Particle Builder A Board Game for the Teaching of the Standard Model of Particle Physics at a Secondary Level.
Lachlan McGinness, Yutong Ma, Mohammad Attar, Andrew Carse, Yeming Chen, Thomas Green, Jeong-Yeon Ha, Yanbai Jin, Amy McWilliams, Theirry Panggabean, Zhengyu Peng, Jing Ru, Jiacheng She, Lujin Sun, Jialin Wang, Zilun Wei, Jiayuan Zhu · 2025
Read Particle Builder A Board Game for the Teaching of the Standard Model of Particle Physics at a Secondary Level. by Lachlan McGinness, Yutong Ma, Mohammad Attar, Andrew Carse, Yeming Chen, Thomas Green, Jeong-Yeon Ha, Yanbai Jin, Amy McWilliams, Theirry Panggabean, Zhengyu Peng, Jing Ru, Jiacheng She, Lujin Sun, Jialin Wang, Zilun Wei, Jiayuan Zhu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-21116.txt.
Introduction
Lachlan McGinness and colleagues evaluate in 2025 Particle Builder, a board game that teaches the Standard Model of particle physics to secondary students. Particle physics entered many school curricula over the last decade, yet its particles are abstract. The game, built in 2016 by teachers from several countries, turns them into cards listing each particle's charge, spin, mass, and lifetime, drawn from Particle Data Group values.
Players build particles from quarks across seven levels of rising difficulty, reaching exchange particles, colour charge, and neutrino oscillations. The physical game has been viewed over 11,000 times and downloaded more than 2,000 times from CERN's Zenodo archive; a browser version pits students against a simple AI. In trials with 281 Australian high school students, 225 completed pre- and post-tests. Their average learning gain was 0.16 after a one-to-two-hour game session, comparable to the 0.17 gain from a week and a half of traditional instruction.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lachlan McGinness, Yutong Ma, Mohammad Attar, Andrew Carse, Yeming Chen, Thomas Green, Jeong-Yeon Ha, Yanbai Jin, Amy McWilliams, Theirry Panggabean, Zhengyu Peng, Jing Ru, Jiacheng She, Lujin Sun, Jialin Wang, Zilun Wei, Jiayuan Zhu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 11 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-21116
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Particle Builder A Board Game for the Teaching of the Standard Model of Particle Physics at a Secondary Level. Lachlan McGinness, Yutong Ma, Mohammad Attar, Andrew Carse, Yeming Chen, Thomas Green, Jeong-Yeon Ha, Yanbai Jin, Amy McWilliams, Theirry Panggabean, Zhengyu Peng, Jing Ru, Jiacheng She, Lujin Sun, Jialin Wang, Zilun Wei, Jiayuan Zhu Abstract I Introduction Over the last decade, the Standard Model of Particle Physics has been included in many secondary physics curricula worldwide [ 1 ] . However, its abstract nature and heavy reliance on symbolic representation make it difficult to teach at the secondary-school level. In response, a number of hands on resources have been developed to teach specialised lessons on scattering [ 2 ] , anti-matter [ 3 ] and quarks [ 4 ] . The Particle Builder board game was created in 2016, by an international group of physics teachers. The game introduces the structure of matter and core ideas of particle physics through interactive gameplay, allowing students to build particle systems, compare their properties, and discover the underlying rules of the Standard Model themselves. The physical version of the board game is freely available on CERN’s Zenodo repository (https://zenodo.org/records/3594204) and has been viewed over 11,000 times and downloaded over 2000 times [ 5 ] . However, there is a significant time cost for classroom teachers to print sufficient copies of the game for a class to play. To address this problem, the game was later adapted into a browser-based format that allows students to play against a basic Artificial Intelligence (AI) [ 6 , 7 ] , available at https://particle-builder.anu.edu.au. We have tested the game with 281 Australian high school students. Of these, 225 completed both a pre-test and post-survey, allowing us to evaluate their learning outcomes and collect feedback on the game. We use these data to determine whether the game can improve student understanding of the Standard Model. II The Particle Builder Game There are seven ‘game’ levels in Particle Builder with different rules. Level one is the simplest, while level seven contains the most analogies to particle physics concepts. In the most basic version of the game, students collect cards, which represent fundamental particles, to build a particle system (‘target’). Each card lists the key properties of a fundamental particle, including its electric charge, spin, mass and mean lifetime, see Figure 1 . These values are taken from the Particle Data Group [ 8 ] and related sources [ 9 , 10 ] . Students compare these quantities and learn to identify which group each particle belongs to, distinguishing among quarks, leptons, and bosons. During play, students