Groups with a finite Busemann boundary are virtually cyclic

Corentin Bodart, Liran Ron-George, Ariel Yadin · 2025

Read Groups with a finite Busemann boundary are virtually cyclic by Corentin Bodart, Liran Ron-George, Ariel Yadin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20495.txt.

Introduction

Bodart, Ron-George, and Yadin finish a sorting of groups by their geometric edge. Their 2025 note studies Cayley graphs of groups built from finite generator sets. Busemann functions measure distance relative to a fixed basepoint. Closing their set adds points at infinity, forming an edge. How many such points a group has reflects its large-scale shape.

The theorem: finitely many Busemann points forces the group to be virtually cyclic. Such groups are nearly just the integers in disguise. Combined with earlier work, this completes the full sorting. Every group with a finite such edge is now classified. A new notion called annihilators drives the proof. The edge stays fixed under the group's own action. Metric-functionals were proposed as analogues of linear functionals for spaces. Support came from the Israel Science Foundation. Finite edges turn out to be extremely restrictive.

Catalog record

CREATORCorentin Bodart, Liran Ron-George, Ariel Yadin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20495

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Groups with a finite Busemann boundary are virtually cyclic Thanks: Research supported by the Israel Science Foundation, grant no. 954/21. Corentin Bodart, Liran Ron-George, Ariel Yadin Abstract . This note is a continuation of the study of the relationship between the geometry of Cayley graphs and the size of its metric-functional boundary. We show that if there exists a Cayley graph with finitely many Busemann points then the underlying group is virtually cyclic. Together with previous works, this completes the full characterization of groups with finite metric-functional boundaries. The main new notion introduced is that of annihilators . 1. Introduction Let (X,d) be a metric space. Fix a basepoint x_{0}\in X and consider the so-called Busemann functions b_{x}\colon X\to\mathbb{R} given by b_{x}(y)=d(x,y)-d(x,x_{0}) . If we identify X with the set \{b_{x}\ :\ x\in X\} , we can compactify X by taking the closure of \{b_{x}\ :\ x\in X\} under the topology of pointwise convergence. This results in a compact space denoted \overline{(X,d)} . The “new” part of this space, \partial(X,d):=\overline{(X,d)}\setminus\{b_{x}\ :\ x\in X\} is called the metric-functional boundary , and its elements are called metric-functionals . (If we were to use the topology of uniform convergence on bounded sets instead, this construction would result in something known as the horofunction boundary [ 5 ] . Throughout this note we only consider countable discrete spaces X , so there is no distinction between horofunctions and metric-functionals.) It has been proposed by A. Karlsson to use metric-functionals to study general metric spaces, in analogy to the way that linear-functionals are used to study vector spaces. This has been quite fruitful, see e.g., [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] and references therein. Our focus is for the case where X=G is a finitely generated group. In this case, the metrics of special interest are left-invariant metrics d , i.e., metrics satisfying d(zx,zy)=d(x,y) for all x,y,z\in G . The canonical basepoint to choose for a group G is, of course, the identity element x_{0}=1 . A group G acts on \{f\colon G\to\mathbb{R}\ |\ f(1)=0\} by x.f(y)=f(x^{-1}y)-f(x^{-1}) . For a left-invariant metric d on a group G one observes that x.b_{y}=b_{xy} , which implies that \partial(G,d) is an invariant compact set. This metric-functional boundary of a group has proved quite useful in studying the geometry of a group, especially in the context of Cayley graphs , see e.g., [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 6 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] among many other works. Thinking of metric-functionals as analogs of linear-functionals, a natural idea is to consider annihilators (defined below). As an application we completely characterize the case of a finite metric-functional boundary, showing that this property does not depend on the specific choice of Cayley graph, and is equivalent to having a finite-index cyclic subgroup. 