The dawn is quiet II: Gaia XP constraints on the Milky Way’s proto-Galaxy from very metal-poor MDF tails

Boquan Chen, Matthew D. A. Orkney, Yuan-Sen Ting, Michael R. Hayden · 2025

Read The dawn is quiet II: Gaia XP constraints on the Milky Way’s proto-Galaxy from very metal-poor MDF tails by Boquan Chen, Matthew D. A. Orkney, Yuan-Sen Ting, Michael R. Hayden (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18901.txt.

Introduction

Boquan Chen and three co-authors constrain how the Milky Way's earliest proto galaxy formed by studying its most metal poor stars. The chemical pattern of old stars records how much cold gas the young Galaxy held, how fast gas flowed in, and how efficiently it formed stars. Those factors trade off against each other.

Using metallicity catalogs built from Gaia spectra, they measure the slope of the metal poor tail of the distribution. Chemical evolution models matching that slope favor a moderate initial gas reservoir, sustained by weak steady inflow, with star formation efficiency much like today's during the first billion years. Simulated Milky Way analogs show similar tails.

Catalog record

CREATORBoquan Chen, Matthew D. A. Orkney, Yuan-Sen Ting, Michael R. Hayden
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18901

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The dawn is quiet II: Gaia XP constraints on the Milky Way’s proto-Galaxy from very metal-poor MDF tails Boquan Chen, Matthew D. A. Orkney, Yuan-Sen Ting, Michael R. Hayden Abstract The earliest phase of the Milky Way’s evolution involved a transition from a dispersion-supported proto-galaxy to a rotationally supported disk. A key chemical signature of this transition is the moderate rise in [ α \alpha /Fe] near [ Fe / H ] ≈ − 1.3 \mathrm{[Fe/H]}\approx-1.3 , which we previously interpreted as evidence for α \alpha -enhanced gas accretion fueling early disk formation. However, this trend alone does not uniquely constrain the trade-off between initial gas mass, inflow rate, and star formation efficiency (SFE), leaving the physical condition of the proto-Milky Way uncertain. To break this degeneracy, we analyze the metal-poor tail ( − 3 < [ Fe / H ] < − 2 -3<\mathrm{[Fe/H]}<-2 ) of the Milky Way’s metallicity distribution function (MDF) using Gaia DR3 BP/RP (XP) metallicities from ten catalogs. After applying recommended quality cuts, all catalogs exhibit a single-slope exponential tail with slopes k ≃ 0.5 k\simeq 0.5 –2.0. Comparison with one-zone galactic chemical-evolution (GCE) models that replicated the [ α \alpha /Fe]-rise from Paper I shows that shallow tails ( k ≃ 0.6 k\simeq 0.6 ) require a massive initial cold gas reservoir ( ≳ 10 9 ​ M ⊙ \gtrsim 10^{9}\,\mathrm{M_{\odot}} ), while steeper tails ( k ≳ 1 k\gtrsim 1 ) arise from small reservoirs that built up over time with weak inflow. MDFs with k ≃ 1.0 k\simeq 1.0 are best reproduced under our GCE framework, which favor a proto-Galaxy with a moderate gas reservoir ( 10 8 10^{8} – 10 9 ​ M ⊙ 10^{9}\,\mathrm{M_{\odot}} ) sustained through weak continuous inflow ( ∼ 2 ​ M ⊙ ​ yr − 1 \sim 2\ \mathrm{M_{\odot}\ yr^{-1}} ) and SFE comparable to today’s value (a few × 10 − 10 ​ yr − 1 \times 10^{-10}\,\mathrm{yr^{-1}} ) during the first Gyr. This scenario is reinforced by MDFs of 30 Milky Way analogs in the Auriga simulations, which exhibit similar slopes ( k ≈ 1.2 k\approx 1.2 ). The metal-poor MDF tail thus provides a quantitative constraint on the Milky Way’s early gas accretion and star formation history. I Introduction The earliest phase of the Milky Way’s formation was dominated by a rapid and turbulent phase in the form of a compact proto-galaxy, preceding the emergence of the rotationally supported disk. Elemental abundances from APOGEE and kinematics from Gaia indicate an in-situ, kinematically hot “Aurora” phase at low metallicity, followed by a fast “spin-up” of the Galaxy as its disk started to form between -1.3<[\mathrm{Fe/H}]<-0.9 over \sim 1–2 Gyr, with a simultaneous drop in abundance scatter ( 9 ) . A central concentration of 18,000 giant stars with [Fe/H] <-1.5 have been found within \sim 5 kpc of the Galactic center and proposed to be the proto-Galactic nucleus. These stars suggest that the metal-poor “heart” contains >10^{8}\ \mathrm{M_{\odot}} and formed >12.5 Gyr ago ( 67 ) . Multiple components belonging to the proto-Galaxy have also