Simulating the Stellar Bycatch: Constraining the Prevalence of Extraterrestrial Transmitters within Radio SETI Surveys 2025 Simulating the Stellar Bycatch: Constraining the Prevalence of Extraterrestrial Transmitters within Radio SETI Surveys – References
Louisa A. Mason, Michael A. Garrett, Andrew P. V. Siemion · 2025
Read Simulating the Stellar Bycatch: Constraining the Prevalence of Extraterrestrial Transmitters within Radio SETI Surveys 2025 Simulating the Stellar Bycatch: Constraining the Prevalence of Extraterrestrial Transmitters within Radio SETI Surveys – References by Louisa A. Mason, Michael A. Garrett, Andrew P. V. Siemion (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20231.txt.
Introduction
Mason, Garrett, and Siemion count the silent stars hiding inside SETI telescope beams. Their 2025 paper simulates the stellar bycatch of radio surveys. A telescope aimed at one star captures many others too. Those background stars widen the true search sample. Gaia catalogs miss faint and crowded-region stars though.
The Besançon Galactic Model simulates the missing population. It fills beams with statistically realistic stars. The team reanalyzed Breakthrough Listen's Enriquez and Price survey. Over six million stars fell inside 1,229 pointings. The search volume reached out to twenty-five kiloparsecs. Limits tightened on strong, steady alien transmitters. Within 2.5 kiloparsecs, under a thousandth of a percent of systems host one. That bound assumes near-zero signal drift rates. A free calculator spreads the method to others. SETI limits now rest on fuller star counts. Surveys look less human-centered than often claimed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Louisa A. Mason, Michael A. Garrett, Andrew P. V. Siemion |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20231
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulating the Stellar Bycatch: Constraining the Prevalence of Extraterrestrial Transmitters within Radio SETI Surveys 2025 Simulating the Stellar Bycatch: Constraining the Prevalence of Extraterrestrial Transmitters within Radio SETI Surveys – References Louisa A. Mason, Michael A. Garrett, Andrew P. V. Siemion Abstract Searches for radio technosignatures place constraints on the prevalence of extraterrestrial transmitters in our Galaxy and beyond. It is important to account for the complete stellar population captured within a radio telescope’s field of view, or stellar ’bycatch’. In recent years, catalogues from ESA’s Gaia mission have enabled SETI surveys to place tighter limits on extraterrestrial transmitter statistics. However, Gaia remains restricted by magnitude limits, astrometric uncertainty at large distances, and confusion in crowded regions. To address these limitations, we investigate the use of the Besançon Galactic Model to simulate the statistical underlying stellar population to derive more realistic constraints on the occurrence of extraterrestrial transmitters. We apply this method to Breakthrough Listen’s Enriquez/Price survey, modelling 6,182,364 stellar objects within 1229 individual pointings and extending the search out to distances ≤ 25 \leq 25 kpc. We place limits on the prevalence of high duty cycle transmitters within 2.5 kpc, suggesting ≤ ( 0.000995 ± 0.000002 ) % \leq(0.000995\pm 0.000002)\% of stellar systems contain such a transmitter (for near-zero drift rates and EIRP min ≳ 5 × 10 16 {}_{\mathrm{min}}\gtrsim 5\times 10^{16} W). In support of broader adoption, we provide a simple calculator tool that enables other researchers to incorporate this approach into their own SETI analyses. Our results enable a more complete statistical estimation of the number and stellar type of systems probed, thereby strengthening constraints on technosignature prevalence and guiding the analysis of future SETI efforts. We also conclude that SETI surveys are, in fact, much less biased by anthropocentric assumptions than is often suggested. \varv 1 Introduction The search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) — whether for intentional beacons, accidental leakage, or relic signals from extinct civilisations — spans a vast and complex parameter space. This includes dimensions such as position on the sky, observing frequency, total bandwidth, spectral resolution, temporal cadence, signal modulation, and sensitivity, as discussed by 35 . SETI surveys aim to reduce the volume of unsearched multidimensional parameter space to tighten the bounds on the prevalence of extraterrestrial transmitters. Narrowband single-dish SETI surveys typically search for signals across a broad range of Doppler drift rates (e.g. \pm 4 Hz/s) and possess a field of view at 1 GHz that spans several arcminutes. Each pointing thus encompasses a significant number of background (and occasionally foreground) celestial objects ( N_{*} ) which are passively included in the analysis of