Designing Reputation Systems for Manufacturing Data Trading Markets: A Multi-Agent Evaluation with Q-Learning and IRL-Estimated Utilities
Kenta Yamamoto, Teruaki Hayashi · 2025
Read Designing Reputation Systems for Manufacturing Data Trading Markets: A Multi-Agent Evaluation with Q-Learning and IRL-Estimated Utilities by Kenta Yamamoto, Teruaki Hayashi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-19930.txt.
Introduction
Kenta Yamamoto and Teruaki Hayashi design reputation systems for markets where firms trade manufacturing data. Buyers cannot check data quality before paying, so trust is the central problem in these young markets. The study builds a multi-agent simulator of such a market, in the spirit of European efforts like GAIA-X and Catena-X.
Agents learn by reinforcement learning, while inverse reinforcement learning estimates their utility functions from real behavior data. The authors test five reputation designs, from time-decay and Bayesian schemes to PageRank-style ones. PeerTrust best matched price to quality while blocking monopoly. They then build a hybrid system that combines the strengths of the five for steadier price-quality links.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kenta Yamamoto, Teruaki Hayashi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-19930
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Designing Reputation Systems for Manufacturing Data Trading Markets: A Multi-Agent Evaluation with Q-Learning and IRL-Estimated Utilities Kenta Yamamoto, Teruaki Hayashi Abstract Recent advances in machine learning and big data analytics have intensified the demand for high-quality cross-domain datasets and accelerated the growth of data trading across organizations. As data become increasingly recognized as an economic asset, data marketplaces have emerged as a key infrastructure for data-driven innovation. However, unlike mature product or service markets, data-trading environments remain nascent and suffer from pronounced information asymmetry. Buyers cannot verify the content or quality before purchasing data, making trust and quality assurance central challenges. To address these issues, this study develops a multi-agent data-market simulator that models participant behavior and evaluates the institutional mechanisms for trust formation. Focusing on the manufacturing sector, where initiatives such as GAIA-X and Catena-X are advancing, the simulator integrates reinforcement learning (RL) for adaptive agent behavior and inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) to estimate utility functions from empirical behavioral data. Using the simulator, we examine the market-level effects of five representative reputation systems—Time-decay, Bayesian-beta, PageRank, PowerTrust, and PeerTrust—and found that PeerTrust achieved the strongest alignment between data price and quality, while preventing monopolistic dominance. Building on these results, we develop a hybrid reputation mechanism that integrates the strengths of existing systems to achieve improved price–quality consistency and overall market stability. This study extends simulation-based data-market analysis by incorporating trust and reputation as endogenous mechanisms and offering methodological and institutional insights into the design of reliable and efficient data ecosystems. I Introduction Recent advances in machine learning and big data analytics have increased the demand for diverse high-quality datasets across industries. As sensing, networking, and distributed computing technologies mature, massive amounts of heterogeneous data are generated and shared in real time. To leverage these data for innovation, organizations increasingly participate in data trading beyond institutional boundaries, giving rise to data marketplaces that function as the foundational infrastructure for a data-driven economy [1–6]. To address these challenges, a simulator that can model the key elements of data markets and reproduce participant behavior under diverse rules and regulations is required [7-9]. Accordingly, we developed a data-market simulator that integrates multi-agent reinforcement learning (RL) and inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) to model participant behavior and evaluate the institutional mechanisms for trust formation. Focusing on the manufacturing domain, where large-scale data-sharing initiatives, such as GAIA-X and Catena-X, are advancing, we designed a simulation framework that reflects real-world decision dynamics in data trading. In the proposed approach, IRL is used to estimate the utility of participants based on behavioral traces on a production data platform, whereas RL enables agents to form and adapt their strategies over time. Using this simulator, we examined the market-level impacts of five representative reputation systems—Time-decay, Bayesian-beta, PageRank, PowerTrust, and PeerTrust—which are widely studied in the areas of trust management and distributed systems [10–14]. The results demonstrated that PeerTrust yielded the highest alignment between data prices and quality. Building on these findings, we developed a novel hybrid reputation system that integrates the strengths of the existing models and achieves improved market consistency. This study makes three contributions. 