Resolving the flat-spectrum conundrum: clumpy aerosol distributions in sub-Neptune atmospheres 2015 Resolving the flat-spectrum conundrum: clumpy aerosol distributions in sub-Neptune atmospheres – 10
James E. Owen & James Kirk · 2025
Read Resolving the flat-spectrum conundrum: clumpy aerosol distributions in sub-Neptune atmospheres 2015 Resolving the flat-spectrum conundrum: clumpy aerosol distributions in sub-Neptune atmospheres – 10 by James E. Owen & James Kirk (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-19013.txt.
Introduction
James E. Owen and James Kirk solve a puzzle in the spectra of sub-Neptune planets: many look flat when they should show composition lines. Flat spectra can mean a metal rich air or high grey haze. Escaping hydrogen and helium rule out the metal story for several planets, while even haze of small grains cannot flatten the spectrum, and large grains need absurd production rates.
Clumpy haze breaks the tie. Modestly thick clumps at high altitude flatten the spectrum even with small grains and sane production rates. Clumps lengthen the mean free path of light and wash out its wavelength dependence, so patchy haze acts grey. A third path thus explains the flat look.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James E. Owen & James Kirk |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-19013
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Resolving the flat-spectrum conundrum: clumpy aerosol distributions in sub-Neptune atmospheres 2015 Resolving the flat-spectrum conundrum: clumpy aerosol distributions in sub-Neptune atmospheres – 10 James E. Owen & James Kirk Abstract Transmission spectroscopy of sub-Neptunes was expected to reveal their compositions and hence origins, yet many show flat near- to mid-infrared spectra. Such spectra can be explained either by metal dominated atmospheres or by high-altitude, grey aerosols. Observations of escaping hydrogen and helium from several of these planets rule out metal dominated atmospheres, while homogeneous distributions of small aerosols cannot produce flat spectra and large particles require unphysically high production rates. We investigate the role of heterogeneous, “clumpy” aerosol distributions in shaping transmission spectra. Modestly optically thick clumps at high altitudes can produce flat spectra even with small particles and physically realistic production rates. Clumping increases the effective photon mean-free path while reducing wavelength dependence, allowing the aerosol distribution to behave as an effective grey absorber. Applying this framework to the sub-Neptune TOI-776c, we show that clumpy aerosols can reconcile the observed flattening of its transmission spectrum with a primordial H/He-dominated atmosphere. We further discuss implications for emission spectra, where enhanced stellar radiation penetration and altered scattering in a clumpy medium could produce observable signatures. These results suggest that clumpy aerosol distributions naturally resolve the tension between flat spectra and low-metallicity atmospheres and may be a common feature of sub-Neptune exoplanets. More broadly, our results highlight the need to consider aerosol heterogeneity when interpreting high-altitude microphysics and the spectral appearance of exoplanet atmospheres with JWST, and motivate theoretical work to identify the physical mechanisms capable of generating clumpy aerosol distributions. 1 Introduction Exoplanet surveys have demonstrated that the most common type of exoplanets discovered to date are small ( \lesssim 4 R ⊕ ), low-mass ( \lesssim 20 M ⊕ ) planets on close-in orbits (periods <100 days). This type of planet is found around most stars ( 29 ; 20 , e.g.) ; however, the lack of Solar System analogues and the fact that they were not predicted by pre- Kepler planet formation models ( 44 , e.g.) mean their origins remain hotly debated ( 6 , e.g.) . This class of close-in planets can be further subdivided. The radius valley represents a deficit of exoplanets with sizes of \sim 1.8 R ⊕ ( 32 , e.g.) , where the critical size is orbital-period ( 104 , e.g.) and stellar-mass dependent ( 110 ; 105 ; 85 , e.g.) . Even before the radius valley was confirmed observationally, theoretical models predicted its existence ( 81 ; 59 ; 46 ; 16 , e.g.) as a transition between terrestrial composition planets and objects with about 1% of their mass in primordial H/He atmospheres, arising from photoevaporation of their atmospheres. 