Cross Domain Evaluation of Multimodal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning of different datasets into the Amazon CoT Framework
Nitya Tiwari, Parv Maheshwari, Vidisha Agarwal · 2025
Read Cross Domain Evaluation of Multimodal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning of different datasets into the Amazon CoT Framework by Nitya Tiwari, Parv Maheshwari, Vidisha Agarwal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20701.txt.
Introduction
Nitya Tiwari, Parv Maheshwari, and Vidisha Agarwal ask in 2025 whether a reasoning method that shines on science questions survives broader topics. The method, Multimodal Chain-of-Thought, first writes out a short rationale, then infers the final answer from it. Image features enter a T5 language model through a gated fusion step. The method had set records on the ScienceQA benchmark, so the team carried it to three different datasets.
They tested A-OKVQA and OKVQA, which demand commonsense and world knowledge about images. They also tested ChartQA, which asks questions about data charts. Ablation studies, removing one part at a time, showed that vision features significantly reduced invented details in the rationales. Even so, reasoning quality swung widely by question type. Commonsense questions proved the hardest to handle well. The authors close with practical guidance for builders of multimodal reasoning systems and the weak points where generalisation still fails.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nitya Tiwari, Parv Maheshwari, Vidisha Agarwal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20701
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cross Domain Evaluation of Multimodal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning of different datasets into the Amazon CoT Framework Nitya Tiwari, Parv Maheshwari, Vidisha Agarwal Abstract While recent work has extended CoT to multimodal settings, achieving state-of-the-art results on science question answering benchmarks like ScienceQA, the generalizability of these approaches across diverse domains remains underexplored. This work presents a comprehensive analysis of Multimodal Chain-of-Thought (Multimodal-CoT) reasoning, evaluating its effectiveness on the A-OKVQA, OKVQA and ChartQA datasets, which requires broad commonsense and world knowledge beyond scientific reasoning. We implement the two-stage framework proposed by Zhang et al. [ 3 ] , which separates rationale generation from answer inference and integrates vision features through a gated fusion mechanism with T5-based language models. Through systematic ablation studies, we analyze the contributions of vision features, rationale quality, and architectural choices. Our findings reveal that while vision integration significantly reduces hallucination in rationale generation, the effectiveness of CoT reasoning varies substantially across question types, with commonsense reasoning presenting particular challenges. This work provides practical insights for researchers implementing multimodal reasoning systems and identifies key areas for future improvement in cross-domain generalization. 1 Introduction The remarkable success of large language models (LLMs) in recent years has been significantly enhanced by Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting [ 4 ] , a technique that encourages models to generate intermediate reasoning steps before arriving at final answers. This approach has proven particularly effective for complex reasoning tasks, enabling models to decompose multi-step problems into more manageable sub-problems. However, most CoT research has focused exclusively on text-based reasoning, leaving the multimodal domain—where vision and language must be jointly processed—relatively unexplored. Human reasoning naturally integrates information from multiple modalities. Consider reading a science textbook: our comprehension is greatly enhanced by the interplay between textual explanations and visual diagrams, figures, and tables. This multimodal nature of human knowledge acquisition motivates the development of AI systems capable of similar integrated reasoning. The challenge lies not only in processing multiple modalities but in generating coherent reasoning chains that effectively leverage both visual and textual information. Recent work by Zhang et al. [ 3 ] introduced Multimodal-CoT, a framework that incorporates both language and vision modalities into a two-stage reasoning process. Their approach achieved state-of-the-art performance on the ScienceQA benchmark [ 5 ] , demonstrating that models under 1 billion parameters can perform effective multimodal reasoning when properly structured. However, a critical question remains: How well does Multimodal-CoT generalize beyond scientific questions to broader domains requiring diverse forms of reasoning? 1.1 Motivation and Research Questions While the success of Multimodal-CoT on ScienceQA is impressive, scientific reasoning represents only one facet of human cognition. Real-world multimodal reasoning encompasses diverse challenges including commonsense understanding, world knowledge, spatial reasoning, and cultural context—domains where the characteristics of questions and required reasoning strategies may differ substantially from structured science problems. This work addresses the following research questions: 1. Domain Generalization : How does Multimodal-CoT perform on open-domain multimodal reasoning tasks that require commonsense and world knowledge rather than scientific principles? 