CHIPS-TB: Evaluating Tight-Binding Models For Metals, Semiconductors, and Insulators Journal: Nuclear Physics B

In Jun Park, Kamal Choudhary · 2025

Read CHIPS-TB: Evaluating Tight-Binding Models For Metals, Semiconductors, and Insulators Journal: Nuclear Physics B by In Jun Park, Kamal Choudhary (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20740.txt.

Introduction

In Jun Park and Kamal Choudhary present in 2025 CHIPS-TB, a framework for comparing tight-binding models, the semi-empirical shortcuts engineers use to predict a material's behaviour. The gold standard, density functional theory, is accurate but too slow for large nanoscale systems. Tight-binding models run far faster, yet parameter sets behave differently on materials, and nobody had benchmarked them under one protocol.

CHIPS-TB lines up five parameterisations, including the DFTB-based MatSci, PBC, and PTBP sets plus SlaKoNet and TB3PY, and tests them on more than 50 materials for semiconductor design. The checks cover bandgaps, band structures, and bulk modulus, how strongly a material resists squeezing. References come from two density-functional methods, OptB88vdW and TBmBJ-DFT, and from experimental data in the JARVIS-DFT database. The code is on GitHub and results sit on the JARVIS-Leaderboard, so new parameter sets face the same yardstick.

Catalog record

CREATORIn Jun Park, Kamal Choudhary
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20740