108 and 95 used precise masses and radii for a population of planets to demonstrate that there was a transition in planetary composition at a radius similar to the radius valley. Planets with radii smaller than the (period-dependent) radius valley are consistent with an “Earth-like” bulk density, are likely terrestrial planets, and are often termed “super-Earths”. Planets with larger radii must contain a voluminous volatile envelope/atmosphere to explain their bulk densities, and are often termed “sub-Neptunes”. This result has only become stronger with increasing sample sizes and measurement precision ( 84 , e.g.) . The composition of sub-Neptunes’ volatile envelopes has been a matter of intense debate. Comparisons to mass-loss models suggest H/He-dominated atmospheres, irrespective of whether photoevaporation or core-powered mass-loss is considered ( 82 ; 35 ; 91 , e.g.) . These H/He-dominated atmospheres might then be enriched with heavy elements through chemical interactions and miscibility between the core and envelope ( 98 ; 69 ; 89 ; 111 ; 12 ; 38 ; 109 ; 93 , e.g.) , giving rise to higher-metallicity atmospheres. Alternatively, motivated by some planet population synthesis models, super-Earths and sub-Neptunes might form through different channels, with sub-Neptunes primarily forming outside the water snow-line before migrating to shorter periods ( 113 ; 63 , e.g.) . These formation scenarios, when combined with atmospheric escape, suggest that sub-Neptunes contain steam-dominated envelopes/atmospheres ( 106 ; 13 , e.g.) . Although detailed evolution models of multi-planet systems can break some of the degeneracies ( 78 ; 77 , e.g.) , at the population level the density distributions between “water-worlds” and H/He-rich sub-Neptunes are completely degenerate ( 92 , e.g.) . While understanding the exoplanet population as a function of age might provide additional information ( 94 , e.g.) , direct measurement of the observable atmosphere’s composition should provide a more direct probe of a sub-Neptune’s envelope composition. Despite occasional successes ( 66 ; 86 ; 7 ; 21 , e.g.) , recent JWST observations ( 107 ; 14 ; 3 ; 103 ; 2 ; 74 , e.g.) have demonstrated that the transmission spectra of many sub-Neptunes are flat (i.e. showing little or no evidence for wavelength dependence in their transmission spectrum) out to long wavelengths ( \sim 5 \mu m). These results imply that their atmospheres are either extremely metal-rich, or have optically thick, high-altitude aerosols (pressures \lesssim 1 mbar) ( 107 , e.g.) . However, there are challenges to both interpretations. Making the majority of sub-Neptunes have metal dominated atmospheres would make it difficult to match the location of the radius-gap with mass-loss models, pointing to a large (order-of-magnitude or larger) theoretical error in mass-loss model calculations ( 76 , e.g.) . This error would be difficult to reconcile with the success of the models in explaining direct observations of ongoing mass loss ( 24 , e.g.) . Furthermore, several of the planets – TOI-776 b/c ( 60 ) , TOI-836c ( 114 ) and GJ 3090 b ( 2 ) – have had primordial gas detected escaping from their atmospheres, indicating a large H/He reservoir in their envelopes. In the case of TOI-776 c the Lyman- \alpha transit was detected with sufficiently high signal-to-noise to rule out a steam-dominated atmosphere as the source. Thus, if the flat-spectrum sub-Neptunes do indeed have H/He-dominated atmospheres, then the high-altitude aerosol solution is equally unsatisfactory. Producing high-altitude aerosols that are optically thick to 5+\mu m requires large particles (with sizes larger than the typical wavelength of observation). However, large particles settle out of low-pressure environments extremely quickly. For example, the settling time for a 10 \mu m particle at 1 mbar in a typical sub-Neptune is only a few hours. Such large particle sizes would require aerosol production rates in excess of 10^{-9} g cm -2 , significantly larger than those that can be produced by self-consistent microphysical models ( 48 ; 56 , e.g.) . Therefore, we are left with a conundrum: either there is a missing piece of physics in our modelling of sub-Neptunes’ transmission spectra, or there must be a large theoretical error in our understanding of atmospheric composition and mass-loss, or of exoplanet aerosols. In this work, we explore the former. Instead of considering homogeneous aerosol distributions, which have been primarily used in previous modelling efforts, we consider the impact of a highly heterogeneous aerosol distribution. Instead of uniformly mixing aerosols within the atmosphere, we consider the impact of a “clumpy” aerosol distribution, in which small