Quantum and classical analyses of intertwined phase transitions in odd-mass Nb isotopes
\firstname A. \lastname Leviatan \fnsep · 2025
Read Quantum and classical analyses of intertwined phase transitions in odd-mass Nb isotopes by \firstname A. \lastname Leviatan \fnsep (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-18095.txt.
Introduction
A. Leviatan analyzes intertwined quantum phase transitions in odd mass niobium isotopes, where an atomic nucleus changes shape as protons or neutrons are added. The study uses an interacting boson fermion model with configuration mixing, which treats the odd particle coupled to a core of paired nucleons.
The quantum analysis finds two transitions superimposed: a gradual shape evolution inside one configuration and an abrupt crossing between normal and intruder configurations. A classical analysis then shows what that means for the odd particle's motion in the deformed field of the neighboring even zirconium cores. Together the views clarify how competing structures reshape these nuclei.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | \firstname A. \lastname Leviatan \fnsep |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-18095
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum and classical analyses of intertwined phase transitions in odd-mass Nb isotopes \firstname A. \lastname Leviatan \fnsep Abstract Quantum phase transitions (QPTs) in odd-mass Nb isotopes are investigated in the framework of the interacting boson-fermion model with configuration mixing. A quantum analysis reveals a Type I QPT (gradual shape-evolution within the intruder configuration) superimposed on a Type II QPT (abrupt crossing of normal and intruder states), thus demonstrating the occurrence of intertwined QPTs. A classical analysis highlights the implications for the single particle motion in the deformed field generated by the even-even Zr cores. 1 Introduction Quantum phase transitions (QPTs) are qualititative changes in the properties of a physical system induced by variation of parameters in the Hamiltonian. Such structural changes are manifested empirically in nuclei as transistions between shapes and can be categorized into two types. The first, denoted as Type I Diep80 , is a shape-phase transition within a single configuration, as encountered in the neutron number 90 region Cejnar2010 . The second, denoted as Type II Frank2006 , is a phase transition involving a crossing of different configurations, as encountered in nuclei near (sub-) shell closure Heyde11 . In most cases, the strong mixing between the configurations obscures the individual QPTs. However, if the mixing is small, the Type II QPT can be accompanied by a distinguished Type I QPT within each configuration separately. Such a scenario, referred to as intertwined QPTs, occurs in the even-even Zr (Z=40) isotopes Gavrielov2019 ; Gavrielov2020 ; Gavrielov2022 . In the present contribution, we discuss both quantum and classical analyses of a similar scenario in the adjacent odd-even Nb (Z=41) isotopes gavleviac22 ; Gav23 ; LevGav25 . 