also encounter essential ideas such as the Pauli Exclusion Principle, anti-matter and annihilation. Figure 1: The Up Quark card from Particle Builder. The card contains the electric charge, spin, mass and mean lifetime which the students must examine regularly in the game. Electric charge is given in units of elementary charge (e). The higher levels incorporate many other particle physics concepts. These concepts include the fundamental forces and exchange particles (level 2), color charge (level 3), randomness and probability (level 4), W^{+} and W^{-} transformations (level 5), neutrino oscillations (level 6), and spontaneous decay/transformation (level 7). Baryons, mesons and other particle systems such as positronium and hydrogen serve as targets that players attempt to build. The game is designed for upper secondary students and takes about ten minutes per round. In a typical one hour lesson, students can complete the first two levels, replaying them to reinforce understanding before advancing to higher levels. Particle Builder makes use of the anti-colour convention proposed by Wiener in 2017 [ 11 ] . Research has shown that younger students often hold misconceptions about particle physics, including imagining particles as static objects, or assuming that particles have the same properties as macroscopic matter such as colour, temperature, or even personification [ 12 ] . To minimize these misunderstandings, the Particle Builder illustrations intentionally avoid representing the fundamental particles as spheres. Instead, the cards feature abstract, imaginative characters to emphasize that the images are symbolic rather than realistic. The online version was developed by students at the Australian National University and maintains the structure of the original board game. The online platform provides a tutorial to help students learn to play. Many studies have found that digital and gamified learning environments can increase student engagement and concentration while reducing learning-related stress [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] .Figure 2 shows the basic gameplay flow, while Figure 3 presents a screenshot of the interface. Figure 2: Flow diagram showing the basic gameplay of Particle Builder. Full instructions for playing the game can be found at Zenodo [ 5 ] . Figure 3: Screenshot of the online version of Particle Builder, showing a human player versus the AI opponent. III Learning Outcomes Particle builder covers learning outcomes included in many high school curricula such as [ 1 , 19 , 18 ] : • recognize and name the six flavors of lepton and the six flavors of quarks • understand that all leptons and quarks have corresponding antiparticles • appreciate that quarks and anti-quarks combine to form baryons, anti-baryons and mesons • write balanced strong interactions, understanding the role of gluons • write balanced weak interactions, understanding the role of W and Z bosons Particle Builder directly supports these learning goals through its level-based design: • Level 1: Students identify particle types (quarks, leptons, and bosons), and compare their electric charge, spin, mass, and lifetime. They also learn to recognize particle-antiparticle pairs and understand annihilation. • Level 2: Students explore the fundamental forces and their exchange particles (photon, gluon, Z boson). • Level 3: Students investigate color charge by assigning color to quarks and combining them into color neutral systems. • Level 4: Students are introduced to randomness through probabilistic interaction outcomes. • Level 5: Students apply conservation of charge, baryon number, and lepton family number through W^{+} and W^{-} transformations. • Level 6: Students simulate neutrino oscillations by allowing flavor changes among neutrinos. • Level 7: Students investigate particle decays. IV Survey Methods We wrote a set of nine questions which take students on average 5-6 minutes to complete as a pre and post survey. The survey covers the core topics covered in more than 60% of curricula [ 1 ] , focusing on anti-matter and annihilation , leptons and quarks , particle interactions , and particle systems . This was given to the students a few days prior to activity. The same questions were given again as a post-test afterwards. No other particle physics instruction was given between the surveys. We had two control groups, where we evaluated the gain from 1.5 weeks (approximately 7 hours) of particle physics instruction. One control group ( N=23 ) received traditional instruction (powerpoints and worksheets), while the other ( N=7 ) received traditional instruction but completed the quark-puzzle activity [ 4 ] in the place of one traditional lesson. We use this as a baseline measure but note that the improvement in the controls is for more than a week’s worth of instruction, not just a single activity or lesson. The game was taken to secondary school