INFLUENCE OF CONVERTER CURRENT LIMITING AND PRIORITIZATION ON PROTECTION OF HIGHLY IBR-PENETRATED NETWORKS

Andrés E Quintero \ad 1 \corr, Vinícius A Lacerda \ad 1, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt \ad 1, Moisés J. B. B. Davi \ad 2, Mario Oleskovicz \ad 2 · 2025

Read INFLUENCE OF CONVERTER CURRENT LIMITING AND PRIORITIZATION ON PROTECTION OF HIGHLY IBR-PENETRATED NETWORKS by Andrés E Quintero \ad 1 \corr, Vinícius A Lacerda \ad 1, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt \ad 1, Moisés J. B. B. Davi \ad 2, Mario Oleskovicz \ad 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-21385.txt.

Introduction

Andrés E. Quintero and colleagues warn in 2025 that inverter controls can sabotage the relays protecting transmission lines. As solar and wind inverters replace spinning generators, fault currents shrink toward the inverters' nominal rating and take shapes protection never anticipated. The team simulated an IEEE 39-bus network of grid-forming and grid-following inverters, with current limiting, ride-through logic, and prioritisation.

Two protection schemes were tested. Distance protection, using a mho characteristic, could overestimate a fault's location for phase-to-ground loops near the first zone's reach. Differential protection, using an alpha-plane method, faced the opposite failure: for external faults, the operating point briefly entered the trip region, on the healthy phase of some faults under grid-following control. Both strike in the first moments. The authors conclude converter controls, current limits, and priority choices can undermine how reliable and secure older schemes are, needing stronger safeguards.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrés E Quintero \ad 1 \corr, Vinícius A Lacerda \ad 1, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt \ad 1, Moisés J. B. B. Davi \ad 2, Mario Oleskovicz \ad 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-21385

