The Effect of the Fast-Flavor Instability on Core-Collapse Supernova Models: II. Quasi-Equipartition and the Impact of Various Angular Reconstruction Methods

Tianshu Wang, Adam Burrows · 2025

Read The Effect of the Fast-Flavor Instability on Core-Collapse Supernova Models: II. Quasi-Equipartition and the Impact of Various Angular Reconstruction Methods by Tianshu Wang, Adam Burrows (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20767.txt.

Introduction

Tianshu Wang and Adam Burrows test in 2025 a cheap shortcut for a costly supernova effect. Inside a collapsing star, neutrinos are so dense that they can swap flavours through the fast flavour instability, altering the signals astronomers predict. Simulating that conversion is brutal: it unfolds in nanoseconds, 500 to 1,000 times faster than a simulation timestep, and can slow calculations by factors of 10 to 20.

Wang and Burrows ran one- and two-dimensional supernova simulations with fast flavour conversion on, testing angular reconstruction methods and three-species versus four-species neutrino transport. The conversion's effects proved insensitive to those choices, and the star's flow changed only slightly. Their deliverable is a quasi-equipartition approximation: rework an ordinary simulation without oscillations to estimate the converted signals. Its errors in neutrino counts and energies stayed below 2 percent for one-dimensional models and below 10 percent in two dimensions, sparing groups the cost of full physics.

Catalog record

CREATORTianshu Wang, Adam Burrows
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20767