1.1. Notation All groups considered are assumed to be countable, unless explicitly stated otherwise. The identity element in a group G is denoted by 1=1_{G} . A metric d on a group G is called left-invariant if d(zx,zy)=d(x,y) for all x,y,z\in G . For such a metric we write |x|=|x|_{d}:=d(x,1) . We will also assume that our metrics are proper , i.e., the ball \{y\in G:d(x,y)\leq r\} is compact for all x\in G and r\geq 0 . Given a finitely generated group G , and a finite, symmetric generating set S , define the Cayley graph \Gamma(G,S) as the graph whose vertex set is G and edge set is \{\{x,xs\}\ :\ x\in G\ ,\ s\in S\} . The graph metric on \Gamma(G,S) is denoted by d_{S} . It is easily seen to be left-invariant. We write |x|_{S}=|x|_{d_{S}} . A metric d is called a Cayley metric if d=d_{S} for some finite, symmetric generating set S . Groups equipped with their Cayley metrics are (coarsely) geodesic spaces. It can be shown that if \gamma=(\gamma_{n})_{n} is an infinite geodesic in a Cayley graph \Gamma(G,S) (see Section 2 below for precise definitions), then the limit \gamma_{\infty}:=\lim_{n}b_{\gamma_{n}}\in\overline{(G,d_{S})} exists and is an element of the metric-functional boundary \partial(G,d_{S}) (see e.g., [ 12 , Lemma 3.2] for a proof). Such a metric-functional, arising as the limit along a geodesic, is called a Busemann point . The set of all Busemann points in \partial(G,d_{S}) is denoted by \partial_{b}(G,d_{S}) . For a group property \mathcal{P} , we say that a group G is virtually - \mathcal{P} if there is a finite index subgroup [G:H]<\infty such that H is \mathcal{P} . For example, G is virtually- \mathbb{Z} if there exists a finite index subgroup [G:H]<\infty such that H\cong\mathbb{Z} (where \mathbb{Z} denotes the additive group of integers). 1.2. Main results Our main result is the following. Theorem \@upn 1.1 Let G be a finitely generated, infinite group. The following are equivalent. • For any Cayley metric d_{S} on G , the metric-functional boundary \partial(G,d_{S}) is finite. • There exists a Cayley metric d_{S} on G such that the set of Busemann points \partial_{b}(G,d_{S}) is finite. • G is virtually- \mathbb{Z} . The fact that all Cayley graphs of virtually- \mathbb{Z} groups have only finitely many Busemann points was shown in [ 14 ] . An alternative short proof was provided by Sam Shepperd, see [ 12 ] . The other direction, i.e., the implication that if every Cayley graph has a finite metric-functional boundary then the group is virtually- \mathbb{Z} , was shown in [ 12 ] . This note complements these previous works proving that if there exists one Cayley graph with a finite set of Busemann points, then the group must be virtually- \mathbb{Z} (and thus all Cayley graphs have a finite metric-functional boundary). In order to prove Theorem 1.1 , we must first analyze the virtually-Abelian case. Theorem \@upn 1.2 Let d_{S} be a Cayley metric on a finitely generated, infinite, virtually Abelian group G . Then, \partial_{b}(G,d_{S}) is finite if and only if G is virtually- \mathbb{Z} . The proof of Theorem 1.2 is in Section 4 . In order to prove Theorem 1.1 we require the notion of annihilators , which will be introduced in the next section. The main result is Lemma 1.5 , see below. The proofs of Theorem 1.1 and of Lemma 1.5 are in Section 5 . 1.3. Annihilators Fix some left-invariant metric d on a finitely generated group G . In studying the structure of the set of Busemann points, a natural subgroup arises, as we now explain. A group G acts naturally on \overline{(G,d)} by x.h(y)=h(x^{-1}y)-h(x^{-1}) . A subset L\subseteq\overline{(G,d)} is called invariant if x.L=\{x.h\ :\ h\in L\}=L for all x\in G . Note that x.b_{y}=b_{xy} , so \{b_{x}:x\in G\} and its complement \partial(G,d) are invariant. Also, if d_{S} is a Cayley metric, then for any infinite geodesic \gamma=(\gamma_{n})_{n} we have that (x\gamma_{n})_{n} is also a geodesic, so \partial_{b}(G,d_{S}) is an invariant set. Given a subset L\subseteq\partial(G,d) we define the annihilator of L to be N_{L}:=\bigl\{x\in G\ :\ \forall\ h\in L\ ,\ h(x)=0\bigr\}. We write N=N_{\partial(G,d)} , the annihilator of the whole metric-functional boundary. Note that the smaller L is, the larger N_{L} becomes. Proposition \@upn 1.3 If L\subseteq\partial(G,d) is invariant, then N_{L} is a subgroup. Proof. This is immediate from h(x^{-1}y)=x.h(y)-h(x) and h(1)=0 . \sqcap

Read the complete text