Symbiotic Stars (Including T Corona Borealis) Are Not Immediate Progenitors of Normal Type Ia Supernovae
Bradley E. Schaefer · 2025
Read Symbiotic Stars (Including T Corona Borealis) Are Not Immediate Progenitors of Normal Type Ia Supernovae by Bradley E. Schaefer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-19948.txt.
Introduction
Bradley E Schaefer tests a popular idea about where normal Type Ia supernovae come from. The symbiotic idea says the exploding white dwarf's partner must be a red giant with a heavy wind. That claim makes sharp predictions that can be checked in remnants, old images, spectra, and early light from many past explosions.
Schaefer gathers tests covering many normal supernovae of this type: searches for leftover red giants, pre-eruption images, hydrogen and helium lines, radio and X-ray signals, and early brightening. None of the tested systems shows the needed red giant companion. He concludes that symbiotic systems make up, at most, a tiny fraction of normal Type Ia progenitors, far too small to measure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bradley E. Schaefer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-19948
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Symbiotic Stars (Including T Corona Borealis) Are Not Immediate Progenitors of Normal Type Ia Supernovae Bradley E. Schaefer Abstract A popular solution to the Type Ia supernova (SNIa) progenitor problem is that the immediate progenitors are symbiotic star systems. This solution requires that the companion star of the exploding white dwarf must be a red giant star with a heavy stellar wind. This has been tested for 189 normal SNIa, with all tested systems being proven to not have the required red giant: (A) Zero-out-of-9 normal type Ia supernova remnants have any red giant ex-companion star near the center with limits of M V M_{V} > > 0.0. (B) Zero-out-of-2 normal SNIa in nearby galaxies have any red giant at the position as seen in archival pre-eruption images by HST to limits of M V M_{V} > > 0.0. (C and D) Zero-out-of-111 normal SNIa have any detected hydrogen or helium emission lines in their eruption spectra, with limits on entrained gas of M H M_{\rm H} < < 0.22 and M He M_{\rm He} < < 0.07 M ⊙ , which is the minimum mass lost by a red giant in a nearby blastwave. (E and F) Zero-out-of-9 nearby normal SNIa were detected in the radio or X-rays, as required from the ejecta/wind impact, to limits of M ˙ wind \dot{M}_{\rm wind} < < 3 × \times 10 − 9 10^{-9} M ⊙ yr -1 . (G) Zero-out-of- ∼ \sim 69 normal SNIa display any brightening in the first few days to limits of M V M_{V} > > − - 18, as required for a red giant companion when we are looking down its shadowcone. With zero-out-of-189 normal SNIa having any possibility of having a red giant companion, the fraction of SNIa with symbiotic progenitors is < < 0.53%. The overwhelming conclusion is that normal SNIa are not from symbiotic-progenitors in any measurable fraction. I INTRODUCTION The nature of the immediate progenitor systems of Type Ia supernovae (SNIa) is a grand challenge problem of high importance for all of astrophysics, where for decades there has been vigorous experiments, theory, and discussion, yet with no final conclusion (Livio 2000, Maoz, Mannucci, & Nelemans 2014, Livio & Mazzali 2018, Patat & Hallakoun 2018, Ruiter & Seitenzahl 2025). Everyone agrees that the SNIa progenitors involve a close binary system with a white dwarf (WD) of carbon/oxygen (CO) composition. But there are many possibilities for the nature of the companion star close around the WD, how the mass of the CO WD increases to the point of igniting runaway thermonuclear burning so as to explode the WD, and the detailed site and explosion mechanism within the WD. All popular solutions to the SNIa-progenitor problem fall into one of two groups of explanations, with these groups being labeled by the number of WDs in the binary. The single-degenerate (SD) models all postulate that there is only one WD (i.e., only one degenerate star in the binary), where the other star in the binary is a relatively normal companion star that supplies gas, usually by Roche lobe overflow, to the CO WD, leading to its ultimate explosion. The double-degenerate (DD) models postulate that the companion star is a second WD (i.e., with two degenerate stars) that is in-spiraling (from gravitational radiation) so that the two WDs collide or merge, whereupon the carbon is ignited to power the complete disintegration of the star. One of the most popular SD models is that the progenitor is a symbiotic star, where the companion is a red giant star with a massive stellar wind feeding the WD (Kenyon et al. 1993, Hachisu, Kato, & Nomoto 1999, Meng & Yang 2010). Symbiotic star systems (SSS) consist of a WD in a fairly close binary with a red giant that has a dense stellar wind (Mikołajewska 2010, Munari 2019, Mikołajewska et al. 2021). One class of SSS is the S-type, where the red giant fills its Roche lobe with this supplying the gas that falls onto the WD. The other class of SSS is the D-type, where a high density wind provides the gas that falls onto the WD. A fraction of the SSS have companions that are ordinary Mira stars, with these all being D-type. The SSS appear in the optical as dominated by the spectrum of the red giant, but with a blue excess from the accretion light, with the usual flickering in the light curves on all time scales. The stellar wind and its dust makes the SSS bright in the infrared and radio bands. The accretion onto the WD makes for the SSS to be weak X-ray sources. T Corona Borealis (T CrB) is the most famous SSS, with an M4 III companion in a 227 day orbit, and with known classical nova eruptions in the years 1217, 1787, 1866, 1946, and one that is likely to erupt any month now. (Schaefer 2023a, 2023b). T CrB is just one of four so-called ‘symbiotic recurrent nova’ (SyRN) systems of four similar sister systems, with the others being RS Oph, V3890 Sgr, and V745 Sco. The SSS-progenitor model has the requirement that the supernova progenitors have an ordinary red giant companion with a heavy stellar wind. (This is just saying that the progenitor is an SSS.) This requirements can be tested by seeking for a red giant companion star by all of seven search methods (Section 2). The two direct tests seek to spot the red giant star either before or after the supernova (Sections 2.1 and 2.2). The five indirect tests seek to spot some inevitable effect caused by any red giant caught in the blastwave from the exploding WD. These effects include bright nebular hydrogen and helium lines from the red giant atmosphere stripped and entrained into the eject (Section 2.3), the impact of the SN ejecta onto the stellar wind around the red giant making highly luminous radio and X-ray sources (Section 2.4), and the Kasen effect (Kasen 2010) where a red giant creates a hole in the ejecta whose edge is bright shocked gas creating a blatant peak in the light curve with the peak reaching comparable to the main maximum within hours of the explosion (Section 2.5). II TESTING WHETHER SNIa HAVE A RED GIANT COMPANION STAR The SSS-progenitor model requires that the companion star be a red giant in a fairly close orbit around the WD. This makes a prediction that can be tested. If a particular SNIa is found to have a red giant companion, then this would substantially strengthen the SSS-progenitor model. If a particular SNIa is found to not have a red giant companion, then that progenitor cannot be a SSS. If many SNIa are found to have no red giant companions, then the fraction of SSS-progenitors must be small. A number of methods have been used to test whether a particular SNIa has a red giant companion star. Here, I will enumerate the many methods and particular supernovae tested, with the results summarized in Table 1. Note that these tests are all made for normal SNIa events, with no rare or unusual event classes. (That is, the tests here do not include any of the various types of