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Effect of the Fast-Flavor Instability on Core-Collapse Supernova Models: II. Quasi-Equipartition and the Impact of Various Angular Reconstruction Methods Tianshu Wang, Adam Burrows Abstract In this work, we explore in a consistent fashion the effects of fast flavor conversion (FFC) in 1D and 2D core-collapse supernova (CCSN) simulations. In addition, we investigate the impact of various angular reconstruction methods and compare the “3-species” and “4-species” neutrino transport schemes. We find that the FFC effects are insensitive to the different methods tested and that the FFC alters supernova hydrodynamics is only minor ways. We also present a “quasi-equipartition” approximation which can be used to estimate the FFC-altered neutrino properties by post-processing the neutrino signals extracted from no-oscillation CCSN simulations. The relative errors in neutrino number and energy luminosities of this phenomenological method are less than 2% for 1D models, and less than 10% for 2D models. This method provides a simple way to include the effects of FFC on neutrino signals without implementing a complex and expensive FFC scheme or redoing simulations. I Introduction With the extremely high neutrino number density, the core of a core-collapse supernova (CCSN) serves as an ideal environment for collective neutrino oscillations ( 9 ; 5 ; 13 ; 20 ) . Fast flavor conversion (FFC), triggered by the fast flavor instability (FFI), is arguably the most discussed scenario in the collective oscillation context ( 42 ; 43 ; 52 ; 44 ; 36 ; 18 ; 50 ; 33 ; 39 ; 26 ; 32 ; 31 ; 53 ; 57 ) . With timescales as short as a few nanoseconds, there is a possibility that FFC changes the neutrino radiation fields and signatures and the hydrodynamics of CCSN models in a significant way. There have been attempts to identify where in the supernova core angular crossings could occur ( 2 ; 16 ; 25 ; 1 ; 19 ; 28 ; 41 ; 40 ; 7 ) , but the feedback on supernova hydrodynamics is often missing in those studies. There have also been attempts to perform supernova and binary neutrino star (BNS) merger simulations with parameterized models of the effects of the FFC ( 10 ; 11 ; 24 ; 34 ; 35 ) . These generally make ad hoc assumptions about flavor mixing and where and when it occurs, and the results depend sensitively on the chosen free parameters whose values and appropriateness are quite uncertain. Therefore, the effects of FFC on the CCSN outcomes remain uncertain. However, currently the full quantum kinetic calculation of the FFC is in general too expensive to be included in sophisticated radiation-hydrodynamic simulations of CCSNe. First, the instability criterion of the FFI is that the angular distribution of the difference between electron lepton number and heavy lepton number (ELN-XLN) crosses zero ( 8 ; 26 ; 12 ) . To accurately capture the development of FFC, the neutrino angular distribution evolution needs to be closely followed, which requires an expensive multi-angle neutrino transport scheme. Compared to current multi-dimensional CCSN simulations, this may lead to a computational slow-down by factors of 10 to 20. Second, the timescale of the FFC can be as short as a few nanoseconds, which is about 500 - 1000 times shorter than the typical hydrodynamic timestep in CCSN simulations. In addition, as a quantum effect, the accurate treatment of FFC requires the evolution of the entire density matrix, instead of only its diagonal terms, which leads to another factor of two slow-down. In short, a comprehensive treatment of the FFC would make CCSN simulations four to five orders of magnitude slower, which will not be affordable any time soon. Therefore, in order to make progress, several approximate methods have been explored. By assuming that the angular distributions have a certain functional form, closure relations have been used in classic or quantum angular-moment methods to avoid the expensive multi-angle transport scheme ( 61 ; 18 ; 28 ; 27 ; 14 ; 22 ) . Instead of following the nanosecond-timescale evolution of the FFC, several methods have been proposed to predict the asymptotic/steady states of fast neutrino-flavor conversion ( 37 ; 58 ; 15 ; 38 ; 21 ; 17 ) , which enables the use of a larger timestep in the simulations. Some of the asymptotic/steady state prediction methods rely on only the diagonal terms of the density matrix and can be applied to classic neutrino transport schemes. Therefore, each of the three major slow-down factors of the FFC calculation can be removed through reasonable approximations, and a combination of these methods allows the FFC to be included in CCSN simulations without undue extra computational cost. 56 adopted such a combined method in 1D (spherical) and 2D (axis-symmetric) CCSN simulations and finds that the FFC effects significantly change the neutrino properties, while leaving CCSN hydrodynamics almost unchanged. This is because the FFC occurs mostly at relatively large radii where neutrino-matter interactions become very weak. Although the results look intriguing, this study has several limitations. First, 56 used a “3-species” neutrino transport scheme in which \nu_{\mu} , \bar{\nu}_{\mu} , \nu_{\tau} , and \bar{\nu}_{\tau} were assumed to have exactly the same properties. Without FFC, this is a good approximation if muons and tauons are ignored. However, when the FFC is operating, differences between \nu_{e} and \bar{\nu}_{e} can be converted into differences between heavy lepton neutrinos and anti-neutrinos and enforcing \nu_{\mu}=\bar{\nu}_{\mu}=\nu_{\tau}=\bar{\nu}_{\tau} breaks total ELN-XLN conservation. Although it is argued in 56 that the errors introduced by the “3-species” scheme are tolerable, such arguments need to be tested by a “4-species” scheme in which heavy lepton neutrinos and anti-neutrinos are treated separately. Second, the effects of the angular reconstruction methods, i.e., the closure choices, have yet to be studied. 7 uses several different post-processing methods to identify the FFI unstable regions in 1D CCSN models and finds that different closures (and other types of ELN-XLN crossing identification methods) can lead to significantly different results. However, it’s unclear if such sensitivity is due to the FFC itself or due to the different treatments of the neutrino angular distributions between the transport calculation and the post-processed FFI identification. In addition, it’s unclear if feedback from the supernova simulation suppresses or enhances the sensitivity. Therefore, a self-consistent sensitivity study of angular reconstruction methods using an on-the-fly FFC treatment is preferred. In this work, we present models in both 1D (spherical) and 2D (axisymmetric) done with different fast-flavor conversion schemes. We compare the FFC results calculated by the “4-species” and “3-species” schemes. Under the “4-species” scheme, we compare the FFC results calculated using three different closures. We find that the findings in 56 can be reproduced by all the FFC methods mentioned here, showing that the presented FFC effects are robust. In addition, we study in detail the FFC effects on the radiated supernova neutrinos. We find that the neutrino signals extracted from CCSN models without any FFC calculation can be post-processed by a “quasi-equipartition” method to mimic the FFC effects. This phenomenological method provides a simple way to include the effects of FFC on neutrino signals without implementing a complex and expensive FFC scheme and re-doing the simulations. This paper is arranged as follows: in Section II ,

Read the complete text