Laminar and Turbulent Flow in Wavy Pipes under Strong Wall Modulations
I. El Mellas \aff 1, J. J. Hidalgo \aff 1 and M. Dentz \aff 1 · 2025
Read Laminar and Turbulent Flow in Wavy Pipes under Strong Wall Modulations by I. El Mellas \aff 1, J. J. Hidalgo \aff 1 and M. Dentz \aff 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17458.txt.
Introduction
Ismail El Mellas, Juan J. Hidalgo, and Marco Dentz simulate fluid flow through pipes whose walls wave in a sinusoidal pattern, from smooth laminar flow up to turbulence. Direct numerical simulations span bulk Reynolds numbers from one to over five thousand. The waviness changes the physics early: at quite low speeds, flow can reverse in the troughs. Recirculation zones form and sharply raise friction, an effect classical formulas based on bulk geometry fail to capture.
The authors define an effective hydraulic radius that does capture it. Wall modulation also triggers turbulence far below the classical threshold for smooth pipes, with a critical Reynolds number that falls as the wall amplitude grows, following a power law. In the turbulent regime the flow behaves as fully rough, and the wall amplitude, read through the hydraulic radius, estimates the equivalent sand roughness. The Moody chart, they conclude, cannot describe such pipes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | I. El Mellas \aff 1, J. J. Hidalgo \aff 1 and M. Dentz \aff 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17458
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Laminar and Turbulent Flow in Wavy Pipes under Strong Wall Modulations I. El Mellas \aff 1, J. J. Hidalgo \aff 1 and M. Dentz \aff 1 Abstract We investigate laminar and turbulent flow in pipes with periodically varying cross-sections, using direct numerical simulations over a range of Reynolds numbers between 1 − 5300 1-5300 . Pipe diameters are sinusoidally modulated in the axial direction, resulting in constrictions that reduce the local pipe radius by up to 40 percent. Such pronounced geometric roughness is encountered across disciplines, but is particularly relevant to karst systems, where dissolution-driven wall deformation leads to strong cross-sectional variability. Unlike classical roughness studies that assume small, homogeneous wall perturbations, the present configuration introduces large-scale axial variations that significantly affect flow structure, separation behaviour, and pressure drop even in the laminar regime. Once a critical roughness is exceeded, flow reversal appears at Reynolds numbers smaller than 25 25 , inducing local recirculation zones and significantly increasing friction. These effects are not captured by classical models based solely on bulk geometric parameters, but require the definition of an effective hydraulic radius. Furthermore, the strong wall-induced mixing promotes an early transitions to turbulence in a Reynolds range between 500 and 1000, well below the classical threshold for smooth pipes. At higher roughness, the influence of Reynolds number becomes increasingly hidden by geometric effects, as the flow is dominated by inertial separation and wall-induced disturbances. The peak-to-peak amplitude provides a robust estimator for the equivalent sandgrain roughness. These findings emphasise the limitations of traditional friction laws in geometrically complex conduits and point to the need for new models that account for the interplay between large-scale roughness and inertial effects. \lefttitle I. El Mellas, J. J. Hidalgo and M. Dentz \righttitle Journal of Fluid Mechanics \corresau Marco Dentz, , Ismail El Mellas, keywords Pipe flow, turbulence, rough walls 1 Introduction Most real conduits are neither straight nor smooth. Corrugated pipes, stented arteries, ventilation ducts and fractured rocks all show variations in cross-section, curvature and surface texture that alter flow resistance and mixing. Karst caves represent an extreme natural example: dissolution of limestone produces channels with irregular shapes and rough walls ( Curl 1966 ; Dreybrodt 2012 ; Claudin et al. 2017 ) . These geometric variations control head loss, solute transport and residence time, yet hydrological models still rely on empirical formulas derived for smooth pipes, such as the Hagen-Poiseuille law or the Darcy-Weisbach equation ( Cohen & Kundu 2004 ) . When roughness is considered, it is typically introduced through a relative roughness correction using the Moody diagram ( Moody 1944 ) , which assumes a uniform distribution of small-scale texture superimposed on an otherwise circular cross-section. This approach becomes increasingly unreliable when the roughness is large enough to alter the cross-sectional area itself, as is often the case in natural conduits. In such conditions, roughness is no longer just a wall property but a