Proton mass decompositions in the NNLO QCD

Kazuhiro Tanaka · 2025

Read Proton mass decompositions in the NNLO QCD by Kazuhiro Tanaka (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18310.txt.

Introduction

Kazuhiro Tanaka reviews how the proton's mass splits into parts from quarks and gluons. The split starts from how the proton bends space in a formal sense, through factors that code that response. At zero momentum shift those factors give the mass shares, which split further into quark mass terms and a trace anomaly term.

Tanaka reports the fresh values at a high order of precision in the strong force theory. He also tracks how each share shifts when the energy scale used in the math changes. A second split, based on the trace free and trace parts of the energy tensor, gets the same care. The review gives a clear ledger of what makes up the proton's mass.

Catalog record

CREATORKazuhiro Tanaka
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18310

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Proton mass decompositions in the NNLO QCD Kazuhiro Tanaka Abstract Proton matrix elements of the QCD energy-momentum tensor are expressed by the gravitational form factors. The forward values of the gravitational form factors allow for a decomposition of the proton mass into the contributions from quarks and gluons, and the further subdivisions into the contributions from quark masses and from the QCD trace anomaly may be considered. We present the most recent evaluations of these mass decompositions, using a recent quantitative evaluation of the forward values of relevant gravitational form factors at the next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) QCD. We also calculate the renormalization scale dependence of each component within these decompositions. The results indicate several shortcomings of those decompositions. We propose a new decomposition according to the twist of the relevant operators, i.e., classifying the effects via the partonic motion according to asymptotic freedom and the parton correlation by non-perturbative QCD interactions. We demonstrate the improvements by our new decomposition. We also present the results for the pion, which exhibit quite different parton-correlation behaviors from the proton. The energy-momentum tensor (EMT) plays fundamental roles in quantum field theories, arising in the generators for the Poincaré, dilatation, and conformal transformations Treiman et al. 1986 ; Braun et al. 2003 . In QCD the EMT is composed of several composite operators, and their physical interpretations are not straightforward due to their sophisticated renormalization properties Collins 1986 ; Ji 1995a ; Hatta et al. 2018 and the associated trace anomalies Nielsen 1977 ; Adler et al. 1977 ; Collins et al. 1977 ; Tanaka 2019 ; Ahmed et al. 2022 . These complications, in particular, have been preventing the attempts Ji 1995b ; Ji 2021 ; Lorcé 2018 ; Metz et al. 2020 ; Liu 2021 ; Ji et al. 2021 ; Lorcé et al. 2021 to understand the mass structure of the proton from the EMT. The symmetric EMT in QCD, T^{\alpha\beta}=T^{\alpha\beta}_{q}+T^{\alpha\beta}_{g} , reads Ji 1995b ; Braun et al. 2003 ; Polyakov and Schweitzer 2018 \displaystyle T^{\alpha\beta}_{q}=i\bar{\psi}\gamma^{(\alpha}\overleftrightarrow{D}^{\beta)}\psi,\;\;\;T_{g}^{\alpha\beta}=-F^{\alpha\lambda}F^{\beta}_{\ \lambda}+\frac{\eta^{\alpha\beta}}{4}F^{2}, (1) where