Revisiting the Measurement of Polarization
Juan A. Crespo, Armajac Raventós-Pujol · 2025
Read Revisiting the Measurement of Polarization by Juan A. Crespo, Armajac Raventós-Pujol (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18944.txt.
Introduction
Juan A Crespo and Armajac Raventós-Pujol revisit a landmark 1994 model of political polarisation by Esteban and Ray. That model's main result rests on treating individuals as infinitely divisible, a mathematical convenience that sharply restricts which polarisation indices are allowed. Crespo and Raventós-Pujol show the assumption is unnecessary: dropping it yields a broader family of indices that still satisfy the original axioms of the theory.
The wider family avoids counter-intuitive rankings that the original results can produce, where a society is scored as more polarised in ways that clash with plain judgement. It also gives empirical researchers more flexibility in choosing a measure. The note is a careful piece of theory repair, loosening a classic result without breaking its foundations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Juan A. Crespo, Armajac Raventós-Pujol |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18944
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting the Measurement of Polarization Thanks: Both authors are partially supported by Comunidad de Madrid (Spain) excelence grant H2019/HUM-5891 and Spanish MICIU grant PID2024-161056NB-I00. Second author is partially supported by grants of the Spanish MINECO CEX2021-001181-M and MICIU/AEI /10.13039/501100011033. They are deeply indebted to Ignacio Ortuño and Klaus Desmet for their insightful questions and comments which greatly improved this paper. They also thank Shlomo Weber, Juan de Dios Moreno and Antonio Cabrales for their helpful suggestions. The paper was presented at the 13th Conference on Economic Design, the 48th Simposio de Análisis Económico, and in seminars at Universidad Carlos III and Universidad Autónoma de Madrid. The authors are grateful to all attendees for their valuable feedback. Juan A. Crespo, Armajac Raventós-Pujol Abstract . We revisit Esteban and Ray’s (1994) seminal model of polarization. Their main result (unnecessarily) relies on the assumption that individuals are infinitely divisible, which imposes strong restrictions on admissible polarization indices. We show that relaxing this assumption yields a broader family of indices consistent with the original axioms. The resulting indices avoid counter-intuitive rankings that arise when using results on the original paper and provide greater flexibility for empirical applications. Introduction It has been 30 years since Esteban and Ray’s (1994) seminal contribution to the measurement of polarization [ 11 ] . In their model, antagonism in society depends on the alienation individuals feel toward members of other groups, as well as on their identification with their own group. They introduce a set of axioms that formalize the concept of polarization, thereby narrowing the set of admissible measures interpretable as polarization indices. The Esteban–Ray measure has since become well established and widely applied in economics and political science to address diverse empirical and theoretical questions [ 2 , 3 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 13 , 14 , 17 ] . The present paper makes three contributions. First, using the original model and axiomatization, we show that the concept of polarization admits a broader set of measures with fewer parameter restrictions. By considering that individuals are infinitely divisible, Esteban and Ray (1994) make a simplifying assumption that is not innocuous: it sharply limits the set of feasible polarization indices. Second, we provide examples in which these restrictive measures yield counterintuitive rankings of societies. In these cases, a more flexible antagonism function, which is consistent with the original model and axiomatization, produces rankings that align better with intuitive judgments. Third, we show that expanding the feasible set of indices gives empirical researchers greater flexibility. Depending on the context, a researcher may wish to adopt different functional forms or parameterization for how antagonism increases with group size or with inter-group distance. To identify the broader set of polarization indices consistent with the Esteban–Ray model and axiomatization, we begin by removing the assumption that individuals are infinitely divisible. We then re-examine the role of Condition H and Axioms 1–3. We show that Condition H is equivalent to requiring that the antagonism function decomposes as the product of identification and alienation, where identification is a non-negative power function of group size. We then prove that Axiom 1 is equivalent to requiring that the role of identification cannot be neutral . Axiom 2 is equivalent to assuming that the marginal effect of distance on alienation is non-decreasing . Finally, while Axiom 1 concerns identification and Axiom 2 concerns alienation, Axiom 3 rules the relationship between the two. More specifically, once an alienation function has been set, Axiom 3 restricts the feasible range of powers for the identification function and vice versa. These three equivalences allow us to view the axioms from a new perspective: whereas Esteban and Ray formulated them using a macro perspective , namely, how polarization depends on the shape of social distributions, they can now be reformulated through a micro perspective , namely, the properties of individual antagonism functions. Not only that, when one does not admit that individuals are infinitely divisible. the precise characterization we obtain of antagonism functions enables us to construct new examples of indices (see Section 4 ) that satisfy Condition H and the axioms. Those measures of polarization cannot be extended to the domains for populations used by ER, namely the positive real numbers. Thus, these examples show that the simplification made in [ 11 ] is the reason they obtained such a restrictive family of polarization indices 1 1 1 In words by ER: “This theorem dramatically narrows the class of allowable polarization measures.” and, therefore, that it was a technical assumption that was not harmless. Our paper is not a theoretical quibble about a technical assumption, we show the restricted set of indices obtained by Esteban and Ray leads to counter-intuitive results. Specifically, we compare distributions of two societies that are easily rankable based on our intuitive understanding of which is more polarized. We then show that Esteban–Ray indices would rank these societies erroneously, whereas the broader set of indices we identify would allow for correct rankings (see Section 5 for details). In that sense, our findings are important for empirical work, as they allow for a broader range of possibilities when modeling the effects of group size and intergroup distance on antagonism. For instance, we suggest revisiting articles that employed the Esteban–Ray index and dismissed the role of polarization in certain phenomena (e.g., the effect of political polarization on government size [ 16 ] or of religious polarization on conflict [ 1 ] ). Moreover, the decoupling of axioms and our macro–micro equivalences sheds light on the interpretation of the axioms. If one of the axioms does not fit the observed properties of antagonism, the practitioner may disregard that axiom while continuing to rely on the remaining ones. This departs from Esteban and Ray’s approach, in which all axioms were intertwined in proving the characterization theorem. For example, it has been shown that in some contexts the marginal effect of distance on alienation becomes negligible at large distances (e.g. [ 8 ] ). Using our equivalences, we can see that this assumption violates only Axiom 2 because, in this case, the alienation function would not be convex. In that case, one may remove Axiom 2, adopt an alienation function with a plateau beyond a threshold, and obtain a polarization index that still satisfies Condition H and Axioms 1 and 3. The paper is organized as follows. Section 1 reintroduces the model of Esteban and Ray. Section 2 is devoted to study Condition H and its effect on antagonism functions. Section 3 provides necessary and sufficient conditions for each of Esteban and Ray’s three axioms in terms of antagonism. Section 4 introduces new examples of polarization indices. Finally, Section 5 compares the performance of these new indices with the classical Esteban–Ray indices in specific distributions. 1. The Model by Esteban and Ray As mentioned in the introduction, Esteban and Ray’s model builds on the individual perception of the effective antagonism that each member of a society feels toward others. We review the model, focusing on the domains in which polarization indices are defined, avoiding the assumption that individuals within each group are infinitely divisible, and adjusting the axioms accordingly. 1.1. Distributions and polarization indices Assume that a society consists of