2 IBFM for multiple configurations Odd-A nuclei are treated in the interacting boson-fermion model (IBFM) IBFMBook , as a system of monopole ( s ) and quadruple ( d ) bosons, representing valence nucleon pairs, and a single (unpaired) nucleon. The (single-configuration) IBFM Hamiltonian has the form \displaystyle\hat{H}(\xi)=\hat{H}_{\rm b}+\hat{H}_{\rm f}+\hat{V}_{\rm bf}~. (1) We focus the discussion to an odd fermion in a single- j orbit for which, \displaystyle\hskip-28.45274pt\hat{H}_{\rm b}(\epsilon_{d},\kappa,\chi)=\epsilon_{d}\,\hat{n}_{d}+\kappa\,\hat{Q}_{\chi}\cdot\hat{Q}_{\chi} (2a) \displaystyle\hskip-28.45274pt\hat{H}_{\rm f}(\epsilon_{j})=\epsilon_{j}\,\hat{n}_{j} (2b) \displaystyle\hskip-28.45274pt\hat{V}_{\rm bf}(\chi,A,\Gamma,\Lambda)=A\,\hat{n}_{d}\,\hat{n}_{j}+\Gamma\,\hat{Q}_{\chi}\cdot(a_{j}^{{\dagger}}\,\tilde{a}_{j})^{(2)} \displaystyle+\Lambda\sqrt{2j+1}:[(d^{{\dagger}}\,\tilde{a}_{j})^{(j)}\times(\tilde{d}\,a_{j}^{{\dagger}})^{(j)}]^{(0)}: (2c) The boson part ( 2a ) contains pairing and quadrupole terms, where \hat{n}_{d}\!=\!\sum_{m}d^{{\dagger}}_{m}d_{m} , \hat{Q}_{\chi}\!=\!d^{\dagger}s+s^{\dagger}\tilde{d}+\ \chi\,(d^{\dagger}\tilde{d})^{(2)} and \tilde{d}_{m}\!=\!(-1)^{m}d_{-m} . The fermion part ( 2b ) involves the number operator, \hat{n}_{j} , and the boson-fermion part ( 2c ) is composed of monopole, quadrupole and exchange terms, where :\!-\!: denotes normal ordering and \tilde{a}_{j,m}\!=\!(-1)^{j-m}a_{j,-m} . A change in the parameters \xi=(\epsilon_{d},\kappa,\chi,\epsilon_{j},A,\Gamma,\Lambda ) of \hat{H}(\xi) induces Type I QPTs Petrellis2011a ; Petrellis2011b ; Boyukata2021 , relevant to odd-mass nuclei. The interacting boson-fermion model with configuration mixing (IBFM-CM) gavleviac22 ; Gav23 is an extension of the IBFM to include configurations with N,N\!+\!2,\dots bosons, representing shell model spaces built on 0p-0h, 2p-2h, \ldots particle-hole excitations across closed shells. For two configurations ( A,B ), the IBFM-CM Hamiltonian can be cast in matrix form, \displaystyle\hat{H}(\xi_{A},\xi_{B},\omega)=\begin{bmatrix}\hat{H}_{A}(\xi_{A})&\hat{W}(\omega)\\ \hat{W}(\omega)&\hat{H}_{B}(\xi_{B})\end{bmatrix}~. (3) Here \hat{H}_{A}(\xi_{A}) and \hat{H}_{B}(\xi_{B}) represent, respectively, the normal A configuration ( N boson space) and the intruder B configuration ( N+2 boson space), both coupled to a single j -fermion and \hat{W}(\omega) a mixing term. Specifically, \displaystyle\hskip-42.67912pt\hat{H}_{A}(\xi_{A})=\hat{H}_{\rm b}(\epsilon^{A}_{d},\kappa_{A},\chi)+\hat{H}_{\rm f}+\hat{V}_{\rm bf}~, (4a) \displaystyle\hskip-42.67912pt\hat{H}_{B}(\xi_{B})=\hat{H}_{\rm b}(\epsilon^{B}_{d},\kappa_{B},\chi)+\kappa^{\prime}_{B}\,\hat{L}\cdot\hat{L}+\Delta_{B}+\hat{H}_{\rm f}+\hat{V}_{\rm bf}~, (4b) \displaystyle\hskip-42.67912pt\hat{W}(\omega)=\omega\,[\,(d^{\dagger}d^{\dagger})^{(0)}+(s^{\dagger})^{2}\,+{\rm H.c.}]~. (4c) where \hat{L}\cdot\hat{L} is a rotational term, \Delta_{B} an energy off-set and H.c. stands for Hermitian conjugate. For simplicity, \hat{H}_{\rm f}(\epsilon_{j}) and \hat{V}_{\rm bf}(A,\Gamma,\lambda) are taken to be the same in both configurations. A change in the parameters (\xi_{A},\xi_{B},\omega) can induce a Type I QPT within each configuration and a Type II QPT of configuration crossing. For \hat{H}_{\rm f}=\hat{V}_{\rm bf}=0 , the IBFM-CM Hamiltonian of Eq. ( 3 ) reduces to that of the interacting boson model with configuration mixing (IBM-CM) Duval1981 ; Duval1982 , relevant to the study of configuration-mixed QPTs and shape-coexistence in even-even nuclei. Figure 1: Schematic representation of the two coexisting shell-model configurations ( A and B ) for {}^{99}_{41} Nb 58 . The corresponding numbers of proton bosons ( N_{\pi} ) and neutron bosons ( N_{\nu} ), are listed for each configuration and N=N_{\pi}+N_{\nu} . The eigenstates |\Psi;j,J\rangle of \hat{H} , Eq. ( 3 ), are linear combinations of wave functions \Psi_{\rm A} and \Psi_{\rm B} , involving bosonic basis states in the two spaces |[N],\alpha,L\rangle and |[N\!