The Driver-Blindness Phenomenon: Why Deep Sequence Models Default to Autocorrelation in Blood Glucose Forecasting footnoteinfo Submitted to the IFAC World Congress 2026. This work was partially supported by The LaunchPad for Diabetes program and Capital One.

Heman Shakeri · 2025

Read The Driver-Blindness Phenomenon: Why Deep Sequence Models Default to Autocorrelation in Blood Glucose Forecasting footnoteinfo Submitted to the IFAC World Congress 2026. This work was partially supported by The LaunchPad for Diabetes program and Capital One. by Heman Shakeri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20601.txt.

Introduction

Shakeri names a failure of glucose forecasting models: they ignore what drives glucose. His 2025 paper calls the pattern driver-blindness. Insulin, meals, and activity plainly move blood sugar in the body. Deep sequence models get those signals as inputs too. Yet adding them barely improves forecasts over glucose history alone.

A metric called delta-drivers measures that missing gain directly. Across the literature the gain sits near zero in study after study. Three causes interact to produce the blindness. Model designs favor copying the recent past of the target itself. Driver data arrive noisy, mistimed, and confounded in practice. Bodies differ so much that population models wash out individual patterns. Fixes include physiology-based feature encoders for the drivers. Causal regularization and per-person personalization also help partly. The paper urges journals to require the delta-drivers number. Driver-blind models should not pass as state of the art.