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

INFLUENCE OF CONVERTER CURRENT LIMITING AND PRIORITIZATION ON PROTECTION OF HIGHLY IBR-PENETRATED NETWORKS Andrés E Quintero \ad 1 \corr, Vinícius A Lacerda \ad 1, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt \ad 1, Moisés J. B. B. Davi \ad 2, Mario Oleskovicz \ad 2 Abstract This paper investigates how grid-forming (GFM) and grid-following (GFL) control strategies in inverter-based resources (IBRs) influence line distance and differential protection in converter-dominated transmission systems. A modified IEEE 39-bus system is evaluated with GFM and GFL units equipped with low-voltage ride-through logic, current limiting, and positive- or negative-sequence prioritization. Distance protection is implemented with a mho characteristic, while line differential protection uses an alpha-plane approach. Results show that phase-to-ground loops in distance protection can substantially overestimate the fault location near the Zone-1 reach. For line differential protection, external faults may cause the operating point to briefly enter the trip region of the alpha-plane, even for the healthy-phase in ABG faults under GFL control and during the initial moments of the fault, demanding strong external security measures. These findings highlight that modern converter controls, together with current limitation and sequence-current prioritization, can compromise the reliability and security of traditional protection schemes. keywords CURRENT LIMITATION, CURRENT PRIORITIZATION, INVERTER-BASED RESOURCES, LINE PROTECTION ALGORITHMS, LVRT 1 Introduction The transition towards renewable-dominated power systems has introduced a steady increase in inverter-based resources (IBRs) in transmission networks. This transition has resulted in challenges for the operation and protection of these systems 10374177 , IEEE_PES_TR81_2020 . IBRs are power-electronic interfaces that exhibit different fault current behavior, thus not following the behavior expected from traditional synchronous generators. Furthermore, in actual power systems these IBRs are integrated into the networks primarily through two control strategies, grid-following (GFL) and grid-forming (GFM), with the latter introduced to overcome limitations of conventional GFL approaches 9982455 . This integration has not occurred without challenges. Specifically, line protection such as distance, directional, and phase-selection algorithms are being affected SEL1 , 8666728 , 10542885 . The operational differences between synchronous generators and inverter-based resources (IBRs) are essential to evaluating the performance of traditional protection schemes. A critical distinction lies in the limited short-circuit contribution of IBRs, which typically remains close to their nominal rating 9973369 . To ensure converter integrity, various current-limiting strategies have been proposed and implemented—ranging from control in the stationary frame to the synchronous reference frame ZAREI2021107020 , 10362015 , 10842930 . These dynamics have been recently studied 10807525 , 10689179 and they also influence the dynamic response and system stability during disturbances and its capacity to support the system during low-voltage ride-through (LVRT) events. This has led to efforts to seek improved control strategies for GFM and GFL converters during LVRT 9948153 . Consequently, this change of paradigm is directly impacting relay sensitivity, selectivity, and fault detection reliability. To better understand how protection functions are affected by GFL and GFM control, several works have attempted to address this matter 10547428 , 11193857 . The recent contributions make clear the current need to understand how protection systems are affected by converters. Moreover, a crucial aspect is the existence of many approaches to control and operate GFM and GFL converters, resulting in a wider scope and greater challenge for researchers, making the analysis harder since there is no standard approach and the implementation is usually up to the developer, where only compliance with certain requirements is mandatory. However, most works tend to analyze the response of the system considering only grid-following or grid-forming control approaches, leaving room for a more comprehensive review considering both solutions. The performance of protection functions is also affected by the capability of an IBR to inject positive- and/or negative-sequence currents during LVRT events of asymmetrical faults, which is determined by its control design. This aspect is relevant given that some IBRs are limited to positive-sequence injection only, which restricts the fault signatures detectable by protection devices and reduces the information available for accurate fault classification and localization 10902358 . Moreover, implementing GFL controls that can handle only positive-sequence injection has been shown to negatively affect negative-sequence directional overcurrent and quadrilateral distance protection elements 10547428 . Even after the efforts to understand the impacts of high IBR penetration in modern power systems, there are topics that still need further exploration. For instance, how current limiting and prioritization affect different protection functions is scarcely studied, considering that the selected method will directly affect the electrical quantities available for relays to operate. Furthermore, line differential protection is usually considered to be blinded against these new scenarios and is not often studied. This work therefore proposes to explore how current limitation and prioritization strategies could affect the operation of line distance and alpha-plane differential protection. 2 Converter control schemes: GFM and GFL Given the critical influence of the control scheme on protection algorithm performance, as highlighted in recent studies, the GFM and GFL strategies, including the current-limiting and prioritization modules, were implemented to assess line protection behavior. The converter connection at the transmission level is shown in Fig. 1 . Each unit connects to the high-voltage terminal v_{g}^{abc} through a delta–wye transformer, synthesizes the terminal voltage v_{m}^{abc} , and measures the current i_{c}^{abc} and voltage v_{c}^{abc} after the filter inductance L . Figure 1 : Grid-forming converter interface to the AC network The GFM control strategy consists of a cascaded control formed by an outer voltage loop that generates current references, which then pass through the inner current-control loop. The control is performed in decoupled positive- and negative-sequence qd frames, enabling independent control of both sequences, which is important for assessing the performance of the protection functions. The inner loop employs typical PI controls, while the outer loop uses a virtual admittance that responds to grid-voltage changes; this is shown in Fig. 2 . Figure 2 : Control structure of the grid-forming unit Virtual-admittance voltage control has attracted notable interest recently 9640078 , 9189190 , exhibiting favorable small-signal stability margins for GFM operation against strong grids, often exceeding those of virtual-impedance schemes 9662150 . The parameters R_{v} and L_{v} correspond to the admittance parameters, while the term \omega L_{v} captures the cross-coupling between the q and d axes. Their absolute values and ratio are key determinants of closed-loop stability 9662150 . Active- and reactive-power regulation in the GFM unit are achieved through virtual synchronous generator and reactive droop control schemes, respectively, as shown in Fig. 3(a) and Fig. 3(b) . The active-power loop provides inertial behavior and smooth convergence to the reference power, while the reactive-power loop maintains voltage regulation at the PCC through a proportional–integral controller. ((a)) Virtual synchronous generator ((b)) Reactive power droop Figure 3 : P and Q control schemes Within this architecture, the virtual-admittance stage delivers the unconstrained references \hat{i}^{qd^{\pm}} , after which LVRT requirements and a current-limiting block produce the final references i^{qd^{\pm}} delivered to the inner current controllers. The grid-following control, shown in Fig. 4 , is simpler and includes an inner current loop and a PLL locked to the v_{d} component, with voltage and current qd components obtained via a decoupled double synchronous reference frame (DDSRF). The reference current i^{*qd^{\pm}} is modified by the LVRT logic, complying with reactive-current requirements, and then passed to the current-limiting and prioritization stage. Figure 4 : Control structure of

Read the complete text