The Dark Side of Flexibility: How Aggregated Cyberattacks Threaten the Power Grid
Daniel Myrén, Zeeshan Afzal, Mikael Asplund · 2025
Read The Dark Side of Flexibility: How Aggregated Cyberattacks Threaten the Power Grid by Daniel Myrén, Zeeshan Afzal, Mikael Asplund (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17748.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Myrén, Zeeshan Afzal, and Mikael Asplund warn that flexible energy use in smart grids can be turned into a weapon. Aggregators control many batteries, chargers, and other flexible loads at once, so an attacker who seizes that control could shift large amounts of power suddenly.
The authors study attack plans that aim to break the grid's first swing of stability after a sudden change. They find that a lot of power is needed, yet current flexible capacity could in principle be enough to threaten a national grid. The work urges stronger guarding of aggregator systems.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Myrén, Zeeshan Afzal, Mikael Asplund |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 75 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17748
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Dark Side of Flexibility: How Aggregated Cyberattacks Threaten the Power Grid Daniel Myrén, Zeeshan Afzal, Mikael Asplund Abstract Flexible energy resources are increasingly becoming common in smart grids. These resources are typically managed and controlled by aggregators that coordinate many resources to provide flexibility services. However, these aggregators and flexible energy resources are vulnerable, which could allow attackers to remotely control flexible energy resources to launch large-scale attacks on the grid. This paper investigates and evaluates the potential attack strategies that can be used to manipulate flexible energy resources to challenge the effectiveness of traditional grid stability measures and disrupt the first-swing stability of the power grid. Our work shows that although a large amount of power is required, the current flexibility capacities could potentially be sufficient to disrupt the grid on a national level. 1 Introduction The electric grid must always maintain a balance between demand and supply [ 19 ] to ensure continuous and efficient power delivery. This balance is typically measured through the frequency of alternating current (AC) and is set at 50 Hz in the EU (also called nominal frequency). Figure 1 illustrates this task of maintaining balance. When power production and consumption are perfectly balanced, the grid frequency stays at its nominal value. If consumption exceeds production, the frequency decreases. If production exceeds consumption, the frequency increases. Consequently, the grid operators continuously monitor the frequency to detect and mitigate any imbalances. If the frequency deviations are not promptly managed and counteracted, there is a risk of significant disruptions such as blackouts and damage to critical infrastructures such as generators [ 5 ] . The growing prevalence of renewable energy sources (RESs) such as solar and wind in the power grid makes power generation more variable and unpredictable, creating a challenge to maintain the balance between supply and demand [ 17 ] . This increased variability creates a need for flexible energy resources (FERs) such as energy storage systems and heat pumps which are increasingly utilized by grid operators as a solution to maintain the stability of the grid. These resources can quickly adapt their energy consumption or inject more energy into the grid to restore balance when required, and are expected to grow significantly in numbers over the coming years [ 30 ] . Another significant challenge with a higher share of RESs and FERs is that most RESs do not inherently contribute to grid inertia. As a result, a grid with reduced inertia and higher variability in energy production becomes more sensitive and susceptible to fluctuations in demand and bidirectional energy flow, where certain FERs, such as batteries, can both consume power from the grid (charging) and supply energy back to it (discharging). Unfortunately, these factors introduce new risks and vulnerabilities to the power grid, increasing its exposure to both cyber and physical threats. Adversaries could manipulate FERs to increase their demand or inject energy into the grid, to execute large-scale distributed attacks with potentially catastrophic consequences [ 6 ] . Furthermore, the ability to remotely control these resources enables attackers to launch large scale attacks capable of impacting the stability of the power grid [ 19 ] . By targeting aggregators, attackers can potentially take control over and manage hundreds or thousands of distributed assets simultaneously. Figure 1 : Balance between supply and demand and its impact on frequency As the capacity, prevalence, and reliance on FERs continue to grow, they will likely draw increased attention from adversaries. It is therefore crucial to investigate the threats posed by adversaries who can control and manipulate multiple FERs within the power grid. In this work, we identify potential attack methods or strategies where adversaries can manipulate demand and bidirectional energy flow of aggregated FERs and assess the impact of these strategies on the grid frequency stability. Moreover, we evaluate the severity of these attacks in the context of both current and future capacities of FERs and analyze the effectiveness of existing frequency mitigation measures such as the Fast Frequency Reserve (FFR) and Frequency Containment Reserves (FCR) in countering such threats. By investigating potential attack strategies, their impact, and their severity, we aim to provide insights into how FERs can be manipulated to affect the frequency stability of the power grid. This knowledge is expected to inform the development of robust defensive strategies to protect the power grid against these emerging threats. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. Section 2 provides necessary background and an overview of the related work. It also highlights the gaps that we aim to fill. Section 3 defines aggregated attack strategies that adversaries could employ to destabilize the grid. Section 4 describes the simulation environment, grid model, and results from evaluating the impact of identified attacks on the stability of the grid. Section 5 provides a discussion on the results and outlines future research directions. Finally, section 6 provides conclusions. 2 Background & Related Work The frequency of the power grid directly influences the speed of generators and other rotating components connected to the power grid [ 5 ] . If the frequency falls below 49.5 Hz, it becomes necessary to start disconnecting specific loads to reduce demand. Should the frequency, despite these measures, fall below 47.5 Hz, large power stations are automatically disconnected, potentially cascading to total system collapse and widespread power blackouts. Conversely, an increase in frequency is also problematic and dangerous for the grid. If the frequency exceeds 52 Hz, the power stations are disconnected from the grid to prevent damaging vital components. Regardless of whether the frequency increases or decreases from the nominal frequency, exceeding these critical thresholds leads to the disconnection of loads and generators, potentially triggering a chain reaction that can ultimately cause the entire system to collapse. System-wide power blackouts would significantly disrupt and put enormous stress on society as critical infrastructure and essential services cease normal operations. This has been seen is several recent real-world incidents such as the cascading power outage in Puerto Rico, the major blackout in Spain and Portugal leaving millions without power for a half-day, and the attack against Ukraine’s power grid [ 34 ] . To maintain grid balance and correct any deviations in frequency, constant coordination is required among many actors, including power grid operators (TSOs and DSOs), energy producers, and consumers [ 5 ] . In the Nordic countries, the power grids are tightly interconnected with bilateral connections [ 33 ] . The frequency is managed by coordinating the production and consumption within the Nordic synchronous grid, with each country incorporating frequency reserve resources that provide up and down regulation to minimize frequency fluctuations. Fluctuations in the power grid frequency are traditionally mitigated by two primary mechanisms: inertia provided by the large rotating masses such as turbines and frequency reserve resources [ 5 ] . The rotational masses in turbines and generators directly connected to the grid act as an initial buffer against changes in demand and generation. If the frequency decreases, the synchronous generators rotate slower, releasing some of their rotational energy to the power grid. Conversely, if the frequency increases, the generators rotate faster, absorbing some of the excess energy in the grid as rotational energy. As RESs increasingly constitute