Catalog record

CREATORHeman Shakeri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20601

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Driver-Blindness Phenomenon: Why Deep Sequence Models Default to Autocorrelation in Blood Glucose Forecasting footnoteinfo Submitted to the IFAC World Congress 2026. This work was partially supported by The LaunchPad for Diabetes program and Capital One. Heman Shakeri Abstract Deep sequence models for blood glucose forecasting consistently fail to leverage clinically informative drivers—insulin, meals, and activity—despite well-understood physiological mechanisms. We term this Driver-Blindness and formalize it via Δ drivers \Delta_{\text{drivers}} , the performance gain of multivariate models over matched univariate baselines. Across the literature, Δ drivers \Delta_{\text{drivers}} is typically near zero. We attribute this to three interacting factors: architectural biases favoring autocorrelation (C1), data fidelity gaps that render drivers noisy and confounded (C2), and physiological heterogeneity that undermines population-level models (C3). We synthesize strategies that partially mitigate Driver-Blindness—including physiological feature encoders, causal regularization, and personalization—and recommend that future work routinely report Δ drivers \Delta_{\text{drivers}} to prevent driver-blind models from being considered state-of-the-art. keywords Blood glucose forecasting; Time series prediction; Deep learning; Multivariate modeling; Causal inference; Diabetes management. 1 Introduction Modern deep learning architectures should, in principle, be well suited to multivariate time series forecasting. Transformers, recurrent networks, and state-space models can represent long-range dependencies, attend across channels, and integrate heterogeneous signals in high-dimensional latent spaces. In practice, however, recent analyses show that many of these models behave as sophisticated univariate forecasters: prediction performance is dominated by intra-variable autocorrelation and improves little, if at all, when exogenous covariates are added 7 . Large-scale benchmarks in generic time series forecasting reach a similar conclusion: carefully tuned linear models and channel-independent residual modules often match or outperform Transformer architectures, suggesting that much of the apparent gain comes from learning deep autocorrelation rather than consistently exploiting multivariate structure ( 42 ; 10 ) . Blood glucose forecasting for people with Type 1 diabetes provides a particularly sharp instance of this broader phenomenon. In contrast to many application domains where the causal role of potential drivers is ambiguous, glucose dynamics are governed by well-established pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic mechanisms ( 2 ; 27 ) . Rapid-acting insulin has a characteristic onset, peak, and tail; meal absorption produces stereotyped increases in blood glucose over 60–120 minutes ( 8 ) ; physical activity transiently changes insulin sensitivity ( 22 ) ; circadian rhythms modulate insulin sensitivity over the day ( 14 ; 30 ) ; menstrual cycles affect glucose control in a subset of individuals, though with substantial heterogeneity ( 36 ; 16 ) . From a modeling perspective, insulin doses, carbohydrate intake, and activity should be highly informative drivers that enable forecasts beyond what continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) history alone can provide ( 40 ) . Algorithmically, the glucose forecasting literature has followed the broader evolution of time-series modeling. Early work relied on linear autoregressive models and Kalman-filter–type estimators, often coupled to simplified compartmental physiology ( 29 ; 37 ) . Subsequent studies introduced nonlinear machine-learning predictors and hybrid schemes that encode insulin and meal information into physiologically meaningful features such as insulin-on-board (IOB), carbs-on-board (COB), and glucose rate-of-appearance curves before feeding them to neural networks ( 3 ; 41 ) . More recent approaches adopt deep sequence architectures, including CNNs and LSTMs ( 28 ; 1 ; 25 ) , probabilistic and quantile-based forecasters ( 13 ) , Temporal Fusion Transformers and related attention models ( 43 ; 33 ) , and personalized or pre-trained variants that learn patient embeddings or shared representations across cohorts ( 9 ; 11 ) . Across these algorithmic families, reported errors at standard horizons have steadily decreased, suggesting substantial progress on the forecasting task. Empirical results tell a different story when we ask how much these models actually gain from driver information. We define “Driver-Blindness” through the metric \Delta_{\text{drivers}}=\mathbb{E}\big[L(f_{\text{uni}})-L(f_{\text{multi}})\big], (1) where L is a loss function such as RMSE, f_{\text{uni}} is a model using only CGM history, and f_{\text{multi}} is a model from the same architectural family that also receives exogenous inputs. Clinically meaningful multivariate models should achieve \Delta_{\text{drivers}}\gg 0 , indicating that driver information substantially improves forecasts relative to strong univariate baselines. Across the glucose forecasting literature, this is rarely observed. Studies spanning Gaussian processes, recurrent networks, dilated CNNs, and Transformer-style models ( 3 ; 28 ; 25 ; 1 ; 13 ; 33 ; 43 ) consistently report modest or negligible gains over strong CGM-only baselines when insulin and meal channels are added. Borle et al. ( 5 ) used Gaussian process ensembles on forty-seven individuals with detailed diabetes diaries. The multivariate model achieved a mean absolute error of 48.65 mg/dL compared with 52 mg/dL for a trivial baseline that predicts each patient’s mean glucose, corresponding to \Delta_{\text{drivers}} of only a few milligrams per deciliter, which the authors described as “unexpectedly poor.” Zhu et al. ( 43 ) studied the OhioT1DM dataset with a Temporal Fusion Transformer. They found that CGM and time-of-day accounted for over ninety percent of the learned feature importance; removing all driver channels (meals, insulin, exercise) improved RMSE by about 0.3 mg/dL, i.e. \Delta_{\text{drivers}}<0 . A synthesis of results across diverse architectures reveals that, expressed as a percentage reduction in RMSE relative to the univariate baseline, \Delta_{\text{drivers}} is typically between five and ten percent at thirty minutes, and between ten and twenty percent by sixty minutes. Given the strength of physiological priors, these numbers are alarmingly small. Driver-Blindness is not only a missed opportunity. It also reflects a deeper causal inference failure. Most real-world diabetes datasets are generated under a behavior policy, where patients actively adjust insulin and meals in response to anticipated or observed glucose levels. Insulin doses are often administered immediately before or after meals; correction boluses are given in response to hyperglycemia; exercise is scheduled in ways that correlate with these patterns. Flexible models trained purely to minimize predictive loss on such observational data can fit these behavior-induced correlations without learning the true delayed causal effects of treatments on glucose. This flexibility–causality tradeoff is now visible in hybrid and Neural ODE architectures. Zou et al. ( 44 ) showed that when hybrid neural ODE models are trained solely on forecast RMSE, the neural component can override known mechanistic constraints. In synthetic and real-data experiments, they observed models that inferred insulin increases glucose (or that carbohydrates decrease it) because treatment doses almost always coincided with high glucose states in the training data. When asked to rank treatment interventions, many flexible models produced error rates statistically indistinguishable from random guessing while maintaining strong predictive accuracy. 24 demonstrated a related “forecast–control” paradox: an LSTM forecaster achieved substantially lower RMSE than a rule-based Loop controller, yet when used to drive closed-loop insulin delivery, it produced markedly worse time-in-range. In both cases, the models were well adapted to the behavior policy that generated the data but poorly grounded in the physiology that should govern interventions. In this paper we focus on explaining why deep multivariate models collapse into effectively univariate, autocorrelation-dominated behavior in this setting and on what design principles can mitigate this collapse. We first present an inferential framework based on the balance between internal dynamics and external evidence, describe how gradient-based optimization naturally leads to low-arousal, driver-blind regimes when training on noisy, confounded data ( 38 ) , and then structure the resulting failure

Read the complete text