Power sector models featuring individual BEV profiles: Assessing the time-accuracy trade-off
Adeline Guéret · 2025
Read Power sector models featuring individual BEV profiles: Assessing the time-accuracy trade-off by Adeline Guéret (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-19449.txt.
Introduction
Adeline Guéret asks how many individual electric car profiles a power system model really needs. Adding dozens of separate battery electric vehicle profiles, instead of one averaged profile, keeps real variety but slows the model down. Too few profiles can distort the optimal plan the model produces.
Tests show accuracy rises with profile count only up to a threshold, after which extra profiles add little robustness. For fleets of five to twenty million vehicles, the rule of thumb is one profile per two hundred thousand to two hundred fifty thousand vehicles. The study also checks whether the choice of specific profiles skews results, guiding modelers on time versus accuracy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adeline Guéret |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-19449
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Power sector models featuring individual BEV profiles: Assessing the time-accuracy trade-off Adeline Guéret Abstract Electrifying passenger cars will impact future power systems. To understand the challenges and opportunities that arise, it is necessary to reflect “sector coupling” in the modeling space. This paper focuses on a specific modeling approach that includes dozens of individual BEV profiles rather than one aggregated BEV profile. Although including additional BEV profiles increases model complexity and runtime, it avoids losing information in the aggregation process. We investigate how many profiles are needed to ensure the accuracy of the results and the extent to which fewer profiles can be traded for runtime efficiency gains. We also examine whether selecting specific profiles influences optimal results. We demonstrate that including too few profiles may result in distorted optimal solutions. However, beyond a certain threshold, adding more profiles does not significantly enhance the robustness of the results. More generally, for fleets of 5 to 20 million BEVs, we derive a rule of thumb consisting in including enough profiles such that each profile represents 200,000 to 250,000 vehicles, ensuring accurate results without excessive runtime. \DeclareAutoCiteCommand superscript [] 1 Introduction Battery electric vehicles (BEVs) have significant potential to mitigate climate change, as they offer an efficient way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the passenger road transport sector [ 39 , 38 , 34 , 33 ] . Electrifying the light-duty vehicle fleet will increasingly intertwine the previously separate transport and electricity sectors. This evolution toward “sector coupling” must be reflected in modeling if we want to better understand and anticipate the challenges and opportunities ahead [ 26 , 30 , 12 ] . From a modeling perspective, integrating BEVs and power systems remains a complex endeavor, particularly since spatiotemporal scales can differ significantly. Agent-based transport models focus on understanding travel behavior at a microscopic scale [ 16 ] . These simulations can typically generate travel activities with a resolution of one minute for exact geographic coordinates and a very large number of agents. Travel diaries and more recent related statistical methods also leverage very precise data, e.g., exact times and locations of trips, in particular since developments in big data techniques have opened the door to GPS tracking and mobile phone data collection [ 2 ] . This level of granularity is well-suited for analyzing the impacts of BEVs on local or regional distribution grids [ 20 , 29 , 40 , 43 ] . However, for other applications such as coupling with capacity expansion and/or generation power sector models, this level of granularity is too high, as these models are usually defined at an hourly resolution or lower and rely on aggregated data for local regions or entire countries [ 28 ] . Including a representation of BEVs in capacity expansion or dispatch models therefore requires abstraction of some details, in the form of data aggregation or of stylized assumptions regarding trip patterns, plug-in or charging behaviors, etc. This has led to the development of stochastic tools to generate synthetic BEV mobility data. Inspired by agent-based transport models, these tools usually harvest empirical data from travel surveys and create additional modules to compute the data required by power sector models, such as driving electricity consumption and power rating time series [ 22 ] . The first attempts to integrate electric mobility in power sector models date back to the late 2000s [ 21 , 24 ] . These attempts included limited detail regarding the transport modeling side. For example, individual car driving profiles were not considered. Instead, an overall transport demand profile and one single large battery were modeled. Additionally, assumptions were made regarding the proportion of the fleet that is driving at certain times of the day and the proportion of parked vehicles that are effectively connected to the grid. Later developments increasingly acknowledged the importance of taking into account car travel behaviors and induced vehicle charging patterns. This allows for a more accurate representation of BEVs’ availability and load, enabling a better understanding of conflicts and synergies with other time-varying factors, such as variable renewable energy sources (vRES) [ 27 , 44 , 35 , 36 , 15 , 19 ] . Although representing a diversity of BEV profiles in power sector models is methodologically established by now, there are still different approaches to integrating them more precisely. One approach is to aggregate a large number of very detailed mobility profiles. The resulting aggregated time series of, e.g., driving or charging electricity consumption, and, if applicable, grid availability, and battery storage level are then included in power sector models as if there were only one representative vehicle [ 8 , 42 , 23 , 3 ] . This approach encompasses a great wealth of driving profiles while maintaining relatively low additional model complexity. However, the aggregation step results in the loss of some information contained in individual profiles. This has led to the development of alternative aggregation methods [ 25 ] . Another approach is to include several (dozens of) individual BEV profiles scaled to match a given fleet size [ 13 , 14 , 9 ] . With this approach, accuracy at the individual profile level is not lost in aggregation because each profile retains its internal coherence across mobility patterns, driving electricity consumption, grid availability, and battery storage level dynamics. However, including additional individual BEV profiles is computationally demanding, and potentially intractable, especially if representativeness at the fleet level requires including a very large number of profiles. In this work, we focus on the second approach, the “individual BEV profiles” approach. We do not intend to compare how different approaches behave. Using an open-source stochastic tool to generate synthetic BEV profiles and an open-source power sector model, we investigate how increasing the number of BEV profiles included in a power sector model affects runtime and the accuracy of optimal solutions. Additionally, we analyze the role of profile selection, i.e., whether and to what extent results change when drawing alternative BEV profile samples, for a given number of profiles. We show that, beyond 60-80 BEV profiles, runtime increases steeply with the overall number of profiles. However, our findings underscore the importance of including at least 20 BEV profiles to avoid overestimating the cost impact of BEVs when modeling fleets with 5 to 20 million BEVs. Additionally, we find that optimal capacity mixes vary significantly with the number of profiles included. Our results suggest that ensuring robust optimal capacity results requires including more BEV profiles than are needed for stable cost results, particularly for stationary Li-ion battery technologies. Provided that enough profiles are included, profile selection only marginally influences optimal results for most technologies, except for solar photovoltaic (PV), for which optimal capacity depends more on profile selection when BEVs charge smartly. We derive a rule of thumb according to which including enough profiles such that each BEV profile represents between 200,000 and 250,000 BEVs ensures reasonable runtimes and accurate optimal results for fleets of 5 to 20 million BEVs in various settings. 2 Results 2.1 Scenarios In our study, scenarios refer to a system including BEVs, while the reference represents a system without BEVs. Nothing else except the introduction of BEV profiles differs between the reference