Covariance spectrum of MAXI J1820+070: On the nature of the Comptonizing flow
Shuai-Kang Yang, Bei You, Niek Bollemeijer, Phil Uttley, A.J. Tetarenko, Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Liang Chen, P. Casella, J.A. Paice, Yang Bai, Sai-En Xu · 2025
Read Covariance spectrum of MAXI J1820+070: On the nature of the Comptonizing flow by Shuai-Kang Yang, Bei You, Niek Bollemeijer, Phil Uttley, A.J. Tetarenko, Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Liang Chen, P. Casella, J.A. Paice, Yang Bai, Sai-En Xu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17285.txt.
Introduction
Shuai-Kang Yang and 10 co-authors analyze flickering X-ray emission from MAXI J1820+070, a black hole binary, using the covariance spectrum, a tool that isolates how different energy bands vary together. For the first time, the team extends such coherence studies into hard X-rays up to 150 keV, during the system's hard spectral state. They detect a clear drop in coherence above 30 keV on both short and long timescales.
Fitting the covariances and average spectra with a Comptonization model, where photons gain energy by scattering off hot electrons, produced a surprise. The electrons tied to slow variability are hotter than those tied to fast variability, and their temperature stays steady while the fast component's evolves. The authors explain the pattern with two Comptonizing regions fed by different seed photons, one elevated above the disk. The geometry's evolution may drive the observed changes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shuai-Kang Yang, Bei You, Niek Bollemeijer, Phil Uttley, A.J. Tetarenko, Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Liang Chen, P. Casella, J.A. Paice, Yang Bai, Sai-En Xu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17285
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Covariance spectrum of MAXI J1820+070: On the nature of the Comptonizing flow Shuai-Kang Yang, Bei You, Niek Bollemeijer, Phil Uttley, A.J. Tetarenko, Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Liang Chen, P. Casella, J.A. Paice, Yang Bai, Sai-En Xu Abstract We present an analysis of the covariance spectrum of the black hole X-ray binary MAXI J1820+070 during its hard state. For the first time, we extend coherence and covariance studies into the hard X-ray band up to ∼ \sim 150 keV. We detect a clear drop in coherence above 30 keV on both short- and long-timescales relative to the 2–10 keV reference band. To investigate the origin of the coherent variability, we simultaneously fit the short- and long-timescale covariances and the time-averaged spectra with the Comptonization model. Surprisingly, the electron temperature associated with long-timescale variability is significantly higher than that on short timescales. Moreover, the temperature on long timescales remains relatively constant throughout the hard state, whereas the short-timescale temperature evolves with X-ray luminosity. We attribute the drop in coherence to multiple sources of seed photons, i.e., the blackbody and synchrotron photons. The independence between these two photon fields leads to the drop in coherence. Moreover, to explain the lower electron temperature on short timescales, we propose a two-Comptonization framework in which short-timescale variability arises from a vertically extended central region, while long-timescale variability originates at larger radii. The elevated geometry of the inner region leads to illumination primarily by cooler outer-disk photons, yielding a lower electron temperature. In this case, the evolution of the height of the elevated region could explain evolution of the electron temperature associated with the coherent variability throughout the hard state. I Introduction Figure 1: Insight -HXMT light curves (in units of counts per second) of MAXI J1820+070 obtained from the HE (squares, 28–150 keV), ME (triangles, 10–30 keV), and LE (dots, 1–10 keV) detectors. Different colored shaded regions mark the five epochs selected for our spectral and timing analyses. In systems with accreting black holes (BHs), such as X-ray binaries (XRBs) that contain stellar-mass black holes and active galactic nuclei (AGNs) housing supermassive black holes, the observed X-ray photons primarily originate from the regions near the black holes. In the so-called hard state, the X-ray energy spectrum typically features two components: weak thermal emission in the low-energy band and strong power-law emission in the high-energy band ( 55 ) . The weak thermal emission is believed to originate from a geometrically thin, optically thick disk, while the strong power-law emission is attributed