Spin-adapted open-shell time-dependent density functional theory: towards a simple and accurate method for spin-flip-down excitations

Hewang Zhao and Zhendong Li · 2025

Read Spin-adapted open-shell time-dependent density functional theory: towards a simple and accurate method for spin-flip-down excitations by Hewang Zhao and Zhendong Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-16906.txt.

Introduction

Hewang Zhao and Zhendong Li introduce XSF-TDA, a method for computing spin-flip excitations of open-shell molecules without the spin contamination that plagues spin-flip time-dependent density functional theory. Flipping a spin during excitation is the natural route to bond breaking states and inverted singlet-triplet gaps, but contaminated answers are hard to trust.

The method grows out of the authors' earlier spin-adapted open-shell theory for spin-conserving excitations. The paper compares strategies for suppressing contamination across unrestricted and mixed-reference variants of the spin-flip approach. Pilot calculations on prototype systems show XSF-TDA describing bond breaking and inverted gap systems more faithfully than its predecessors. It is a step toward a spin-flip method that is both simple enough for routine use and accurate enough for chemistry's hard cases.

Catalog record

CREATORHewang Zhao and Zhendong Li
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-16906

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spin-adapted open-shell time-dependent density functional theory: towards a simple and accurate method for spin-flip-down excitations Hewang Zhao and Zhendong Li Abstract A major challenge in using spin-flip time-dependent density functional theory (SF-TD-DFT) for spin-flip-down excitations is the presence of spin contamination. While several improved methods have been developed in the past, a simple and accurate method remains elusive. Here, based on our previous development on spin-adapted open-shell TD-DFT for spin-conserving excitations (X-TD-DFT) [Z. Li and W. Liu, J. Chem. Phys. 135, 194106 (2011)], we introduce a method termed as XSF-TDA for modeling spin-flip-down excitations, and provide an in-depth comparison of different methodologies for mitigating spin contamination in SF-TDA. Pilot applications to prototype systems demonstrate the promise of XSF-TDA over existing SF-TDA methods, including unrestricted SF-TDA (USF-TDA) and mixed-reference SF-TDA (MRSF-TDA), in describing bond breakings and inverted singlet-triplet gap systems. keywords spin-flip; time-dependent density functional theory; spin contamination; spin adaptation † † affiliation: Key Laboratory of Theoretical and Computational Photochemistry, Ministry of Education, College of Chemistry, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China 1 Introduction Spin-flip time-dependent density functional theory (SF-TD-DFT) [ 1 ] , which extends the earlier spin-flip framework [ 2 ] to TD-DFT, has garnered significant attention for its ability to describe electronic transitions beyond the reach of conventional linear response spin-conserving TD-DFT. For instance, it can be used to study spin-flip transitions in spin-flip emitters [ 3 , 4 ] , which represent a distinct class of luminescent materials that exhibit unique photophysical properties due to spin‐forbidden yet radiative transitions. Apart from spin-flip transitions, SF-TD-DFT is also capable of capturing certain double excitations, single-bond dissociation processes, and the correct topology of conical intersections [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] , which are notoriously challenging for DFT and spin-conserving TD-DFT within the adiabatic approximation [ 8 ] . The initial implementation of SF-TD-DFT by Shao et al. [ 1 ] employed a collinear hybrid exchange–correlation (XC) kernel within the Tamm–Dancoff approximation (TDA). This formulation necessitates the use of hybrid XC functionals; pure density functionals would otherwise yield excitation energies that are simply orbital energy differences. Subsequently, Wang and Ziegler introduced a noncollinear XC kernel [ 9 , 10 ] , which was originally proposed in the context of relativistic TD-DFT for spinor excitations [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] , within the local density approximation (LDA) to describe spin-flip excitations in a nonrelativistic framework. Later, full noncollinear XC kernels were implemented for generalized gradient approximation (GGA) and hybrid functionals, both within TDA [ 14 , 15 ] and in full SF-TD-DFT [ 16 ] . However, numerical instabilities can arise with noncollinear GGA kernels. To address this, an adiabatic local density approximation (ALDA0) [ 16 , 17 ] was introduced, neglecting density gradients in the XC kernel evaluation to enhance numerical stability. More recently, alternative strategies based on a multicollinear