A Recommender System Based on Binary Matrix Representations for Cognitive Disorders Journal: Nuclear Physics B
Raoul H. Kutil, Georg Zimmermann, Christian Borgelt · 2025
Read A Recommender System Based on Binary Matrix Representations for Cognitive Disorders Journal: Nuclear Physics B by Raoul H. Kutil, Georg Zimmermann, Christian Borgelt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18645.txt.
Introduction
Raoul H. Kutil, Georg Zimmermann, and Christian Borgelt build a recommender that guides diagnosis of cognitive disorders by symptoms. Diagnosis is delicate: disorders share symptoms, and the next most telling symptom to check is hard to pick from memory alone. Their system rests on a binary matrix that maps each disorder to its symptom set.
As a patient's known symptoms come in, the matrix filters rows and columns to the live candidates. The system then names the next symptom whose answer splits the field most. A Python prototype was tested on synthetic and some real cases. The aim is decision support, not a verdict: a guide for which question to ask next. Such a guide could steady a hard, overlap prone task.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Raoul H. Kutil, Georg Zimmermann, Christian Borgelt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18645
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Recommender System Based on Binary Matrix Representations for Cognitive Disorders Journal: Nuclear Physics B Raoul H. Kutil, Georg Zimmermann, Christian Borgelt Abstract Background : Diagnosing cognitive (mental health) disorders is a delicate and complex task. Identifying the next most informative symptoms to assess, in order to distinguish between possible disorders, presents an additional challenge. This process requires comprehensive knowledge of diagnostic criteria and symptom overlap across disorders, making it difficult to navigate based on symptoms alone. Objective : This research aims to develop a recommender system for cognitive disorder diagnosis using binary matrix representations. Method : The core algorithm utilizes a binary matrix of disorders and their symptom combinations. It filters through the rows and columns based on the patient’s current symptoms to identify potential disorders and recommend the most informative next symptoms to examine. Results : A prototype of the recommender system was implemented in Python. Using synthetic test and some real-life data, the system successfully identified plausible disorders from an initial symptom set and recommended further symptoms to refine the diagnosis. It also provided additional context on the symptom-disorder relationships. Conclusion : Although this is a prototype, the recommender system shows potential as a clinical support tool. A fully-developed application of this recommender system may assist mental health professionals in identifying relevant disorders more efficiently and guiding symptom-specific follow-up investigations to improve diagnostic accuracy. 1 Introduction Accurate diagnosis is essential for effective treatment, but the process is often complicated by the complexity and symptom overlap among mental disorders. Diagnostic manuals like the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th Edition) and ICD-10 (International Classification of Diseases, 10th Edition) provide criteria meant to standardize diagnosis, but these criteria can be met in many different ways. The DSM is the standard classification system used by mental health professionals to diagnose and categorize mental disorders. It provides clear description, the previously mentioned criteria, and codes to ensure consistency and reliability in diagnosis across clinical settings. The ICD (International Classification of Diseases, 10th Edition) includes much more, but does not specifically focus on mental health issues. Each disorder includes a wide range of possible criteria-satisfying symptom combinations that fulfil the minimum requirements for diagnosis, though additional symptoms may also be present. For example, the first criterion for Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) includes nine items (consisting of over 20 symptoms), of which any five must be present, with at least one being either the symptoms depressed mood or loss of interest. This results in over seven million possible valid symptom combinations. Each symptom combination is a valid configuration for satisfying this criterion of the diagnosis. A symptom combination satisfying all diagnostic criteria of a disorder will be referred to as symptom profile, or simply profile. Such variability makes diagnosis especially difficult when symptoms overlap across disorders, as seen in the shared symptoms of MDD, anxiety disorders, bipolar disorder, and certain personality disorders. This overlap complicates differential diagnosis, the process of distinguishing one disorder from others with similar symptoms. Despite