Magnetic susceptibility of hot hadronic medium and quark degrees of freedom near the QCD cross-over point
Rupam Samanta, Wojciech Broniowski · 2025
Read Magnetic susceptibility of hot hadronic medium and quark degrees of freedom near the QCD cross-over point by Rupam Samanta, Wojciech Broniowski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-19255.txt.
Introduction
Rupam Samanta and Wojciech Broniowski study how hot hadronic matter responds to a magnetic field just below the point where quarks break free. Lattice computer results for this magnetic susceptibility clash with the standard hadron resonance gas model, which predicts far too strong a diamagnetic response above a certain heat.
The mismatch hints that quarks already matter below the crossover, adding a paramagnetic push, while pions still explain the low-temperature behavior. The authors build a quark-meson model whose quark masses come from lattice data at zero field. With quark and meson loop effects included, the model matches the lattice results up to the crossover point.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rupam Samanta, Wojciech Broniowski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-19255
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Magnetic susceptibility of hot hadronic medium and quark degrees of freedom near the QCD cross-over point Rupam Samanta, Wojciech Broniowski Abstract We argue that the lattice QCD results for the temperature-dependent magnetic susceptibility of the medium below the cross-over temperature are difficult to reconcile with the available hadronic models. In particular, in the widely used Hadron Resonance Gas model, reproducing well numerous other features of the medium, one observes a substantially too strong diamagnetism compared to the lattice simulations. One thus needs a significant source of paramagnetism below the QCD cross-over temperature, possible to achieve with sufficiently light fermions. We thus consider a quark-meson model, where the temperature-dependent quark masses are fixed from the baryon-baryon and baryon-strangeness susceptibility data from the lattice at zero magnetic field. We show that in such a framework one can describe the magnetic susceptibility, with the vacuum contributions duly incorporated. In the hadronic picture, we also evaluate the contribution of the pion–vector-meson loops to the magnetic susceptibility evaluated via the photon polarization, showing it is small and paramagnetic. I Introduction Magnetic properties of the hot strongly interacting medium have been actively studied on the lattice Bali et al. 2012a ; Bali et al. 2012b ; D’Elia 2013 ; Endrödi 2013 ; Bonati et al. 2013 ; Bonati et al. 2014 ; Bali et al. 2014 ; Bali et al. 2020 ; Endrődi and Markó 2022 ; Ding et al. 2024 ; Endrodi 2025 ; Astrakhantsev et al. 2024 ; Ding et al. 2025 ; for recent reviews see Andersen et al. 2016 ; Adhikari et al. 2026 . Apart from their fundamental nature, they are associated with very interesting physical phenomena, such as the chiral magnetic effect Kharzeev et al. 2008 ; Fukushima et al. 2008 ; Kharzeev et al. 2016 , or the magnetic catalysis and inverse catalysis (for a recent review, see, e.g., Andersen 2021 ), reflecting the dependence of the quark condensates on the magnetic field. The information from the lattice QCD at non-zero temperature T , vanishing chemical potentials, and non-zero magnetic field B , involves also properties such as the magnetic field dependent susceptibilities related to various conserved charges (baryon, strangeness, electric) Ding et al. 2024 ; Ding et al. 2025 , the chiral susceptibilities Karsch and Laermann 1994 ; Sasaki et al. 2007 ; Bazavov et al. 2012a , or magnetization Bali et al. 2014 ; Adhikari and Andersen 2021 . A very basic and relevant quantity is the magnetic susceptibility, \chi_{B} Bali et al. 2012b ; Endrödi 2013 ; Bonati et al. 2014 ; Bali et al. 2020 ; Endrődi and Markó 2022 , central to this work, as it describes the response of the medium to the magnetic field near B=0 . It is well known that at vanishing chemical potentials, QCD exhibits a cross-over phase transition Stephanov et al. 1998 ; Fodor and Katz 2004 ; Aoki et al. 2006 ; Fukushima and Hatsuda 2011 near the pseudo-critical temperature T_{c}\sim 