The Cumulants Expansion Approach: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Johannes Kerber, Helmut Ritsch, Laurin Ostermann · 2025

Read The Cumulants Expansion Approach: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly by Johannes Kerber, Helmut Ritsch, Laurin Ostermann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-20115.txt.

Introduction

Kerber, Ritsch, and Ostermann stress-test a beloved shortcut for quantum many-body problems. Their 2025 paper examines the cumulants expansion approach. Quantum state spaces grow exponentially with system size. Exact treatment quickly becomes impossible numerically. The expansion replaces operator products by simpler averages.

Its lowest order is the familiar mean field approximation. Higher orders keep progressively more correlations. Two test problems probe where the method holds. A chain of interacting atoms showed textbook behavior. Accuracy improved smoothly as expansion order rose. A factoring-by-annealing problem told the opposite story. Beyond mean field, extra orders bought nothing there. Some cases produced wildly oscillating, non-physical solutions. Higher orders sometimes agreed worse than lower ones. No general rule predicts success in advance yet. The authors want rigorous criteria for safe use. Physicists get a candid map of the method's moods.

Catalog record

CREATORJohannes Kerber, Helmut Ritsch, Laurin Ostermann
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-20115

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Cumulants Expansion Approach: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Johannes Kerber, Helmut Ritsch, Laurin Ostermann Abstract The configuration space, i.e. the Hilbert space, of compound quantum systems grows exponentially with the number of its subsystems: its dimensionality is given by the product of the dimensions of its constituents. Therefore a full quantum treatment is rarely possible analytically and can be carried out numerically for fairly small systems only. Fortunately, in order to obtain interesting physics, approximations often very well suffice. One of these approximations is given by the cumulants expansion, where expectation values of products of operators are approximated by products of expectation values of said operators, neglecting higher-order correlations. The lowest order of this approximation is widely known as the mean field approximation and used routinely throughout quantum physics. Despite its ubiquitous presence, a general criterion for applicability and convergence properties of higher order cumulants expansions remains to be found. In this paper, we discuss two problems in quantum electrodynamics and quantum information, namely the collective radiative dissipation of a dipole-dipole interacting chain of atoms and the factorization of a bi-prime by annealing in an adiabatic quantum simulator. In the first case we find smooth, convergence behavior, where the approximation performs increasingly better with higher orders, while in the latter going beyond mean field turns out useless and, even for small system sizes, we are puzzled by numerically challenging and partly non-physical solutions. I Introduction The mathematical framework used for quantum systems consists of a square-integrable vector space, the so-called Hilbert space, which supports state vectors and linear mappings, i.e. operators representing actions on these state vectors. The dimension of this Hilbert space is given by the number of basis states, where joint systems feature a dimension that is the product of the dimensions of its constituents creating an exponential scaling of the configuration space with the number of components. Therefore, ’exact’ calculations of larger systems become ’exponentially more difficult’, both, analytically as well as in numerical simulations. Consequently, an entire zoo of approximation techniques has been developed in order to obtain physically valuable and useful results 5 ; 14 ; 33 ; 3 ; 35 . A longstanding successful technique and the matter of interest of the present manuscript is the cumulants expansion method 18 ; 34 , where the full dynamics of the system given by the Schrödinger or the master equation is transformed into the Heisenberg picture, i.e. the time evolution is transferred from the state vector or density matrix to the observables. Subsequently, a (possibly open) set of differential equations for the operators can be derived, where the time dependence of the operators is tied to higher-order products of other operators. Upon taking expectation values of these equations one can obtain an approximated closed set of differential equations by replacing the expectation values of products of operators of higher order with products of expectation values of operators of lower order. This implicitly assumes statistical independence of higher order correlations. The general procedure of the cumulants expansion method is depicted in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Model Systems and Order of Expansion. Our toy models consist of N interacting identical two-level systems. The dimension of a full quantum dynamics scales exponentially with N as 2^{N}\times 2^{N} considering the Quantum Langevin Equation (QLE). The first order of the cumulants expansion, dubbed mean field approximation, scales only linearly with system size, u.e. \mathcal{O}(N) , but does not account for quantum correlations. Including all pairwise quantum correlations in second order gives \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) . Higher order cumulants bring back multi-particle quantum correlation at the cost of a polynomial increase in equation numbers as a function of the order of the expansion. Applying the first-order of the cumulants expansion method to a given problem is known as mean field approximation 15 , neglecting all quantum correlations between operators. In analogy to the Ehrenfest theorem, where the equations of motion of the expectation values of position and momentum of a quantum harmonic oscillator correspond to the Euler-Lagrange equations of its classical analogue 6 , one interprets this first order approximation as close to the ’classical’ limit, ignoring key quantum correlation effects. Including all pairwise quantum correlations typically already accounts for a large part of the quantum fluctuations in the system as it e.g. includes equations for operator uncertainty values. Many successful applications as e.g. in laser theory are based on second order cumulants expansions 28 ; 13 ; 2 . However, one has to keep in mind, that the solutions do not guarantee a consistent physical time evolution corresponding to a physically allowed quantum state or density matrix. Now, given the cascaded nature of the underlying commutators that have to be evaluated in order to go to higher orders, the expansion is seldomly performed beyond mean field or second order 3 ; 30 ; 13 . Up until very recently, although the general recipe is straight-forward, the cumbersome algebraic book keeping has outweighed the prospective benefits of performing these calculations. With the advent of symbolic frameworks 11 ; 36 and, in particular, our own QuantumCumulants.jl toolbox 27 , cumulants expansion equations can now be, at least in principle, derived automatically up to an arbitrary order. The toolbox currently allows for finite and countably infinite Hilbert spaces. The simplest of those types of systems (and also the subject of the present study) is a compound system of N identical two-level systems. As the square of any combination of single constituent operators is proportional to the identity, an N -th order cumulants expansion is identical to the full quantum dynamics (FQD) (see Fig. 1 ). At this point no general applicability criterion for the cumulants expansion exists nor are there general proofs of convergence. The usual and widely accepted procedure goes like this: solve a small exactly treatable toy system for its full dynamics, solve the same system in the desired cumulants expansion approximation order and do this for increasing system size usually in steps of 1 until the exact solution becomes impossible to calculate. If the targeted expectation values of the full solution vs. the approximation agree on a reasonable level, deem the approximation legit and scale up the system for the approximation. While this certainly has its legitimacy and has been applied successfully many times 28 ; 38 ; 4 including our own work 16 ; 9 , the convergence of the method is by no means rigorous or strictly quantifiable. In this paper we intend to show that this usual procedure can work very well (”The Good”), fail (”The Bad”) and leave one completely puzzled with chaotic uncontrollable solutions (”The Ugly”), even for surprisingly small size examples. To this end we look at two apparently quite similar toy setups, a handful of two-level systems in two scenarios: dipole-dipole mediated collective radiation and a bi-prime factorization algorithm by means of adiabatic quantum computing. Before we begin, let us briefly recap the concept of the cumulants expansion method (CEM) and its mathematical underpinnings. II The Cumulants expansion Let X_{1},X_{2},\cdots,X_{n} be n ordered random variables. The joint cumulant of these variables is defined as the coefficient of the Maclaurin series of the so-called multivariate cumulant generating function 22 . The joint cumulant

Read the complete text