these challenges, accurate diagnosis is crucial, as misdiagnosis can lead to ineffective treatment, prolonged suffering, and increased healthcare costs. While updates to diagnostic criteria, based on clinical research and practitioner feedback, have improved specificity for some conditions, the knowledge remains primarily narrative and not machine-readable. Ontologies like the Human Disease Ontology and the ICD ontology aim to structure this information, but they either reflect the authors’ interpretations or fail to represent critical relationships between symptoms and diagnostic criteria. As a result, these tools fall short of supporting scalable, computational analysis. The lack of a comprehensive, machine-readable diagnostic framework limits the ability to analyze and distinguish disorders effectively. Clinicians must make decisions under time constraints and cognitive limitations, often relying on heuristics like availability, representativeness, and confirmation bias. While these mental short cuts help manage complexity, they can introduce error, particularly when atypical symptom patterns are involved. Enhancing diagnostic accuracy and minimizing bias requires a balance between intuitive judgment and systematic analysis, supported by improved tools for representing and navigating diagnostic knowledge. Systems like Phen2Gene [ 1 ] , DXplain [ 2 ] , and Infermedica [ 3 ] [ 4 ] exemplify diverse clinical recommendation approaches, each designed to achieve specific objectives. While Phen2Gene prioritizes genes from phenotype profiles, DXplain offers knowledge-based differential diagnoses, and Infermedica dynamically refines disease rankings using probabilistic and machine-learning methods. Together, they show how recommendation strategies can be successfully applied across diverse clinical tasks. Strasser-Kirchweger et al. (2025) [ 5 ] introduced a novel framework that utilizes a binary system to represent the relationship between symptoms and diagnostic criteria. This representation enabled the development of a measure for assessing the similarity between cognitive disorders as described in the DSM-5 [ 6 ] , and for exploring the potential of a delineation method between disorders. Initial experiments with the proposed measure showed alignment with expert assessments of the relative similarity among various disorders. Building on this work, Kutil et al. (2025) [ 7 ] addressed the challenges of generating symptom combinations and computing similarity measures for highly complex disorders. These issues were effectively tackled using a generator-based representation of disorders, which was originally designed to bridge the narrative descriptions with their binary matrix counterparts. This study proposes a prototype for a recommender system application designed to support medical professionals in navigating the diagnostic framework of the DSM-5. It implements abductive reasoning in a vectorized framework, drawing inspiration from inference-based diagnostic models proposed by Reggia et al. (1990) [ 8 ] . Abductive reasoning serves as the computational basis for deriving plausible diagnostic explanations from observed symptom patterns, consistent with its formalization as a core inference process (Selman et al., 1989) [ 9 ] and its distinction from deduction (Shanahan, 1989) [ 10 ] . The goal is to enhance the reliability and efficiency of the diagnostic process by suggesting the most informative symptoms to evaluate next. The core idea behind the algorithm is that a clinician needs only to input a set of observed symptoms to receive suggestions for likely disorders and the next most informative symptoms to investigate, eliminating the need for additional manual research and any human error that could occur thereby. 1.1 Binary Matrix Representation A machine-actionable representation is a translation of narrative text into a format computers can efficiently process. While computers can store and read raw text from sources like the DSM-5, extracting meaningful insights is challenging due to inconsistencies in symptom naming and ambiguities in conjunctions ("and"/"or") from the diagnostic criteria. Natural language processing (NLP) helps interpret these complexities, but a direct translation into a binary system simplifies analysis. A binary matrix is such a machine-actionable representation. In this approach, symptoms are represented as binary values ( 1 for presence, 0 for absence). The collection of symptoms as a list or as a binary vector necessary for a valid diagnosis is called a symptom profile. Two methods are considered: one that focuses solely on symptom presence/absence and another that incorporates logical rules for a more detailed representation [ 7 ] . The "Maximum Profile" method (MP) represents each disorder as a single binary vector, marking all relevant symptoms with 1 s and absent ones with 0 s. Vertically stacking these vectors