Kepler-1624b Has No Significant Transit Timing Variations

Haedam Im, Morgan Saidel, Heather A. Knutson, Michael Greklek-McKeon, Shreyas Vissapragada, Karen A. Collins, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Kimberly Paragas, Richard P. Schwarz, Avi Shporer, Gregor Srdoc · 2025

Read Kepler-1624b Has No Significant Transit Timing Variations by Haedam Im, Morgan Saidel, Heather A. Knutson, Michael Greklek-McKeon, Shreyas Vissapragada, Karen A. Collins, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Kimberly Paragas, Richard P. Schwarz, Avi Shporer, Gregor Srdoc (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17709.txt.

Introduction

Haedam Im leads a team of twelve authors re-examining Kepler-1624b, a sub-Saturn planet orbiting a small red star. Earlier work found its transits arriving early or late by about two minutes, a wobble that hinted at a hidden companion planet. Such resonant pairs are rare and prized, since they constrain how planets form and drift. The team reworks the archived Kepler transits and stretches the record by eleven years.

New data from the TESS satellite and from telescopes at Palomar and Las Cumbres are fitted together with the old record. The wobble comes out far weaker than first reported, and a formal model comparison favours a single planet over two. The authors stress the care needed before claiming companions from small timing shifts in faint systems.

Catalog record

CREATORHaedam Im, Morgan Saidel, Heather A. Knutson, Michael Greklek-McKeon, Shreyas Vissapragada, Karen A. Collins, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Kimberly Paragas, Richard P. Schwarz, Avi Shporer, Gregor Srdoc
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17709