T^{\alpha\beta}_{q} and T_{g}^{\alpha\beta} are the gauge-invariant quark part and gluon part, D^{\alpha}=\partial^{\alpha}+igA^{\alpha} , \overleftrightarrow{D}^{\alpha}\equiv(\overrightarrow{D}^{\alpha}-\overleftarrow{D}^{\alpha})/2 , R^{(\alpha}S^{\beta)}\equiv(R^{\alpha}S^{\beta}+R^{\beta}S^{\alpha})/2 , F^{\alpha\lambda} is the gluon field strength tensor, and \eta^{\alpha\beta} is the metric tensor; we have neglected the gauge-variant terms, i.e. the ghost terms and the gauge fixing term, as they do not affect our final results 1 1 1 The hadron matrix elements of those gauge-variant terms vanish, see e.g., Collins 1986 ; Kodaira and Tanaka 1999 . . T^{\alpha\beta} can be constructed from the canonical EMT by adding appropriate total-divergence contributions to make it symmetric, T^{\alpha\beta}=T^{\beta\alpha} , while preserving the continuity equation, \partial_{\alpha}T^{\alpha\beta}=0 . All composite operators presented in this Letter are renormalized in the MS-like (MS, \overline{\rm MS} ) schemes in the dimensional regularization Collins 1986 , and we follow the conventions of Tanaka 2023 . Our proton state |p\rangle has the eigenvalue p^{\alpha} for the 4-momentum operator defined as the volume integral of T^{0\alpha} and is normalized as \langle p^{\prime}|p\rangle=2p^{0}(2\pi)^{3}\delta^{(3)}(p^{\prime}-p) . Then, translation invariance allows us to show \langle p|T^{\alpha\beta}|p\rangle=2p^{\alpha}p^{\beta} , from which the well-known expressions for the proton mass M read, \displaystyle 2M^{2}=\left.\langle p|T^{00}|p\rangle\right|_{\bm{p}=\bm{0}},\;\;\;\;\;\;2M^{2}=\langle p|\eta_{\alpha\beta}T^{\alpha\beta}|p\rangle, (2) as the “rest energy” and as the “invariant mass”. The invariant mass of ( 2 ) leads to the well-known proton mass formula Shifman et al. 1978 associated with the trace anomaly Nielsen 1977 ; Adler et al. 1977 ; Collins et al. 1977 , i.e., T^{\alpha}_{\ \alpha}=\frac{\beta(g)}{2g}F^{2}+[1+\gamma_{m}(g)]m\bar{\psi}\psi , with the QCD \beta -function \beta(g) and the anomalous dimension for the quark mass, \gamma_{m}(g) . Thus, the proton mass is expressed by the non-perturbative matrix elements \langle p|F^{2}|p\rangle , \langle p|m\bar{\psi}\psi|p\rangle ; these matrix elements of the Lorentz scalar operators equal the corresponding matrix elements at the rest frame, as \langle p|{\cal O}(0)|p\rangle =\langle p|{\cal O}(0)|p\rangle|_{\bm{p}=\bm{0}}=2M\langle\int d^{3}x{\cal O}(x)\rangle , with {\cal O}(x)=F^{2}(x),m\bar{\psi}\psi(x) , where we have introduced the shorthand notation for the expectation value in the rest frame as \langle\,\cdots\,\rangle\equiv(\langle p|\cdots|p\rangle/\langle p|p\rangle)_{\bm{p}=\bm{0}} . As discussed below, \langle p|m\bar{\psi}\psi|p\rangle is expressed by the sigma terms determined (semi)emprically; then, the condition that the second equation of ( 2 ) should reproduce the value of the proton mass allows us to evaluate the proton matrix element \langle p|F^{2}|p\rangle . Now, using those non-perturbative values of \langle p|F^{2}|p\rangle as well as of \langle p|m\bar{\psi}\psi|p\rangle , the separation of T^{\alpha\beta} into ( 1 ) allows us to decompose the proton mass into the quark and gluon contributons as M={\cal M}_{q}+{\cal M}_{g} (see ( 14 ) below), combined with the trace anomaly, as taking trace after renormalization 2 2 2 Taking trace and performing