The Iberian Blackout: A Black Swan or a Gray Rhino ? † A Thorough Power System Analysis
Abdallah Alalem Albustami, Ahmad F. Taha* · 2025
Read The Iberian Blackout: A Black Swan or a Gray Rhino ? † A Thorough Power System Analysis by Abdallah Alalem Albustami, Ahmad F. Taha* (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17433.txt.
Introduction
Abdallah Alalem Albustami and Ahmad F Taha revisit the Iberian blackout of April 28, 2025. When the mainland grid in Spain and Portugal fell after a fast voltage rise, mass generator trips, and loss of synchrony. An expert panel blamed many linked factors, from weak voltage control and slow response gear to protection settings that did not match needs and poor sight of the wider grid.
Rather than retell the collapse, the authors build a security check around its lesson. Given the grid's present state, they ask whether the next likely trip, ramp, or switching act could push guarded voltages past relay limits before controls can answer. Their method folds protection limits into a dynamic voltage check, aiming to warn operators while there is still time to act.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abdallah Alalem Albustami, Ahmad F. Taha* |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17433
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Iberian Blackout: A Black Swan or a Gray Rhino ? † A Thorough Power System Analysis Thanks: † A Black Swan is a rare, hard-to-predict event with outsized impact that seems obvious only in hindsight. In contrast, a Gray Rhino is a highly probable, high-impact threat that is visible and approaching, yet neglected until it happens. Abdallah Alalem Albustami, Ahmad F. Taha* Abstract On April 28, 2025, the Iberian power system suffered a full blackout. It was the first documented overvoltage-driven cascade in Europe. The event sparked debate about root causes, including high renewables output, low inertia, and operator actions. This paper presents a thorough power system analysis of the incident to sort signal from noise and explain, step by step, how the blackout unfolded. Specifically, we (i) reconstruct the timeline and causal chain of the incident, (ii) present and summarize contributing factors using factual findings from incident reports, (iii) reproduce the blackout on an IEEE test system, (iv) analyze the incident from a system-theoretic, voltage-control perspective, and (v) translate our analysis into practical, technical measures that aim to mitigate and prevent similar incidents. I Introduction and Paper Contributions O n April 28, 2025, at 12:33:27 CEST, the Iberian mainland power system experienced a complete blackout, disconnecting Spain, Portugal, and a small region of France near the Spanish border. The cascade from initial overvoltage-induced generation trips to system-wide collapse occurred within approximately 30 seconds. This blackout differs fundamentally from historical patterns. Major grid failures typically originate from either extreme natural events or from transmission system overload followed by undervoltage or underfrequency cascades. It represents the first documented case in Continental Europe where cascading generation disconnections occurred due to sustained overvoltage conditions at collector substations that remained unobservable to transmission operators, a failure mode unprecedented in the synchronous area. The incident prompted considerable discussion and debate regarding root causes, with analyses variously emphasizing high renewable generation, system inertia, voltage control inadequacies, and operational decisions made to address morning oscillations. Rather than advocate for a single causal narrative, this work seeks to present a thorough, system-theoretic understanding of the different blackout causes. Paper Audience, Contributions, and Organization . The only required background needed for the readability of this paper are basic power system analysis and some rudimentary control systems language. The paper contributions are as follows. • While many incident reports describe the incident’s chronology in detail, this work adds a complementary perspective by analyzing how the documented factors interacted to produce the cascade by identifying the enabling mechanisms and their dynamic coupling via a differential-algebraic power system model. • The cascade is replicated on the IEEE 39-bus system to enable diagnostics and a better system-level understanding of how the blackout unfolded. All simulation codes are publicly available [ 1 ] . • The cascade is analyzed through the differential-algebraic structure governing transmission systems to reveal how topology changes and inadequate reactive response degraded voltage control on the timescales relevant for protection coordination. • Three practical measures are proposed—finite-horizon voltage control assessment, stability-aware meshing guidance, and voltage-aware emergency coordination. These could potentially mitigate similar over-voltage cascades. