Trust in AI emerges from distrust in humans: A machine learning study on decision-making guidance

Johan Sebastián Galindez-Acosta, Juan José Giraldo-Huertas · 2025

Read Trust in AI emerges from distrust in humans: A machine learning study on decision-making guidance by Johan Sebastián Galindez-Acosta, Juan José Giraldo-Huertas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-16769.txt.

Introduction

Johan Sebastián Galindez-Acosta and Juan José Giraldo-Huertas test a mechanism they call deferred trust: when people distrust human advisors, their reliance shifts to AI systems that look more neutral or competent. Fifty-five undergraduates chose guidance from AI agents, voice assistants, peers, adults, or priests across thirty factual, emotional, and moral scenarios.

Adults were picked most overall, AI second. Clustering showed AI dominating factual scenarios while humans prevailed on social and moral ones. Lower prior trust in priests, peers, and adults consistently predicted choosing AI, exactly the deferred trust pattern, and machine learning models predicted selections well from trust and demographic variables. Profiles high in AI trust combined human distrust, lower technology use, and higher socioeconomic status. The authors warn that fluency-driven over-reliance is a real risk and argue for transparency that calibrates vigilance.

Catalog record

CREATORJohan Sebastián Galindez-Acosta, Juan José Giraldo-Huertas
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-16769