the integrated power spectrum. As a result, these surveys are sensitive not only to signals originating from the nominal target star, but also to potential transmitters distributed across the full field of view. Quantifying this ‘stellar bycatch’ — the incidental population of stars within the telescope beam — enables more realistic constraints to be placed on the prevalence of extraterrestrial transmitters probed by SETI surveys (see 34 ). ESA’s Gaia mission and its associated astrometric catalogue have enabled better estimates of the Galactic stellar bycatch for the original Breakthrough Listen surveys by 12 and 26 (see 34 ). This methodology has since been adopted by other studies, including those by 21 , 19 , and 24 . The inclusion of the stellar bycatch increases the total population of stars surveyed within a given pointing direction and observational time frame. However, the latest Gaia data release includes only 1.8 billion Galactic objects ( 13 ) and remains limited by magnitude limits, astrometric uncertainties, and confusion in densely populated regions. Catalogues derived from Gaia , such as those by 5 represent a lower bound on the true stellar bycatch encountered in SETI surveys. By utilising galactic stellar population synthesis models, we can not only predict the number distribution of stars as a function of distance for a particular cut through the Milky Way, but also yield the range of stellar classes that a typical survey passively includes. Even strictly “targeted” single-dish SETI surveys nominally focused on specific stellar type (such as nearby Main Sequence stars) invariably encompass a much broader array of spectral types through their incidental stellar bycatch. Without accounting for this broader context, we risk underestimating the true extent and scientific reach of SETI survey efforts. In this paper, we use the Besançon Galactic Model (BGM) to simulate stars within the field of view of SETI surveys in order to place better limits on the prevalence of extraterrestrial transmitters in the Milky Way. In section 2, we discuss the limitations of using Gaia alone to estimate the stellar bycatch population and briefly outline the BGM’s simulation method. In section 3, we utilise the BGM to simulate the stellar population associated with the 26 survey and compare the limits on prevalence and stellar population properties calculated against previous studies utilising Gaia by 34 . In section 4, we provide a public domain calculator that estimates the stellar bycatch as a function of pointing position and field of view. In section 5, we present our conclusions and evaluate the significance of employing simulations to estimate the stellar bycatch for future SETI surveys. 2 Modelling the Milky Way 2.1 Limitations of Gaia ESA’s Gaia mission has transformed our understanding of the Milky Way by providing astrometric measurements for over a billion stellar objects. However, like all observational datasets, its completeness and reliability are subject to important limitations. The mission achieves high completeness for stars with apparent magnitudes in the range 12<G<17 , and can extend to G\sim 20 in regions of low stellar density. In contrast, heavily crowded fields with more than 400,000 stars per square degree see completeness drop to G\sim 18 ( 20 ) . Distance estimates are also affected by parallax uncertainties; for sources with a fractional parallax error f>0.2 , geometric distance estimates such as those provided by 5 are preferred. In the cases of large or negative fractional parallax errors, inferred distances are dominated by modelling prior errors. This limits reliable distance estimation within the Gaia catalogue (where 0<f<1 ) to within 10 kpc. The classification of stellar types in Gaia is typically inferred from photometric colour, using the difference G_{BP}-G_{RP} . However, in crowded regions or for faint sources, background contamination and confusion — particularly from unresolved binaries — can significantly degrade the accuracy of spectral classification ( 1 ) . Distinguishing between nearby Main Sequence stars and White Dwarfs, for instance, is often problematic in these regimes. To mitigate these issues, stringent quality filters are applied to extract clean stellar samples. Yet this comes at a significant cost: only about 30% of objects in Gaia DR2 pass the recommended contamination filters ( 1 ) . As a result, while Gaia provides an invaluable foundation for stellar population studies, it offers only a lower limit on the true number of stars intercepted by wide-field SETI observations. 2.2 The Besançon Galactic Model The BGM ( 30 , 6 ) is a dynamical self-consistent model of the Milky Way. The model is used across astrophysics research, including studies of Galactic structure, stellar populations (in particular for low mass stars), extinction mapping and microlensing predictions (