JWST COMPASS: Insights into the Systematic Noise Properties of NIRSpec/G395H From a Uniform Reanalysis of Seven Transmission Spectra

Tyler A. Gordon, Natalie M. Batalha, Natasha E. Batalha, Artyom Aguichine, Anna Gagnebin, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Annabella Meech, Nicholas Scarsdale, Johanna Teske, Nicole L. Wallack, Nicholas Wogan · 2025

Read JWST COMPASS: Insights into the Systematic Noise Properties of NIRSpec/G395H From a Uniform Reanalysis of Seven Transmission Spectra by Tyler A. Gordon, Natalie M. Batalha, Natasha E. Batalha, Artyom Aguichine, Anna Gagnebin, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Annabella Meech, Nicholas Scarsdale, Johanna Teske, Nicole L. Wallack, Nicholas Wogan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18196.txt.

Introduction

Tyler A. Gordon and 11 co-authors rework seven planet transit data sets from the James Webb Space Telescope in one shared way. The COMPASS program studies small planets with the NIRSpec tool, which records how starlight changes as a planet crosses its star. Small signals and steady noise have made some of these results hard to read.

The team models the shape and drift of the light trace to clean the data. They find the fix helps most when each reading uses few groups, and that noise is worst in one mid range of light. Real errors run just a bit above the forecast tool. New limits on what the planet air may hold close the work.

Catalog record

CREATORTyler A. Gordon, Natalie M. Batalha, Natasha E. Batalha, Artyom Aguichine, Anna Gagnebin, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Annabella Meech, Nicholas Scarsdale, Johanna Teske, Nicole L. Wallack, Nicholas Wogan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE99 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18196