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

CHIPS-TB: Evaluating Tight-Binding Models For Metals, Semiconductors, and Insulators Journal: Nuclear Physics B In Jun Park, Kamal Choudhary Abstract As semiconductor technologies continue to scale down to the nanoscale, the efficient prediction of material properties becomes increasingly critical. The tight-binding (TB) method is a widely used semi-empirical approach that offers a computationally tractable alternative to Density Functional Theory (DFT) for large-scale electronic structure calculations. However, conventional TB models often suffer from limited transferability and lack standardized benchmarking protocols. In this study, we introduce a computational framework (CHIPS-TB) for evaluating and comparing tight-binding parameterizations across diverse material systems relevant to semiconductor design, focusing on properties such as electronic bandgaps, band structures, and bulk modulus. We assess model parameterizations including Density Functional Tight-Binding (DFTB)-based MatSci, PBC, PTBP, SlaKoNet and TB3PY against OptB88vdW, TBmBJ-DFT and experimental reference data from the JARVIS-DFT database for 50+ materials pertinent to semiconductor applications. The CHIPS-TB code will be made publicly available on GitHub and benchmarks will be available on JARVIS-Leaderboard. 1 Introduction The continued miniaturization of semiconductor devices has amplified the demand for accurate and efficient predictive modeling of material properties. While Density Functional Theory (DFT) [ 36 ] remains a cornerstone of first-principles electronic structure calculations, its high computational cost limits its applicability to large or complex systems, particularly in high-throughput and device-scale simulations [ 40 , 23 ] . To overcome these limitations, the tight-binding (TB) method has emerged as a widely adopted semi-empirical alternative [ 37 , 27 , 30 , 20 , 2 , 14 , 47 , 17 , 35 , 10 ] . By simplifying the electronic structure problem through the use of localized atomic orbitals and empirical hopping parameters, TB methods offer orders-of-magnitude improvements in computational efficiency compared to DFT. The term tight in tight-binding refers to the approximation that atomic wave function overlap is confined primarily to neighboring atoms. This simplification enables the omission of long-range interactions in the Hamiltonian, significantly reducing computational complexity. The TB method is a semi-empirical computational approach capable of calculating electronic band structures while accounting for external influences such as strain, electric fields, and optical radiation on the material system [ 19 , 31 , 42 , 33 , 34 , 44 , 28 , 13 , 9 ] . This has enabled their use in applications ranging from nanodevice modeling to materials discovery. The TB approach is primarily employed to compute the band structure and single-particle Bloch states of materials. Parameters for the TB Hamiltonian, typically expressed in real-space, are derived from first-principles calculations to ensure physical accuracy. This parameterized Hamiltonian can then be applied to simulate very large systems, including both periodic and non-periodic structures, at a significantly reduced computational cost. Constructing a TB Hamiltonian involves developing a model that accurately reproduces the band energies obtained from reference first-principles methods. Several variants of the TB method have been developed to improve accuracy, transferability, and computational efficiency across diverse material systems. At the core of many of these approaches is the Slater-Koster (SK) formalism, which parameterizes hopping integrals based on orbital symmetries and directional cosines. This foundational model provides a versatile framework that underpins much of modern TB methodology. Among the more advanced variants, Wannier-function-based TB models derive parameters directly from first-principles calculations, offering a high degree of accuracy while preserving computational efficiency [ 26 ] . The Density Functional Tight-Binding (DFTB) method extends traditional TB by incorporating self-consistent charge corrections and repulsive potentials, making it a popular choice for complex systems [ 10 , 19 ] . Further refinements include the three-body tight-binding (TB3PY) model, which introduces additional interaction terms to improve band structure predictions across a wider range of materials [ 12 ] . Semiempirical methods such as Parametric Method 6 with D3 Dispersion, H4 Hydrogen-Bonding, and Halogen-Bonding Corrections (PM6-D3H4X) [ 39 ] , Third-order Density Functional based Tight-Binding method augmented with Grimme’s D3 dispersion correction using Becke-Johnson damping (DFTB3-D3(BJ)), and Geometry, Frequency, Noncovalent, version 2 - extended Tight-Binding (GFN2-xTB) [ 2 ] enhance standard TB approaches by integrating dispersion corrections and multipole electrostatics, extending their applicability to molecular and condensed-phase systems. More recently, the Parameterized Tight-Binding (PTB) model has been proposed to generate transferable Hamiltonians based on high-throughput data fitting, aiming to bridge the gap between accuracy and generalizability [ 8 ] . Another advanced approach is SlaKoNet, a neural network framework based on the Slater-Koster tight-binding formalism [ 6 ] . SlaKoNet aims to optimize TB parameters by training on higher-level DFT data, such as meta-GGA bandgaps, using PyTorch-based neural networks for improved scalability and accuracy across diverse systems. Collectively, these models represent a spectrum of trade-offs between physical rigor and computational speed, highlighting the need for systematic benchmarking across material classes to guide the development of reliable TB parameterizations. Despite the promise of TB methods, a major challenge remains: transferability. TB models, being parameter-dependent, often fail to maintain accuracy across chemically and structurally diverse systems. This highlights the need for systematic benchmarking frameworks that can quantitatively assess their predictive capabilities relative to trusted reference data. Some of the previous works pertaining to TB benchmarking include works by Gruden et al. for reaction energetics [ 15 ] , Oliveira et al. [ 29 ] for small clusters. While previous benchmarking efforts (e.g., CHIPS-FF) have focused on evaluating interatomic force fields [ 45 ] , the unique characteristics of electronic structure prediction with tight-binding models necessitate a specialized framework. Evaluating band structures, bandgaps, and electronic states requires distinct metrics and analyses to understand how TB approximations impact charge distribution, electron-hole interactions, and band dispersion. This work, CHIPS-TB, provides a unique contribution by focusing specifically on these electronic properties and offering insights into the underlying physics captured by different TB formalisms. In this work, we present a computational benchmarking framework for evaluating TB models using reference data from the JARVIS-DFT database [ 3 , 46 , 7 ] . We focus on two representative TB approaches, DFTB and TB3PY , along with SlaKoNet, and benchmark their performance across 50+ materials relevant to semiconductor applications. By comparing key electronic structure metrics such as bandgaps and eigenvalue spectra, we assess the strengths and limitations of each model, with the goal of guiding future development of transferable and efficient TB parameterizations. 2 Methodology Figure 1: Workflow for the evaluation of tight-binding models. Structural information and pre-calculated DFT properties are obtained from the JARVIS-DFT database. The structural data serves as input to various electronic structure methods-including VASP (OptB88vdW (OPT)-DFT) , TB3PY (tight-binding), and DFTB (tight-binding) to compute key material properties such as bandstructure, density of states, bandgap (E g ), and bulk modulus ( K ). These computed properties are compared against DFT references using the run\_chipstb.py script with a configuration file (e.g., tb\_input.json ). The resulting performance metrics are reported on the JARVIS Leaderboard to evaluate the accuracy of different tight-binding models. We developed a computational framework for benchmarking tight-binding (TB) models against reference data from the JARVIS-DFT database, which includes OptB88vdW (OPT)-DFT [ 18 ] and TB-mBJ [ 41 ] calculations performed using the Vienna Ab-initio Simulation Package (VASP) [ 21 , 22 ] , the JARVIS-Tools package, as well as available experimental data. The methodology consists of three main steps: (1) extracting

Read the complete text