The Strict 2-Category Structure of Distorted Monoidal Categories
Joaquim Reizi Higuchi · 2025
Read The Strict 2-Category Structure of Distorted Monoidal Categories by Joaquim Reizi Higuchi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17544.txt.
Introduction
Joaquim Reizi Higuchi widens a tool of category theory. A monoidal category pairs objects with a tensor product. Braided versions add a swap move between factors, and the swap is always assumed to undo itself. Higuchi's distorted monoidal categories drop that rule: the moves between tensor products need not undo themselves, and they can depend on direction, yet coherent reasoning about tensors still works.
These structures suit processes that cannot be reversed and that care about resources and direction, which standard braidings cannot model. Higuchi shows the structures form a strict two-category, where the laws for composing and swapping hold exactly, not just up to a matching map. He gives a constructive, type-safe calculus for swaps, with recipes like idempotent twists of standard braidings and graded unit distortions. Uses may include directed homotopy theory, categorical quantum mechanics, and non-symmetric operads, with checking kept within reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joaquim Reizi Higuchi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17544
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Strict 2-Category Structure of Distorted Monoidal Categories Joaquim Reizi Higuchi Abstract We develop a typed, constructive framework for distorted monoidal categories —monoidal categories equipped with a unit distortion Λ : Id ⇒ Id \Lambda:\mathrm{Id}\Rightarrow\mathrm{Id} and a binatural distortion σ X , Y : X ⊗ Y → Y ⊗ X \sigma_{X,Y}:X\otimes Y\to Y\otimes X satisfying hexagon–style axioms without assuming invertibility. With σ \sigma -lax monoidal functors required to satisfy strict compatibilities with Λ \Lambda and σ \sigma , and monoidal natural transformations as 2-cells, these structures assemble into a strict 2-category. Strictness holds on the nose : for composable F , G , H F,G,H , μ X , Y H ( G F ) = μ X , Y ( H G ) F and μ 0 H ( G F ) = μ 0 ( H G ) F , \mu^{H(GF)}_{X,Y}=\mu^{(HG)F}_{X,Y}\quad\text{and}\quad\mu^{H(GF)}_{0}=\mu^{(HG)F}_{0}, and the interchange law for 2-morphisms is an equality. Conceptually, we identify a 2-monad presentation whose strict algebras, strict morphisms, and 2-cells instantiate the foregoing data; our contribution is the explicit, type-safe calculus that realizes these general facts at the level of concrete diagrammatic proofs. We give robust existence schemes for non-invertible distortions via normalized idempotent twists of a braiding and for nontrivial unit distortions via graded characters, and we exhibit a sharp test case showing that monoidality of Λ \Lambda is independent of the other axioms. The resulting calculus generalizes braided monoidal categories ( Λ = Id \Lambda=\mathrm{Id} , σ \sigma invertible) and supports irreversible or resource-sensitive tensorial reasoning, with immediate applicability to directed homotopy, categorical quantum processes with measurement, and non-symmetric operadic situations. The constructions and proofs are designed for formal verification. 1 Introduction Monoidal categories form the common language for tensorial phenomena across algebra, topology, quantum theory, and computer science. The symmetric case, where a symmetry \sigma:X\otimes Y\xrightarrow{\cong}Y\otimes X is invertible, is classical [ 1 , 3 ] . Many natural systems, however, are intrinsically directed : they admit canonical ways to reorder tensor factors that need not be reversible, while still supporting coherent tensor calculus. Typical sources include concurrency and directed homotopy [ 6 ] , irreversible processes in categorical quantum mechanics, and algebraic situations where filtrations or truncations introduce loss of information. From braidings to distortions. We propose a flexible but type - safe abstraction we call a distorted monoidal category : a monoidal category (\mathcal{C},\otimes,\mathbf{I},\alpha,\lambda,\rho) equipped with a binary distortion \sigma_{X,Y}:X\otimes Y\to Y\otimes X obeying typed hexagon axioms and a unit distortion \Lambda:\mathrm{Id}_{\mathcal{C}}\Rightarrow\mathrm{Id}_{\mathcal{C}} obeying monoidality and unit normalizations (Definition 2.1 ). Unlike braidings, \sigma is not assumed invertible, and \Lambda may be nontrivial. This relaxes symmetry just enough to capture irreversible interchange while preserving a workable coherence calculus. 