defining part of the overall geometry, and the underlying flow physics cannot be captured by standard friction factor correlations. To isolate the influence of wall geometry, many studies use simplified rough-walled pipes. Such configurations allow systematic changes in roughness height, wavelength or curvature, providing a bridge between smooth, idealised models and the multiscale geometry of natural conduits. Many studies have aimed to define an equivalent sand-grain roughness height ( k_{s} ) to represent the effect of different surface roughness geometries. The equivalent sand-grain roughness height, k_{s} , introduced by Nikuradse 1933 and Schlichting 1936 , remains the principal reference for quantifying wall friction. The non-dimensional roughness height is typically expressed in viscous units as k_{s}^{+}=k_{s}u_{\tau}/\nu , where \nu/u_{\tau} is the viscous length scale, \nu is the kinematic viscosity, and u_{\tau} defined below. Following Flack & Schultz 2014 , flow is hydrodynamically smooth when k_{s}^{+}\lesssim 5 , transitionally rough for 5\lesssim k_{s}^{+}\lesssim 70 and fully rough when k_{s}^{+}\gtrsim 70 . Roughness increases wall friction compared with smooth walls, but the mechanisms differ across these regimes: viscous damping dominates in the smooth regime, geometry controls drag in the transitional regime, and pressure drag governs friction in the fully rough regime, making it nearly independent of Reynolds number. Compared to smooth surfaces, wall roughness enhances friction, which results in a reduced inner-scaled mean velocity profile. This reduction, referred to as the roughness function proposed by Clauser 1954 and Hama 1954 , is typically expressed as: \Delta U^{+}=\frac{1}{\kappa}\log k_{s}^{+}+A-B(k_{s}^{+}), (1) where \kappa\approx 0.4 is the von Kármán constant, and A\approx 5 is the smooth-wall additive constant, and B depends on the roughness geometry and k_{s}^{+} ( Jimenez 2004 ) . As k_{s}^{+} increases, the flow moves from the smooth to the transitional regime. When \Delta U^{+}>7 , the flow is usually considered fully rough, and B becomes independent of Reynolds number. In wall-bounded turbulent flows, the velocity profile is typically separated into two regions: the inner layer, which is directly influenced by the wall and viscous effects, and the outer layer, where the dominant motions are larger in scale and relatively unaffected by the fine-scale details of the wall. The inner layer includes the viscous sublayer, the buffer region, and the lower logarithmic layer, and its structure is strongly modified by roughness elements, particularly when their height in wall units, k_{s}^{+} , becomes significant. In contrast, the outer layer is assumed to become increasingly independent of wall characteristics as the Reynolds number increases. This is the basis of Townsend’s outer-layer similarity hypothesis ( Townsend 1976 ) , which states that when there is sufficient scale separation (i.e., k_{s}/\delta\ll 1 , where \delta is the outer length scale of the flow, such as the pipe radius), roughness effects remain confined to the near-wall region. Under these conditions, the outer-layer turbulence retains a universal structure, and the effect of roughness manifests primarily as a downward shift in the mean velocity profile, quantified by an additive constant \Delta U^{+} , in the logarithmic law. However, this assumption may break down when the roughness becomes comparable to the boundary layer thickness or induces large-scale secondary flows that extend into the outer region ( Jimenez 2004 ) . Townsend’s hypothesis has been shown to approximately hold across a variety of canonical roughness types, such as sand-grain roughness, cylindrical elements, and spherical particles ( Flack et al. 2005 ; Chan et al. 2015 ; Busse et al. 2015 ; Busse et al. 2017 ) . These studies, both experimental and numerical, represent roughness as small-scale geometric perturbations superimposed on otherwise smooth and straight channels or pipes, using idealised elements like hemispheres, ribs, or random sand-grain topographies ( Jimenez 2004 ; Busse et al. 2015 ; Thakkar et al. 2016 ) . These studies model roughness as small-scale perturbations superimposed on an otherwise straight conduit, idealised elements such as hemispheres, ribs, or sand-grain like particles. More recent investigations have extended these works to irregular and stochastic roughness in both plane channels and pipes, exploring how roughness amplitude, spacing, and spatial arrangement modulate near-wall turbulence and affect the mean flow ( Thakkar et al. 2018 ; De Maio et al. 2023 ) . Parallel efforts have aimed to establish direct correlations between the equivalent sand-grain roughness height k_{s} and the underlying geometric characteristics of the roughness elements (