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

JWST COMPASS: Insights into the Systematic Noise Properties of NIRSpec/G395H From a Uniform Reanalysis of Seven Transmission Spectra Tyler A. Gordon, Natalie M. Batalha, Natasha E. Batalha, Artyom Aguichine, Anna Gagnebin, James Kirk, Mercedes López-Morales, Annabella Meech, Nicholas Scarsdale, Johanna Teske, Nicole L. Wallack, Nicholas Wogan Abstract JWST has already observed near-infrared transmission spectra of over a dozen super-Earths and sub-Neptunes. While some observations have allowed astronomers to characterize sub-Neptunes in unprecedented detail, small feature amplitudes and poorly-understood systematics have led to ambiguous results for others. Using the first seven targets from the COMPASS program, which is currently surveying 12 small planet atmospheres using NIRSpec/G395H, we investigate these timeseries systematics. We implement a model that uses the principle components of the normalized pixel fluxes to account for variations in the shape and position of the spectral trace. We find that observations with a smaller number of groups-per-integration benefit most profoundly from the use of this model, and that systematics are particularly strong between 2.8 and 3.5 μ \mu m. Despite these systematics, pandexo is a relatively accurate predictor of the precision of the spectra, with real error bars on average 5% larger in NRS1 and 12% larger in NRS2 than predicted. We compute new limits on metallicity and opaque pressure level for each target and compare these to previous results from the COMPASS program. Next, we co-add spectra from multiple targets to reduce the effective noise in the combined spectra in hopes of detecting transmission features in common between the targets, but this exercise does not yield compelling evidence any signals. We find that a handful of additional transits are sufficient to break the degeneracy between metallicity and aerosols for the majority of our targets, pointing towards the possibility of unraveling the mysteries of these worlds with future allocations of JWST time. I Introduction Sub-Neptunes and super-Earths, planets larger than the Earth but smaller than Neptune’s radius of 3.86 R_{\oplus} , are a numerous class of exoplanets that have no counterpart in the Solar System. Since the discovery of this population of small planets by the Kepler mission ( 19 ; 12 ) the origins and atmospheres of these planets have been a mystery. As super-Earths and sub-Neptunes represent potentially habitable environments ( 63 ; 49 ) and make enticing targets for biosignature searches ( 75 ; 86 ; 89 ; 54 ; 69 ) , understanding their histories and present-day environments is a key goal for exoplanet scientists. The masses and radii of super-Earths and sub-Neptunes permit a range of possible compositions ( 85 ; 32 ; 90 ) . The smallest members of this population, the super-Earths, are likely to have a predominantly rocky interior composition and may or may not possess atmospheres ( 35 ) . Throughout this work we use the term “super-Earth” to refer to planets below the radius gap ( 34 ) at about 1.8 R_{\oplus} , a region of the mass-radius parameter space with a low occurrence of planets which is thought to separate terrestrial worlds from the lower density sub-Neptunes. The radii of sub-Neptunes, defined in this work as any planets smaller than Neptune but above the radius gap, can be explained by several different classes of interior models including gas dwarfs (a rocky core underneath a thick, low mean molecular weight atmosphere, 47 ; 78 ), true mini-Neptunes (small rocky cores overlain by some combination of water ice, liquid water, and an H 2 -dominated atmosphere, 80 ), steam worlds (a rocky core underneath a high mean molecular weight steam/supercritical H 2 O atmosphere, 62 ; 2 ), or even Hycean worlds (a rocky core overlain by thick hydrosphere with liquid water at the surface and a thin H 2 -dominated atmosphere, 54 ; 55 ). While some studies have attempted to deduce the existence of distinct populations of these planet types by careful examination of their mass-radius distribution, these efforts have been hampered by degeneracies between different interior models and uncertainties in models of atmospheric loss ( 67 ; 79 ; 22 ) . The role of transmission spectroscopy in this landscape is to provide additional constraints to break the degeneracies in mass and radius that permit multiple possible compositions for any given planet. Furthermore, by allowing us to detect molecules and measure their abundances, transmission spectroscopy gives us clues to the origins and subsequent evolution of these worlds. While the NIRSpec instrument has displayed excellent performance and several JWST sub-Neptune observations have allowed for detailed atmospheric characterizations ( 17 ; 55 ; 84 , e.g.) , atmospheric signals for all but the nearest planets with clear, low-metallicity, large scale-height atmospheres still sit near the observed noise floor. This has resulted in a number of more ambiguous observations (e.g. 3 ; 24 , and the COMPASS papers listed in Table 1 ) . Compounding this challenge is the fact that JWST time-series observations frequently display red noise of uncertain origin on timescales of minutes to hours with amplitudes of tens to hundreds of parts-per-million in the white light curves ( 52 ; 92 ; 82 , e.g.,) , degrading the precision of transmission spectra to below what is predicted by tools like Pandeia ( 71 ) and Pandexo ( 13 ) (which uses Pandeia as the backend noise simulator). Studies of individual planets observed with NIRSpec have dealt with this noise in a variety of ways, for example by fitting the light curve with a systematics model that incorporates auxiliary timeseries such as the x and y-positions of the trace on the detector as measured during spectral extraction ( 81 ; 83 , e.g.) or various engineering parameters associated with the telescope ( 92 ; 42 , e.g.,) . While these techniques show promise, there is still a need to develop a more complete understanding of detector effects as well as a set of best-practices for mitigating red noise and reaching closer to the photon noise limit. A primary aim of this study is to progress towards that goal with respect to NIRSpec. In this work we leverage the uniformity of the COMPASS dataset of sub-Neptune and super-Earth transmission spectra to study the characteristics of the NIRSpec detectors and the noise properties of the light curves. All COMPASS targets were observed using NIRSpec/G395H in the Bright Object Time-Series mode with the SUB2048 subarray, F290LP filter, and S1600A1 slit in the NRSRAPID readout pattern. The number of transits for each target was chosen to achieve a transit SNR of 30 ppm at 4 \mu m when binned to a spectral resolution of R=100, according to pre-observation simulations using Pandexo . We carry out uniform reductions of all seven datasets using ExoTiC-JEDI ( 6 ) holding all reductions procedures and settings identical between all targets, followed by white and spectral light curve fitting using a custom fitting code. We describe both the reduction and the fitting procedure in Section II . When fitting the light curves we apply a newly-developed systematics model, which is introduced in Section II and described in more detail in Section III . Using this model, we proceed to analyze the instrumental systematics present in NIRSpec/G395H observations and discuss their impacts on transmission spectra. Following the analysis of

Read the complete text