Generalized Landau Paradigm for quantum phases and phase transitions
Xie Chen · 2025
Read Generalized Landau Paradigm for quantum phases and phase transitions by Xie Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-19793.txt.
Introduction
Xie Chen asks whether a wider version of the Landau paradigm can organize all quantum phases of matter. Landau's framework reads phases through broken symmetries, but many quantum phases discovered since fall outside it. Recent ideas about generalized symmetries and generalized gauging hint at an upgrade.
In this essay, those beyond-Landau phases and their transitions are recast as breaking of generalized symmetries, often produced by a gauging step framed through topological holography. The picture promises a systematic map of quantum phases. Chen also sets out what still must be understood before the generalized paradigm becomes a working tool.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xie Chen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-19793
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Generalized Landau Paradigm for quantum phases and phase transitions Xie Chen Abstract The Landau paradigm is a central dogma for understanding phase and phase transitions in condensed matter systems, yet for decades, it has been known that a variety of quantum phases exist beyond the framework. Is there a more general framework that provides a systematic understanding of phases and phase transitions in quantum many-body systems? In this Essay, we discuss how the recently developed notions of generalized symmetry and generalized gauging point to a way to extend the Landau paradigm. In the new framework, beyond-Landau phases and transitions are attributed to the breaking of generalized symmetries, often induced by the generalized gauging procedure facilitated through the symmetry topological field theory formalism. We discuss what needs to be understood to make the generalized Landau paradigm useful in the study of quantum phase and phase transitions. The comeback of Landau.— In the 1930s, Lev D. Landau established the foundational rules for describing phases and phase transitions in physical systems Landau 1937 . For half a century, this framework was the central dogma in condensed matter physics, covering almost every phase diagram that physicists sought to understand, from water to crystals to superconductors. Cracks started to show in the 1980s with the discovery of the quantum Hall effect whose nontrivial order cannot be attributed to the breaking of any symmetry Klitzing et al. 1980 ; Tsui et al. 1982 . Today, these beyond-Landau phases and phase transitions are standard topics in research articles and textbooks. Yet, in the last decade, new ideas have emerged that may suggest that everything can still be described as Landau after all Gaiotto et al. 2015 ; Hofman and Iqbal 2019 ; Delacrétaz et al. 2020 ; Iqbal and McGreevy 2020 ; Moradi et al. 2022 ; Bhardwaj et al. 2023 ; McGreevy 2023 . Can that be true? Let us wind back and start from the basics. A central question in condensed matter physics is to understand phases and phase transitions. What distinguishes phases? What characterizes the critical point at phase transitions? A particularly fascinating aspect of the answers to these questions is the emergence of universality . The universal features of phases and phase transitions are determined by a few simple factors, while no other detail—such as chemical composition, interaction strength, lattice constant—matters. Thanks to universality, knowledge gained from studying phases and phase transitions in one system, even a toy model, can be applied to many other systems within the same so-called universality class . In the original Landau paradigm, symmetry is the key factor underlying universality. This is best illustrated by the simple example of the phases of water. Water molecules can exist in three phases: gas, liquid, or solid. The gas and liquid phases can be smoothly connected beyond the critical point at 374 °C and 218 atm, and are thus considered as the same fluid phase. In contrast, the solid phase is always separated from the fluid phase by a phase transition line. The key difference is that the solid breaks the full translation symmetry by forming a lattice, while the fluid does not. Because of this difference in symmetry, solids and fluids are sharply distinguishable. Their difference can be quantified by their x-ray diffraction pattern, which is structureless for the fluids but displays peaks for solids. This almost mundane example captures the essential insight of the original Landau paradigm. The original Landau paradigm For systems whose interactions do not preserve any symmetry, • no sharp distinction among different parts of the phase diagram, • only one phase exists. For systems whose interactions preserve certain symmetry (forming a group G ), • phases are distinguished by how the symmetry is spontaneously broken, • different phases are labeled by the subgroup H of symmetry that is not broken, • phases labeled by different H are always separated by phase transitions, • a continuous transition can exist between phases with ‘compatible’ symmetries H_{1}\subset H_{2} , • the continuous transition is driven by the fluctuation of an ‘order parameter’ which transforms trivially under H_{1} but non-trivially under H_{2} . The original Landau paradigm was built upon intuitions about classical systems, such as crystals breaking translation symmetry or ferromagnets breaking spin rotation symmetry. In fact, Pierre Curie, when studying magnetism, had already highlighted the importance of group theory and symmetry breaking (SB) Curie, P. 1894 . But Landau’s formalism also works amazingly well for some intrinsically quantum systems, like superconductors TER HAAR 1965 . On the other hand, the quantum world holds more surprises. The original Landau paradigm is effective when quantum phases are classical-like, in the sense that the state of the system can be qualitatively described without entanglement. When entanglement starts playing a major role in the many-body state, phases and phase transitions exist well beyond what the Landau paradigm predicts. Since the discovery of the quantum Hall effect, the study of beyond-Landau phases and phase transitions has become a central topic in quantum condensed matter physics. Universal features of topological WEN 1990 ; Kitaev 2003 and symmetry-protected topological Gu and Wen 2009 ; Pollmann et al. 2012 phases have been identified. Continuous transitions between (symmetry-protected) topological phases and incompatible symmetry-broken phases are discovered, where the critical fluctuation often involves emergent fractional degrees of freedom, hence the name deconfined quantum critical point Ardonne et al. 2004 ; Senthil et al. 2004 ; Lu and Lee 2014 . It is generally accepted that, apart from symmetry, topological features in quantum systems, arising from intrinsic many-body entanglement, are crucial in distinguishing phases and characterizing phase transitions. However, many questions are still unanswered: What phases can exist? Which phases can be connected through continuous phase transitions? What are the universal features of these transitions? Much progress has been achieved for free-fermion topological phases, where topology of the band-structure characterizes the phases and transitions occur via band-gap closing. In the presence of strong interactions, however, our understanding remains limited. Beyond Landau phases and phase transitions For systems whose interactions do not preserve any symmetry, • a variety of phases exist, distinguished by their topological order . For systems whose interactions preserve certain symmetry (forming a group G ), • different phases can exist without breaking any symmetry, distinguished by their Symmetry Protected Topological Order , • a continuous transition can exist between symmetry-breaking phases with incompatible symmetries H_{1}\not\subset H_{2} . The generalized Landau Paradigm.— While progress in the last 40 years took us away from the original Landau paradigm, recent discoveries suggest that many of these beyond-Landau phases and transitions can still be captured by the Landau paradigm, if we are more flexible about the definition of symmetry in quantum systems and embrace a more general version of the procedure called gauging . When we think of symmetries in a quantum many-body setting, the familiar types that come to mind, such as spin rotation, time reversal, and lattice translation, share some common features. They are associated with unitary or anti-unitary operators that act globally on the whole system, with symmetry charges carried by point-like operators. Each of these aspects can fail in the now generalized concept of what constitutes a symmetry Gaiotto et al. 2015 ; McGreevy 2023