlighting the difficulty of reliably predicting minority outcomes (e.g., penalty kicks) and providing a reproducible benchmark rather than a deployable decision tool. Separately, public-facing analyses model goal-kicking success as a function of distance and lateral angle, offering practically-useful (albeit context-free) estimates ( 6 ) . Building on these strands—and informed by lessons from the NFL literature on decision modeling—we directly evaluate the penalty decision. Our contribution is a decision-ready EP framework for the penalty decision. We construct two context-aware surfaces: (i) the expected points of a possession beginning with a lineout, estimated from phase-level data by field location, and (ii) the expected points of a kick at goal, which integrates a continuous angle–distance model of kick success together with the continuation value of misses (e.g., 22 m drop-outs and in-play recoveries) rather than treating misses as zero. Comparing these surfaces yields decision maps (zero-difference contours) indicating where each option maximizes expected return, and sensitivity analyses showing how the frontier shifts with kicker accuracy and expected meters gained to touch. We also make explicit the translation from penalty location to resulting lineout location and document assumptions required when bridging club-phase data and international kicking records. To our knowledge, this is the first comprehensive EP-based assessment of penalty strategy in rugby union that produces decision-ready artifacts; complementing prior methodological advances and isolated kicking models while laying the groundwork for future win-probability analysis in rugby. We proceed with an overview of the data, then continue with an outline of our methodology and results. 2 Data 2.1 Phase-Level Data Our primary dataset consists of phase-level event logs from the 2018/19 Premiership Rugby season compiled by 5 , covering 132 matches and 35,199 phases of play. Each record describes the on-field state at the start of a phase: the initiating event type, a zonal field location and side, the current score differential, and the next score in points for or against the team in possession. We harmonize timestamps to “seconds remaining in match” so that time is strictly decreasing within a game and directly comparable across halves. The unit of observation in the dataset is a phase , defined as the period between subsequent rucks. The phase count resets following restarts (e.g., lineouts, scrums, kick-offs) or major infringements that halt play. A possession sequence is an ordered set of phases by the same team without an opposition touch that changes possession. Unless otherwise stated, Expected Points estimates condition on the first phase of a possession sequence (e.g., a lineout), because that is the decision-relevant entry state. Figure 1 summarizes the zonal discretization of the pitch used in the phase-level data. Figure 1 : Field zones used in the phase-level dataset 2.2 Phase-Level Data Processing For the EP model, the unit of analysis is a possession that begins with a lineout. We therefore restrict the dataset to opening phases of play (i.e., observations with \text{Phase}=1 ) whose initiating event is a lineout. Each such record represents a distinct possession entry state. We then construct several derived variables that encode field position, time, and game context: • Field position. The original zone labels are converted into a continuous coordinate, meter_line , which records the distance in meters from the team’s own goal line at which the lineout originates. • Time remaining. Total seconds remaining in the match are transformed to Sec_Remain_Half , the seconds remaining in the current half, to better align with rugby’s two-period structure. • Score and card context. Points_Difference records the score differential (for the team in possession), while Card_Diff tracks the net player advantage in terms of yellow or red cards. • Team strength. WinPct_Diff is the running difference in win percentage between each team and its opponent at kickoff, computed from their prior matches. To address potential double counting across consecutive possessions, we create a grouping identifier, run_id , which indexes sequences of possessions that (i) begin with lineouts for the same team, (ii) share the same point differential at the start of the possession, and (iii) have the same eventual scoring outcome. Within each run_id we also compute n_same , the number of such consecutive possessions. The role of

Read the complete text