been identified and characterized with a mix of in situ vs accreted origins ( 49 ; 38 ) . The disk of the Milky Way commenced its assembly around 13 Gyr ago, with its star formation rate (SFR) peaking around 11 Gyr ago, coinciding with the Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus (GSE) ( 84 ; 81 ; 9 ; 83 ) . This used to be considered unusually early, but a cold rotating disk has been confirmed by an extra-galactic observation at z\sim 4.3 when the universe was only 1.5 Gyr old ( 57 ) . The quiescent evolution of the disk took over around 8 Gyr ago and continued to the present as evidenced by a clear division in the stellar age-metallicity distribution ( 36 ; 76 ; 29 ; 69 ) . These three phases of evolution are confirmed by a sample of ten million giants from Gaia ( 17 ) . However, there is evidence that the kinematically defined thin and thick disk could have also co-evolved from 13 Gyr ago ( 58 ; 11 ) . As the Galactic disk began to form, a moderate rise in [ \alpha /Fe] appeared near \mathrm{[Fe/H]}\approx-1.3 , even among stars on low-eccentricity orbits ( 21 ; 9 ; 67 ) . This feature marks the transition from the turbulent, kinematically hot Aurora phase to the onset of ordered, rotationally supported star formation and has been interpreted as the chemical signature of the disk’s birth. In Paper I ( 18 ) , we showed that the observed [ \alpha /Fe] upturn is best explained by the sudden onset of \alpha -enhanced gas inflow-pre-enriched by core-collapse supernovae in the halo-which supplied both angular momentum and fuel for renewed star formation after a preceding inflow-poor phase. The resulting enhancement thus reflects the coupled chemical and dynamical effects of the accreted material. However, the [ \alpha /Fe]-rise alone cannot uniquely determine the proto-Galaxy’s initial gas mass, star-formation efficiency, or inflow timescale, as multiple parameter combinations yield similar patterns. To break this degeneracy, we now turn to the slope of the metal-poor tail of the metallicity distribution function (MDF), which traces the balance between gas supply and metal production during the Galaxy’s earliest evolution. The all-sky BP/RP spectrophotometry (XP spectra) from Gaia DR3 offers an unprecedented opportunity to extend the analysis beyond the [ \alpha /Fe] feature and directly probe the metal-poor tail of the Galactic MDF. Because the XP selection is essentially photometric and astrometric-without pre-selection on kinematics, latitude, or metallicity-it provides a nearly unbiased census of stars across the Milky Way. Covering 330-1050 nm for about 220 million sources observed with a single, homogeneous instrument and calibration pipeline, XP spectra capture strong metal-sensitive features such as Ca ii H & K. When combined with parallaxes and broadband photometry, these data break key degeneracies among stellar parameters, enabling uniform metallicity estimates that reach into the Galactic plane and low- |\mathrm{z}| regions long under-sampled by spectroscopic surveys. Building on Paper I, we now exploit the XP-based metallicity catalogs to study the logarithmic MDF over -3<\mathrm{[Fe/H]}<-2.0 . Using a grid of one-zone GCE models that replicated the [ \alpha /Fe]-rise in Paper I, we interpret the observed slopes to constrain the proto-Galaxy’s parameters. Very metal-poor (VMP; \mathrm{[Fe/H]}<-2.0 ) and extremely metal-poor (EMP; \mathrm{[Fe/H]}<-3.0 ) stars provide the most direct fossil record of the proto-Galaxy, retaining the chemical and kinematic signatures of the first star-formation episodes. Even small, well-characterized samples offer strong constraints on early enrichment and gas accretion-for instance, asteroseismic ages of \sim 12 Gyr for stars with \mathrm{[Fe/H]}\approx-2.7 set lower bounds on the onset of in-situ disk formation ( 39 ) . Interpreting such ancient populations requires GCE modeling, which links observables such as the MDF, [ \alpha /Fe]-[Fe/H] trends, and age-abundance relations to the underlying inflow, outflow, and star formation histories (SFH). Historically, VMP and EMP stars have constrained the critical metallicity for low-mass star formation and the yields of the first supernovae ( 34 ; 62 ; 70 ; 13 ) , but robust statistical inference has been limited by the rarity of such stars and strong selection biases. Gaia XP now provides the first

Read the complete text