Quantum Key Distribution: Bridging Theoretical Security Proofs, Practical Attacks, and Error Correction for Quantum-Augmented Networks

Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh, Mahadevan Subramaniam · 2025

Read Quantum Key Distribution: Bridging Theoretical Security Proofs, Practical Attacks, and Error Correction for Quantum-Augmented Networks by Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh, Mahadevan Subramaniam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20602.txt.

Introduction

Jha, Parakh, and Subramaniam review quantum key distribution from proofs to real-world attacks. Their 2025 paper surveys how quantum physics promises unbreakable shared keys. Ideal security proofs assume perfect devices and channels. Practice brings photon tricks, hardware flaws, and noisy links. Bridging that divide is the review's mission.

Protocols sort into classes by their core mechanism. BB84-style schemes rest on the uncertainty principle. Hybrid three-stage designs enable direct secure communication. Continuous-variable frameworks form a third family. Twin-field and device-independent methods get modern chapters too. Three attack families receive in-depth treatment afterward. Photon-number splitting, Trojan-horse, and jamming attacks are dissected. Quantum error correction codes then counter the damage. Advanced codes raise channel fidelity and system robustness markedly. Quantum-augmented networks tie the story to deployment. Experimental breakthroughs punctuate the theoretical survey.

Catalog record

CREATORNitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh, Mahadevan Subramaniam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE116 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20602

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Key Distribution: Bridging Theoretical Security Proofs, Practical Attacks, and Error Correction for Quantum-Augmented Networks Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh, Mahadevan Subramaniam Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is revolutionizing cryptography by promising information-theoretic security through the immutable laws of quantum mechanics. Yet, the challenge of transforming these idealized security models into practical, resilient systems remains a pressing issue, especially as quantum computing evolves. In this review, we critically dissect and synthesize the latest advancements in QKD protocols and their security vulnerabilities, with a strong emphasis on rigorous security proofs. We actively categorize contemporary QKD schemes into three key classes: uncertainty principle-based protocols (e.g., BB84), hybrid architectures that enable secure direct communication (eg, three-stage protocol), and continuous-variable frameworks. We further include two modern classes of QKD protocols, namely Twin-field QKD and Device-Independent QKD, both of which were developed to have practical implementations over the last decade. Moreover, we highlight important experimental breakthroughs and innovative mitigation strategies, including the deployment of advanced Quantum Error Correction Codes (QECCs), that significantly enhance channel fidelity and system robustness. By mapping the current landscape, from sophisticated quantum attacks to state-of-the-art error correction methods, this review fills an important gap in the literature. To bring everything together, the relevance of this review concerning quantum augmented networks (QuANets) is also presented. This allows the readers to gain a comprehensive understanding of the security promises of quantum key distribution from theoretical proofs to experimental validations. K eywords Quantum Key Distribution, Quantum communication, Quantum attacks, Quantum Error Correction Codes 1 Introduction From Caesar’s shift cipher to modern-day encryption algorithms, the need for private communication has driven cryptographic innovation for centuries. In traditional cryptography methods, two legitimate parties, Alice and Bob, share a communication channel and communicate privately even in the presence of an illegitimate party, Eve. Our current standards of secure communications are derived from the last seven decades of information science and cryptography schemes such as public-key authentication. However, in the last three decades, the introduction of quantum computers has put the security of current communications in need of serious revision. Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is one of the major candidates for secure communication in the age of quantum computers. QKD establishes shared secret keys between two parties, Alice and Bob, by exploiting the principles of quantum mechanics [ 1 , 2 ] . Throughout the last couple of decades, the development of QKD networks has made great strides. Intercity networks such as the DARPA network [ 3 ] , Trieste network [ 4 ] , Tokyo network [ 5 ] , etc., are prime examples of rapidly growing interest in the development of practical quantum networks. In addition to land-based quantum networks, the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) developed a satellite-based quantum network using a decoy-state QKD transmitter on a low-orbit satellite [ 6 ] . The rapidly growing interest in QKD calls for the evaluation of its security measures. The security of QKD is due to the inherent laws of physics [ 7 , 8 ] . The laws, such as the no-cloning principle, which dictates that unknown quantum states cannot be cloned with absolute certainty [ 9 ] . This establishes the unconditional security basis for QKD. Therefore, the use of an ideal single-photon source to transmit a quantum state to generate a key eliminates any chances that the eavesdropper could clone the state and obtain the key for themselves, thus establishing a theoretically secure key. However, single-photon sources are not the most practical in the current times and have many associated problems, such as random bursts of multiple photons [ 10 ] . There are several other issues related to the security and overall efficiency of QKD protocols, one such problem being noisy communication channels. In general, we cannot achieve 100% security for any key distribution system whose security depends on physical devices. This is due to several imperfections in physical devices and their implementations [ 11 ] . The effect of channel noise cannot be distinguished from an eavesdropper attack, and thus, it presents a serious problem. Even with quantum error correction codes (QECC), we still need to estimate the possible information leaked to the eavesdropper. This requires modification of existing security proofs of QKD protocols to account for several channel noises. In this review, we survey quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols from legacy schemes (e.g., BB84, B92) to modern designs (e.g., twin-field), covering both theoretical foundations and implementation details. The article is intended for readers with basic familiarity with quantum networking and maps protocol choices to their associated threat models by exploring practical attacks that can compromise security. We also assess QKD’s security guarantees through standard mathematical proof frameworks and, finally, review quantum error-correction codes (QECCs), at both the theoretical and implementation point of view. We also include a discussion about how these attack and defense mechanics are essential to efficient working of quantum-augmented networks (QuANets), which can serve as the long-term solution to deploy large scale quantum-augmented networks. This work is organized as follows: Sec 1.1 explains the scope of this review article. Sec 2 explains the basics of different QKD protocols. This section is divided into three subsections: protocols based on the uncertainty principle (BB84 protocol), protocols that can be used for secure communication (three-stage protocol), and continuous variable protocols. Sec 3 explores several practical attacks on the QKD system, and highlights some of the experimental and simulation-based works on the Photon-number splitting attack, the Trojan horse attack, and jamming attacks. Sec 4 goes over the security paradigms in QKD systems, summarizes some of the standard security proofs for the several QKD classes mentioned above. Sec 5 discusses some of the benchmark quantum error correction codes, along with some recent theoretical and experimental works realizing several QECCs. Sec 6 discusses the relevance of this review work in the current age of quantum networks and how this analysis can be of importance in the discussion of quantum-augmented networks (QuANets). 1.1 Scope of this Review The field of quantum communication has seen massive strides in recent years. Several practical networks have been constructed, and several practical attacks have been explored using both simulators and experimental setups. There have been several review works done on QKD and quantum cryptography. Xu et al., [ 12 ] present an in-depth review of QKD strategies and different hacking attempts on QKD networks. The work explores different theoretical security proofs associated with QKD protocols, such as Shor-Preskill [ 13 ] , and Lo-Chau [ 14 ] security proofs. However, this work does not review the security proofs for the continuous-variable QKD protocol. Apart from this, the review work was done in 2020 , and there have been significant developments regarding different attacks on quantum networks. In another study, Horace et al., [ 11 ] explored the core information-theoretic security guarantees of cryptosystems and revealed significant limitations in existing QKD security analyses. This work, too, does not explore experimental updates regarding the security of QKD protocols. The main focus of this review is to fill this gap in some significant review works regarding the security of QKD protocols, experimental works on attacks on QKD protocols, and error correction codes. The focus of this review lies in both the theoretical and

Read the complete text