2. Failure Modes : What types of reasoning errors occur when applying Multimodal-CoT to diverse question types, and how do these differ from errors in scientific reasoning? 3. Practical Implementation : What are the computational requirements and practical considerations for deploying Multimodal-CoT systems with limited resources? 2 Literature Review 2.1 Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting emerged as a breakthrough technique for eliciting complex reasoning from large language models. Wei et al. [ 4 ] demonstrated that providing few-shot examples with intermediate reasoning steps dramatically improves performance on arithmetic, commonsense, and symbolic reasoning tasks. This work established that sufficiently large models (typically exceeding 100 billion parameters) exhibit emergent reasoning abilities when prompted appropriately. Subsequent research has explored various aspects of CoT reasoning: Zero-Shot CoT : Kojima et al. [ 7 ] showed that simply appending phrases like ”Let’s think step by step” to questions enables zero-shot CoT reasoning, eliminating the need for hand-crafted examples. This demonstrates that reasoning capabilities are latent within the models rather than purely learned from demonstrations. Self-Consistency : Wang et al. [ 8 ] introduced self-consistency decoding, which samples multiple reasoning paths and selects the most consistent answer through majority voting. This approach significantly improves reliability by mitigating the impact of spurious reasoning chains. Least-to-Most Prompting : Zhou et al. [ 9 ] proposed decomposing complex problems into simpler sub-problems solved sequentially, with each solution building on previous results. This hierarchical approach proves particularly effective for compositional reasoning tasks. Automatic CoT Generation : Zhang et al. [ 10 ] developed Auto-CoT, which automatically constructs diverse demonstrations by clustering questions and generating reasoning chains using zero-shot CoT. This reduces the manual effort required for prompt engineering while maintaining effectiveness. Despite these advances, CoT research has predominantly focused on text-only scenarios, with limited exploration of multimodal reasoning where visual information must be integrated with textual reasoning chains. 2.2 Multimodal Learning and Vision-Language Models The integration of vision and language has been a longstanding challenge in artificial intelligence. Early approaches relied on separate vision and language modules with limited interaction [ 20 ] . Recent years have witnessed the rise of unified vision-language models that process both modalities within a single framework. Vision-Language Pretraining : Models like CLIP [ 11 ] , ALIGN [ 12 ] , and BLIP [ 13 ] learn aligned vision-language representations through contrastive learning or image-text matching objectives. These models demonstrate strong zero-shot transfer capabilities across various vision-language tasks. Large Multimodal Models : Recent work has scaled vision-language models to unprecedented sizes. Flamingo [ 14 ] interleaves visual inputs with text in a few-shot learning framework. GPT-4V extends GPT-4’s capabilities to visual inputs, while Gemini [ 15 ] provides native multimodal understanding. These models show impressive capabilities but require massive computational resources. Instruction-Tuned Multimodal Models : LLaVA [ 16 ] , InstructBLIP [ 17 ] , and LLaMA-Adapter [ 18 ] fine-tune large vision-language models on instruction-following data, enabling more flexible and controllable multimodal reasoning. However, these approaches typically rely on models with billions of parameters. A key limitation of current large multimodal models is their reliance on image captioning or visual feature extraction as an intermediate step, potentially losing fine-grained visual information critical for reasoning. Moreover, their computational requirements make deployment challenging for resource-constrained settings. 2.3 Visual Question Answering Visual Question Answering (VQA) requires models to answer natural language questions about images. Traditional VQA approaches [ 19 ] focused on relatively simple questions answerable through object detection and attribute recognition. Attention Mechanisms : Early neural VQA models employed attention mechanisms to align visual regions with question words. Methods like Bottom-Up Top-Down attention [ 20 ] , Bilinear Attention Networks (BAN) [ 21 ] , and Multi-modal Compact Bilinear pooling (MCB) [ 22 ] demonstrated the importance of fine-grained vision-language interaction. Knowledge-Based VQA : Recognizing that many questions require external knowledge beyond what is visible in images, researchers developed knowledge-augmented VQA systems. OK-VQA [ 23 ] and its successor A-OKVQA [ 6 ] explicitly require commonsense and world knowledge, making them more challenging and realistic. Reasoning in VQA : Recent work emphasizes multi-step reasoning for VQA. Visual Entailment [ 24 ] frames VQA as a reasoning task. Compositional VQA datasets like CLEVR [ 25 ] and GQA [ 26 ] require