1.1 Conceptual position and novelty Our main structural result (Theorem 4.1 ) places distorted monoidal categories within the standard 2 - categorical paradigm. Let \mathsf{S} be the 2 - monad on \mathbf{Cat} whose strict algebras are strict monoidal categories and whose pseudoalgebras are (weak) monoidal categories [ 5 ] . By freely adjoining to a \mathsf{S} –algebra the additional data (\sigma,\Lambda) satisfying the typed axioms (D1)–(D4), one obtains a 2 - monad \mathsf{T}_{\sigma} . Distorted monoidal categories, \sigma –lax monoidal functors satisfying strict compatibilities (S \Lambda ), (S \sigma ), and monoidal natural transformations are precisely the \mathsf{T}_{\sigma} –pseudoalgebras, lax \mathsf{T}_{\sigma} –morphisms, and \mathsf{T}_{\sigma} –transformations . In particular, they assemble into a strict 2 - category because composition of lax \mathsf{T}_{\sigma} –morphisms is defined on the nose for 2 - monads of algebraic type. The novelty of this paper is therefore not the abstract existence of a 2 - category, which follows from general 2 - monad theory, but the typed, constructive calculus that realizes it concretely for non - invertible interchange: 1. an explicit axiomatics that prevents domain/codomain mismatches; 2. explicit composite laxators whose associativity and unitality hold as equalities ; 3. robust existence patterns for non - invertible distortions and nontrivial unit distortions (idempotent twists and graded characters), all checked constructively against (D1)–(D4). These ingredients make the framework ready for mechanization and for applications where reversibility genuinely fails. 1.2 Main results 1. Strict 2 - categorical structure (Theorem 4.1 ). Objects are distorted monoidal categories, 1 - morphisms are \sigma –lax monoidal functors satisfying (S \Lambda ) and (S \sigma ), and 2 - morphisms are monoidal natural transformations. Composition of 1 - morphisms uses \mu^{GF}_{X,Y}:=G(\mu^{F}_{X,Y})\circ\mu^{G}_{FX,FY},\qquad\mu^{GF}_{0}:=G(\mu^{F}_{0})\circ\mu^{G}_{0}, and satisfies \mu^{H(GF)}_{X,Y}=\mu^{(HG)F}_{X,Y},\qquad\mu^{H(GF)}_{0}=\mu^{(HG)F}_{0} as literal equalities. Vertical and horizontal compositions of 2 - cells and the interchange law hold strictly. 2. Typed hexagons and oriented Yang–Baxter. The hexagon axioms (D3) are stated with explicit sources and targets. In the strict monoidal case they specialize to oriented Yang–Baxter relations, appropriate for non - invertible \sigma . 3. Existence schemes for non - invertible \sigma (Proposition 5.2 , Example 5.3 ). Given a braided category (\mathcal{C},\beta) and a binatural, normalized, multiplicative idempotent family e_{X,Y} , the composite \sigma:=\beta\circ e satisfies (D1)–(D3) while typically failing to be invertible. This yields coherent, lossy interchanges built from classical braidings. 4. Nontrivial unit distortions \Lambda in graded settings (Example 5.4 ). For a monoidal grading by a commutative monoid M and any character \chi:M\to(k^{\times},\cdot) extended by 0 , the assignment \Lambda_{V}|_{V_{m}}=\chi(m)\cdot\mathrm{Id} is natural, unital, and monoidal (D4). This clarifies when nontrivial \Lambda exist and explains their absence in ungraded \mathbf{Vect}_{k} and \mathbf{Set} . 5. Correctness of examples and necessity of axioms (Example 5.5 ). We give fully verified examples and a sharp counterexample showing that (D4) is independent of (D1)–(D3). 1.3 Techniques and verification strategy We adopt a proof discipline that scales to formalization: 1. all equalities are typed; 2. binaturality of \sigma and the laxators is used via explicit naturality lemmas; 3. composite structures are verified by factorizing through the associativity/unit axioms of F and G and reassembling via naturality; and 4. when constructing non - invertible \sigma , we isolate the idempotent data responsible for loss and impose a 2 - cocycle law ensuring the hexagons. 1.4 Relationship to existing work When \sigma is invertible and \Lambda=\mathrm{Id} , we recover braided monoidal categories [ 3 ] . Our distortions are related to, but distinct from, pre - braidings, skew - monoidal categories, and lax centers: the present axioms require no invertibility, treat unit distortions explicitly, and enforce typed hexagons. On the structural side, our 2 - categorical viewpoint matches the general fact that pseudoalgebras and lax morphisms for a 2 - monad form a strict 2 - category [ 5 ] ; we instantiate this concretely for \mathsf{T}_{\sigma} and provide verified existence schemes for non - invertible interchanges. The broader bicategorical picture, including oplax morphisms and double - categorical envelopes, connects to [ 4 , 7 ] and is developed further in Section 6 . 1.5 Organization Section 2 fixes notation and states the axioms. Section 3 proves the naturality and composition lemmas used repeatedly. Section 4 establishes the strict 2 - category structure, including on - the - nose associativity/unitality for composite laxators and the interchange law. Section 5 provides verified constructions of non - invertible \sigma and nontrivial \Lambda , and a counterexample showing the independence of (D4). Finally, Section 6 presents the 2 - monad semantics in