Measuring fluxes between wave and geostrophic features in rotating non-hydrostatic flows with variable stratification
Jeffrey J. Early, Gerardo Hernández-Dueñas, Leslie M. Smith, Cimarron Wortham, M.-Pascale Lelong · 2025
Read Measuring fluxes between wave and geostrophic features in rotating non-hydrostatic flows with variable stratification by Jeffrey J. Early, Gerardo Hernández-Dueñas, Leslie M. Smith, Cimarron Wortham, M.-Pascale Lelong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18161.txt.
Introduction
Jeffrey Early and four co-authors present a framework for separating ocean flow into wave and balanced geostrophic parts and measuring the energy fluxes between them. That split is a long standing challenge when stratification varies and motions are non hydrostatic. Their separation rests on the principle that waves leave no signature in a certain potential vorticity quantity.
From new expressions for available energy they build a complete orthogonal basis of modes and rewrite the motion equations as coupled wave and geostrophic systems. In mid ocean simulations they find an inverse cascade for geostrophic energy, a forward cascade for waves, and a direct transfer from geostrophic flow to waves.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jeffrey J. Early, Gerardo Hernández-Dueñas, Leslie M. Smith, Cimarron Wortham, M.-Pascale Lelong |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 135 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18161
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Measuring fluxes between wave and geostrophic features in rotating non-hydrostatic flows with variable stratification Jeffrey J. Early, Gerardo Hernández-Dueñas, Leslie M. Smith, Cimarron Wortham, M.-Pascale Lelong Abstract A challenge in physical oceanography is quantifying the energy content of waves and balanced flows and the fluxes that connect these reservoirs with their sources and sinks. Methodological limitations have prevented decompositions for realistic flows with non-hydrostatic motions and variable stratification. We present a framework that separates the flow into wave and geostrophic components using the principle that waves have no Eulerian available potential vorticity signature. Starting from new expressions for available energy and potential vorticity conservation, we construct a basis of wave and geostrophic modes, complete and orthogonal with respect to quadratic approximations of the conserved quantities. Using the resulting non-hydrostatic projection operators, the nonlinear equations of motion are expressed as coupled wave and geostrophic equations, quantifying cascade and transfer fluxes of wave and geostrophic energy. We apply the method to non-hydrostatic mid-ocean simulations with geostrophic mean-flow, near-inertial, and tidal forcing. From these experiments, we construct source-sink-reservoir diagrams for exact and quadratic fluxes, quantifying the fluxes between geostrophic and wave components. Because the cascade fluxes obey total energy conservation, we construct energy flow diagrams within the wave and geostrophic reservoirs and diagnose nonlocal transfers. The simulations show a geostrophic inverse cascade, a forward wave cascade, and a direct transfer of geostrophic to wave energy, with no indication of a forward geostrophic cascade. The mean-flow-only simulation shows weak spontaneous wave emission during spin-up, which diminishes to zero. Finally, we evaluate the decomposition by comparing linearized and fully conserved available potential vorticity, finding that errors become significant at scales below 15 km. Key Points • A decomposition of wave and geostrophic total energy applicable to non-hydrostatic flows with arbitrary stratification • Application to realistic mid-ocean simulations with geostrophic-only and geostrophic-plus-wave forcing • Identification of inverse geostrophic cascade, forward wave cascade, and strong geostrophic-to-wave transfer 1 NorthWest Research Associates, Seattle, WA, USA 2 National Autonomous University of Mexico Campus Juriquilla, Querétaro, Mexico 3 Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, USA 4 Department of Mathematics, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, USA 1 Introduction Identifying energy pathways, from sources to sinks through the different reservoirs, remains one of the central challenges of oceanography. 