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Trust in AI emerges from distrust in humans: A machine learning study on decision-making guidance Johan Sebastián Galindez-Acosta, Juan José Giraldo-Huertas Abstract This study explores the dynamics of trust in artificial intelligence (AI) agents, particularly large language models (LLMs), by introducing the concept of "deferred trust", a cognitive mechanism where distrust in human agents redirects reliance toward AI perceived as more neutral or competent. Drawing on frameworks from social psychology and technology acceptance models, the research addresses gaps in user-centric factors influencing AI trust. Fifty-five undergraduate students participated in an experiment involving 30 decision-making scenarios (factual, emotional, moral), selecting from AI agents (e.g., ChatGPT), voice assistants, peers, adults, or priests as guides. Data were analyzed using K-Modes and K-Means clustering for patterns, and XGBoost models with SHAP interpretations to predict AI selection based on sociodemographic and prior trust variables. Results showed adults (35.05%) and AI (28.29%) as the most selected agents overall. Clustering revealed context-specific preferences: AI dominated factual scenarios, while humans prevailed in social/moral ones. Lower prior trust in human agents (priests, peers, adults) consistently predicted higher AI selection, supporting deferred trust as a compensatory transfer. Participant profiles with higher AI trust were distinguished by human distrust, lower technology use, and higher socioeconomic status. Models demonstrated consistent performance (e.g., average precision up to 0.863). Findings challenge traditional models like TAM/UTAUT, emphasizing relational and epistemic dimensions in AI trust. They highlight risks of over-reliance due to fluency effects and underscore the need for transparency to calibrate vigilance. Limitations include sample homogeneity and static scenarios; future work should incorporate diverse populations and multimodal data to refine deferred trust across contexts. Author Contributions Johan Sebastián Galindez-Acosta: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Software, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review and editing. Juan José Giraldo-Huertas: Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Supervision, Validation, Writing – review and editing. Declaration of Interest The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this article. Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) has become a phenomenon of significant cultural impact as it seeks to simulate processes that inherently require human intelligence, such as environmental perception, planning and execution of actions, and adaptation through learning ( 5 ; 16 ) . AI has permeated human practices through the dynamics of generative artificial intelligence, supervised and unsupervised learning, and large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude ( 22 ) . The use of these technologies has been greatly influenced by the level of trust placed in them, a central variable in the human relationship with artificial intelligence ( 19 ) . Trust refers to a subjective attitude, whereas trustworthiness refers to objective characteristics. Person A trusts person B if person B fulfills a set of certain factors ( 17 ) . Trust is defined within a specific and unpredictable context in which person A assumes that person B will act in their interest according to person B’s agency (motivations, values, goals, or commitment), thereby accepting a degree of risk and vulnerability. For this process to remain unbiased, trust and trustworthiness must align coherently ( 11 ) . When discussing trust in artificial intelligence, the absence of agency in AI systems shifts the focus to measurable factors such as reliability, accuracy, and transparency. Unlike interpersonal trust, which depends on assumptions about motivations and goals, trust in AI is grounded in expectations of consistent performance in unpredictable and vulnerable contexts ( 35 ) . This concept can be sub-categorized into epistemic trust, related to perception of the competence and reliability of the evaluated agent, and social trust, which explains perception of benevolence, interpersonal relationship, and group affiliation with the agent ( 21 ) . Poor trust and trustworthiness calibration in artificial intelligence can lead to maladaptive interactions with these technologies ( 29 ; 37 ; 19 ; 34 ) . Adult participants report perceiving AI-supported decision making as less fair, particularly when outcomes are unfavorable to them, while biases also emerge in children’s views of artificial agents’ competence compared to human agents; children tend to perceive that artificial agents do not make errors even when both face equal epistemic competition and prefer them in guidance situations ( 3 ; 41 ) . Similarly, trust in decision-making agents, whether human or robotic, often appears statistically comparable in adults, yet participants consistently favor human agents due to familiarity, tradition, and perceived contextual understanding in tasks related to football refereeing ( 9 ) . Likewise, studies on children’s interactions with digital voice assistants further illustrate this misalignment. While older children increasingly trust voice assistants for factual information and humans for personal information, their preferences are not linked to the perceived epistemic capacities of either informant, highlighting a disconnect between trust, reliability and trustworthiness ( 18 ) . Advances in understanding trust have found that this phenomenon is influenced by human, artificial agent, environment, technology development and institutional-related variables ( 19 ; 11 ; 17 ) . Those factors can be enumerated as higher perceptions of anthropomorphism, perceived cognitive competencies of AI agent, scenarios with risk for participants or others, knowledge background required for decision making, the declaration of intentionalities of AI agents, personality of AI agent and reputation of the technology ( 35 ; 13 ; 30 ; 7 ; 12 ; 33 ; 42 ) . Despite substantial advances in understanding variables influencing trust process, important gaps remain, particularly in categories related to the human user ( 20 ) . Meta-analyses identified small overall effect sizes in human-related categories affecting trust in AI, while chatbots remain with the smallest predictive effects of known trust-influencing factors ( 23 ) . Results underscore the importance of studying trust phenomena in technologies that are becoming increasingly prevalent in daily use such as conversational agents like ChatGPT. Traditional technology acceptance models like TAM, UTAUT and UTAU2 primarily frame trust as a function of perceived usefulness, ease of use, and behavioral intention, treating AI as a passive tool rather than an interactive agent ( 10 ; 44 ; 27 ) . However, for LLMs, this reductionist view overlooks how their conversational capabilities simulate human-like agency, triggering interpersonal trust dynamics ( 8 ) . Studies highlight that users attribute mental states, such as motives or intentions, to LLMs, leading to trust formation processes more aligned with social psychology than mere utility assessments ( 31 ) . This shift necessitates moving beyond TAM/UTAUT to models that account for relational and epistemic factors, where trust emerges from perceived benevolence and competence in simulated interactions ( 8 ) . LLMs evoke strong perceptions of agency through natural language interaction and apparent intentionality ( 8 ; 31 ) . Such anthropomorphic qualities trigger cognitive mechanisms similar to those in interpersonal trust, including epistemic trust (perceived competence and reliability), selective trust (reliance on unverified knowledge), and the activation of epistemic vigilance, the capacity to evaluate source credibility and coherence ( 6 ) . Epistemic vigilance functions as a safeguard in human communication, enabling individuals to filter unreliable information by assessing credibility, coherence, and relevance ( 39 ) . Applied to AI contexts, this vigilance extends to evaluating LLM-generated content for potential biases or hallucinations ( 6 ) . Yet, the fluency and

Read the complete text