REFLECTing SPERET: Measuring and Promoting Ethics and Privacy Reflexivity in Eye-Tracking Research CCS: Security and privacy Human and societal aspects of security and privacy CCS: Human-centered computing Ubiquitous and mobile computing systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical stud

Susanne Hindennach, Mayar Elfares, Céline Gressel, Andreas Bulling · 2025

Read REFLECTing SPERET: Measuring and Promoting Ethics and Privacy Reflexivity in Eye-Tracking Research CCS: Security and privacy Human and societal aspects of security and privacy CCS: Human-centered computing Ubiquitous and mobile computing systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical stud by Susanne Hindennach, Mayar Elfares, Céline Gressel, Andreas Bulling (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18965.txt.

Introduction

Susanne Hindennach, Mayar Elfares, Céline Gressel, and Andreas Bulling measure how eye tracking researchers reflect on ethics and privacy in their own work. Eye tracking now serves health care, marketing, and surveillance, all high stakes uses. Guides exist, yet how scholars weigh these issues in practice was scarcely studied.

Two tools, built with input from over seventy researchers, frame the study. REFLECT is a qualitative questionnaire; SPERET is a quantitative scale for ethics and privacy reflexivity. Findings show a field that cares about user privacy, knows its method limits like sample bias, and holds a nuanced sense of duty that grows as a project matures. The tools let the field grade its own conscience.

Catalog record

CREATORSusanne Hindennach, Mayar Elfares, Céline Gressel, Andreas Bulling
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18965

