Calculation and analysis of exciton couplings via a subsystem formulation of the G ​ W GW -Bethe–Salpeter Equation

Sarathchandra Khandavilli, Arno Förster, Lucas Visscher · 2025

Read Calculation and analysis of exciton couplings via a subsystem formulation of the G ​ W GW -Bethe–Salpeter Equation by Sarathchandra Khandavilli, Arno Förster, Lucas Visscher (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-17077.txt.

Introduction

Sarathchandra Khandavilli, Arno Förster, and Lucas Visscher develop a way to pull apart exciton couplings, the interactions that let energy move between molecules after light absorption. Their setting is the GW-Bethe-Salpeter method, a standard tool for computing excited states, recast so each molecular fragment can be examined on its own. Localized orbitals let them split an excited state into parts sitting on one fragment and parts shared as charge transfer between fragments.

Tests on ethylene and pyrene pairs reveal how truncating the excitonic basis and approximating couplings shift the computed energies. The team then applies the method to chlorophyll pairs, where slight shape distortions create weak charge-transfer asymmetries. The framework offers a practical route to reading excitonic behavior in large molecular assemblies, fragment by fragment.

Catalog record

CREATORSarathchandra Khandavilli, Arno Förster, Lucas Visscher
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-17077

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Calculation and analysis of exciton couplings via a subsystem formulation of the G ​ W GW -Bethe–Salpeter Equation Sarathchandra Khandavilli, Arno Förster, Lucas Visscher Abstract We present a fragment-based framework for analyzing exciton couplings within the G ​ W GW –BSE formalism using localized molecular orbitals, and assess how excitonic states in molecular dimers can be decomposed into local and charge-transfer (CT) sectors. Our localization procedure preserves orbital orthonormality via a block-diagonal unitary transformation, enabling a simple and interpretable analysis of excitonic interactions. Using ethylene and pyrene dimers as model systems, we identify key effects of excitonic basis truncation and coupling approximations on excitation energies. We then extend the method to chlorophyll dimers, where weak CT asymmetries emerge due to geometric distortions. This framework offers a tractable route to analyze excitonic behavior in complex systems and paves the way for future fragment-based reconstruction of full exciton coupling matrices in large molecular assemblies. I Introduction One of the most critical issues in quantum chemistry is accurately describing excited states Loos, Scemama, and Jacquemin 2020 , particularly charge-transfer (CT) excitations Loos et al. 2021 ; Mester and Kállay 2022 , which play a fundamental role in processes such as photosynthesis Cheng and Fleming 2009 ; Curutchet and Mennucci 2017 and photovoltaic energy conversion Gruber et al. 2012 ; Mikhnenko, Blom, and Nguyen 2015 . While time-dependent Runge and Gross 1984 ; Petersilka, Gossmann, and Gross 1996 density-functional theory Hohenberg and Kohn 1964 ; Kohn and Sham. L. J. 1965 (TD-DFT) can be applied to large molecules Tamura, Saito, and Ishikita 2021 ; Sirohiwal and Pantazis 2022 ; Volpert et al. 2023 ; Capone et al. 2023 , it is often not accurate enough to provide definitive analyses and predictions. TD-DFT calculations tend to underestimate CT excitation energies, since the kernels of commonly used semilocal exchange-correlation functionals do not sufficiently describe the non-locality of CT excitations Tozer 2003 ; Dreuw and Head-Gordon 2004 . Range-separated Leininger et al. 1997 hybrid functionals Yanai, Tew, and Handy 2004 , which incorporate non-local Hartree-Fock exchange at long range, help address this problem Chai and Head-Gordon 2008 ; Rohrdanz, Martins, and Herbert 2009 , though achieving good accuracy typically requires systematic tuning of the range-separation parameters Stein, Kronik, and Baer 2009 ; Refaely-Abramson, Baer, and Kronik 2011 ; Kronik et al. 2012 and careful adjustment of the short- and long-range exact exchange fractions, which are highly system-specific. Loos et al. 2021 Computationally tractable alternatives to TD-DFT include equation-of-motion (EOM) coupled cluster (CC) Monkhorst 1977 ; Stanton and Bartlett 1993 and the GW Hedin 1965 ; Golze, Dvorak, and Rinke 2019 (where G represents the single-particle Green’s function and W represents the screened Coulomb interaction)-Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) method Strinati 1988 ; Onida, Reining, and Rubio 2002 ; Blase, Duchemin, and Jacquemin 2018 . Despite a canonical scaling of N^{6} , thanks to recent algorithmic developments