Neural posterior estimation of the line-of-sight and subhalo populations in galaxy-scale strong lensing systems

Birendra Dhanasingham, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Daniel Gilman · 2025

Read Neural posterior estimation of the line-of-sight and subhalo populations in galaxy-scale strong lensing systems by Birendra Dhanasingham, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Daniel Gilman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17732.txt.

Introduction

Birendra Dhanasingham, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, and Daniel Gilman explore whether neural methods can reveal dark matter clumps in strong gravitational lens images. Small halos along the line of sight and inside the main lens galaxy bend light in subtle ways that may differ between dark matter theories.

They train a neural estimator to infer lens and clump properties from images at once. Recovery of clump mass patterns proves hard, and two kinds of halo signals trade off against each other. The network also struggles with the pattern measures it targets, pointing to needs in training data and model form.

Catalog record

CREATORBirendra Dhanasingham, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Daniel Gilman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17732

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Neural posterior estimation of the line-of-sight and subhalo populations in galaxy-scale strong lensing systems Birendra Dhanasingham, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, Daniel Gilman Abstract Strong gravitational lensing is a powerful probe for studying the fundamental properties of dark matter on sub-galactic scales. Detailed analyses of galaxy-scale lenses have revealed localized gravitational perturbations beyond the smooth mass distribution of the main lens galaxy, largely attributed to dark matter subhalos and intervening line-of-sight halos. Recent studies suggest that, in contrast to subhalos, line-of-sight halos imprint distinct anisotropic features on the two-point correlation function of the effective lensing deflection field. These anisotropies are particularly sensitive to the collisional nature of dark matter, offering a potential means to test alternatives to the cold dark matter paradigm. In this study, we explore whether a neural density estimator can directly identify such anisotropic signatures from galaxy-galaxy strong lens images. We model the multipoles of the two-point function using a power-law parameterization and train a neural density estimator to predict the corresponding posterior distribution of lensing parameters, alongside parameter distributions for dark matter substructure. Our results show that recovering the dark matter substructure mass functions and mass-concentration parameters remains challenging, owing to difficulties in generating uniform training data set while using physically motivated priors. We also unveil an important degeneracy between the line-of-sight halo mass-function amplitude and the subhalo mass-function normalization. Furthermore, the network exhibits limited accuracy in predicting the two-point function multipole parameters, suggesting that both the training data and the adopted power-law fitting function may inadequately represent the true underlying structure of the anisotropic signal. Neural Inference of Lensing Substructure keywords gravitational lensing: strong – methods: data analysis – methods: statistical – dark matter 1 Introduction Dark matter plays a pivotal role in shaping the intricate structure we observe across the universe today. According to the standard Lambda Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM) model, the formation of dark matter structures follows a hierarchical, bottom-up process, with smaller halos forming first and merging to form larger structures with increasing mass and size. While smaller dark matter halos may lack the gravitational pull to retain gases and remain unseen, larger halos are known to host visible structures such as clusters, groups, and galaxies. Although the \Lambda CDM model has been highly successful in explaining the formation and evolution of structures on mass scales larger than \sim 10^{11}\,{M}_{\odot} and length scales larger than \sim 1 Mpc, questions persist regarding its efficacy in the non-linear regime, where small-scale halos play a significant role ( 22 ) . Various alternative dark matter models have emerged over time to address the shortcomings of the \Lambda CDM model in this regime. For instance, warm dark matter (WDM) models ( 18 ; 15 ; 33 ; 110 ; 136 ; 11 ; 101 ; 79 ) propose modifications to linear theory predictions within the \Lambda CDM framework, while self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) scenarios ( 123 ; 130 ; 129 ; 106 ; 98 ; 62 ; 63 ; 61 ; 64 ; 45 ; 23 ) alter nonlinear predictions within collisionless CDM models described by the Boltzmann equation. Consequently, the precise characterization of dark matter halos at sub-galactic scales offers a critical assessment of the \Lambda CDM paradigm. Strong gravitational lensing serves as a potent tool for constraining dark matter microphysics, particularly in this non-linear regime. In addition to the gravitational effects induced by the main lensing galaxy’s smooth mass distribution, the presence of dark matter substructures introduces subtle distortions in the observed images ( 17 ; 16 ; 48 ; 3 ; 21 ; 122 ; 92 ; 29 ; 73 ) . A meticulous examination of these distortions offers valuable insights into the underlying physics governing these substructures. Recent observations of galaxy-galaxy strong lensing have resulted in several reported detections of dark matter halos ( 132 ; 134 ; 135 ; 133 ; 91 ; 58 ; 90 ; 36 ; 124 ; 125 ; 100 ; 85 ) . These halos may either represent subhalos within the main lens ( 83 ; 26 ) or halos along the line of sight that coincidentally project near the lensed images ( 67 ; 145 ; 76 ; 37 ; 2 ) . Current research efforts aimed at constraining dark matter through strong lensing predominantly involve either modeling individual substructures within lens systems ( 132 ; 134 ; 135 ; 133 ; 58 ; 105 ; 86 ; 116 ; 117 ; 146 , see e.g.,) or considering the collective impact of substructure on lensing images to derive statistical constraints ( 145 ; 34 ; 41 ; 42 ; 8 ; 31 ; 52 ; 51 ; 54 ; 60 ; 66 ; 40 ; 38 ; 39 ; 9 ; 50 ; 65 , see e.g.,) . In recent years, machine learning has emerged as a valuable tool for analyzing strong lens images and effectively constraining dark matter substructure within strong lens systems using observational data. Numerous studies have demonstrated that trained neural networks can robustly constrain the parameters of strong lens models directly from observations ( 59 ; 97 ; 114 ; 139 ; 138 ; 47 ; 5 ; 6 , see e.g.,) . Additionally, within the strong lens community, there has been significant interest in automated modeling of strong gravitational lenses with neural networks ( 49 , see e.g.,) , as well as the development of machine learning-based tools to identify gravitational lenses from upcoming surveys ( 109 ; 25 ; 75 ; 143 ; 103 ; 107 ; 104 , see e.g.,) . Furthermore, while many studies have developed tools to successfully constrain the subhalo mass function using strong lens observations ( 20 ; 19 ; 93 ; 88 ; 137 , see e.g.,) , others have focused on detecting dark matter substructure in mock strong lens images ( 77 ; 43 ; 68 ; 127 , see e.g.,) . With the inventory of strong lenses available for study expected to expand significantly, with over a thousand identified lenses currently and tens of thousands anticipated through upcoming wide-field optical imaging surveys ( 80 ; 71 ; 118 ; 27 ; 141 ; 84 ) , machine learning-based approaches offer the advantage of statistical inference to better handle these large datasets and impose tight constraints on dark matter properties. In 137 , a simulation-based inference (SBI) pipeline was employed, utilizing a trained neural network to estimate the posterior density of the subhalo mass function and to place constraints on lens populations. However, they observed only a weak correlation between the actual and inferred normalization of the subhalo mass function. They concluded that by integrating their network with a hierarchical inference framework, it is possible to accurately infer the subhalo mass function across various configurations while efficiently scaling to populations with hundreds of lenses. Although these findings are encouraging, neural posterior estimators still have limitations in terms of their constraining power. In 138 , the primary methodological limitation of neural posterior estimation was identified as the size of the training dataset. 138 then utilized sequential neural posterior estimation to significantly enhance the quality of the training samples and thus improve the constraining power of the data. In their work, 39 introduced the

Read the complete text