155 MeV, passing gradually from hadronic degrees of freedom below T_{c} to quarks and gluons above. The hadronic side is frequently described with the Hadron Resonance Gas model (HRG) Fermi 1950 ; Pomeranchuk 1951 ; Hagedorn 1965 ; Koch et al. 1986 , involving stable hadrons and resonances, mimicking the inter-hadron interactions Dashen et al. 1969 ; Venugopalan and Prakash 1992 . HRG reproduces very well many features of hot medium measured on the lattice Karsch et al. 2003 ; Gyulassy and McLerran 2005 . In the absence of the magnetic field, the list includes the entropy density, the energy density and pressure, the sound velocity Huovinen and Petreczky 2010 ; Bazavov et al. 2014 ; Ding et al. 2015 , the susceptibilities associated to conserved currents and their correlations and cumulants Borsanyi et al. 2012 ; Bazavov et al. 2012b ; Bellwied et al. 2015 ; Borsanyi et al. 2018 ; Bollweg et al. 2021 . At 0<B\lesssim 0.15~{\rm GeV}^{2} (we use natural units of \hslash=c=k_{B}=e=1 throughout this paper), conserved charge susceptibilities Ding et al. 2021 ; Ding et al. 2024 ; Ding et al. 2025 for T\sim 150~{\rm MeV} are properly reproduced in HRG after the inclusion of the physical magnetic moments of hadrons Samanta and Broniowski 2025 . With the above successes, HRG became a standard benchmark for the evaluation of thermodynamic quantities in the hadronic phase. Moreover, this is to be linked with the success in the description of the particle yields (see Andronic et al. 2018 and references herein) in ultra-relativistic nuclear collisions, where statistical hadronization with the chemical freeze-out at T\sim T_{c} leads to a remarkable agreement of the model with the experimental data. Consequently, a conviction followed that below T_{c} we deal with just hadrons, and above with quarks and gluons. Certainly, the cross-over nature of the transition makes the division smooth, with hadrons and partons overlapping near T_{c} , but in practice HRG could be applied up to T_{c} with a stunning accuracy. One of the goals of this paper is to point out that there is a notable difficulty in the application of HRG to describe the lattice data for \chi_{B} in the vicinity of T_{c} . A comparison study was already done in the lattice papers Bali et al. 2014 ; Bali et al. 2020 and most recently in Brandt et al. 2024 , but the significance of the vivid mismatch near T_{c} has not been accentuated, while the agreement between HRG and the lattice at lower T , where the pions largely dominate, was welcome. We try to address this mismatch in the range of T where HRG is expected to be valid, stressing that to be able to describe the lattice data, a suitable model, including the vacuum effects Endrödi 2013 ; Kamikado and Kanazawa 2015 , needs to possess sufficient paramagnetism. It also implies that the paramagnetic degrees of freedom in that region must be sufficiently light, not to be damped thermally. Natural candidates here are quarks of constituent masses of a few hundred MeV, appearing in the system from the melt-down of baryons (see, e.g., McLerran et al. 2009 ; McLerran and Reddy 2019 ; Marczenko et al. 2023 . The methodology applied in this paper is as follows: we use a non-interacting quark-meson model below T_{c} to describe \chi_{B} , while demanding a simultaneous description of the lattice data for the baryon-baryon ( \chi_{\cal{BB}} ) and baryon-strangeness ( \chi_{\cal{BS}} ) susceptibilities. The reason for such choice is that (constituent) quarks can provide the needed paramagnetism in the vicinity of T_{c} , while pions and kaons provide diamagnetism at lower T . Specifically, we use the lattice data for \chi_{\cal{BB}} and \chi_{\cal{BS}} (at B=0 ) Bollweg et al. 2021 to find the temperature dependence of the effective quark masses. For these susceptibilities, as we carefully discuss in Sec. III.2 , in the independent particle approach only the thermal part of the free energy contributes, because the vacuum part does not explicitly depend on the chemical potentials. With thus obtained temperature-dependent quark masses, and with the pions and kaons present, we compute the subtracted magnetic susceptibility \chi_{B}(T)-\chi_{B}(0) , as provided by the lattice simulations Bali et al. 2020 ; Brandt et al. 2024