renormalization do not commute; if their order were reversed, as taking trace before renormalization, the RHS of ( 3 ) would be modified into m\bar{\psi}\psi , which corresponds to the “D2 scheme” Metz et al. 2020 ; Lorcé et al. 2021 ; Liu 2021 . , for each part of ( 1 ), \displaystyle T_{q\ \alpha}^{\alpha}=m\bar{\psi}\psi+\frac{{{\alpha_{s}}}}{{4\pi}}\left(\frac{{{n_{f}}}}{3}F^{2}+\frac{{4{C_{F}}}}{3}m\bar{\psi}\psi\right)+\cdots, (3) and T_{g\ \alpha}^{\alpha}=T^{\alpha}_{\ \alpha}-T_{q\ \alpha}^{\alpha} , with \alpha_{s}\equiv g^{2}/4\pi , for N_{c} color with C_{F}=(N_{c}^{2}-1)/2N_{c} ; ( 3 ) holds in the MS-like schemes, and the ellipses stand for the corrections at the two loops ( {\cal O}(\alpha_{s}^{2}) ) and higher, which are derived in Hatta et al. 2018 ; Tanaka 2019 ; Ahmed et al. 2022 . The quantitative results using the three-loop formulas Tanaka 2019 for ( 3 ) will be discussed in Figs. 2 , 4 below. The rest energy of ( 2 ) reads M=(\langle p|T^{00}|p\rangle/2M)_{\bm{p}=\bm{0}} =\langle\,H\,\rangle , and H=\int d^{3}x[T_{q}^{00}(x)+T_{g}^{00}(x)] , i.e., \displaystyle H=\int d^{3}x\Bigl[\bar{\psi}\bigl(i\bm{\gamma}\cdot\overleftrightarrow{\bm{D}}+m\bigr)\psi+\frac{1}{2}\bigl(\bm{E}^{2}+\bm{B}^{2}\bigr)\Bigr], (4) denotes the QCD Hamiltonian composed of the quark Dirac Hamiltonian and the chromoelectric/chromomagnetic Hamiltonian, as derived from ( 1 ), so that M=\langle\,H\,\rangle leads to the mass formula as the sum of the rest energies, M=U_{q}+U_{g} , due to the quark and gluonic degrees of freedom. The corresponding expectation values of the quark and gluon Hamiltonian operators of ( 4 ) could be computed by non-perturbative methods like lattice QCD Yang et al. 2018 . Here, alternatively, we represent and evaluate them using the gravitational form factors, A_{r}(\Delta^{2},\mu) and \bar{C}_{r}(\Delta^{2},\mu) with r=q,g , which are the functions of \Delta^{2}\equiv(p^{\prime}-p)^{2} as well as the renormalization scale \mu , and are defined for each of ( 1 ) as \displaystyle\!\!\!\langle p^{\prime}|T_{r}^{\alpha\beta}|p\rangle=\bar{u}(p^{\prime})\bigl[A_{r}\gamma^{(\alpha}\overline{p}^{\beta)}+\bar{C}_{r}M\eta^{\alpha\beta}\bigr]u(p)+\cdots, (5) where \overline{p}^{\alpha}\equiv(p^{\alpha}+p^{\prime\alpha})/2 , u(p) is the proton spinor, and the ellipses stand for the terms associated with the other Lorentz structures that vanish as \Delta=p^{\prime}-p\to 0 (see e.g., Polyakov and Schweitzer 2018 ; Tanaka 2018 ; Tong et al. 2022 ; Fujii et al. 2025 ). The sum rule, \bar{C}_{q}(\Delta^{2},\mu)+\bar{C}_{g}(\Delta^{2},\mu)=0 , is derived by contracting ( 5 ) with \Delta_{\alpha} and using \partial_{\alpha}T^{\alpha\beta}=0 . Also, \langle p|T^{\alpha\beta}|p\rangle=2p^{\alpha}p^{\beta} ensures the forward sum rule, A_{q}(0,\mu)+A_{g}(0,\mu)=1 . Physically, the gravitational form factors represent the coupling of the proton with a graviton. Instead of probing them via such impractical graviton-proton processes, the gravitational form factors can be accessed through the spin-2 contributions induced by the two vector currents; e.g., with the two electromagnetic currents, the deeply virtual Compton scatterings Ji 1997 in JLab Burkert et al. 2018 and the future electron-ion collider (EIC) allow us to probe the gravitational form factors. Substituting the forward limit of ( 5 ) into M=\langle\,H\,\rangle , we

Read the complete text