formulation have been proposed [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . A major drawback of SF-TD-DFT is the presence of excited-state spin contamination [ 21 , 22 ] , which arises from the incompleteness of the excitation manifold. We define a subspace as spin complete if it contains all the determinants required to form spin eigenfunctions, and a method as spin-adapted if all its configurations are spin eigenfunctions. Note a subtle distinction: spin-adaptation requires that only spin eigenfunctions are included, but does not necessitate inclusion of all the configurations within a spin-complete subspace. To illustrate the spin contamination issue in SF-TD-DFT, consider a triplet reference system as depicted in Fig. 1 . The orbitals of the high-spin open-shell state can be categorized into closed-shell (C), open-shell (O), and virtual-shell (V). We denote a single excitation from an \alpha core orbital to a \beta virtual orbital as CV( \alpha\beta ). It is easy to find that only OO( \alpha\beta )-type spin-flip-down excitations generate a spin-complete subspace. In contrast, the other three types - CV( \alpha\beta ), OV( \alpha\beta ), and CO( \alpha\beta ) - result in spin contamination due to the spin incompleteness of their generated configurations. The determinants shown in red in Fig 1 , which are higher excitations than singles with respect to the reference, are necessary to achieve spin completeness/adaptation. Within wavefunction theory, methods such as spin-complete spin-flip configuration interaction singles (SC-SF-CIS) [ 23 ] have been developed to address this issue by directly incorporating the missing higher excitations. However, adapting such approaches to TD-DFT is challenging due to the absence of an explicit wavefunction. Although propagator corrections [ 21 ] and generalized excitation operators [ 24 ] have been proposed to include higher-order excitations in TD-DFT, these methods have not seen practical application. Figure 1: Illustration of the excited-state spin contamination problem in SF-TD-DFT/SF-TDA due to the incompleteness of the excited state manifold generated by spin-flip-down single excitations. Configurations in red color represent the missing higher excitations with respect to the reference to achieve spin completeness/adaptation. Building on the insight that the missing configurations for spin completeness can be accessed from other components of the open-shell reference, one of the present authors developed [ 22 ] a spin-adapted random phase approximation (S-RPA) and time-dependent density functional theory (S-TD-DFT) using the tensor equation-of-motion (TEOM) formalism originally introduced in nuclear physics [ 25 ] . A key feature of S-RPA is that only single excitations explicitly enter the final matrix elements, while the contributions from higher excitations required for spin-adaptation are implicitly incorporated via the Wigner-Eckart theorem [ 22 ] . This crucial property allows for a direct translation of the matrix elements into the TD-DFT framework, leading to S-TD-DFT [ 26 ] without the need to go beyond the adiabatic approximation. Subsequently, a more accurate and simpler version, termed X-TD-DFT [ 27 ] , was introduced to better account for spin degeneracy conditions and to eliminate double counting of correlation for those already spin-adapted states. X-TD-DFT has been shown to achieve accuracy comparable to conventional closed-shell TD-DFT for spin-conserving excitations [ 28 ] . For spin-flip-down excitations, a similar strategy can in principle be applied to achieve spin adaptation, as proposed in the original work [ 22 ] and later implemented by Zhang and Herbert [ 5 ] and Chima and Visscher [ 29 ] . However, addressing double counting of correlation in this context is more challenging, as spin contamination affects three types of excitations, and adding the effects of higher excitations for spin-adaptation may deteriorate the excited states dominated by the OO( \alpha\beta ) type of excitations, which are already spin-complete. Another relevant approach is the mixed-reference SF-TD-DFT within TDA (MRSF-TDA) proposed by Lee et al. [ 30 , 31 ] , which uses only the M_{S}=\pm 1 components of a triplet reference to mitigate spin contamination, but is not applicable to other spin states. In summary, a general, simple, and accurate spin-adapted method for spin-flip-down excitations is still lacking. In this work, we present a method termed as XSF-TDA, which extends our previous developments in spin-adapted TD-DFT [ 22 , 26 , 27 ] to spin-flip-down excitations. We introduce a practical approach to alleviate the double counting of correlation resulting from the implicit inclusion of high-order excitations for spin adaptation. Pilot applications on small systems, where high-level theoretical or experimental reference

Read the complete text