Dutta, Neese, and Izsák 2016 ; Dutta et al. 2018 EOM-CC with single and double excitations (EOM-CCSD) can be applied to systems of the order of 100 atoms Sirohiwal et al. 2020 . Unfortunately, its accuracy diminishes for larger molecules, where it is even outperformed by the lower-scaling second-order CC (CC2) method Loos et al. 2020 ; Loos and Jacquemin 2021 ; Véril et al. 2021 and systematically overestimates CT excitation energies Knysh et al. 2024 . Its similarity-transformed variant Nooijen and Bartlett 1997a ; Nooijen and Bartlett 1997b performs somewhat better Loos et al. 2021 but requires the selection of an active space. GW -BSE, on the other hand, has a moderate canonical computational cost, and a low-scaling implementation has enabled applications to systems with thousands of correlated electrons Förster and Visscher 2022 . GW -BSE accurately describes singlet excited states in weakly correlated systems Bruneval and Marques 2013 ; Förster and Visscher 2022 ; McKeon et al. 2022 also with Rydberg Gui, Holzer, and Klopper 2018 or CT Gui, Holzer, and Klopper 2018 ; Bhattacharya et al. 2024 ; Knysh et al. 2024 ; Förster 2025 character. GW -BSE is therefore a suitable method for the calculation of CT states in large molecular complexes of interest in photochemistry or photovoltaics. While the accuracy of the electronic structure method is important for a quantitatively and qualitatively correct description of excited states, the characterization of excited states poses an additional challenge. CT excitations are difficult to characterize due to the spatially delocalized nature of the excitonic wavefunction in the molecular orbital (MO) basis of large supramolecular systems. This spatial delocalization induces mixing between local and CT states, complicating their identification and analysis. Accurate description of these states is crucial, as they are precursors to charge separation in photosynthetic processes and to the development of photovoltaic technologies Mikhnenko, Blom, and Nguyen 2015 ; Gruber et al. 2012 . Although CT states can be identified by visualizing molecular orbitals involved in the transition, such a characterization might sometimes fail and is not systematic. Hence, several systematic descriptors, based for instance on the overlap between the occupied and virtual states involved in the transition, orbital centroids, natural transition orbitals, or attachment/detachment densities have been proposed Peach et al. 2008 ; Plasser and Lischka 2012 ; Guido et al. 2013 ; Plasser, Wormit, and Dreuw 2014 ; Plasser et al. 2014 (See Ref. 2 for a recent review). While useful for characterizing CT excitations, the fact that they all rely on different criteria illustrates the non-trivial nature of characterizing CT states in the molecular orbital picture. Partitioning the system into smaller subsystems Manby et al. 2012 ; Jacob and Neugebauer 2024 allows to analyze the character of excited states in a conceptually clear manner in terms of localized orbitals Neugebauer 2007 ; Tölle et al. 2019 ; Sen and Visscher 2022 and can reduce computational complexity Curutchet and Mennucci 2017 . Several proposed methods in this field can broadly be classified into two categories: bottom-up and top-down approaches. In bottom-up embedding schemes, the wave function of the total quantum many-body system is reconstructed from the wave functions of its subsystems or fragments. In this approach, inter-subsystem interactions are added to the subsystem Hamiltonians. In contrast, top-down embedding approaches start with the full Hamiltonian and wave function, but (initially) neglect correlations between specific fragments, simplifying the problem by focusing first on the most relevant interactions. In the context of DFT we refer the readers to References 57 and 58 for more details on these methods. In subsystem TD-DFT Jacob and Neugebauer 2024 one may distinguish between approaches based on the orbital-free formalism of Weslowski and Warshel Wesolowski and Warshel 1993 which employs non-orthogonal orbitals and thus requires use of a kinetic energy density functional approximation, and the projection-based embedding method suggested by Manby and coworkers Manby et al. 2012 where orbital orthogonality between the subsystems is enforced. Both approaches allow for precise characterization of excited states in terms of local Neugebauer 2007 and CT Tölle et al. 2019 ; Sen and Visscher 2022 character. A versatile implementation of sub-system TD-DFT Neugebauer 2009 ; Tölle, Böckers, and Neugebauer 2019 ; Tölle and Neugebauer 2022 was realised by the Neugebauer group Unsleber et al. 2018 . They follow a bottom-up approach, initially partitioning the systems into smaller fragments and then

Read the complete text