63 constructed a ‘strawman energy budget’ from numerous observational sources with large uncertainties. In numerical models, on the other hand, producing a detailed energy budget hinges on (1) partitioning the flow into distinct constituents, i.e., the wave and balanced flow, and (2) precisely measuring their respective energies and associated energy fluxes. While it is relatively easy to compute total energies and total energy fluxes from numerical simulations, finding a decomposition for waves and vortex motions that is grounded in meaningful and measurable dynamics, e.g. a timescale separation, and that satisfies energy orthogonality between the flow constituents is far more challenging. Here, the term ‘vortex’ refers to the geostrophic or balanced part of the flow with dynamics linked to potential vorticity conservation. Not all linear flow decompositions satisfy energy orthogonality, yet this property is essential for uniquely interpreting energy transfers between reservoirs. Attempts at understanding and quantifying wave-vortex interactions have a long history and use a variety of methodologies. One approach is to use simplified geometry, typically either shallow-water or triply-periodic models. In both cases the linearized equations of motion admit both slow vortical modes and fast internal gravity wave modes proportional to Fourier modes ( 30 ; 42 ; 38 ) . The separation is dynamical in nature, based on potential vorticity inversion. This approach allows an energetically orthogonal decomposition where all modes have a unique signature of total energy ( 29 ; 4 ; 46 ; 47 ; 56 ; 57 ; 37 ; 22 ; 16 ; 21 ; 51 , e.g.) . An advantage of complete orthogonal decompositions is that interactions can be intentionally restricted to isolate important interactions ( 22 ; 15 ; 21 , e.g.) while the full nonlinear equations of motion remain unapproximated in general, thereby eliminating at least one source of uncertainty when interpreting results. The disadvantage of this approach is the constrained model geometry, which severely limits realism. Another approach is to use asymptotic models ( 59 ; 68 ; 65 ; 55 ; 39 ; 66 , e.g.) . This approach offers the advantage of isolating the physical process of interest, but the disadvantage of approximating the equations of motion and thus the conservation laws. A final approach is to use a primitive equation model with realistic boundary conditions, and construct a filter to decompose the output ( 19 ; 49 ; 3 ; 50 ; 2 ; 43 , e.g.) . The advantage is that no physics is lost in the model. The disadvantages are that these decompositions typically treat kinetic energy only, precluding analysis of inertial ranges, and rely on linear-theory scale separations to partition the flow. One of the most important properties of rotating stratified fluids is the existence of inertial cascades 27 ; 6 ; 41 . In quasigeostrophic flow, energy exhibits an inverse cascade, from small to large scales, while at the same time potential enstrophy cascades from large to small scales. To observe these dual cascades simultaneously requires a basis of eigenmodes that are orthogonal with respect to both energy and potential enstrophy. Wave energy, by contrast, cascades forward from large to small scales, e.g. 34 ; 70 ; 36 ; 62 . The concepts of completeness and orthogonality are critical for discussing spectra and fluxes between flow components. To demonstrate this, let the state of a geophysical fluid be given by (u,v,w,\eta,p) for fluid velocity (u,v,w) with vertical displacement \eta and pressure p . Any basis capable of representing all physically realizable states of the fluid is said to be complete . To lowest order, the total volume-integrated available energy of the rotating, non-hydrostatic Boussinesq fluid is \mathcal{E}\left[(u,v,w,\eta)\right]=\frac{1}{2}\int\left(u^{2}+v^{2}+w^{2}+N^{2}\eta^{2}\right)dV (1) where N^{2}(z) is the squared buoyancy frequency. If the fluid can be linearly decomposed into two distinct parts such that \left(u,v,w,\eta\right)=\left(u_{1}+u_{2},v_{1}+v_{2},w_{1}+w_{2},\eta_{1}+\eta_{2}\right) then \mathcal{E}\left[\left(u,v,w,\eta\right)\right]=\mathcal{E}\left[\left(u_{1},v_{1},w_{1},\eta_{1}\right)\right]+\mathcal{E}\left[\left(u_{2},v_{2},w_{2},\eta_{2}\right)\right]+\epsilon_{12} (2) where \epsilon_{12} is a quadratic cross-term. For a sparse-data decomposition, the hope is that the cross-term \epsilon_{12} is small, but for a full-knowledge decomposition it may be possible to find solutions where \epsilon_{12}=0 and the decomposition is energetically orthogonal . With energy orthogonality as a guiding principle, we can define a set of reservoirs as a partition of the full fluid state, each with distinct energy. Because potential enstrophy is also quadratic at lowest order, a wave–vortex decomposition must satisfy enstrophy orthogonality following rules analogous to ( 2 ). When a basis is both complete and energetically orthogonal then each basis member has a unique energy signature—a feature that allows one to uniquely interpret that energy is moving from somewhere to somewhere else. Moreover, the lack of cross-terms also allows us to write energy spectra for separate flow components because the total energy is the sum of the squares of the amplitudes of the basis functions. This is exactly analogous to a Fourier series which partitions the total variance of a periodic function in terms of orthogonal Fourier modes. Importantly, energy orthogonality is not just a choice, but a requirement