+\!2],\alpha,L\rangle , coupled to a j -fermion. The boson ( L ) and fermion ( j ) angular momenta are coupled to J , \displaystyle\hskip-28.45274pt|\Psi;j,J\rangle=a\,|\Psi_{A},[N],j;J\rangle+b\,|\Psi_{B},[N\!+\!2],j;J\rangle \displaystyle\hskip 5.69046pt=\sum_{\alpha,L}C^{(N,J)}_{\alpha,L,j}|N,\alpha,(L\otimes j)J\rangle \displaystyle\hskip 14.22636pt+\sum_{\alpha,L}C^{(N+2,J)}_{\alpha,L,j}|N+2,\alpha,(L\otimes j)J\rangle~. (5) The probability of normal-intruder mixing is given by, a^{2}=\sum_{\alpha,L}|C^{(N,J)}_{\alpha,L,j}|^{2}\;\;\;,\;\;\;b^{2}=\sum_{\alpha,L}|C^{(N+2,J)}_{\alpha,L,j}|^{2}=1-a^{2}~. (6) 3 Quantum analysis of the Nb chain Positive-parity states in {}^{A}_{41} Nb isotopes with mass number A\!=\!\text{93--105} are described in the shell model by coupling a proton in a \pi(1g_{9/2}) orbit to the respective 40 Zr cores with neutron number 52–64. In the latter, the normal A configuration corresponds to having no active protons above the Z\!=\!40 sub-shell gap, and the intruder B configuration corresponds to two-proton excitation from below to above this gap, creating 2p-2h states. The IBFM-CM model space employed, consists of a single j=9/2 fermion and [N]\oplus[N+2] boson spaces with N\!=\!1,2,\ldots,7 for 93-105 Nb. The two configurations relevant for 99 Nb are shown schematically in Fig. 1 . The parameters of the IBFM-CM Hamiltonian ( 4 ) and transition operators are determined from a fit in the manner described in gavleviac22 ; Gav23 ; LevGav25 . \begin{overpic}[fig2-energies-Nb.pdf] \end{overpic} Figure 2: Comparison between (a) experimental and (b) calculated lowest-energy positive-parity levels in Nb isotopes. Empty (filled) symbols indicate a state dominated by the normal A (intruder B) configuration. In particular, the 9/2^{+}_{1} state is in the A (B) configuration for neutron number 52–58 (60–64) and the 5/2^{+}_{1} state is in the A (B) configuration for 52–54 (56–64). Figure 3: Evolution of spectral properties along the Nb chain. Symbols (solid lines) denote experimental data (calculated results). (a) Percentage of the intruder (B) component [the b^{2} probability in Eq. ( 6 )], in the ground state ( J^{+}_{gs} ) and first-excited state ( 7/2^{+}_{1} ). Values of J^{+}_{gs} are indicated at the top. (b) B(E2;7/2^{+}_{1}\to J^{+}_{gs}) in W.u. (c) Quadrupole moments of J^{+}_{gs} in eb . (d) Magnetic moments of J^{+}_{gs} in \mu_{N} . For the data, see Fig. 2 of gavleviac22 . Figure 2 shows the experimental and calculated levels of selected states in the Nb isotopes along with assignments to configurations based on Eq. ( 6 ). Empty (filled) symbols indicate a dominantly normal (intruder) state with small (large) b^{2} probability. In the region between neutron number 50 and 56, there appear to be two sets of levels with weakly deformed structure, associated with configurations A and B. All levels decrease in energy for 52–54, away from closed shell, and rise again at 56 due to the neutron \nu(2d_{5/2}) subshell closure. From 58, there is a pronounced drop in energy for the states of the B configuration. At 60, the two configuration cross, indicating a Type II QPT, and the ground state changes from 9/2^{+}_{1} to 5/2^{+}_{1} , becoming the bandhead of a K=5/2^{+} rotational band composed of 5/2^{+}_{1},7/2^{+}_{1},9/2^{+}_{1},11/2^{+}_{1},13/2^{+}_{1} states. The intruder B configuration remains strongly deformed and the band structure persists beyond 60. The above trend is similar to that encountered in the even-even Zr isotopes with the same neutron