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

REFLECTing SPERET: Measuring and Promoting Ethics and Privacy Reflexivity in Eye-Tracking Research CCS: Security and privacy Human and societal aspects of security and privacy CCS: Human-centered computing Ubiquitous and mobile computing systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing Susanne Hindennach, Mayar Elfares, Céline Gressel, Andreas Bulling Abstract . The proliferation of eye tracking in high - stakes domains – such as healthcare, marketing and surveillance – underscores the need for researchers to be ethically aware when employing this technology. Although privacy and ethical guidelines have emerged in recent years, empirical research on how scholars reflect on their own work remains scarce. To address this gap, we present two complementary instruments developed with input from more than 70 researchers: REFLECT, a qualitative questionnaire, and SPERET (Latin for "hope"), a quantitative psychometric scale that measures privacy and ethics reflexivity in eye tracking. Our findings reveal a research community that is concerned about user privacy, cognisant of methodological constraints, such as sample bias, and that possesses a nuanced sense of ethical responsibility evolving with project maturity. Together, these tools and our analyses offer a systematic examination and a hopeful outlook on reflexivity in eye - tracking research, promoting more privacy and ethics - conscious practice. An overview of our approach. Figure 1 . Using a novel REFLECT questionnaire, we asked eye-tracking researchers to reflect on the privacy and ethics aspects of their research. Based on an analysis of their reflections we further propose SPERET – a psychometric S cale to measure P rivacy and E thics R eflexivity within E ye T racking. An overview of our approach. The image shows avatars with white lab coats and eye trackers that represent eye-tracking researchers. On the left side there is a thought bubble that represents the REFLECT questionnaire. Inside the thought bubble there is a scale representing ethics with a lock to represent privacy and an eye to represent eye tracking. On the right hand side there is a symbol for the SPERET scale. It is a sheet symbol with \textbf{S}cale to measure \textbf{P}rivacy and \textbf{E}thics \textbf{R}eflexivity within \textbf{E}ye \textbf{T}racking written on it, and checkboxes indicating that this is a item scale. 1. Introduction The falling cost and growing portability of eye-tracking hardware are shifting it from a specialised instrument used in psychology and human - computer interaction labs to a pervasive technology employed across domains, such as marketing analytics, medical and psychiatric diagnosis, intelligent tutoring systems or next - generation user interfaces ( Bulling 2016 ) . The accompanying emerging social pervasion creates an urgent imperative to develop and deploy eye tracking responsibly ( Liebling and Preibusch 2014 ; Gressel et al. 2023 ) . In this regard eye-tracking researchers so far mainly focus on privacy as it pertains to an individual’s right to control the collection, use, storage, and dissemination of their gaze data ( Liebling and Preibusch 2014 ; Bozkir et al. 2023 ; Gressel et al. 2023 ) . While privacy represents an important element of responsible research, broader ethical considerations also include issues of justice and fairness in participant sampling, as well as the anticipation and positively influencing potential consequences of the use of eye tracking technologies ( Lavoie et al. 2025 ; Kaufmann et al. 2021 ; Hooge et al. 2025 ; Nyström et al. 2025 ; Niehorster et al. 2025 ) . Numerous ethical guidelines have been proposed for conducting human - subject research ( Gostin 1991 ; Rice 2008 ; Shamoo and Khin-Maung-Gyi 2021 ) and for handling biometric data ( North-Samardzic 2020 ; Sutrop 2010 ; Alterman 2003 ) . These guidelines typically concentrate on procedural ethics – such as informed consent and anonymisation – while offering little empirical insight into the informal ethical reasoning, socio - technical assumptions, and perceived responsibilities of the researchers who actually develop the methods and systems. Researchers determine the project scope, select the technologies, and often decide whether and how to involve ethicists ( Spindler 2025 ) . Even when ethicists are included, their input usually arrives at later stages of the project ( Spindler 2025 ) . Consequently, many ethical and privacy decisions are made by eye-tracking researchers who lack formal training in ethics or privacy, relying instead on unconscious assumptions and informal reasoning ( Bieler et al. 2021a ) . This is despite the fact that ethical research demands that unconscious assumptions be continuously interrogated and aligned with established ethical theories ( von Unger 2021 ) . This practice – stepping back from one’s own work, questioning underlying premises, and conceptualising the factors that shape research unconsciously or contextually – is known as reflexivity ( Bieler et al. 2021b ; Attia and Edge 2017 ; von Unger 2021 ) . Beyond fostering ethically sound research, reflexivity also provides a methodological basis for empirically analysing researchers’ perceptions of privacy and ethical issues. This is essential because it offers a systematic means of assessing how researchers incorporate ethical and privacy considerations into their practice ( Berghaeuser et al. 2025 ) . The goal of this work is to foster and examine reflexivity in eye tracking research in order to promote ethical research practice. To achieve this, we developed two complementary tools: (1) REFLECT – a qualitative questionnaire, and (2) SPERET – a psychometric scale The REFLECT questionnaire elicits reflection via open questions about privacy and ethical aspects of research projects, while the SPERET scale offers a standardised means to assess researchers’ reflexivity by asking for their agreement with validated items derived from the REFLECT insights. A core part of development was the active involvement of eye-tracking researchers ( N>70 ) through offline workshops and online questionnaires, representing the perspectives of a diverse group of domain experts. This contrasts prior scale development ( Farzand et al. 2024 ; Hasan et al. 2023 ) in which items were generated through discussions among a small group of researchers or within a single research team (typically fewer than three researchers). Complementarily, while REFLECT serves as an in-depth individual assessment that can help small teams to articulate their reflexivity, the standardised and quantifiable assessment of SPERET can enable broad assessment across larger research groups. Together, they can identify gaps in ethical reflexivity, guide training or point out where an external ethical expertise is needed and thus open a connection point for interventions to enhance responsible research conduct. We argue that our tools should be presented as developmental self - assessment instruments intended to provoke reflection, dialogue and ethical growth, rather than as evaluative devices that judge moral integrity or determine eligibility for participation, funding or promotion. Framed in this way, they retain a formative purpose, encouraging researchers to engage critically and honestly with their assumptions, values and decision - making processes. When incorporated into facilitated discussions or interdisciplinary ethics training, the tools become catalysts for collective learning, helping teams to uncover blind spots and negotiate divergent perspectives. By contrast, using them as ranking or gate - keeping mechanisms would undermine their reflective potential and encourage performative rather than genuine engagement. Consequently, preserving a developmental framing is essential for the instruments to foster authentic ethical reflexivity and to contribute meaningfully to a responsible research culture. 2. Related Work 2.1.

Read the complete text