1. We developed a simulation-based experimental platform to analyze institutional mechanisms in data markets using ML-based behavioral modeling. 2. We conducted a comparative analysis of reputation systems under large-scale data trading scenarios. 3. We proposed a new hybrid reputation mechanism to enhance trust and market efficiency. This study bridged the domains of machine learning, multi-agent simulation, and big data ecosystem design, offering a computational framework to understand how reputation and trust can sustain a scalable and reliable data marketplace. II Related Works and Our Approach II-A Data Trading Markets and Their Challenges The emergence of data trading markets, which are also referred to as data marketplaces, has been widely discussed as a new form of the digital economy [1–6]. These markets enable cross-domain data exchange and the economic use of data assets. Studies have proposed technologies that facilitate such exchanges, including pricing mechanisms [15,16] and data-protection frameworks [6]. However, despite growing academic and industrial interest, data markets remain in their infancy, with limited observable phenomena. Institutional structures and market rules are still evolving, and a comprehensive understanding of the optimal design principles is lacking. Moreover, information asymmetry poses a major challenge; it is difficult to evaluate data quality or verify content before purchase. Consequently, ensuring data reliability and participant trust remains a crucial, yet unresolved issue in data market design. II-B Trust and Reputation in Online and Data Markets To address similar challenges in product and service markets, online platforms have long employed reputation systems to ensure quality and foster trust among market players. Since the early days of e-commerce, platforms such as eBay and Amazon have demonstrated that trustworthy sellers receive higher ratings and that better reputations correlate with increased transaction prices [17,18]. Subsequent research has examined the mechanisms by which reputation influences purchasing decisions and explored review bias, trust propagation, and rating fairness [19–22]. Although these systems encourage participation, they also exhibit inflation and bias in their ratings. To mitigate these effects, algorithms that weigh reviewers based on credibility or past behavior have been proposed, including those used on Q&A platforms such as Stack Overflow [23]. More recent studies have focused on graph-based trust propagation, including EigenTrust [12], which applies PageRank principles and probabilistic models such as Beta Reputation [11]. Parallel efforts have addressed fake review detection and manipulation using linguistic, behavioral, and social graph features to enhance robustness [24,25]. In the context of data-trading markets, these issues become even more critical: data quality cannot be verified before data purchase and analysis, and transactions often depend on the perceived trustworthiness of providers [18]. II-C Simulation Approaches for Market and Institutional Design Simulation-based analysis has emerged as a principal method for studying market-level dynamics and evaluating institutional mechanisms such as reputation systems. Multi-agent simulations enable controlled experimentation with market rules, revealing macro-level effects from micro-level behaviors [26]. Previous studies have demonstrated the potential of such approaches to capture phenomena that are otherwise unobservable, thereby supporting the design and validation of market institutions. Fernandez et al. [27] emphasized the importance of adopting simulation-based methods in data-market research. For instance, a previous study constructed a network representation of a market in which traded datasets were modeled as nodes consisting of variable sets, and scenario analyses of data-purchasing behaviors were performed [28]. Another study proposed a simulation framework in which buyer agents perform random walks on a data network to reproduce the relationships between datasets, thereby assessing the impact of different purchasing strategies [29]. Research is also being conducted on agent-based data-market simulations that enable data replication and resale [30]. However, these studies generally overlook the role of trust and reputation in shaping market outcomes. In reality, particularly in markets characterized by information asymmetry, perceptions of the reliability of data providers and datasets have a decisive impact on trading decisions. The absence of reputation mechanisms in existing simulations limits their ability to capture the process through which trust is built, propagated, and reflected in price formation. II-D Summary and Our Approach To address this gap, this study incorporated reputation systems as endogenous market mechanisms within a multi-agent simulation framework. By integrating RL for adaptive decision making and