to inverse Comptonization occurring close to the black hole ( 16 ; 18 ; 36 ) . I.1 Models of the accretion flow It has been proposed that the thin disk is truncated at a specific radius, within which a hot flow develops ( 15 ) . The co-evolution of the thin disk and the hot flow plays a crucial role in the state transitions observed during the outbursts of XRBs. Recently, 52 demonstrated that, in the framework of a truncated disk model, the truncation radius of MAXI J1820+070 increases as the mass accretion rate declines, indicating that the inner hot flow is expanding as this source transitions from the soft state to the hard state. In this context, soft photons originating from the outer disk can act as seed photons. These photons are Compton up-scattered by thermal electrons within the hot flow through inverse Compton processes. This mechanism accounts for the observed power-law-like X-ray continuum. The nature of the Comptonizing hot flow is still a topic of debate. On the one hand, the advection-dominated accretion flow (ADAF), proposed by 29 , has been widely used to explain the hard X-ray emission observed in BHXRBs, often referred to as a corona. This corona is commonly regarded as the primary region for Comptonization. On the other hand, past studies have suggested that the jet base could also be a potential site for Comptonization emission ( 27 ) . In this context, either the disk blackbody or synchrotron photons could serve as the dominant seed photons for the inverse-Compton scattering process. In MAXI J1820+070, during the rising hard state, i.e., before transitioning to the soft state, the illumination of the hard X-ray Comptonization emission on the disk is weakening according to the broad X-ray spectral fits ( 54 ) , as the hard X-ray Comptonization is contracting towards the BH ( 20 ; 11 ) . It was hypothesized that the source of X-ray Comptonization may act as an outflowing corona during the rising hard state of MAXI J1820+070, contributing to the observed decrease in its illumination ( 54 ) . When simultaneous observations in optical and/or infrared wavelengths are coupled with radio and X-ray data, a broadband spectral energy distribution (SED) can be constructed. The analysis of these fits will enhance our understanding of the sources of X-ray Comptonization ( 24 ; 32 ; 30 ; 2 ; 14 ; 51 ; 37 ) . It has been observed that during the hard state, jet emission is characterized by a flat to slightly inverted, optically thick spectrum that extends from the radio to the infrared/optical bands ( 25 ; 10 ; 8 ) . The jet spectrum transitions from optically thick to optically thin emission with a spectral break at \nu_{b}\sim 10^{11–14}\rm{Hz} ( 34 ; 35 ) . This transition may also significantly contribute to the infrared/optical bands ( 26 ; 33 ; 40 ; 12 ) . The optical and infrared (OIR) photons can serve as seed photons for Comptonization. I.2 Measurements and nature of variability In addition to the multi-wavelength observation on a long timescale of days, as mentioned above, the fast variability on a timescale of seconds in the inter-bands is also crucial in revealing the physics of the X-ray emission ( 3 ; 4 ; 5 ; 17 ; 48 ; 57 ) and the accretion–ejection connection ( 38 ; 31 ; 45 ; 58 ; 6 ) . One can construct X-ray variability spectra by calculating the PDS for each energy channel and integrating it over a specific frequency range to obtain the variance in that channel. This yields the root-mean-square (RMS) spectrum, which characterizes the variability of spectral components within that frequency range ( 44 ) . 47 introduced the technique of covariance spectra, which shares similarities with RMS spectra but is more robust in low signal-to-noise regimes. It measures the covariance between a given energy channel and a broader reference band, enabling the isolation of variability contributions from different spectral components on distinct timescales. Covariance spectra and ratios derived from XMM-Newton observations of GX 339-4 revealed enhanced disk blackbody variability relative to the Comptonized emission below one keV on timescales longer than one second, which are caused by instabilities in the disc itself. As a result, we aim to extend the covariance spectrum into the high-energy band, enabling us to study X-ray Comptonization from a timing perspective. It is essential to note that the power-law Comptonization spectrum decreases at higher energies, with a cutoff that reaches approximately 100 keV. This cutoff is typical for the hard spectral states observed in BHXRBs ( 53 ) . Therefore, it is crucial to ensure that X-ray observations extend into the high-energy band. I.3