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section II reconstructs the Iberian blackout chronology. Section III describes how we replicate the cascade on a test system. Section IV discusses the factors that led to the blackout using factual findings from incident reports and our understanding. Section V develops a system-theoretic, voltage control analysis of the blackout, and Section VI presents replication results. Section VII proposes practical mitigation measures and concludes the paper. II The Iberian Blackout: Event Sequence This section delineates the event sequence that led to the blackout and summarizes the main factual findings documented in official reports in technical detail, for a high-level overview, refer to Fig. 1 . The European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E) expert panel published a 262-page factual report [ 2 ] providing a detailed sequence of events. Red Eléctrica de España (REE) also released a technical report on the incident [ 3 ] , and the Spanish government published an analysis committee report in Spanish [ 4 ] . These documents establish the event chronology but explicitly defer root-cause analysis and recommendations to future work. We refer to these as the primary sources. Fig. 1: High-level chronology of the April 28 blackout. The morning of April 28 was characterized by light system loading and high renewable integration. At 12:30, the generation mix comprised 82% renewables, predominantly solar and wind inverters, 10% nuclear, 3% combined-cycle gas, 1% coal, and 4% cogeneration, meeting light holiday demand of 25,184 MW (around 56% of historical peak) [ 4 , p. 38] . System inertia was correspondingly low at H_{\text{tot}}= 2.21–2.71 seconds [ 2 , p. 36] . Minor inter-area oscillations (0.2 Hz, causing 4–7 kV voltage swings) occurred at 10:30, 11:03, and 11:23, all of which damped naturally within minutes [ 3 , p. 3] . Between 12:03 and 12:08, a forced oscillation with dominant frequency 0.63 Hz emerged in southwestern Iberia, producing voltage swings reaching 30 kV at some 400 kV substations and exciting the 0.21 Hz East-Centre-West inter-area mode [ 2 , p. 53] . The origin of the 0.63 Hz oscillation remains unresolved (at the time of writing in November 2025), REE characterizes it as a forced oscillation possibly originating at a PV plant in Badajoz [ 3 , p. 12] , whereas the ENTSO-E Expert Panel did not confirm the cause [ 2 , p. 59] . A second inter-area oscillation (0.21 Hz) occurred between 12:19 and 12:22, with the Iberian Peninsula oscillating coherently against Continental Europe. Operators responded per protocols: between roughly 12:03 and 12:25, they energized ( energizing a circuit, also referred to as network meshing , is to close breakers and apply voltage so the line is in service) several 400 kV circuits to decrease system impedance, switched off several shunt reactors during the oscillation window, with the first reconnections occurring minutes later (at around 12:26) as voltages began to rise [ 2 , pp. 19–21] . At 12:05, exports to France were reduced , and at 12:19 REE asked RTE to reduce the exchange further. At 12:11, operators reconfigured the HVDC interconnection from AC-emulation (PMODE3) to fixed-power mode (PMODE1 * * * PMODE1 (fixed-power): line controls active power to a constant setpoint regardless of system frequency/angle. PMODE3 (AC-emulation): active power tracks voltage-angle difference so the HVDC contributes inter-area damping. ) at 1,000 MW export [ 4 , p. 103] . These actions damped oscillations by 12:22, and by 12:30 voltages settled to 410–420 kV (within the 375–435 kV envelope) and frequency stabilized near 50 Hz. At 12:26, recognizing deteriorating conditions, operators requested rapid synchronization of additional conventional generators with dynamic voltage control capability in the southern zone. The shortest offered lead time was 1.5 hours, meaning the unit could not be online until around 14:00—far beyond the sub-minute timescale of the impending cascade [ 4 , p. 35] . Between 12:32:00 and 12:32:57, approximately several hundred megawatts were lost from distributed generation and net load increases. At 12:32:57, a 400/220 kV generation transformer tripped due to overvoltage on the 220 kV collector side (242 kV), disconnecting 355 MW and