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Kepler-1624b Has No Significant Transit Timing Variations Haedam Im, Morgan Saidel, Heather A. Knutson, Michael Greklek-McKeon, Shreyas Vissapragada, Karen A. Collins, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Kimberly Paragas, Richard P. Schwarz, Avi Shporer, Gregor Srdoc Abstract It is relatively rare for gas giant planets to have resonant or near-resonant companions, but these systems are particularly useful for constraining planet formation and migration models. In this study, we examine Kepler-1624b, a sub-Saturn orbiting an M dwarf that was previously found to exhibit transit timing variations with an amplitude of approximately 2 minutes, suggesting the presence of a nearby non-transiting companion. We reanalyze the transits from archival Kepler data and extend the TTV baseline by 11 years by combining TESS data with three new ground-based transit observations from Palomar and Las Cumbres Observatories. We jointly fit these datasets and find that the TTV amplitude is significantly weaker in our updated analysis. We calculate the Bayes factor for a one-planet versus two-planet model and find that the one-planet model is preferred. Our results highlight the need for careful analysis of systems with relatively low amplitude TTV signals that are identified in large automated catalogs. I Introduction Transit and radial velocity surveys have revealed that M dwarfs frequently host compact systems of multiple small ( <3~R_{\oplus} ) planets [ 22 , 51 , 29 , 47 , e.g.,] , and that the occurrence rate of small planets around M stars is higher than for Sun-like stars [ 22 , 55 , 47 ] . Chachan and Lee [13] proposed that this can be explained by the higher pebble accretion efficiency in the inner disks of M dwarfs versus Sun-like stars. In contrast, the occurrence rate of gas giants around M dwarfs is substantially lower than that of Sun-like stars [ 7 , 48 , 10 , 54 , 47 ] . This is likely due to a combination of factors, including: (1) lower-mass stars tend to have less massive protoplanetary disks [ 4 ] and thus most have insufficient material to form large planetary cores [ 13 , 35 , 21 , e.g.,] , (2) the longer orbital timescales of M dwarfs slow down core formation [ 43 ] , and (3) M dwarf disks dissipate faster due to intense UV radiation [ 1 ] . These factors make it difficult for M dwarf systems to form the massive cores required for runaway gas accretion before the disk dissipates [ 11 , 34 ] . For stars of all masses, models of giant planet formation suggest that these planets are most easily formed at orbital separations greater than a few au [ 6 , 33 , 32 , 49 , 12 , e.g.,] . This means that most giant planets on close-in orbits likely migrated inward from a more distant formation location. However, we currently have very few observational constraints on migration mechanisms for gas giants orbiting M dwarfs. One way to obtain these constraints is to look for the presence of companions located near orbital resonances [ 30 , 70 , e.g.,] . The presence of these companions is a hallmark of disk migration, which makes it more likely for these small planets to be captured into orbital resonances with the gas giant [ 14 , 18 , 37 , e.g.,] . However, when we plot the sample of all confirmed planets with nearby companions within 2% of a first-order orbital resonance, the few gas giants ( R>4~R_{\oplus} ) in the sample all orbit G and K stars (Figure 1 ). Figure 1: Orbital period versus planet radius for all planet pairs with period ratios within 2% of a first-order resonance. The colors of the points indicate the effective temperature of the host star, and each planet pair is connected by a solid black line. The location of Kepler-1624b in this space is marked by a star. This plot was generated using data from the NASA Exoplanet Archive [ 3 ] . It is possible that these companions exist, but have not yet been identified in the literature. Transit timing variations (TTVs)—deviations from the periodic transit times expected for a planet on a Keplerian orbit—provide a convenient method to search for these companions using existing survey data [ 70 , e.g.,] . TTVs result from dynamical interactions between planets and are particularly pronounced for planet pairs near first-order mean motion resonances [ 20 , 2 ] . Holczer et al. [28] compiled a catalog based on the Kepler survey that identified systems with statistically significant TTVs. 15 of the systems identified in this catalog had M dwarf hosts ( T_{\text{eff}}<3900\text{ K} ), but only one (Kepler-1624, also known as KOI-4928) contained a transiting gas giant planet ( R_{p}>4~R_{\oplus} ) with TTVs. Holczer et al. [28] reported a relatively small TTV amplitude of 2.120\pm 0.680 minutes for Kepler-1624b, and Gajdoš et al. [26] also reported a similar amplitude of 1.9\pm 0.2 minutes. However, a more recent reanalysis of this system by Kaye and Aigrain [36] incorporating new TESS observations did not find evidence for statistically significant TTVs in this system. In this paper, we investigate the TTVs of Kepler-1624b [ 50 ] , a Neptune-sized exoplanet ( R_{\text{p}}=6.59_{-0.17}^{+0.17}~R_{\oplus} , P=3.2903045\pm 4.6\times 10^{-6} days) orbiting an M dwarf star. 1 1 1 We quote transit shape and ephemeris parameters from [ 50 ] but recalculate R_{\text{p}} using stellar parameters rederived in this work. We reanalyze all available Kepler and TESS data along with three new high-precision observations, each obtained by the Wide-field InfraRed Camera (WIRC) on the 200 inch Hale Telescope at Palomar Observatory, the SINISTRO camera on the 1 m telescope at McDonald Observatory, and MuSCAT3 on the 2 m Faulkes Telescope North (FTN), respectively. In § II , we describe the details of each observation and our fits to obtain transit midtimes. In § III , we detail the dynamical model used to interpret our TTVs. In § IV , we present the results of our analysis and assess the statistical significance of the TTV signal. Lastly, in § V , we discuss the broader implications of this study. Figure 2: Kepler light curve before detrending (left) and after detrending (right). The red line shows the Gaussian kernel convolution trend described in § II.2 . Blue points indicate masked data ( \pm 0.8 transit durations around each transit midtime). Figure 3: Transit light curves for Kepler-1624b from multiple instruments. (a) Kepler, (b) Palomar/WIRC, (c) TESS, (d) LCOGT/SINISTRO i band, and (e) LCOGT/MuSCAT3 multiband. For Kepler, the light curves of individual transits are phased up using the individual best-fit transit times. For TESS, we phase individual transits using transit times from the best-fit one-planet model. For (a), the gray points show unbinned phased data, where each point corresponds to a 30-minute integration. For (b), unbinned photometry is shown as gray circles, and 10-minute binned photometry is shown as black circles. For (c), we use 10-minute bins for the black points and 2-minute bins for the gray points. For (d), we show the unbinned data as gray points. For (a)–(d), the best-fit transit light curves are overplotted in red, with the 1 \sigma confidence range overplotted as light red shading. For (e), transits in g ,

Read the complete text